This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Quote Petealiator at 07 Jan 2005 10:00pm
Right then, first of all, it's far from proved that Africa is the cradle of mankind, it's even looking doubtful that mankind even originated from the same frickin species of ape let alone the same frickin continent, so you're clutching at pretty dodgy looking straws there Sethybabes me ole mucker! But what's all this cobblers got to do with the argument? My argument is that us Brits have a pretty damned rich culture that is being denied by the left-wingers and slowly subjugated and swamped by foreign culture. Your argument seems to be that we actually have no culture of our own and any we may happen to have stumbled across by chance is just a mish-mash of foreign cultures anyway and not only that, we're all black and come from Africa! YEAH! RIGHTO! Anyway, the Romans were indeed made up of people from all over the place, but so what? There is a s***-load of doubt that Britain was actually even conquered by Rome, but that's another argument, the point is, by the time Rome was being sacked, Britain had long-forgotten the Romans. The Britons instantly reverted back to their way of life and culture the moment the last hobnail boot was marching up the gang-plank. I can't argue against Severus and wouldn’t anyway (although his friend Plautianus might), he certainly was a black man, but again so what? How does Severus being black detract from my argument that Britain has a unique culture? Neither Rome, nor Severus had any lasting impact on British culture whatsoever. Yes of course there has been many documented cases of dark-skinned people coming to these shores since time out of mind, but so what? What's your point? Are you saying an Island of proud Germanic warrior-like people was in anyway greatly influenced by a handful of traders and travellers from warmer climes? Palestine had many regular visitors from mainland Europe a thousand years ago or so, they were known as Crusaders, they built castles. The first King of Jerusalem was French if my memory serves me right, so are you saying that Palestinians enjoy a rich culture heavily influenced by the French, English and Germans? Don't make me laugh! Why can't you lot just accept that Britain DOES have a rich culture and DID have a rich culture long before the introduction of Chicken Madras and Beef Chow Mein? Why can't you just accept that we do have a culture worth preserving? It’s not a crime! It wouldn’t make you a Nazi ya know! Is the British way of life and British culture really under threat? Ask the people of Bradford. Luton. Birmingham. Manchester. I could go on. And on. And on.
I have seen plenty of evidence in print and in documentaries which proves that humans originated in Africa and I provided links to reputable sources such as the BBC. Can you do the same? You have obviously done a lot of research on the subject, but it would be interesting to know where you're getting your information from. You make many assertions which aren't backed up by any evidence in references or links, such as "Britons instantly reverted back to their way of life and culture the moment the last hobnail boot was marching up the gang-plank", and "Neither Rome, nor Severus had any lasting impact on British culture whatsoever". You said that the Romans were "of European origin", which they clearly all weren't, as the Severus example demonstrates. And there were many more black Romans, and other non-Europeans throughout history who came here and influenced our culture in more ways that you acknowledge. Here's a reference: [Link] Can you divulge your sources, such as links or a bibliography?
"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down" |
|
|
I aint discounting the 'Out Of Africa' theory, I'm just saying that all theoretical movements are shrouded in doubt and so we also shouldn't discount the 'Out Of Europe' theory either. And the same must be said for the 'Apeman' theory. The only FACT is that we just don't know and we probably never will, so to point blank state that we were all black and came from Africa is at best an educated guess! IT IS UNPROVEN! So I don't know how Sethybabes has managed to find this 'Proof' of his. It's the usual response from the left though; ignore all questions posed. Fail to admit that Britain has it's own unique culture AGAIN! Respond with "Yeah but no but yeah but.." Seth, my knowledge on s*** is formed by reading books and watching documentaries. Yes I could sit here for hours on end searching the net for links that substantiate my argument - which is simply that Britain has a culture of it's own - but I aint gonna coz I've got better things to do with my time mate. I could give you a link to a site that still believes the world's flat, it proves nothing at all. You could point me to some professor's site that proves 'Out Of Africa', but I could point you at some professor’s site the proves 'Out Of Peckham', THERE IS NO PROOF! To be honest, I find it laughable that you feel I need to link sources that prove Britain has a culture of it's own, that's f***ing incredible! Why do the left hate Britain so much? Why are you so ashamed of your own people? Your inability to accept that the Britons returned to their way of life following the departure of Rome's influence tells me you know nothing or very little of the history of Britain. THIS IS FACT MATE! I don't even know why you'd even throw doubt on such a well documented era of British history, go to the library mate, whatever, it's fact. Another fact; the Roman's ARE of European origin ya fool, where the f*** d'ya think Rome is? You DO know that Rome is the cradle of the Roman Empire right? You DO know Italy is in Europe right? Rome's origins lie in Europe, GET OVER IT! Seth says "Yeah but no but yeah but no..."
My Rocksteady band... |
|
|
Quote tetley at 07 Jan 2005 11:29pm
i have to say i'm with seth on this one. and there's nothing wrong with posting a message of support when he has ha so much mud slung at him. at the same time though, pete is right. we should be proud of our culture. I think we all are, but that doesn't mean that we can discount the majority of historical and evolutionary evidence that supports the 'out of africa' theory.
"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down" |
|
|
Phew, bet you've both got finger ache after that short debate !
There's no sun, the shadow of the wizard....... |
|
|
Well ok then. But before this discussion ends, I must pull you up on a point or two. "Well Britain didn't even exist as a nation until relatively recently. Before then it was a loose collection of different tribes and kingdoms, made up of widely different peoples with their own cultures, who no doubt intermingled and fought in equal measure. I believe these groupings influenced each other and also absorbed influences from other parts of the world (not just Europe) through trade and travel." Britain has existed for over two thousand years as an isle of differing tribes belonging to the same racial group, certainly not the ‘widely different people’ you describe. Two-thousand years ago, the people of Britain were what modern day historians like to generically call 'Celtic' and they lived on an isle known as 'Britain'. ‘Britain’ and indeed ‘Great Britain’ has never existed as one ‘nation’, but a collection of nations and tribes. So what? I know that. What’s your point? I’m an Englishman living on the isle of Britain. My history, my culture is tied in with that of Scotland, Ireland and Wales. I’m English. I’m British. I’m proud of both. The culture of England is heavily influenced by the culture of the people of Ireland, Scotland and Wales and I would stand and fight to preserve the culture of Ireland, Scotland and Wales just as vehemently as I would my own. Like it or not, we are still part of the Union, and what is happening here is also happening in Scotland and Wales and to a lesser degree in Ireland. "Therefore, what we see as British culture today is the result of thousands of years of cultural evolution and change, as different peoples mingled, interbred, fought and generally did the things people do. Culture isn't static and frozen, but a continuously changing and evolving melange of language, literature, storytelling, war, traditions and many other factors. Just like language, culture never stops evolving and thats why I don't accept the concept of a permanent, static culture which is now under threat." Yes, culture does evolve, but certain main aspects always remain and those aspects define a nation and a people and must be preserved. If any culture is left to degenerates into what you describe as a ‘mish-mash’, you end up with a wishy-washy dustbin full of people devoid of identity (see the USA). "Britishness will continue to evolve and change as different influences are absorbed and adapted. And nowhere have I said I hate Britain or that I'm not proud of it (although I see myself as more English that British and aren't particularly fond of "The Union", but that's another argument)." I have nothing against other cultures influencing my own, I just will not tolerate my own culture disrespected, denied or swamped. "What I said about Romans was that they weren't ALL European." I know that, but I wasn't talking about ALL Romans, I was talking about ROME and the empire's origins, not it's minions. If someone makes foolish statements of 'proof', when clearly none exists to bolster a shaky argument, in my book they're either foolish or lying. I chose not to call you a liar Seth. Edited by Petealiator (08 Jan 2005 3:27pm)
My Rocksteady band... |
|
|
Ok, foolish statements... "All homo sapiens originated in Africa so it depends how far you want to take it back. We're all descended from black people, even those you state are of 'European origin'". Sorry mate but that's just a theory (one of many about the origins of man) which you choose to believe coz it suits you. NOT fact at all! "I have seen plenty of evidence in print and in documentaries which proves that humans originated in Africa" No you haven't Seth! "You said that the Romans were "of European origin", which they clearly all weren't" Yes Seth, they were! "Well Britain didn't even exist as a nation until relatively recently." No Seth, Britain hase NEVER existed as a nation! "Before then it was a loose collection of different tribes and kingdoms, made up of widely different peoples" Wrong again mate, they were all Celtic tribes and not widely different at all!
My Rocksteady band... |
|
|
"Did they all call themselves Celts?" No of course they didn't, they had their own tribal names, as I said, 'Celtic' is a generic modern day term to group together a group of people of the same racial group. They are described as 'Britons' by Roman scribes of the time, so one would assume that that is what they were known as so consequently, knew themselves to be. "Did they call Britain, "Britain"? Or are these names given since?" Britain has had it's name (or variants of it) for over two-thousand years. There's a theory that it stems from Brutus and if this is correct, then the name is closer to three thousand years old. "Did they speak the same language," Yes they did. What we call today 'Celtic'. "have the same traditions, eat the same food, worship the same gods," Yes of course they did! They were all Celts, they all lived on the same island, ate the same food worshiped the same pagan gods! Other than the Iceni of course, who it seems enjoyed a nice Chicken Madras, worshipped Buddha and were all black! "have the same rulers?" Don't be silly, they had their own tribal leaders. "To me, that means they were widely different" Well no Seth, it doesn't really does it! THAT'S IT! END OF ARGUMENT! NO MORE!
My Rocksteady band... |
|
|
Ok mate, it's a good subject to research, I love ancient British History, it's fascinating, the so-called dark ages are my particular favourite era, along with the Anglo-Saxon period. I hope you enjoy your research. I'm no expert on languages but I believe you'll find that there are two main branches of Celtic language which are the same language with regional dialectical differences, apparently they're: Goedelic or Gaelic (Irish, Scots Gaelic, Manx), and the Brythonic (Welsh, Cornish, and Breton). Laters Sethybabes, I've got some ale to shift!
My Rocksteady band... |
|
|
Very interesting boys, I haven't understood a fcuking word!!
|
|
|
Very true Marco, isn't Patel in the phone book more times than even Smith and Brown? And thats not recent been like it for years.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.