You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Manchester City vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread
November 8 2026 11.07pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Manchester City vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread


Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
PatrickA Flag London 28 Aug 22 8.40am

We looked comfortable in the first half which is quite an accolade considering who we were playing.
Other than a header over the bar from Foden, we did not really look troubled and looked organised and defended well.
Their goal early in the second half lifted them and Mitchell’s injury disrupted us.
What I couldn’t understand is why Bernardo Silva was given so much space to wreak havoc.
He was picking up the ball in yards of space and drifting in from the right with no real challenge.
He’s an excellent player but I couldn’t understand why we didn’t get tighter to him or try to force him down the line on his weaker right foot.
Most of their attacks seemed to stem from him and we never got to grips with him.
Unlike the first half we looked disorganised and lacking composure and Haaland exploited this to the full.

 

A89M Flag Streatham 28 Aug 22 8.52am

Originally posted by Oddball2021

Yes. That’s what happened. But Schlupp should have filled his position not Richards. Hughes for Schlupp. Every goal from 2-0 up was Richards playing too far back and allowing City to play into the strike zone. Except possibly Harland’s third. Also didn’t help having slow and lesser skilled players like Ayew up forward as the ball kept returning to Mitchell to deal with and that overstretched him causing his breakdown and retirement. Great first half performance though. But it was always an unbalanced side with players like Ayew up forward. Olise and Mateta with Eduard up forward would have given City something to be more wary about, and from 2-0 we could have routed them as they were trying to chase the game. Tactical incompetence cost us 3 points. And as for all the hyper positive dudes and their silver linings, my prediction next week is that we’ll be stung badly if we think it’s an easy 3 pointer.

I’ve seen someone else mention this but correct me if I’m wrong, Mitchell was still on the pitch for City’s first goal. He tracked Bernardo Silva across the box but couldn’t get near him before the shot on goal. Richards looked out of place on the left, poor decision by Viera but let’s not blame him for goals whilst he’s on the bench ha.

 

humber eagle Flag hull 28 Aug 22 9.13am

After a 2 hour drive home with time to reflect of todays game. The key point was the lack off attack, Eze had a good game but watched him enter the box then pass the ball backwards and it ended up going back to our defence. Anderson made a run all the way to their box with no outlet.
On a plus the gents who where sat next to the boy and I in Row BB, I applaud your efforts to wind up the Citeh fans, probably the best comedy duo I've seen for years.
And a special shout out to MH, who graciously got us the tickets. True Palace gent.

 


In my day, a Selfie was what you had when the wife didn't put out.

Numbers Man Flag Tulse Hill 28 Aug 22 9.37am

We were very poor defending in the second half and gave Haaland far too much room and Silva was totally unmarked when he received the pass on the wing to score the first goal. Mitchell had been dragged into the goal mouth leaving Silva on his own.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 28 Aug 22 9.38am

I just hope that physically & emotionally yesterday didn't take too much out of the team / squad for them to respond in the best manner possible in front pf a packed SP on Tuesday night -

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 28 Aug 22 10.24am

The Mitchell injury on top of being cheated out of a fair goal to put us 0-3 up was devastating.
Our left back was still hobbling about and should not have been trying to carry on when the City scorer cut in from Mitchell's side to score a deflected goal.
Unfortunately he was replaced by Richards, an inexperienced Premier League defender, who is obviously a right-sided centre-half asked to suddenly be a left-back away at the champions.
Our squad was really shown up and exposed at this point, in fact what was happening on the pitch was such a mess Richards was switched over to the right side as the goals went in.
A club our size can put out a decent first XI, but cannot compete with the squad depth and world-class subs a club like City can throw on as we struggle to make do and mend with limited resources.

 

djmikeyp Flag 28 Aug 22 10.42am

Commentators are similarly excited by Liverpool, Man Utd and Arsenal goals.
If only Sky and BBC would give us the option of having just the crowd noise, so we could enjoy the game without listening to their 'experts' fawning over the big teams.
And as for the woman commentator...! That's when the mute button gets pressed.

Originally posted by Nubes

It is very annoying hearing the commentators getting over excited at the goals when City score.

 

Wilesy01 Flag Bristol 28 Aug 22 10.55am

Originally posted by djmikeyp

Commentators are similarly excited by Liverpool, Man Utd and Arsenal goals.
If only Sky and BBC would give us the option of having just the crowd noise, so we could enjoy the game without listening to their 'experts' fawning over the big teams.
And as for the woman commentator...! That's when the mute button gets pressed.


I could do with a mute Jermaine Jenas button so I didn't have to hear his toady, crappy opinions on MotD. I have no idea how he's made it as a pundit - he's without any personality or insight.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 28 Aug 22 11.11am

Originally posted by Wilesy01


I could do with a mute Jermaine Jenas button so I didn't have to hear his toady, crappy opinions on MotD. I have no idea how he's made it as a pundit - he's without any personality or insight.

Agreed he never seems to saying anything positive about Palace and definitely never says we had harsh decisions against us

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 28 Aug 22 11.14am

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

City were due a win against us, but I never thought we would put 2 past them in the first 45minutes. As for the disallowed 3rd goal, I’m not sure the keeper had control of the ball and Edouard wasn’t exactly lifting his leg to challenge the keeper.

It will be nice to play some lesser teams, because Arsenal, Liverpool and Man City in your first 4 games is pretty difficult.

Also Man City away, followed by Tuesday night game at home, followed by Newcastle away. Fixture gods really don’t like us

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 28 Aug 22 11.16am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Also Man City away, followed by Tuesday night game at home, followed by Newcastle away. Fixture gods really don’t like us

Not only the fixture gods. Just seen we have Darren England again on Tuesday, how the f does that work?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 28 Aug 22 11.21am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Also Man City away, followed by Tuesday night game at home, followed by Newcastle away. Fixture gods really don’t like us


We've got the two toughest away games behind us and we've come out of them with one more point than expected and with some credit.

With Man U, Brighton and Chelsea to follow the Newcastle game, we'll have played 5 of the so-called big 6 in our first 9 games plus 2 of the next best in Newcastle and our south coast rivals (both away). Let's hope we can avoid banana skins against the eminently winnable games that come after them.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 28 Aug 22 12.23pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Agreed he never seems to saying anything positive about Palace and definitely never says we had harsh decisions against us

What surprised me on MOTD (maybe I shouldn't be surprised) was the dogmatic way in which Jenas dismissed even the slightest possibility that Ayew's goal should have been allowed, as if it was the most ridiculous suggestion he'd ever heard. Ian Wright was a little more sympathetic, speaking - as he said himself - as a forward.

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 28 Aug 22 3.45pm

I didnt really expect anything from the City match yday so was delighted at half time and was expecting the win . The defeat hurt but its kinda made right by not getting beaten by Scummerpool last week , if you lived over here in Ireland you would know why . Thousands of plastic scousers over here with shirts they bought in the 70s that are way too small for them now . I dont think ive ever seen anyone wearing a City shirt.

 

becky Flag over the moon 28 Aug 22 4.02pm

Originally posted by djmikeyp

Commentators are similarly excited by Liverpool, Man Utd and Arsenal goals.
If only Sky and BBC would give us the option of having just the crowd noise, so we could enjoy the game without listening to their 'experts' fawning over the big teams.
And as for the woman commentator...! That's when the mute button gets pressed.

This is where I love the 'sports mode' button..... cuts down the commentary sound and increases the 'stadium effect'.... get the balance right and you get all the crowd noise with just a faintly indecipherable burble in the background.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 28 Aug 22 4.17pm

One positive from yesterday = 2 goals from set pieces!

(PS I wish Andersen would jump like that when he's defending!)

 

djmikeyp Flag 28 Aug 22 4.19pm

If only my telly had such an option!
Sounds just the job.

Originally posted by becky

This is where I love the 'sports mode' button..... cuts down the commentary sound and increases the 'stadium effect'.... get the balance right and you get all the crowd noise with just a faintly indecipherable burble in the background.

 

Hannes Flag Vienna 28 Aug 22 4.41pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Not only the fixture gods. Just seen we have Darren England again on Tuesday, how the f does that work?

If I understood correctly, Darren England stood in for Graham Scott yesterday because he was ill.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 28 Aug 22 4.44pm

Originally posted by Hannes

If I understood correctly, Darren England stood in for Graham Scott yesterday because he was ill.

Thanks hadn’t heard that. Typical of our luck

 

YT Flag Oxford 28 Aug 22 6.16pm

Originally posted by doombear


We've got the two toughest away games behind us and we've come out of them with one more point than expected and with some credit.

With Man U, Brighton and Chelsea to follow the Newcastle game, we'll have played 5 of the so-called big 6 in our first 9 games plus 2 of the next best in Newcastle and our south coast rivals (both away). Let's hope we can avoid banana skins against the eminently winnable games that come after them.

You've written what I've come to accept, which is that sadly Brighton are much better than we are at the moment, as a club and a team.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Manchester City vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread