You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread
November 16 2026 3.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread


Page 85 of 91 < 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 >
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 02 Mar 20 4.22pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

what a difference a week makes in the world of a football fan.

Yes, Parish, Freedman and Hodgson now the dream team.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 02 Mar 20 4.25pm

I think we are also seeing the benefit of the recent periods of rest our players have had (winter break / cup weekends). This combined with a few players coming back from injury have helped us enormously.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 02 Mar 20 4.34pm

Originally posted by scuffy

It's a position where you get a lot of injuries - every club has it.

Try reading my post in context

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 02 Mar 20 7.15pm

We have a mixture of players, some very good, some that work well with others in a unit and some that on their day, are good.

However, we also ride our luck and as we have experienced, it doesn't always pan out - injuries, fatigue, plan a not working then having no plan b...

But we have done enough, as is the remit, to survive with what we have. At times it's been poor, not pretty... but there have been good moments and lucky moments.

We're basically at tipping point, it can go great with investment and restructuring or it could all end in tears and it seems like for now the plan is, 'hold tight, we don't know what quite to do'.

I think the main objective is to reduce wages, get in longer term players whilst cementing our status in the league in record time.

I've always said, if our main goal is to confirm status earlier each season, then that's progression to me. It's a way more positive way of saying survival is our objective - it just has the spin of, in record tme.

 


This was once a quality forum....

jeeagles Flag 02 Mar 20 9.01pm

Originally posted by Vaibow


We're basically at tipping point, it can go great with investment and restructuring or it could all end in tears and it seems like for now the plan is, 'hold tight, we don't know what quite to do'..

Agree with you that for the short to medium term the club is a bit confused about what to do next. No one expected us to stay up this long, now we’ve got the 9th longest continuous spell in the premier league and there’s not really a model for us to follow.

I’d like to see a big push to get a high league finish, especially now we are almost safe. And if safety is all we are looking for in the league, it would be nice to see us have a go in the cups next season.

 

Zaha127 Flag 07 Mar 20 6.28pm

Lets hope the owners actually invest in the club. Roy has done his best and Now the board have to invest this summer. We do not want to be near relegation next season

 

davehuggins Flag 07 Mar 20 6.44pm

The hierarchy must get the summer recruitment right if we can get some younger quality in then the future is looking sound. Just a major problem with the Stadium!!!!

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 07 Mar 20 6.48pm

Originally posted by Zaha127

Lets hope the owners actually invest in the club. Roy has done his best and Now the board have to invest this summer. We do not want to be near relegation next season

tbf we havnt been near one in a number of seasons.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 07 Mar 20 7.15pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

tbf we havnt been near one in a number of seasons.

Thankfully we’ve had Guaita in goal as he’s been worth a lot of points this season, equal to a top of the table keeper.

 


COYP

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 07 Mar 20 8.06pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

tbf we havnt been near one in a number of seasons.

Very true, we are a very neat and tidy outfit at the moment and today proves that beyond any doubt and we need to look no further then Mr Hodgson to understand fully that he is the sole reason that we find ourselves in the position of being safe with nine games still to be played.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 07 Mar 20 8.14pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Thankfully we’ve had Guaita in goal as he’s been worth a lot of points this season, equal to a top of the table keeper.

..and he has shown brilliantly that he can learn from previous mistakes very quickly, almost on a par with Martyn he is.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 08 Mar 20 2.36pm

I find myself slightly amazed to find Palace with the points total that we have and the middle of March yet to arrive.

I have witnessed some groggy performance by Palace this season and haven't always enjoyed watching us play. I can't even say that we have been outstanding in many of the games we have won.

However, on the train up to the match yesterday, I found myself stoutly defending Roy (and to an extent Parish) in the face of criticism from a mate. Whilst there was an element of devil's advocate in my argument ( I have at previous times expressed the same concerns as my mate), I pointed out that with 2 months of the season to go our place in the top flight is all but assured ( and this was before yesterday's victory) - some achievement! This has never happened in the 7 seasons we have been in the Prem.

My mate was trotting out the much aired views that Hodgson is unadventurous, doesn't give younger players a chance, is poor in the transfer market, and has too many favourites whose names are automatically penned into the starting line-up.

Countering this I asked him whether he would prefer that Palace were playing expansive football like that of Brighton (and hovering over the relegation zone), what youngsters did he have in mind ( given the dire record of our Under 23s), what about our summer signings Cahill and McCarthy who are proving increasingly valuable team members, and surely a settled team is no bad thing.

Whatever Roy's shortcomings, in my books, his achievement is remarkable.


 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 08 Mar 20 5.38pm

Originally posted by Pete53

I find myself slightly amazed to find Palace with the points total that we have and the middle of March yet to arrive.

I have witnessed some groggy performance by Palace this season and haven't always enjoyed watching us play. I can't even say that we have been outstanding in many of the games we have won.

However, on the train up to the match yesterday, I found myself stoutly defending Roy (and to an extent Parish) in the face of criticism from a mate. Whilst there was an element of devil's advocate in my argument ( I have at previous times expressed the same concerns as my mate), I pointed out that with 2 months of the season to go our place in the top flight is all but assured ( and this was before yesterday's victory) - some achievement! This has never happened in the 7 seasons we have been in the Prem.

My mate was trotting out the much aired views that Hodgson is unadventurous, doesn't give younger players a chance, is poor in the transfer market, and has too many favourites whose names are automatically penned into the starting line-up.

Countering this I asked him whether he would prefer that Palace were playing expansive football like that of Brighton (and hovering over the relegation zone), what youngsters did he have in mind ( given the dire record of our Under 23s), what about our summer signings Cahill and McCarthy who are proving increasingly valuable team members, and surely a settled team is no bad thing.

Whatever Roy's shortcomings, in my books, his achievement is remarkable.


4-0 Spurs, 0-2 Man.C, 0-2 Leicester, 2-0 Chelsea, 0-2 Southampton, 3-1 Everton.

These are the only games where we lost by more then one goal.

1-2 Liverpool, 2-2 Arsenal away, 2-2 Man.C away.

These are the the other games where we let in more then one goal.

Seven times we scored twice in one game, we have not yet scored more.

All the other games involved one goal each or one to the other, apart from two that finished 0-0.

Edited by Tickled pink (08 Mar 2020 5.42pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 08 Mar 20 7.38pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

4-0 Spurs, 0-2 Man.C, 0-2 Leicester, 2-0 Chelsea, 0-2 Southampton, 3-1 Everton.

These are the only games where we lost by more then one goal.

1-2 Liverpool, 2-2 Arsenal away, 2-2 Man.C away.

These are the the other games where we let in more then one goal.

Seven times we scored twice in one game, we have not yet scored more.

All the other games involved one goal each or one to the other, apart from two that finished 0-0.

Edited by Tickled pink (08 Mar 2020 5.42pm)

Danny Murphy on motd last night said he told his squad at Fulham he wanted them to aim for zero goal difference or better.

The downsides to this are that it’s a tough watch, games can be decided, predicted early on or written off and it could prove difficult to sign attacking or flair players. Look at Benteke and zaha. Both depreciated in value. Many will say that’s a cost to staying in the Prem and I see the viewpoint and understand that there are costs and conflicting issues like in many businesses, but how long can that football strategy that can depreciate the club’s highest value players give the club the financial edge our size of club needs? AWB is a one off, unless our transfer profit is going to come from progressing defensively minded players.

The irony isn’t lost on me of Parish saying before hiring FDB ‘’we must move away from counting on the lucky bounce of the ball as we’ve done in our history and create those definite chances ourselves because that is more....’’ sustainable long term or something.

Now I fully understand why Roy has been hired on a business decision but it isn’t issue free but really the point is that even roy said yesterday after the Watford win that we could easily be 9 points worse off. It could actually be even more if you took away Guaita’s excellent form and us not winning the last 3 games that could’ve been 4 or 5 points. But that’s where I’ll make my main criticism. We’ve forced these 9 points more by being less passive than we’ve been for 6 months. I expect someone to say ive contradicted myself regarding the last 3 wins but I’m saying that our chances of that happening have a higher probability than watching whoever knock it about like brazil while we watch and rely on blocks or Guaita.

Finally there isn’t much synergy within the higher levels of the club. I have stressed issues I think have come about because of whichever of the 3 (Roy, Freedman, Parish). Meyer the German Messi I think Parish signed and had him pose for photos on the rooftop in the hope he’d be that flair player we coined it in with.

Roy is fine regarding our percentage chances of surviving each season but the issues I’ve raised are things I hope those at the top are discussing between themselves. We need some good transfer windows.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (08 Mar 2020 11.57pm)

 


COYP

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 08 Mar 20 9.26pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Danny Murphy on motd last night said he told his squad at Fulham he wanted them to aim for zero goal difference or better.

The downsides to this are that it’s a tough watch, games can be decided, predicted early on or written off and it could prove difficult to sign attacking or flair players. Look at Benteke and zaha. Both depreciated in value. Many will say that’s a benefit to staying in the Prem and I see the viewpoint and understand that there are costs and conflicting issues like in many businesses, but how long can that football strategy that can depreciate the club’s highest value players give the club the financial edge our size of club needs? AWB is a one off, unless our transfer profit is going to come from progressing defensively minded players.

The irony isn’t lost on me of Parish saying before hiring FDB ‘’we must move away from counting on the lucky bounce of the ball as we’ve done in our history and create those definite chances ourselves because that is more....’’ sustainable long term or something.

Now I fully understand why Roy has been hired on a business decision but it isn’t issue free but really the point is that even roy said yesterday after the Watford win that we could easily be 9 points worse off. It could actually be even more if you took away Guaita’s excellent form and us not winning the last 3 games that could’ve been 4 or 5 points. But that’s where I’ll make my main criticism. We’ve forced these 9 points more by being less passive than we’ve been for 6 months. I expect someone to say ive contradicted myself regarding the last 3 wins but I’m saying that our chances of that happening have a higher probability than watching whoever knock it about like brazil while we watch and rely on blocks or Guaita.

Finally there isn’t much synergy within the higher levels of the club. I have stressed issues I think have come about because of whichever of the 3 (Roy, Freedman, Parish). Meyer the German Messi I think Parish signed and had him pose for photos on the rooftop in the hope he’d be that flair player we coined it in with.

Roy is fine regarding our percentage chances of surviving each season but the issues I’ve raised are things I hope those at the top are discussing between themselves. We need some good transfer windows.

My only comment to this viewpoint would be that practically every team would be able to make the same analysis. They will be able to site games where the points were fortuitous . The reality is is Roy has been able to get his players to get the points rather than lose them which would indicate that he and his team are performing.COYP

 

dg1937 Flag 09 Mar 20 12.46pm

The point about goal difference is interesting. Yes it does indicate a somewhat negative mindset but, if you look at the current table, the idea that 0 goal difference = safety is borne out. Just about everyone is more or less in the position they should be, only Brighton ought to be significantly higher as their -8 GD would place them between us and Everton. Last season 0 GD would have got you to about 10th place.

 

jeeagles Flag 09 Mar 20 12.56pm

I think some are getting ahead of themselves about Roy doing a remarkable job.

He's done ok. He's won the last 3 games 1-0. Going into them we would have expected to win the two home games and Brighton are on terrible form.

I think Roy pays too much attention to goal difference. We've dropped a lot of points where we havent attacked teams at 1-0 down.


Will be interesting to see if he tries to push us up the table now that we are safe, or will he keep playing 3 holding midfielders?

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 09 Mar 20 1.29pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

I think some are getting ahead of themselves about Roy doing a remarkable job.

He's done ok. He's won the last 3 games 1-0. Going into them we would have expected to win the two home games and Brighton are on terrible form.

I think Roy pays too much attention to goal difference. We've dropped a lot of points where we havent attacked teams at 1-0 down.


Will be interesting to see if he tries to push us up the table now that we are safe, or will he keep playing 3 holding midfielders?

I think some people make themselves look foolish when they can't recognise the job that Hodgson is doing, but I keep that to myself.

If you were at the games you will have seen a number of missed chances and excellent saves from the opposing goalkeepers - not sure what the manager can do about that.

Given that each place in the league is worth more money ( I think £2m ) why would you expect him to change tactics that have already got us to mid table ? I don't think Steve Parish would endorse experimenting while there are points and prize money at stake, interesting though that might be.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Painter Flag Croydon 09 Mar 20 1.29pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Danny Murphy on motd last night said he told his squad at Fulham he wanted them to aim for zero goal difference or better.

The downsides to this are that it’s a tough watch, games can be decided, predicted early on or written off and it could prove difficult to sign attacking or flair players. Look at Benteke and zaha. Both depreciated in value. Many will say that’s a cost to staying in the Prem and I see the viewpoint and understand that there are costs and conflicting issues like in many businesses, but how long can that football strategy that can depreciate the club’s highest value players give the club the financial edge our size of club needs? AWB is a one off, unless our transfer profit is going to come from progressing defensively minded players.

The irony isn’t lost on me of Parish saying before hiring FDB ‘’we must move away from counting on the lucky bounce of the ball as we’ve done in our history and create those definite chances ourselves because that is more....’’ sustainable long term or something.

Now I fully understand why Roy has been hired on a business decision but it isn’t issue free but really the point is that even roy said yesterday after the Watford win that we could easily be 9 points worse off. It could actually be even more if you took away Guaita’s excellent form and us not winning the last 3 games that could’ve been 4 or 5 points. But that’s where I’ll make my main criticism. We’ve forced these 9 points more by being less passive than we’ve been for 6 months. I expect someone to say ive contradicted myself regarding the last 3 wins but I’m saying that our chances of that happening have a higher probability than watching whoever knock it about like brazil while we watch and rely on blocks or Guaita.

Finally there isn’t much synergy within the higher levels of the club. I have stressed issues I think have come about because of whichever of the 3 (Roy, Freedman, Parish). Meyer the German Messi I think Parish signed and had him pose for photos on the rooftop in the hope he’d be that flair player we coined it in with.

Roy is fine regarding our percentage chances of surviving each season but the issues I’ve raised are things I hope those at the top are discussing between themselves. We need some good transfer windows.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (08 Mar 2020 11.57pm)

How has the value of Benteke and Zaha gone down, because of Roy. Benteke is getting on to 30, so his value will fall, the value of Zaha is what we put on him, not what the market thinks, as nobody has bid anywhere near our value.
We have had some very good transfer windows, bar January with Ayew, Guaita, Cahill, McCarthy and Kouyate picked up for total £15m, all now regulars in the team that have maintained our Premier status.

 

jeeagles Flag 09 Mar 20 2.31pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

I think some people make themselves look foolish when they can't recognise the job that Hodgson is doing, but I keep that to myself.

If you were at the games you will have seen a number of missed chances and excellent saves from the opposing goalkeepers - not sure what the manager can do about that.

Sorry Neillo.... you're just a better palace fan than I am.

 

Page 85 of 91 < 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread