Quote sanitycheck at 09 Dec 2014 10.44am
Quote Johnny Eagles at 09 Dec 2014 8.46am
There was a detailed interview on "Westminster Hour" with two polling experts who have done studies using samples of 90,000 people into voting intentions.
The overwhelming motivation for people who say they will vote UKIP is not fear but disillusion with the three main parties. The majority of UKIP voters are not deserting another party; most of them haven't been voting at all.
So most people intending to vote for UKIP didn't vote in previous elections? I'd like to see the study as that sounds like either a very bold claim or a very interesting finding.
That aside, saying that those voters are motivated by disillusion and not fear is obviously an extreme simplification of the human condition. People are motivated by all kinds of complex factors and handing them a survey isn't going to draw out some kind of truth.
Edited by sanitycheck (09 Dec 2014 10.48am)
[Link]
The relevant clip from the programme.
The discussion was about who would win how many seats.
As far as I recall they reckon:
- Labour will do better than last time in England but will get destroyed in Jockland by the Ess n' Peeee
- Lib Dems will not get destroyed thanks to a) incumbency and b) their opponents in marginals not doing that well
- The Greens will come nowhere because all their voters will go back to Labour
- UKIP will damage Tories most, Labour a bit, but not as much as people expect because mostly their votes will come from previous non-voters
As for your second paragraph, I don't really know how to respond to that.
I was just providing evidence for an additional and more significant factor (disillusion with the political elite) in response to Seth's assertion (forgive the paraphrasing, Seth) that it was all about fear.
Obviously people are motivated by all kinds of complex factors. On the same programme last week there was a review of this book which talks about the primitive and emotional factors which drive voting behaviour.
[Link]
You seem keen to paint me as some kind of simpleton who argues in black and white terms. I think that's unfair.
Edited by Johnny Eagles (09 Dec 2014 11.05am)
...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...
|