You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread
November 21 2026 11.30am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Holmesdale Fanatics thread


Page 88 of 122 < 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 >
Lyons550 Flag Shirley 19 Sep 18 11.13am

Originally posted by spartakev2

Doesn't really answer my question. Would it be certain blocks, where you'd puy those season tickets up fof sale only to 'singers'. Would it be first come, first served, or would they have to be HF members and be 'vetted' bh them.

It doesn't answer it because no one really knows!

It would make sense to allocate a 'block' (wherever that may be) and clearly advise those wishing to buy tickets, season or general admission, in it that its a singing area...forewarned forearmed and all that.

As to how the club would go about releasing the tickets, I guess it'd make sense to offer them to existing seat holders in those areas to then express a preference, before then opening them up to those in the current HF block, before then opening any left up to everyone else.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Isley46 Flag Sanderstead 19 Sep 18 12.37pm

Originally posted by Lyons550

It doesn't answer it because no one really knows!

It would make sense to allocate a 'block' (wherever that may be) and clearly advise those wishing to buy tickets, season or general admission, in it that its a singing area...forewarned forearmed and all that.

.

Why not allocate the Whitehorse Lane?
Ball Park numbers make sense - bear with me...

Whitehorse end holds 2245 in four blocks.
Close one block nearest the away fans for segregation gives roughly 1600 places available to offer to 'singing' fans.

Lower Holmesdale holds 5341 so roughly 750 per block (without A&J).
Offer Z,A,B,C to relocate to the Whitehorse 'singing section' (it is Z,A,B&C that join in the most?)- not all will want to move and Z usually has lots of general sale tickets so not all season tickets.

Offer Whitehorse to relocate to Z,A,B,C

Club Consultation to all those who have season tickets in Z,A,B,C & Whitehorse Lane.

Ticket price for Whitehorse lane increased to cover the loss of approx 550 seats due to segregation requirements and possible policing costs - or club can swallow this cost.

Solves the Family section abuse issue from visiting fans.
Solves the standing issue which annoys some in lower Holmesdale & block Z A/W.

No ground improvements required at present, could be implemented next season if the consultation started now.

If in the future there was then a 'safe standing' trial planned it would be easier to convert Whitehorse to Safe standing and there would be no objection from the incumbents as no other area affected and the 'singing section' would normally stand anyway.

Segregation area won't appear much on TV - singing section will get high profile - attracting more attention / would-be singers

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Sep 18 1.23pm

Originally posted by Isley46

Why not allocate the Whitehorse Lane?
Ball Park numbers make sense - bear with me...

Whitehorse end holds 2245 in four blocks.
Close one block nearest the away fans for segregation gives roughly 1600 places available to offer to 'singing' fans.

Lower Holmesdale holds 5341 so roughly 750 per block (without A&J).
Offer Z,A,B,C to relocate to the Whitehorse 'singing section' (it is Z,A,B&C that join in the most?)- not all will want to move and Z usually has lots of general sale tickets so not all season tickets.

Offer Whitehorse to relocate to Z,A,B,C

Club Consultation to all those who have season tickets in Z,A,B,C & Whitehorse Lane.

Ticket price for Whitehorse lane increased to cover the loss of approx 550 seats due to segregation requirements and possible policing costs - or club can swallow this cost.

Solves the Family section abuse issue from visiting fans.
Solves the standing issue which annoys some in lower Holmesdale & block Z A/W.

No ground improvements required at present, could be implemented next season if the consultation started now.

If in the future there was then a 'safe standing' trial planned it would be easier to convert Whitehorse to Safe standing and there would be no objection from the incumbents as no other area affected and the 'singing section' would normally stand anyway.

Segregation area won't appear much on TV - singing section will get high profile - attracting more attention / would-be singers

It’s not a bad proposal but it’s a bit lower league at that end and I doubt the HF would take it. I think they see even those not into singing much would add to the central blocks in the lower Holmesdale so those moments when everyone is singing Roy’s name would be more frequent across the whole lower.

 


COYP

Palace in the Blood Flag 19 Sep 18 2.24pm

Originally posted by Isley46

Why not allocate the Whitehorse Lane?
Ball Park numbers make sense - bear with me...

Whitehorse end holds 2245 in four blocks.
Close one block nearest the away fans for segregation gives roughly 1600 places available to offer to 'singing' fans.

Lower Holmesdale holds 5341 so roughly 750 per block (without A&J).
Offer Z,A,B,C to relocate to the Whitehorse 'singing section' (it is Z,A,B&C that join in the most?)- not all will want to move and Z usually has lots of general sale tickets so not all season tickets.

Offer Whitehorse to relocate to Z,A,B,C

Club Consultation to all those who have season tickets in Z,A,B,C & Whitehorse Lane.

Ticket price for Whitehorse lane increased to cover the loss of approx 550 seats due to segregation requirements and possible policing costs - or club can swallow this cost.

Solves the Family section abuse issue from visiting fans.
Solves the standing issue which annoys some in lower Holmesdale & block Z A/W.

No ground improvements required at present, could be implemented next season if the consultation started now.

If in the future there was then a 'safe standing' trial planned it would be easier to convert Whitehorse to Safe standing and there would be no objection from the incumbents as no other area affected and the 'singing section' would normally stand anyway.

Segregation area won't appear much on TV - singing section will get high profile - attracting more attention / would-be singers


This is not a bad proposal but I would suggest some minor alterations

First All season ticket holders should be asked if they want a "singing" section and also would they be interested in having a season ticket in that area

If the majority do not want it the idea is dead and the HF need to accept that.

Assuming there is a majority in favour then club can look at where is best location as they will also have an indication of numbers who would take it up. The HF survey is open so anyone or any group can currently influence it so in reality there is no accurate indication of interest.

The HF ultra image also does not help many who may be interested in being part of a singing section would not wish to be considered ultras. I therefore feel that the HF's current stated position and a singing section are not the same thing.

The HF number around 100 and they have said they could swell that to 200 ish for a singing section to take over a single block you need many more than that

 

westquay Flag 58 miles from se25 19 Sep 18 2.37pm

So basically I would love to see the HF back...…
But I want them to sing this..... Old days...


We are the pride of south London, The pride of the south.
We got all the boots and we got all the mouth,
We only drink Whisky and bottles of ale....
We are the famous Holmesdale........

 


"Numb,gutted and shocked . Three words that sum up how I feel."
"Passionate,principled, genius. Three words that sum up Joe Strummer"
Martin Scorcese, Film director.

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 19 Sep 18 3.14pm

Originally posted by Isley46

Why not allocate the Whitehorse Lane?
Ball Park numbers make sense - bear with me...

Whitehorse end holds 2245 in four blocks.
Close one block nearest the away fans for segregation gives roughly 1600 places available to offer to 'singing' fans.

Lower Holmesdale holds 5341 so roughly 750 per block (without A&J).
Offer Z,A,B,C to relocate to the Whitehorse 'singing section' (it is Z,A,B&C that join in the most?)- not all will want to move and Z usually has lots of general sale tickets so not all season tickets.

Offer Whitehorse to relocate to Z,A,B,C

Club Consultation to all those who have season tickets in Z,A,B,C & Whitehorse Lane.

Ticket price for Whitehorse lane increased to cover the loss of approx 550 seats due to segregation requirements and possible policing costs - or club can swallow this cost.

Solves the Family section abuse issue from visiting fans.
Solves the standing issue which annoys some in lower Holmesdale & block Z A/W.

No ground improvements required at present, could be implemented next season if the consultation started now.

If in the future there was then a 'safe standing' trial planned it would be easier to convert Whitehorse to Safe standing and there would be no objection from the incumbents as no other area affected and the 'singing section' would normally stand anyway.

Segregation area won't appear much on TV - singing section will get high profile - attracting more attention / would-be singers


Perfectly sound suggestion tbh...the ONLY drawback I could foresee would be the displays. Maybe hang them from the exec boxes above??


Edited by Lyons550 (19 Sep 2018 3.15pm)

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 19 Sep 18 3.19pm

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood


This is not a bad proposal but I would suggest some minor alterations

First All season ticket holders should be asked if they want a "singing" section and also would they be interested in having a season ticket in that area

If the majority do not want it the idea is dead and the HF need to accept that.

Assuming there is a majority in favour then club can look at where is best location as they will also have an indication of numbers who would take it up. The HF survey is open so anyone or any group can currently influence it so in reality there is no accurate indication of interest.

The HF ultra image also does not help many who may be interested in being part of a singing section would not wish to be considered ultras. I therefore feel that the HF's current stated position and a singing section are not the same thing.

The HF number around 100 and they have said they could swell that to 200 ish for a singing section to take over a single block you need many more than that

Believe it or not, I'm not here to pl55 on anyones chips.
It's all very well discussing ideas, or typing them on a keyboard, but serious consideration needs to be given to the huge amount of beaurocracy (sp) that creating a singing section will bring, rather than waiting for a new stand/rail seating to be commissioned.

1. How do you get feedback from all relevant ST holders ? Internet, post, ? what about those on holiday ?
2. What happens if 51% say NO. ? Do you keep reviewing it until you get a majority ?
2. Where will the singing section be ?
3. Can the club be seen to condone 'standing' whilst in an all-seater stadium ? (nevermind flagpoles, musical instruments and pyrotechnics)

This is why it has to be done properly (however long that takes), and not in some bodged half-@r5ed manner.

And will the HF be in Block B for Noocastle ?
I have it on good authority there will be plenty of black shirts back in Block B on Saturday, with some rather nifty white stripes

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 19 Sep 18 3.34pm

Originally posted by charliehub

In case anyone hasn't signed yet...wearetheholmesdale.com/

No thanks, I'm strongly against selfish agendas to remove people from their seats.

 

Isley46 Flag Sanderstead 19 Sep 18 3.48pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Believe it or not, I'm not here to pl55 on anyones chips.
It's all very well discussing ideas, or typing them on a keyboard, but serious consideration needs to be given to the huge amount of beaurocracy (sp) that creating a singing section will bring, rather than waiting for a new stand/rail seating to be commissioned.

1. How do you get feedback from all relevant ST holders ? Internet, post, ? what about those on holiday ?
2. What happens if 51% say NO. ? Do you keep reviewing it until you get a majority ?
2. Where will the singing section be ?
3. Can the club be seen to condone 'standing' whilst in an all-seater stadium ? (nevermind flagpoles, musical instruments and pyrotechnics)

This is why it has to be done properly (however long that takes), and not in some bodged half-@r5ed manner.

And will the HF be in Block B for Noocastle ?
I have it on good authority there will be plenty of black shirts back in Block B on Saturday, with some rather nifty white stripes

A consultation via direct mail, business reply envelope with bar coded validation and auto data extraction from a well designed reply form to get the result would cost in the region of £5K. Looking to mail only those Season ticket holders affected by seat position - not all the ST holders as moving seats doesn't affect them and these could skew the true results.

Very difficult to forge results as what goes out validates against what comes back. Could do it via a web page but that cuts out those who don't use the web so wouldn't be treating each supporter fairly.

if you don't reply then you are obviously not that bothered.

Set a 30 day reply window and you would have your result for this option. Over 50% and the majority carries. Less than 50% and option binned.

Parish could surely get someone at TAG or Oliver Marketing to put together a decent mail pack for the supporters consultation proposal.

Start now and you would have your answer before xmas.

 

stuckinbristol Flag In the woodwork. 19 Sep 18 3.52pm

Originally posted by Isley46

Why not allocate the Whitehorse Lane?
Ball Park numbers make sense - bear with me...

Whitehorse end holds 2245 in four blocks.
Close one block nearest the away fans for segregation gives roughly 1600 places available to offer to 'singing' fans.

Lower Holmesdale holds 5341 so roughly 750 per block (without A&J).
Offer Z,A,B,C to relocate to the Whitehorse 'singing section' (it is Z,A,B&C that join in the most?)- not all will want to move and Z usually has lots of general sale tickets so not all season tickets.

Offer Whitehorse to relocate to Z,A,B,C

Club Consultation to all those who have season tickets in Z,A,B,C & Whitehorse Lane.

Ticket price for Whitehorse lane increased to cover the loss of approx 550 seats due to segregation requirements and possible policing costs - or club can swallow this cost.

Solves the Family section abuse issue from visiting fans.
Solves the standing issue which annoys some in lower Holmesdale & block Z A/W.

No ground improvements required at present, could be implemented next season if the consultation started now.

If in the future there was then a 'safe standing' trial planned it would be easier to convert Whitehorse to Safe standing and there would be no objection from the incumbents as no other area affected and the 'singing section' would normally stand anyway.

Segregation area won't appear much on TV - singing section will get high profile - attracting more attention / would-be singers

But then they would have to change their name to the Whitehorse Fanatics, or WF.
What about they become the New Fanatics....on second thoughts, best not do that.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 19 Sep 18 4.18pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Believe it or not, I'm not here to pl55 on anyones chips.
It's all very well discussing ideas, or typing them on a keyboard, but serious consideration needs to be given to the huge amount of beaurocracy (sp) that creating a singing section will bring, rather than waiting for a new stand/rail seating to be commissioned.

1. How do you get feedback from all relevant ST holders ? Internet, post, ? what about those on holiday ?
2. What happens if 51% say NO. ? Do you keep reviewing it until you get a majority ?
2. Where will the singing section be ?
3. Can the club be seen to condone 'standing' whilst in an all-seater stadium ? (nevermind flagpoles, musical instruments and pyrotechnics)

This is why it has to be done properly (however long that takes), and not in some bodged half-@r5ed manner.

And will the HF be in Block B for Noocastle ?
I have it on good authority there will be plenty of black shirts back in Block B on Saturday, with some rather nifty white stripes

This singing section you refer to, no idea where it will be.

More consideration is needed as to the criteria to enter.
Will there be open auditions?
Would you have to stand?
How long would you have to sing during the match?
If you don’t sing, would you be thrown out?
Is there going to be an age limit?

 

premier fan Flag BR4 19 Sep 18 4.23pm

have I missed something here;

but why couldn't the HF stayed where they were and just moved when the new stand was ready?

Can't really expect people to give up their ST's.

the argument for better atmosphere is flawed as they've just moved without having a plan in place so we're now worse off for atmosphere.

Edited by premier fan (19 Sep 2018 4.25pm)

Edited by premier fan (19 Sep 2018 4.25pm)

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 19 Sep 18 4.58pm

Originally posted by Isley46

A consultation via direct mail, business reply envelope with bar coded validation and auto data extraction from a well designed reply form to get the result would cost in the region of £5K. Looking to mail only those Season ticket holders affected by seat position - not all the ST holders as moving seats doesn't affect them and these could skew the true results.

Very difficult to forge results as what goes out validates against what comes back. Could do it via a web page but that cuts out those who don't use the web so wouldn't be treating each supporter fairly.

if you don't reply then you are obviously not that bothered.

Set a 30 day reply window and you would have your result for this option. Over 50% and the majority carries. Less than 50% and option binned.

Parish could surely get someone at TAG or Oliver Marketing to put together a decent mail pack for the supporters consultation proposal.

Start now and you would have your answer before xmas.

I think it is important that all interested parties are consulted and that means all season ticket holders.
This will not skew results as it gives the view of all who could be impacted.

As you say it would have to be done by direct mail and include validation.

I think cost would be higher and in the region of 25k but if that can end the discussion one way or another then that is money well spent.

Clearly if a majority of fan's responses say no that has to be the end of it. There is always a problem with people not returning forms but the number of responses need to be representative of the supporters. Professional companies who carry out these type of surveys would advise on what response percentage is meaningful. Maybe an incentive like entry for a draw for a free season ticket for next season would help.

As I said in an earlier response there are 2 questions. One is do you want (or object) to a singing section. The second is do you want to be part of it.

I suspect that the majority will not object to a singing section as people like the atmosphere. However the number who want to be part will be far smaller. It is this number the club need to make plans

 

Hutchyeagle Flag Hove 19 Sep 18 4.59pm

Sums it up in a nutshell

Originally posted by premier fan

have I missed something here;

but why couldn't the HF stayed where they were and just moved when the new stand was ready?

Can't really expect people to give up their ST's.

the argument for better atmosphere is flawed as they've just moved without having a plan in place so we're now worse off for atmosphere.

Edited by premier fan (19 Sep 2018 4.25pm)

Edited by premier fan (19 Sep 2018 4.25pm)

 

bicycle repair man 19 Sep 18 5.15pm

Originally posted by premier fan

have I missed something here;

but why couldn't the HF stayed where they were and just moved when the new stand was ready?

Can't really expect people to give up their ST's.

the argument for better atmosphere is flawed as they've just moved without having a plan in place so we're now worse off for atmosphere.

Edited by premier fan (19 Sep 2018 4.25pm)

Edited by premier fan (19 Sep 2018 4.25pm)


Absolutely correct,the HF have created their own problem,they should have stayed where they were until the main stand has been constucted,when I imagine the lower tier of the Holmesdale will be made a safe standing area.
All these crackpot schemes that they are coming up with would involve uprooting fellow supporters from their regular seats,apart from the fact it would be an administrative nightmare anyway.
Forget the loony schemes and sit tight.


 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 19 Sep 18 5.28pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man


Absolutely correct,the HF have created their own problem,they should have stayed where they were until the main stand has been constucted,when I imagine the lower tier of the Holmesdale will be made a safe standing area.
All these crackpot schemes that they are coming up with would involve uprooting fellow supporters from their regular seats,apart from the fact it would be an administrative nightmare anyway.
Forget the loony schemes and sit tight.


Agree 100%

 

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 19 Sep 18 5.43pm

I agree.

In the meantime let international supporters offer their support to the HF. Let the atmosphere deteriorate. Let one of our USP’s disappear. Finally, let one of the fundamental aspects of our club for which it is now know disappear.

They are good for our club, our image, our atmosphere and our team.

Prawn sandwich anyone?...

 

bicycle repair man 19 Sep 18 5.58pm

No body forced the HF to break up,and allegedly damage the famous Selhurst Park "atmosphere".
They did that all by themselves.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 19 Sep 18 6.15pm

I think an atmosphere is worth easily a million pounds a year. It probably adds a few points over a season (and with it league placings) and also improves the odds of being on the tellybox. So more ££.

Supposing the club spent a tenth of that on an atmosphere, how would that money best be spent?

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

est1905 Flag 19 Sep 18 6.22pm

Originally posted by .TUX.

'I don't know' would've worked.

For you it ususually does fella!

 

Page 88 of 122 < 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread