You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread
November 21 2026 11.30am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Holmesdale Fanatics thread


Page 85 of 122 < 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 >
spartakev2 Flag Anerley 16 Sep 18 9.33am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Why did we even bother then? Why did we bother with supporting our promotion run? Why did we bother supporting the Pulis team THAT MUCH? They would’ve done it without us anyway? Same for most of the other seasons the summer shenanigans started us in the drop zone? Actually why don’t we just watch Prem football on the laptop? We don’t provide anything that tv money doesn’t so why?

Do the players and managers agree with you? Doubtful. As I said, the aim is to improve on that. Having a mute home atmosphere isn’t what I’d call a help. Maybe I’m wrong, along with Hodgson and any other previous manager, players and current players that comment on the contrary to you.

Or is it because the longer we’re here in the Prem the more we take it for granted, expectation, apathy, etc etc, because it now shows without the catalyst for noise there won’t be any the management and players value. Are we big time already and a mainstay in this league?

If the HF are that important, then they're really letting thd club down by sulking. If what you're worried about happens, then they could get their way next season when we are in the Championship. Great fans.

 

Ecopalace Flag Wickham 16 Sep 18 9.38am

I think your taking it to personally, I’m merely stating the facts. There’s more to football than winning, it’s about the experience, the passion, the enjoyment, the atmosphere etc, etc... and with this group of amazing palace fans we get that in abundance. You are sorely missed and I really hope this gets resolved quickly as we have the best atmosphere in the league with this group in place providing joy to many. However someone stated that it’s what’s kept us in the premiership, I think this statement cannot be backed up with our record.


Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Why did we even bother then? Why did we bother with supporting our promotion run? Why did we bother supporting the Pulis team THAT MUCH? They would’ve done it without us anyway? Same for most of the other seasons the summer shenanigans started us in the drop zone? Actually why don’t we just watch Prem football on the laptop? We don’t provide anything that tv money doesn’t so why?

Do the players and managers agree with you? Doubtful. As I said, the aim is to improve on that. Having a mute home atmosphere isn’t what I’d call a help. Maybe I’m wrong, along with Hodgson and any other previous manager, players and current players that comment on the contrary to you.

Or is it because the longer we’re here in the Prem the more we take it for granted, expectation, apathy, etc etc, because it now shows without the catalyst for noise there won’t be any the management and players value. Are we big time already and a mainstay in this league?

 

Username Flag Horsham 16 Sep 18 1.46pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Isn’t the aim to improve it, so home form is better than away form and you’re not relying on counter attacks, breakaway goals, smash and grab victories, things like that? Or we could test the hypothesis that home support doesn’t matter, even though management and players say it does, until we have a real test of a season in the bottom 3, which shouldn’t be too far off given our size, Wilf may be off, etc etc. So we could be taking something away from a team in trouble or not maximising efforts in better seasons.

If you ask supporters around the Premier league, they’ll say football needs more atmosphere like ours, and now we have none. The only people who say it doesn’t apart from here and now are Arsenal fans when we annoy them with constant singing and support at the Emirates.

Not showing up is an odd way to go about improving it though.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Terry Ven Flag 17 Sep 18 12.12pm

Has any of yous lot seen some of the names sining the petishion??? I reckon theres loads of fake ones in there. We cant have that many fans called nigel can we?

 

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 17 Sep 18 12.31pm

Originally posted by fan

let me make this clear I sit in Block E and have done so since 1995 and I am NOT moving. There is solution to all of this the HF came about because they were near to the away fans and loved the banter. Move the away fans back to their original place and the HF will all want to go back to Block B. Simples!!!

I can’t believe this thread is still going. Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

As ticket holders have said, they are not moving so unless the the fanatics return to bloke B, they ain’t coming back. #moveon

Also, if the stadium is a square/circle. Surely it doesn’t matter where you sit to generate noise around the ground????

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 17 Sep 18 12.39pm

When the HF return :

The stadium atmosphere improves.
Roy is given valuable input into tactics and substitutions.
Palace play better and get more points.
The catering improves.
We would be contenders for a top six finish.
Trump will be impeached.
Israel will accept a 2-state solution based on 1970 boundaries.
This thread will finally die

what is there not to like ?

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Midlands Eagle Flag 17 Sep 18 12.48pm

Originally posted by Terry Ven

Has any of yous lot seen some of the names sining the petishion??? I reckon theres loads of fake ones in there. We cant have that many fans called nigel can we?

There are probably considerably more fake ones that genuine signatures including most of NSC who have admitted trying to foul things up

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 17 Sep 18 1.30pm

Originally posted by dorking

[Link]

Doesn't look elitist IMO. Looks like multiple supporters groups backing the inclusive proposal.

2K people liked the HF statement on twitter

Nearly 5k signed the petition.

I have to admire the HF's determination to not give up with this.

I hope the club will take notice and investigate what is feasible, bearing in mind people have come forward and said they would be willing to move to help make it happen.


Agreed, i think it unwise to consider the HF fools. They are clearly more than just youngsters jumping about and waving flags, banging a drum.

I think this will get more interesting, and is probably the wake up call that the clubs hierarchy needed, in that the fans 'own' the club and they're just custodians.

There's a place for both those wanting to sit and those wanting to stand, the latter migrating towards seating when age dictates; but we need the atmosphere to continually attract fans young and old alike if the club is to keep moving forward.

I wonder how many of those in the block behind the goal are 50+ (purely out of interest) and have simply become used to sitting, waiting to be entertained as the article from the Independent suggests...I thought it was a good article and not far off of the mark.

Ultimately, if the club see fit to kick ANY OF US out of our seats for a re-shuffle there's nothing (that I know of) that can stop them. Is anyone aware of anything to the contrary?

So realistically, is upsetting a few of those in the short term for the continued progression of attracting young fans and developing an atmosphere (that on the whole) benefits the club and the team a bad thing?

Or is it just the way it's been handled that wrankles with people?

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 17 Sep 18 1.42pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


Agreed, i think it unwise to consider the HF fools. They are clearly more than just youngsters jumping about and waving flags, banging a drum.

I think this will get more interesting, and is probably the wake up call that the clubs hierarchy needed, in that the fans 'own' the club and they're just custodians.

There's a place for both those wanting to sit and those wanting to stand, the latter migrating towards seating when age dictates; but we need the atmosphere to continually attract fans young and old alike if the club is to keep moving forward.

I wonder how many of those in the block behind the goal are 50+ (purely out of interest) and have simply become used to sitting, waiting to be entertained as the article from the Independent suggests...I thought it was a good article and not far off of the mark.

Ultimately, if the club see fit to kick ANY OF US out of our seats for a re-shuffle there's nothing (that I know of) that can stop them. Is anyone aware of anything to the contrary?

So realistically, is upsetting a few of those in the short term for the continued progression of attracting young fans and developing an atmosphere (that on the whole) benefits the club and the team a bad thing?

Or is it just the way it's been handled that wrankles with people?

That's the funniest thing I've heard for a long time.

Your post tbh is ridiculous. You want to kick 50+ year olds who've supported the club for decades, out of their seats, because they sit and don't sing all the time, so that we can attract a younger crowd. My God, I've heard it all now.

 

dave4343palace Flag Copthorne 17 Sep 18 1.56pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

That's the funniest thing I've heard for a long time.

Your post tbh is ridiculous. You want to kick 50+ year olds who've supported the club for decades, out of their seats, because they sit and don't sing all the time, so that we can attract a younger crowd. My God, I've heard it all now.

Agreed. The thought of being kicked out of my seat of 30 years in the Arthur doesn't bear thinking about, whatever the reason.

 


George Courtney, the World Cup referee, everyone is looking at him. When will he blow....?

Pompyeagle Flag Gosport Hants 17 Sep 18 2.12pm

I have supported Palace now for 60 years and I will continue to do so with or without the HF,

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Sep 18 2.26pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

That's the funniest thing I've heard for a long time.

Your post tbh is ridiculous. You want to kick 50+ year olds who've supported the club for decades, out of their seats, because they sit and don't sing all the time, so that we can attract a younger crowd. My God, I've heard it all now.

You’d prefer not encouraging/attracting younger fans and more of them, or as many as possible? That is how the club grows over time, no other way.

 


COYP

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 17 Sep 18 2.29pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

You’d prefer not encouraging/attracting younger fans and more of them, or as many as possible? That is how the club grows over time, no other way.

Not at all. The new stand will enable us to accommodate more fans, hopefully young ones, which is when the HF should be movend/enlarged...

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 17 Sep 18 3.01pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Not at all. The new stand will enable us to accommodate more fans, hopefully young ones, which is when the HF should be movend/enlarged...

If you look at my earlier posts you'd note that I agree with this...and everything should've been managed...but to think that one set of supporters are beyond being moved purely due the the time they've sat there than you're misguided. Just as it is to think that those who have (for this season) paid for their tickets already should be moved. NONE of us have a RIGHT to sit where we want other than for the season/match we've paid for on that basis.

So the point i'm getting at is BOTH sides of the argument are puerile at best, but its clear that there's a growing demand for a solution. No more, no less...

Perhaps I'm just being pragmatic in seeing past the its my seat and im not giving it up wahhhhhhh, or the I want to sit there and grow the singing base or i'll not support wahhhhhh arguments.

Both are self serving..

For what its worth, I'd rip up the seating allocations and have a singing section in each of the stands once (if ever) the new stand is built!

Edited by Lyons550 (17 Sep 2018 3.03pm)

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 17 Sep 18 3.02pm

Originally posted by Pompyeagle

I have supported Palace now for 60 years and I will continue to do so with or without the HF,


And that makes you no different from lots of others...regardless of how many years we've supported.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 17 Sep 18 3.09pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

You’d prefer not encouraging/attracting younger fans and more of them, or as many as possible? That is how the club grows over time, no other way.

Encouraging youngsters to join the fanatics is NOT the only way to get them to watch us. I got into the Palace through being taken to games by my father. He had five brothers who also took my cousins, their in laws and friends children also. As we grew up and married and had children they were introduced to the delights of Selhurst Park and then their children too. We have always been a family friendly club and my families example is, I am certain, just the tip of the iceberg.

So in conclusion stop making out the HF is the only way to grow the club's supporter base because it's not.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 17 Sep 18 3.12pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Encouraging youngsters to join the fanatics is NOT the only way to get them to watch us. I got into the Palace through being taken to games by my father. He had five brothers who also took my cousins, their in laws and friends children also. As we grew up and married and had children they were introduced to the delights of Selhurst Park and then their children too. We have always been a family friendly club and my families example is, I am certain, just the tip of the iceberg.

So in conclusion stop making out the HF is the only way to grow the club's supporter base because it's not.


Again, i'd agree its not the only way, but its certainly ONE way of doing it. Another is for the team to win things...its like most things in life, everything plays a part and there's no silver bullet solution.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Sep 18 3.31pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Encouraging youngsters to join the fanatics is NOT the only way to get them to watch us. I got into the Palace through being taken to games by my father. He had five brothers who also took my cousins, their in laws and friends children also. As we grew up and married and had children they were introduced to the delights of Selhurst Park and then their children too. We have always been a family friendly club and my families example is, I am certain, just the tip of the iceberg.

So in conclusion stop making out the HF is the only way to grow the club's supporter base because it's not.

That isn’t what I’ve said. I’m talking about a passionate support that shows. That is going/gone. The HF or an organised group or some organisation starts it off at n today’ football.

The family point only allows you to be that small club when the good times are over, mismanaged or steered into, and actually it’s counting on those offspring actually being within reaching distance or even wanting to come with other options of entertainment that weren’t around in decades past.

 


COYP

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 17 Sep 18 3.41pm

The only solution I can see is that HF go back to Block B. Or sit this season out. Have I missed something?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Sep 18 3.55pm

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

The only solution I can see is that HF go back to Block B. Or sit this season out. Have I missed something?

That’s the only solution to this season but it’s probably after the club commit to some sort of investigation into views and options. That’s where it’s stuck I’d expect. The club didn’t do anything and the HF have commented on ‘inaction.’ Until there is some nothing may change.

 


COYP

Page 85 of 122 < 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread