You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy Hodgson


Page 8 of 27 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 14 Dec 23 5.49pm

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

My concern presently is that Roy, like Pardew previously, is a pragmatic manager and may get "more slack" from the management like him in terms of change due to his stature at the club. That said Pardew had the FA cup run and more points in the bank than Roy, so his possible departure may come quicker.

I've never heard Pardew described as '' pragmatic ''. In fact I think he's the opposite.

There's a lot of speculation about Roy's position, which if you take results in isolation, is understandable. Look a little deeper and the wasted summer transfer window and the number of injuries to an already thin squad has lead to the current predicament.

Roy isn't perfect, and the way he is at the moment I suspect he wishes he had bowed out on a relative high at the end of last season. Instead he's been sold a pup by Freedman and Parish.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 14 Dec 23 5.57pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

I've never heard Pardew described as '' pragmatic ''. In fact I think he's the opposite.

There's a lot of speculation about Roy's position, which if you take results in isolation, is understandable. Look a little deeper and the wasted summer transfer window and the number of injuries to an already thin squad has lead to the current predicament.

Roy isn't perfect, and the way he is at the moment I suspect he wishes he had bowed out on a relative high at the end of last season. Instead he's been sold a pup by Freedman and Parish.

Definitely!! you couldn’t get managers with such a different approach, Pardew even said when he took over from Warnock he was taking the shackles off and was going to use the quality and pace we had going forward more i.e. Wilf. Pardews palace was the worst defensively since we’ve been promoted

Edited by monkey (14 Dec 2023 5.58pm)

 

PatrickA Flag London 14 Dec 23 7.44pm

There’s an interesting and extensive McArthur interview during which he discusses his Palace career.
In the interview he credits Pardew for changing Palace from perennial relegation strugglers in approach to a better footballing team willing to compete more offensively.
He credits the signing of Cabaye in particular.
Since Pardew career ended badly at Palace people tend to forget the decent period we had under him.
And look at the players he had - prime Zaha, Dann, Townsend, McArthur , Puncheon,Ward, Cabaye with contributions also from Bolassie, Wickham , Delaney , Jedinak and Sakho.
There’s an argument that squad was better than the current squad, certainly from an attacking standpoint.

Pardew’s career has gone downhill subsequently, and this is not a nostalgia trip to bring him back or anything as nonsensical as that.
It’s merely an observation that he wasn’t the disaster he’s often depicted to be.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 15 Dec 23 7.03am

Pardew had a 40% win record and for a while we were so exciting to watch, but that gradually became terrifying to watch. I really liked it when he was with us, but he clearly was limited as a manager and when the motivation wore off the cracks started to appear. That 5-4 loss to Swansea will live long in my nightmares!

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 15 Dec 23 8.49am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Pardew had a 40% win record and for a while we were so exciting to watch, but that gradually became terrifying to watch. I really liked it when he was with us, but he clearly was limited as a manager and when the motivation wore off the cracks started to appear. That 5-4 loss to Swansea will live long in my nightmares!

I think the big difference between Roy and Pards can be summed up by a standard1-0 loss under Roy vs a 5-4 loss under Pards. Both losses, both zero points, both net goal difference same, but exciting in one and invariably dull in the other. If you could bottle the best of both managers into one then maybe we will have found our future.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 15 Dec 23 9.25am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I think the big difference between Roy and Pards can be summed up by a standard1-0 loss under Roy vs a 5-4 loss under Pards. Both losses, both zero points, both net goal difference same, but exciting in one and invariably dull in the other. If you could bottle the best of both managers into one then maybe we will have found our future.

I think that's the issue. One lost the ability to have us doing the basics and the other has us doing exclusively the basics. Is a solid football team with a bit of flair/goalscoring threat not reliant upon a very limited number of individuals taking matters into their own hands such an impossible dream?

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

southnorwoodhill Flag 15 Dec 23 9.29am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I think the big difference between Roy and Pards can be summed up by a standard1-0 loss under Roy vs a 5-4 loss under Pards. Both losses, both zero points, both net goal difference same, but exciting in one and invariably dull in the other. If you could bottle the best of both managers into one then maybe we will have found our future.

Hodgson's park the bus tactics were responsible for some proper hammerings in his last stint thus exploding the myth surrounding him as a defensive tactical maestro - Man City, Liverpool, Villa all spring to mind. Others games with a big fat zero attempts on target. At least Pardew had a go.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (15 Dec 2023 9.40am)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 15 Dec 23 10.14am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I think that's the issue. One lost the ability to have us doing the basics and the other has us doing exclusively the basics. Is a solid football team with a bit of flair/goalscoring threat not reliant upon a very limited number of individuals taking matters into their own hands such an impossible dream?

You would hope not.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 15 Dec 23 10.42am

Outside of Eze, who was never meant for him anyway Hodgson has never had his squad expanded with anything other than the odd frees , one or two old hands like Cahill, some injury prones , and two or three not good enough to be in the Premier league . Hodgson has produced good attacking. teams when he had the players to do so, but if the opposition was so good he could never beat them that way, why would he try?
Last season everyone available ,Wilf for at least half of the time , the team produced some good attacking stuff. The opposition was lower end yes,, but ask Viera, if you can attack the big sides and get results . The answer is it didn’t happen with him, the squad Hodgson inherited, which is now weaker than then.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 15 Dec 23 11.40am

Sadly Hodgson is old school and can’t get us playing the way younger managers at our level now play. I guess that goes for Lewington as well. We are seeing a different style of play by teams like Luton and Bournemouth who we have played lately and then you have Fulham and Brentford and a host of other teams who play at an intensity going forward that we can’t do under our present management. It doesn’t help that Olise and Eza have hardly played together but even if they do they don’t have enough quality around them or on the bench presently. So, we have old school management and a thin squad. Bad news all around :-(

 

taylors lovechild Flag 15 Dec 23 12.22pm

During Roy's previous reign the fact the team was so passive and lacked movement was excused by the fact we had the oldest (and possibly slowest) squad in the PL. We now fall somewhere in the middle (in terms of average age), but in many games we still look quite slow and passive (Spurs being one of the most extreme examples). The Liverpool game was weird as it could be argued that it showed Roy is still up to it, or it could be questioned why has the team not performed like that in most of the other games this season.

Man City will be another scrap. That might actually suit our depleted squad in a way as we are not going to have the ball and the aim will be simple: stop them by any means. The bigger question will be on Thursday when fans are not going to accept a limp capitulation, regardless of any excuses about injuries. Lose then without a fight and all memories of the spirited display against Liverpool will soon dissipate. Get something from the next two games and the work on Roy's statue may resume, such is the fickleness of football these days.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 16 Dec 23 6.40am

Originally posted by palace chick

Sadly Hodgson is old school and can’t get us playing the way younger managers at our level now play. I guess that goes for Lewington as well. We are seeing a different style of play by teams like Luton and Bournemouth who we have played lately and then you have Fulham and Brentford and a host of other teams who play at an intensity going forward that we can’t do under our present management. It doesn’t help that Olise and Eza have hardly played together but even if they do they don’t have enough quality around them or on the bench presently. So, we have old school management and a thin squad. Bad news all around :-(

Very good post. These are the hard facts. We are being left behind. After Roy's latest deep rambling thoughts posted on the CPFC website, it's clearly time for him to go. He rally has cooked his goose. I also think our board are in a similar place.


Edited by dreamwaverider (16 Dec 2023 6.45am)

Edited by dreamwaverider (16 Dec 2023 6.48am)

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 16 Dec 23 6.52am

Here is the article

Attachment: Every word from Hodgson’s embargoed press conference - News - Crystal Palace F.C..html (575.71Kb)

 

taylors lovechild Flag 16 Dec 23 8.22am

Yes, so Roy has basically confirmed at the end of the season he's leaving Palace. No ambiguity in his statement. As much as I've moaned about him this season I really hope he turns things around and goes out on a high. His football might be miserable at times but we still have a lot to thank him for in bringing stability to the club.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 16 Dec 23 9.47am

I've said it before but I'll say it again.

Moaning about Roy is pointless.

It's the Board that brought him back in the full knowledge that his methods would probably ensure that he could keep the club in the Premier League with relatively limited resources at his disposal.

It's a shame that Roy agreed to it.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

southnorwoodhill Flag 16 Dec 23 10.33am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I've said it before but I'll say it again.

Moaning about Roy is pointless.

It's the Board that brought him back in the full knowledge that his methods would probably ensure that he could keep the club in the Premier League with relatively limited resources at his disposal.

It's a shame that Roy agreed to it.

Methinks that the board brought him back because they genuinely couldn't find anyone else as well as the reasons you state. I also think that had there been a different manager then there is strong likelihood that we wouldn't have as many injuries - the law of probabilities, different training methods, backroom staff etc.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (16 Dec 2023 10.45am)

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 16 Dec 23 10.59am

I think right time to Sack Roy (if deemed needed) is after the Chelsea game, 27th Dec then Paddy takes charge for one game 3 days later, then we have a 20 day break before our next league game, lets hope if deemed necessary we have spoken to or tapped up a replacement who has input into loans, buys and sales.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 16 Dec 23 11.24am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

I think right time to Sack Roy (if deemed needed) is after the Chelsea game, 27th Dec then Paddy takes charge for one game 3 days later, then we have a 20 day break before our next league game, lets hope if deemed necessary we have spoken to or tapped up a replacement who has input into loans, buys and sales.

You forgot the FA Cup 3rd round v Everton, Thurs 4th Jan, so, 16 days Lanzo?

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Putitout Flag Oxford 16 Dec 23 11.52am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I've said it before but I'll say it again.

Moaning about Roy is pointless.

It's the Board that brought him back in the full knowledge that his methods would probably ensure that he could keep the club in the Premier League with relatively limited resources at his disposal.

It's a shame that Roy agreed to it.

Couldn’t agree more. No idea why the board did it. And no idea why he took it, because one thing he isn’t, is not experienced enough, and tuned in enough to know, full well ,there was little chance to get through a season, with a squad thinner than it had been the previous season. Not saying they conned him, but I do think that he suffers for absence of anything promised.
People can and do take easy cracks at him, But no manager would have had an easy ride under these conditions. It’s an. Absolute joke if the board or anyone else thought that the team would not be constantly plagued with injuries , given the present playing conditions at this level it’s a given every club has to deal with it. Can’t think of another team so poorly set up to deal with it. I don’t think Hodgson would have just waked into this , unless he seriously thought ,or was led to believe it would not be the case..

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 16 Dec 23 12.02pm

Originally posted by Putitout

Couldn’t agree more. No idea why the board did it. And no idea why he took it, because one thing he isn’t, is not experienced enough, and tuned in enough to know, full well ,there was little chance to get through a season, with a squad thinner than it had been the previous season. Not saying they conned him, but I do think that he suffers for absence of anything promised.
People can and do take easy cracks at him, But no manager would have had an easy ride under these conditions. It’s an. Absolute joke if the board or anyone else thought that the team would not be constantly plagued with injuries , given the present playing conditions at this level it’s a given every club has to deal with it. Can’t think of another team so poorly set up to deal with it. I don’t think Hodgson would have just waked into this , unless he seriously thought ,or was led to believe it would not be the case..

Ask yourself the same question when he went to Watford after saying he was calling it a day. Addicted, obsessed, hooked into the daily routine. Or the lure of easy £££££££££££.

 

Page 8 of 27 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson