This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Mateta ?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Elpis In a pub 24 Jan 22 7.58am |
|
|
If we are going to buy him I would buy him now . There is a lot to be said for knowing where you are going to be for the next 3 -4 years
|
dreamwaverider London 24 Jan 22 8.03am |
|
|
Yesterday Mateta showed us the power and wisdom of our management /coaching team. He is improving fast. For 20 minutes he and Edouard supported by Olise and Sclupp had Liverpool on the ropes. We were all over them. Admittedly in the first half Liverpool showed us why they are top 3. They were so good we deserved credit just for hanging on. Which we did. Then the unbelievable happened. We changed our format and within minutes of the second half had 3 clear chances. It was like Brazil of the seventies had turned up. Mateta Schluppie Edouard started to really play. Supported by Gallagher Olise and Hughes we actually outplayed them. Hughes hurt his foot and had to go but I was surprised to see Benteke replace Mateta. Maybe he was done. But the guy is improving no end. Some of his touches were very good. Plus he has a big presence which he is starting to use. I just wish Benteke was more daring in every department. He still seems to lack belief, which Mateta doesn’t.
|
Lanzo-Ad Lanzarote 24 Jan 22 8.44am |
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Yesterday Mateta showed us the power and wisdom of our management /coaching team. He is improving fast. For 20 minutes he and Edouard supported by Olise and Sclupp had Liverpool on the ropes. We were all over them. Admittedly in the first half Liverpool showed us why they are top 3. They were so good we deserved credit just for hanging on. Which we did. Then the unbelievable happened. We changed our format and within minutes of the second half had 3 clear chances. It was like Brazil of the seventies had turned up. Mateta Schluppie Edouard started to really play. Supported by Gallagher Olise and Hughes we actually outplayed them. Hughes hurt his foot and had to go but I was surprised to see Benteke replace Mateta. Maybe he was done. But the guy is improving no end. Some of his touches were very good. Plus he has a big presence which he is starting to use. I just wish Benteke was more daring in every department. He still seems to lack belief, which Mateta doesn’t.
Did you see When he was substituted, Vieira gave him extra congrats,
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn
|
pdemeagle eaglebhoy - @eaglism - Cottage in ... 24 Jan 22 8.56am |
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Yesterday Mateta showed us the power and wisdom of our management /coaching team. He is improving fast. For 20 minutes he and Edouard supported by Olise and Sclupp had Liverpool on the ropes. We were all over them. Admittedly in the first half Liverpool showed us why they are top 3. They were so good we deserved credit just for hanging on. Which we did. Then the unbelievable happened. We changed our format and within minutes of the second half had 3 clear chances. It was like Brazil of the seventies had turned up. Mateta Schluppie Edouard started to really play. Supported by Gallagher Olise and Hughes we actually outplayed them. Hughes hurt his foot and had to go but I was surprised to see Benteke replace Mateta. Maybe he was done. But the guy is improving no end. Some of his touches were very good. Plus he has a big presence which he is starting to use. I just wish Benteke was more daring in every department. He still seems to lack belief, which Mateta doesn’t.
This !
This for me is the main reason, JPM has self belief, that backheel v Brighton alone is all the evidence needed plus the fact he has and sticks to his signature individual celebration ! (Anyone who wants to mention Benteke's just remember he copied that off LeBron James of the NBA)
That's been the Benteke problem all along, we've been patient and given him plenty of time and patience in the hopes we'd see the Villa Benteke again but it just hasn't and now likely isn't going to happen, at 31 there's little scope for Benteke to improve but every chance JPM can as he's still developing !
Plus JPM has much more confidence with the ball at his feet too, he's worth the punt imo.
Nice one Daz: [Link]
CPFC 2010 - Stable and Realistic Owners at last ! Roll on Premier League Season 2013/2014 ! Great to be back at last !
PSN = eaglist
|
babylonjohn St Leonards-on-Sea 24 Jan 22 8.59am |
|
|
Mateta showed some class yesterday with a very cool and unselfish assist for Eduouards goal. If that had been Benteke or Ayew they would have gone for glory and messed it up... Not that Benteke ever makes runs like that ! ..... Only just calmed down after that joke of a referees performance GRRRRRR
|
MrRobbo Chaldon 24 Jan 22 9.28am |
|
|
He's not brilliant, but has improved significantly over the last couple of weeks.
The fact that a month or so ago he was going, but is now starting ahead of Benteke (ok low bar I know) is testament to that.
Also lets not forget, we were playing against one of the best teams in the world yesterday, and probably the best back 4.
At this point in time, given the choice I'd take JP over Benteke.
|
The Dolphin 24 Jan 22 10.29am |
|
|
Mateta is looking better. He is pretty swift and gets into good positions. He just needs to chase down a little more and stop being offside so often - although I think a part of that is that he thinks about the ball he wants before our lot give it to him!
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 24 Jan 22 10.45am |
|
|
We know it takes (game) time for players coming from foreign leagues to adjust to the demands of the PL. (Yes we can all identify exceptions like Fernandes at Manure, but they are the exception).
Mateta only started getting reasonable game time in the last month and in that short time has shown progress. Yes, he's ungainly and looks awkward but at 24 he's still young enough to improve. His interaction with Edouard in the second half yesterday was encouraging and as has been said, with the support of Olise, Gallagher and Schlupp (his best game of the season imo) they caused Liverpool a lot of problems and on another day might have snatched something from the game for us.
It seems that the club may have decided to take full advantage of what are believed to be the loan terms to decide whether or not to trigger the option/obligation to buy. The coming months will be interesting if that is the case. I hope he continues to progress and shows he can do a job for us in the PL.
As to the who's the better CF, Benteke or Mateta? Irrelevant in my book. Why? Because we are stuck with Benteke (like it or not) until the summer of 2023 when he will in all probability leave. In other words, he's not the long-term answer to our CF needs. Mateta, on the other hand may be, so even if he isn't yet showing he's the better CF, he may do so in due course. He needs the game time over the coming few months to show whether or not he's worth keeping. Benteke will still be here if at the end of this season the club decide Mateta ISN'T the answer.
|
Steveoxon Oxford 24 Jan 22 10.54am |
|
|
I also agree that Palace should give JP more game time to see how he develops. Although he looks a bit clumsy, I've been impressed with some of his close control in training and also in games and he also seems to get himself into dangerous positions more often than Benteke. Also think that given the players we have, that 4-4-2 works better than 4-4-3.
|
thai-eagle chiang mai 24 Jan 22 11.01am |
|
|
Mateta and Edouard on top, Olise, Eze, Conor, Hughes, and Schlupp/Luka in the middle. And please, please, let Ward enjoy some time on the bench. His passing is killing us....
|
Lanzo-Ad Lanzarote 24 Jan 22 11.22am |
|
Originally posted by Steveoxon
I also agree that Palace should give JP more game time to see how he develops. Although he looks a bit clumsy, I've been impressed with some of his close control in training and also in games and he also seems to get himself into dangerous positions more often than Benteke. Also think that given the players we have, that 4-4-2 works better than 4-4-3.
And the 4-3-3 looks like 4-5-1 most of the time, time to switch to 4-4-2
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn
|
EverybodyDannsNow SE19 24 Jan 22 12.03pm |
|
|
He's significantly better than Benteke IMO - actually makes runs and moves like a striker.
Should have took his chance yesterday when Olise slipped him through but overall I thought he had a good game - he's a handful and looks like he still has scope to improve.
|
Robk 24 Jan 22 12.06pm |
|
|
He needed a bit of time... hopefully he’ll get it... combines well with Edouard.... if he’d scored with that overhead kick a couple of weeks ago people would be saying amazing....
|
eagleman13 On The Road To Hell & Alicante 24 Jan 22 12.11pm |
|
Originally posted by BelfastEagle
Mateta showed again why he is starting now ahead of the likes of Benteke, gets in some good positions works hard and runs well off the ball. Benteke on the the other hand can head the ball….that’s about it.
Lets convert him to a CB then, then he can head balls to his hearts content, he cant score from them ,so, no OG's to worry about.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.
|
Ipswich Eagle Ipswich 24 Jan 22 2.46pm |
|
|
Really enthused by Mateta, I have to say. Still a bit rough around the edges, but I love his bravery and shot selection. Imagine how we'd all be feeling if his overhead kick and the backheel yesterday had gone in - Neither were very far off, frankly.
I've long been fed up of Benteke, and whilst his resurgence of late is encouraging he still cuts a very slow figure in a fast paced game and whilst his link up and holding play at times is much underrated I'd alway go for genuine goal threat from my forwards given a choice.
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 24 Jan 22 4.16pm |
|
Originally posted by Ipswich Eagle
Really enthused by Mateta, I have to say. Still a bit rough around the edges, but I love his bravery and shot selection. Imagine how we'd all be feeling if his overhead kick and the backheel yesterday had gone in - Neither were very far off, frankly.
I've long been fed up of Benteke, and whilst his resurgence of late is encouraging he still cuts a very slow figure in a fast paced game and whilst his link up and holding play at times is much underrated I'd alway go for genuine goal threat from my forwards given a choice.
I thought that was Edouard but then I was some distance from the attempt.
|
Fatherken 24 Jan 22 5.03pm |
|
|
it would help if he put in a tackle or even got close to someone to put one in which he did not do all the time he was on the pitch . Good job it was Mateta who missed those chances because if that were Benteke we would have not heard the end of it
|
ripleyeagle Ripley Surrey 24 Jan 22 5.52pm |
|
Originally posted by Ipswich Eagle
Really enthused by Mateta, I have to say. Still a bit rough around the edges, but I love his bravery and shot selection. Imagine how we'd all be feeling if his overhead kick and the backheel yesterday had gone in - Neither were very far off, frankly.
I've long been fed up of Benteke, and whilst his resurgence of late is encouraging he still cuts a very slow figure in a fast paced game and whilst his link up and holding play at times is much underrated I'd alway go for genuine goal threat from my forwards given a choice.
Good post and I agree.
|
Elwissthebest Marlborough 24 Jan 22 5.56pm |
|
|
I think we should buy Mateta and try to get someone else in on loan. Probably a proper winger. I know it's not my money I'm spending.
|
sprites Auckland 24 Jan 22 7.44pm |
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
He's significantly better than Benteke IMO - actually makes runs and moves like a striker.
Should have took his chance yesterday when Olise slipped him through but overall I thought he had a good game - he's a handful and looks like he still has scope to improve.
Disagree entirely. He only looked okay yesterday because he'd set such a low bar for himself. Whereas CB had previously set such a high bar at Villa and Belgium, we expect him to be world class. He's not world class...but he's a damn sight better than lanky Mateta...imo.
Guess that's the beauty of forums hey.
|