You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Aston Villa vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Aston Villa vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread


Page 8 of 13 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 16 Sep 23 6.35pm

Don't know about anybody else, but, i thought Ayew going off turned it Villa's way especially as Cash & McGinn exploited their left wing, our right, ie Wardy. It worked. Us going ahead so early in the 2nd half wasn't in the script, theirs & ours. Thought Richards played very well despite his 'jet-lag' coming back from the US.

Didn't think Eze was 'at it' today had a few good moments but, also had a few bad. Edouard took his goal well & is now on 5? Who'dve thought. Mateta is growing in confidence & at times looks a real threat, long may that continue. Ayew going off is a concern & how will Johnstone respond to treatment?

Also, don't forget we had a 'rookie' in the dugout, didn't do too bad imo. Some people are blaming(again) Mitchell for the 1st goal, maybe, but he didn't have any cover from Schlupp who i forgot was on the pitch. Doucoure does what he does & made a brilliant tackle/block. Hughes tired in second half but, was ok.

Anyhoo, that's just my opinion of the match.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 16 Sep 23 6.38pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I think solace can be taken in that we probably have exactly the number of points we might have expected after the games we have played.

They did say if we won it would’ve been our best ever premier league start!! Obviously football didn’t exist before the premier league when we had better starts in 1979 and 1991

 

HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 16 Sep 23 6.45pm

0-1 up with three minutes to go and lose 3-1….should be able to see that out. Melts.

 

terryriker Flag Newport Beach 16 Sep 23 7.04pm

My 5 thoughts on today’s loss
1) If Roy is on the touch line, we win this match.
2) Our squad depth is an issue, Ward at starting right back and Richards at back up center back will land us 14th.
3)Ayew’s grit was missed in the final 15
4) Eze wasn’t on the ball enough for me and when he was he was not as aggressive as I’d like.
5) Doucoure didn’t look himself with Lerma’s absence. Hughes had a good match but Cheick was sub par today.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Sep 23 7.08pm

Rubbish game management reminiscent of last season.

The penalty was not a penalty.

Next...

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 16 Sep 23 7.48pm

Originally posted by terryriker

My 5 thoughts on today’s loss
1) If Roy is on the touch line, we win this match.
2) Our squad depth is an issue, Ward at starting right back and Richards at back up center back will land us 14th.
3)Ayew’s grit was missed in the final 15
4) Eze wasn’t on the ball enough for me and when he was he was not as aggressive as I’d like.
5) Doucoure didn’t look himself with Lerma’s absence. Hughes had a good match but Cheick was sub par today.

Thought Doucoure had a great game - disagree with your 5
Even if Ayew hadn’t got injured, he would have been knackered in the last 15 as was most of the players. Missed Lerma big time and needed Hughes on the bench to be one of the quality players missing from the bench to come on for the last 15 / 20 minutes. Even your 4 in my opinion isn’t how I saw it. Thought Eze saw load of the ball but sadly was poor with it :-(
Definitely agree with 2 and our squad depth, especially with the injuries we have.
Biggest issue was not getting that killer 2nd goal and for me it was Eze that was the main culprit in that not happening today.
Mind you if the ref had done his job properly and not given the penalty we would have come out of it with a credible draw?

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 16 Sep 23 8.03pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I don't understand if the ref was so confident it was a penalty why it took him 5 minutes to decide? Surely if he was struggling to tell he doesn't give a penalty? A shame as 1-1 was probably a fair result.

We showed how limited our squad is outside the first 11 but we showed a lot of heart so I'm not going to complain too much, although we should really of finished the game off when we had the chance. The ref awarded Villa the win and we move on.

BTW, for the pedants out there, the penalty should have been retaken for encroachment according to the FA rules. I mean, they probably would have scored again, but the Palace players clearly pointed it out and VAR didn't intervene.


Agree with you there . There was clearly a Villa player in the box when the penalty was taken and should have been retaken , if Johnstone would have save it they would have check to make sure his feet were on the line . I also thought that VAR was brought in to rectify clear and obvious errors yet it took over 5 min of three of them and they still got it wrong . f***ing joke . The only thing clear and obvious to me is that the Ref and Var are inept , usless, currupt or just plain cheats , and how did that Villa manager not get booked for all the complaining he was doing Roy would have went full psycho on him .

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 16 Sep 23 8.10pm

Our lack of depth and quality in our squad is what cost us today. We put our strongest team out and Ayew went off after 20 minutes. The international break didn’t do us any favours whatsoever and we were on the back foot even before the 3 o’clock kick off.

Let’s move on and hopefully we can make amends against Fulham.

 

lagoseagle Flag Rotterdam 16 Sep 23 8.51pm

absolutely, because he is woefully short of PL standard and gets caught out in every game he plays.

Originally posted by eagleman13

Didn't take long for posters to start blaming Richards. FYI, Watkins kicked Richards on the back of the heel & in stumbling Richards then fouled Watkins. OK?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 16 Sep 23 8.53pm

Originally posted by terryriker

My 5 thoughts on today’s loss
1) If Roy is on the touch line, we win this match.
2) Our squad depth is an issue, Ward at starting right back and Richards at back up center back will land us 14th.
3)Ayew’s grit was missed in the final 15
4) Eze wasn’t on the ball enough for me and when he was he was not as aggressive as I’d like.
5) Doucoure didn’t look himself with Lerma’s absence. Hughes had a good match but Cheick was sub par today.


1) Nonsense
2) Correct until you mention Richards who has performed in every game he has been put in (He doesn't get any sold game time if he did we would see what he is really about)
3) He is important to us (shows again why we needed investment in the squad massive loses when these players are out)
4) Other teams know he is the main man for us so the bigger teams will cancel him out (Another example should have purchased other players for other options)
5) He did what he could and needs players around him to do work as well

The way we fell apart at the end was a disgrace and shows Ward is not correct captain it's people like him that should be setting example and screaming at people he doesn't (He is not this level anymore anyway again showing what a joke the squad is if he starts every week)

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 16 Sep 23 9.15pm

Originally posted by terryriker

My 5 thoughts on today’s loss
1) If Roy is on the touch line, we win this match.
2) Our squad depth is an issue, Ward at starting right back and Richards at back up center back will land us 14th.
3)Ayew’s grit was missed in the final 15
4) Eze wasn’t on the ball enough for me and when he was he was not as aggressive as I’d like.
5) Doucoure didn’t look himself with Lerma’s absence. Hughes had a good match but Cheick was sub par today.

1,2 4,5 absolute rubbish

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 16 Sep 23 9.18pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


1) Nonsense
2) Correct until you mention Richards who has performed in every game he has been put in (He doesn't get any sold game time if he did we would see what he is really about)
3) He is important to us (shows again why we needed investment in the squad massive loses when these players are out)
4) Other teams know he is the main man for us so the bigger teams will cancel him out (Another example should have purchased other players for other options)
5) He did what he could and needs players around him to do work as well

The way we fell apart at the end was a disgrace and shows Ward is not correct captain it's people like him that should be setting example and screaming at people he doesn't (He is not this level anymore anyway again showing what a joke the squad is if he starts every week)

Andersen is captain on the pitch and he should have the armband

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

NE14T Flag 16 Sep 23 9.29pm

I get so angry when we’re winning and our players stupidly think time wasting will help. It usually doesn’t. It just gives the TMO or ref excuse to add double time on. These players never learn but they aren’t very clever.

 


The beatings will stop when morale improves.

1969eagle Flag manchester 16 Sep 23 9.47pm

I thought Richards was excellent today and don’t know what he has to do to get a regular game (instead of ward). Eze will be a fine player one day but not until he stops wasting possession. We went toe to toe with a surprisingly poor villa team. Silenced villa park until last 10 mins and that worldie strike. Always miss ayew. Andersen couldn’t pass to save his life today!!!! Great to see edouard n mateta combining. Hughes is a great squad member and surely should be ahead of schlupp. Poor result but pretty damned good performance again

 

Den1923 Flag 16 Sep 23 10.02pm

Originally posted by 1969eagle

I thought Richards was excellent today and don’t know what he has to do to get a regular game (instead of ward). Eze will be a fine player one day but not until he stops wasting possession. We went toe to toe with a surprisingly poor villa team. Silenced villa park until last 10 mins and that worldie strike. Always miss ayew. Andersen couldn’t pass to save his life today!!!! Great to see edouard n mateta combining. Hughes is a great squad member and surely should be ahead of schlupp. Poor result but pretty damned good performance again


I not sure I would say it was a good performance when you are leading after 87 0-1 and end up losing 3-1 (albeit away) to a team that was below you in the league before today's game!

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 16 Sep 23 10.05pm

There has to be moments where contact with the ball and player are at exactly the same time and I feel this is what happened today, the ref easily could've said no pen ..we all know what MOTD will say though.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 16 Sep 23 10.20pm

Originally posted by palace chick

Glad someone else is brave enough to mention how awful Eze was today. Won’t work hard enough in midfield when we played two up top today? And yes to others picking up Mitchell on the first goal allowing the player to control and shoot :-(

Just back from the game.

Yes Eze was poor today. Undoubtedly an exceptional player but was way off it today. Misplaced passes, caught in possession or tackled numerous times and another glaring one on one miss that should’ve put us two nil up and the game to bed.

He wasn’t the only one guilty of misplaced passes and in the first half we gifted the ball back to Villa when we were well placed, time and time again.

Joel was back to being turned inside out again and gifted them an absolute sitter on 18 mins that Johnstone did brilliantly to keep out.

Richards did well but we missed Guehi…similarly Hughes did well but we missed Lerma.

Schlupp ineffective going forward and also him, Ward and Mitchell could not work out how to close down their wide players with Cash & Digne given way too much time and space. If anything I thought Schlupp looked like he was knackered from only 30 mins in.

Mateta did ok and provided a great early cross for our goal but his first touch lets him down far too often for a Premier League player.

Ultimately we paid the price for not being 2-0 up - Eze the main culprit but Ward also missed a sitter when an Andersen knock back put it on a plate for him. Then in the 87th minute some poor defending from Mitchell let Jhon Duran cushion the ball on his chest and get a shot off unchallenged. Why do we switch off like that and concede so many late and costly goals?!

I haven’t seen the penalty / VAR decision yet but Im prepared for MOTD to p*ss me off even more when I do see it.

Back full circle to my opening remark and the point I was responding to made by by palace chick, yes Eze is a great player but he’s not beyond reproach, especially when he has such a poor and error-strewn match such as today.

Edited by Phil’s Barber (16 Sep 2023 10.21pm)

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 16 Sep 23 10.21pm

Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker


Agree with you there . There was clearly a Villa player in the box when the penalty was taken and should have been retaken , if Johnstone would have save it they would have check to make sure his feet were on the line . I also thought that VAR was brought in to rectify clear and obvious errors yet it took over 5 min of three of them and they still got it wrong . f***ing joke . The only thing clear and obvious to me is that the Ref and Var are inept , usless, currupt or just plain cheats , and how did that Villa manager not get booked for all the complaining he was doing Roy would have went full psycho on him .

just corrupt, becoming more obvious every week

 

CT Charlie Flag 16 Sep 23 10.26pm

On the bright side, we were well organized despite Roy's absence. Except for Richards' almost being caught on the offside goal that was erased, he played well. (Not as well as Guehi, but few do.) Mitchell played his best game in recent memory – one stunning moment excepted. (To be fair, no one's perfect and the goal was near-perfect.)

As others have pointed out, losing Ayew so early put more pressure on Ward, who will be targeted throughout the season. With fresh legs, he remains stout. Stalwart. By the 60th minute, or after a run of games, he is inevitably vulnerable. In the future, we should be bringing Richards in for Ward in the final 20-25 minutes. What Richards lacks in confidence/experience, he'd make up for in pace and athleticism.

Lack of depth hurt us. Schlupp, Ward, Hughes, Edouard, Mateta – almost everyone, really – ran low on energy by the 75th minute. The ref ran low on energy, too. At the beginning of the match, he might been clear-headed enough to listen to VAR and reverse his call.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 16 Sep 23 10.56pm

And just to add, that was some of THE worst support for a Home team that I have ever seen.

No atmosphere from the home crowd, zero chanting to get behind their team and the only noise they did make was in the last few minutes once they had scored.

Truly pathetic support for virtually the entire match.

 

Page 8 of 13 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Aston Villa vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread