This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Matov
As you lot speculate on what happened in New York on September 11th, the reaction it spurred in terms of the invasion of Afghanistan and the removal of the Taleban is probably going to lead to, and potentially on the 20th anniversary of the heinous events, concluding with the Taleban back in charge of Kabul. Over 500 British lives, and numerous more injured and maimed, along with thousands of our allies also dying, for what? Sweet f*** All. Apart from a load of arms manufacturers getting richer and no doubt another migrant crisis as Afghans decide, and with perfect justification, to get the hell out of dodge and seek out a better life abroad.
But why this current f***-up has been allowed to play out is the real conspiracy. The US capitulating to a load of f***-heads in flip-flops and driving around on motor-bikes. I do hate to lecture but seriously, if you want to don the tin-foil hats, focus on this. Because we are all being screwed over big time. Over 500 British service personnel dead for nothing. Absolutely wasted lives. And now, unreal barbarity about to engulf millions once more. Iraq, Libya, Afghanistan. All massive f*** ups. And for what? Who gains from this s***? Edited by Matov (12 Aug 2021 10.05pm) A lot of what you say here is spot on, Matov. And by chance they're also the ones who "gain from this s**t" !
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
I'll sound a little conspiracy minded myself, but I certainly do think that the military industrial complex is very real, and that there are conveyor belts that are far from eager to slow. Maybe world events have thrown a spanner in these particular works but there are certainly huge industries interested in endless war come what may, and the rights and wrongs of any conflict are infinity less relevant to them than their bottom line and keeping the wheels turning. As the middle east has often been on the receiving end (and our repeated 'mission accomplished' is always anything but) I really don't see that we've ever helped them our ourselves, simply put trillions into pockets of those who have no real interest inhumanity, or allegiance beyond their own bank balance and ability to influence. They have the ear, and often the twisted arm of those in power, and so help craft so many of the narratives we've all bought into over the years, to the detriment of ourselves and others. Edited by BlueJay (12 Aug 2021 11.11pm) Good post, BlueJay.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lombardinho
I agree with you in that it would be a tough one to pull off.
If you wanted a war in the middle east there are far easier....and more importantly far less risky ways. Over twenty years of Wikileaks and nothing. The domestic attack doesn't hold true for me and all I ever found for it was speculation. For example, one of the contentions is that building 7 was destroyed because it held sensitive information by intelligence agencies......But what's so hard about taking a hammer to a hard drive? If you want to get rid of data on computerised system that isn't copied then you can remove that physical storage and destroy it. As a computing teacher I can tell you there are far easier methods than knocking buildings down. But as always, if there is any compelling information available that alters this view, I will always listen to it. Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Aug 2021 11.35pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Lombardinho
Good post, BlueJay. Cheers pal!
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
The lift shafts were not solid poured concrete. They were block work. This also contributed to the collapse as these cores are a major player in a buildings strength. If you watch a building going up these are generally the first structures. With respect I beleive this wasn't an inside job and a genuine terror attack. Fair do's, cryrst.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
I'll sound a little conspiracy minded myself, but I certainly do think that the military industrial complex is very real, and that there are conveyor belts that are far from eager to slow. Maybe world events have thrown a spanner in these particular works but there are certainly huge industries interested in endless war come what may, and the rights and wrongs of any conflict are infinity less relevant to them than their bottom line and keeping the wheels turning. As the middle east has often been on the receiving end (and our repeated 'mission accomplished' is always anything but) I really don't see that we've ever helped them our ourselves, simply put trillions into pockets of those who have no real interest inhumanity, or allegiance beyond their own bank balance and ability to influence. They have the ear, and often the twisted arm of those in power, and so help craft so many of the narratives we've all bought into over the years, to the detriment of ourselves and others.
I'd agree that the 'military industrial complex', is a label that constitutes a mindset within powerful positions that isn't a neutral entity on the world stage.....in other words it isn't just about money and corporations. The wars it's interested follow the interests of the big money funders within the system.....when you look at what the politicians say it's in the interests of who funds them. If we look at who these wars have been against, and who the US sets itself up against as either friend or enemy in that region....it follows a distinct pattern and is in the interests of one particular middle eastern country that certainly has very powerful representation in America.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I'd agree that the 'military industrial complex', is a label that constitutes a mindset within powerful positions that isn't a neutral entity on the world stage.....in other words it isn't just about money and corporations. The wars it's interested follow the interests of the big money funders within the system.....when you look at what the politicians say it's in the interests of who funds them. Certainly. What's most concerning is that politicians are remarkably easy to get on board by way of 'donations', and I expect a significant number are also compromised (which in part speaks to the level of influence that Israel manages to wield - even though there are other factors of course). The system itself elevates those who are corrupt and compromised because they are useful and a way into influencing decisions where a couple of votes one way or another can make a major difference. Anyone with integrity in politics I expect is either spat out, or will gradually inadvertently make enough small compromises to get things done, that they eventually get absorbed into the same broken system. Broken in terms of us I mean, I'm sure it works great for them
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Certainly. What's most concerning is that politicians are remarkably easy to get on board by way of 'donations', and I expect a significant number are also compromised (which in part speaks to the level of influence that Israel manages to wield - even though there are other factors of course). The system itself elevates those who are corrupt and compromised because they are useful and a way into influencing decisions where a couple of votes one way or another can make a major difference. Anyone with integrity in politics I expect is either spat out, or will gradually inadvertently make enough small compromises to get things done, that they eventually get absorbed into the same broken system. Broken in terms of us I mean, I'm sure it works great for them
I couldn't have put it better myself.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Lombardinho
Fair do's, cryrst. So George Bush or someone at the top must have paid 20 individuals to kill themselves,passengers and 1000s more in the towers to conceal evidence. Alongside knowing exactly how to dismember the said towers in such a way as to fall directly onto another building so destroying it and everything inside. Wouldn't a gas explosion have been easier?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I differ with you a bit here. You say those soldiers died for nothing. I disagree with that on two counts. Firstly, within that 1800 hundred odd 55 British died that day and in my book that meant there was a blood price to pay....that's how I think of it certainly. Secondly, the word soldier doesn't have include the words sold and die for nothing. I come from a military family and the risk of death when you sign up is a small but real part of the package. If you're infanty you are literally the tip of the spear with the primary point of your job to learn how to effectively kill people or be killed. I'm not heartless but 500 soldiers over twenty years isn't even ten minutes of the Somme. And as I said, the number of deaths we took is down to idealistic political decisions from both Bush and Blair. Their Disney land neo con ideas about changing that deeply Islamic country into a western supporting democracy reveals the complete foolery of the modern politician. I'll agree with you on this.....we wasted lives staying there...and that is on their poor judgment, that's for certain. The ideal of wiping the Taleban from the face of the earth was a good one then and a good one now. But those lives have been wasted if, some 20 years later, the Taleban are not only back in power but probably stronger for it. Beat the Russians and now the almighty West. Under Trump, Islamic fundamentalism suffered a massive blow when IS were wiped out. Within less than a year of Biden stealing the election, Islamic fundamentalism has received its biggest boost ever. And it is huge. IS were only ever, a best, a bunch of fanatics who crumbled under air-attacks and the Syrian Army. It's more than conceivable that within the next 5 years the Taleban will be offered a seat at the UN. China are already saying that will recognize its legitimate right to govern. Every Islamic fundamentalist in the world will be able to look at Afghanistan and take great strength from it. And they will be right to do so. That is the point. Plus creating a massive stream of refugees, all of whom have a perfectly legitimate reason to flee. And I hope they make it here in their hundreds of thousands. The UK deserves to pay a price for its part in this f*** up.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Is this the same Taliban that we treated as heroes when they were fighting the Russians?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
The ideal of wiping the Taleban from the face of the earth was a good one then and a good one now. But those lives have been wasted if, some 20 years later, the Taleban are not only back in power but probably stronger for it. Beat the Russians and now the almighty West. Under Trump, Islamic fundamentalism suffered a massive blow when IS were wiped out. Within less than a year of Biden stealing the election, Islamic fundamentalism has received its biggest boost ever. And it is huge. IS were only ever, a best, a bunch of fanatics who crumbled under air-attacks and the Syrian Army. It's more than conceivable that within the next 5 years the Taleban will be offered a seat at the UN. China are already saying that will recognize its legitimate right to govern. Every Islamic fundamentalist in the world will be able to look at Afghanistan and take great strength from it. And they will be right to do so. That is the point. Plus creating a massive stream of refugees, all of whom have a perfectly legitimate reason to flee. And I hope they make it here in their hundreds of thousands. The UK deserves to pay a price for its part in this f*** up.
From all I can sense, although Taliban culture is centuries behind ours, cruel and oppressive, they are not like ISIS. Not yet anyway. They restrict their activities to their own area and don't appear to have offshoots elsewhere. ISIS may have been muted, but Islamic fundamentalism has not been killed. It will continue to resurface whilst the funding to support it remains intact. So surely the way to deal with this is to try to reduce their access to the funds needed to facilitate their activities? Which it seems comes primarily from Saudi. Trump had no part in "wiping out" ISIS! The best you can say is that the Joint Chiefs managed to stop him withdrawing too early. The Biden administration is clearly following a different approach. It's too early to even know what other elements to that approach may be, let alone whether it will succeed, but if the USA is tired of constant wars which fail, then adopting a new strategy is at least not just repeating failure.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
The irony of the situation here is that whilst all the exaggerated allegations by the progressive ultra-liberals about Trump being a sexist, racist, fascist have assisted Biden into office. This has now resulted in 40million Afghans having their burgeoning democracy taken away from them by a group of extreme religious fanatics who are sexist, racist, fascists who will now repress them for decades. Whilst my assumption his conjecture - I cannot imagine Trump pulling troops out of the country if there was a risk of the Afghan Government collapsing. His ego wouldn't allow it. Biden has blood on his hands, including all those soldiers who have now given their life for no reason. Our society is likely likely to be at a much greater risk because of this. Granted but Trump has been thoroughly duped just as much here. Uncle Sam and his dollar did for them and exposed their moral bankruptcy. They would even believe that a terror organisation funded by crime and opium could be a responsible government. If you made it attractive enough to them.
|
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
The irony of the situation here is that whilst all the exaggerated allegations by the progressive ultra-liberals about Trump being a sexist, racist, fascist have assisted Biden into office. This has now resulted in 40million Afghans having their burgeoning democracy taken away from them by a group of extreme religious fanatics who are sexist, racist, fascists who will now repress them for decades. Whilst my assumption his conjecture - I cannot imagine Trump pulling troops out of the country if there was a risk of the Afghan Government collapsing. His ego wouldn't allow it. Biden has blood on his hands, including all those soldiers who have now given their life for no reason. Our society is likely likely to be at a much greater risk because of this. He did pull out of Syria and left the pkk, who had defeated isis in the theatre, the real heroes, to face the might of the Turkish army, after all they had done for us-and trump!And the majority of Americans don"t want any more U.S soldiers dying abroad-ironically most vocal in the deep south, Trumps states- go to bama and they are mad to get out of Afghanistan.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Is this the same Taliban that we treated as heroes when they were fighting the Russians? The very same. We know (or care) so little about the the culture and politics of these countries that government can paint whatever face on any conflict they're gearing up to, and enough of the public typically buy into it to get it over the line. Though nowadays I do sense a war fatigue in that people realise that none of these conflicts or occupations ever really lead anywhere that benefits us.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
The ideal of wiping the Taleban from the face of the earth was a good one then and a good one now. But those lives have been wasted if, some 20 years later, the Taleban are not only back in power but probably stronger for it. Beat the Russians and now the almighty West. Under Trump, Islamic fundamentalism suffered a massive blow when IS were wiped out. Within less than a year of Biden stealing the election, Islamic fundamentalism has received its biggest boost ever. And it is huge. IS were only ever, a best, a bunch of fanatics who crumbled under air-attacks and the Syrian Army. It's more than conceivable that within the next 5 years the Taleban will be offered a seat at the UN. China are already saying that will recognize its legitimate right to govern. Every Islamic fundamentalist in the world will be able to look at Afghanistan and take great strength from it. And they will be right to do so. That is the point. Plus creating a massive stream of refugees, all of whom have a perfectly legitimate reason to flee. And I hope they make it here in their hundreds of thousands. The UK deserves to pay a price for its part in this f*** up. Yep depressing isn't it. I wouldn't be surprised if what most of what you say there ends up becoming true....essentially Neo liberalism failed. I even think that today modern politicians understand that and are moving towards the more authoritarian western form of the Chinese social credit system (which is a form of Chinese facism) as a way of controlling the highly fragmented societies that liberalism has stupidly created both on class and tribal lines. Back after 9/11 It's neo con elites believed that because neo liberalism killed religion in the west and turned its population of genetic Europeans into consumerist zombies, who are principally only interested in materialism and hedonistic self interested thinking that the same process can be globally transported into poor religious and culturally very different countries. That's what liberal idealism does....a fundamental lack of understanding of human nature and environment that ends up killing people.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Granted but Trump has been thoroughly duped just as much here. Uncle Sam and his dollar did for them and exposed their moral bankruptcy. They would even believe that a terror organisation funded by crime and opium could be a responsible government. If you made it attractive enough to them.
I think whether you agreed with him or not the Trump that went into office was a very different one to the Trump that left it. Whoever enters that position is quickly caged by the system which has far more collective power than a president. Trump started by saying at his inauguration that he would be 'carnage' to the system...Bannon's words....but instead a year in he fired Bannon and look what happened. He ended up trying to please the very system that hated him.....completely lost his balls. That said, Trump, even though he was a pathological liar (similar to his critics) was far more realistic about what was possible both in foreign policy and the economy. The orange man was a far better president that his moronic opposition that for sure. The Democrats are a complete disaster zone on everything they touch. Aside from what I regard as abuse from everything they believe in regarding gender and sexuality.....That child sniffing Biden made commitments on taking office like he would solve Covid and that the economy would improve. Well, over a year in and Inflation is now at 5.4 percent, his economic policies are adding massively to the debt and unemployment is at huge levels. Biden canceled the US pipeful in his first week, which would have given them energy independence and is now begging foreign oil suppliers to raise production.....Biden said he had a plan over covid but that has been about as effective as his son's laptop security.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Wondering what the political price for Biden will be. The prospect of increased terrorism in the USA, he must be responsible if it happens. What an a*****le he has turned out to be.
I've been saying for some time that the best outcome for America is peaceful separation into two. Without it, I'm fairly certain there will be blood and separation anyway.....or forced union.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.