This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote serial thriller at 18 Jun 2015 10.20pm
Quote dannyh at 18 Jun 2015 4.42pm
Serial answer me this then. In what religion in this country are you most at risk from radicalisation ? Before you answer consider : Although Jehovah’sitnesses are a pain in the arse, not a single one has knocked on my door, waited for me to answer and blew him self up all over my front gardenn, nor has the Bhuddist who lives next door, hacked my head off whilst I was off to the shops, even the mentalist catholic up the road decided not to set me on fire because I didnt agree with his sky fairy on gay marriage. As I said right at the start it is purely and simply risk management.
Second, how many Muslims do you know directly who have blown themselves up/hacked off their heads/set fire to you? This is the problem I was trying to explain to you Danny, you can accept that radical Islam is a problem AND not tar all Muslims with the same brush. Less than 0.1% of British Muslims have gone out to join IS, thus to make any assumptions on the faith in general is absolutely f*cking nuts. They aren't, its more that in a current generation the only really active, popular form of extremism is Islamist movements. The problem isn't really anything to do with Muslims being more prone to extremism, but that young people are. In previous generations, it was more far left and far right groups, all of which had their terrorist components, from the NF / Combat 18 through to the Angry Brigade, Class War and Baader Meinhof gangs, to the Provos and the UVF, one thing in common was the appeal to young men (primarily) and young women. Look at any revolution, and you'll find cadres of young men and women at the fore (even the armed and police services tends towards the recruitment of young men and women); and this is because young people are very prone towards idealism, over cynicism: they want to make a difference. Many muslim countries have been in a situation in our lifetimes of national liberation from colonial powers, and suffering from corrupt regimes (usually after national liberation) and this has fuelled a large number of movements of Muslims that were politically active and involved in armed struggles, and that tradition has continued on. During the 60s to early 80s, these were typically leftist movements, but the 80s saw the rise of Islamist movements (spurned on initially by the success of the Iranian Revolution, and then the defeat of the Soviet in Afghanistan). Consequently, that tradition of insurgency, continued into Chechnya, Palestine, Lebanon, Bosnia etc through the 90s, and saw the rise of groups such as Al-Qaeda etc bringing an ideological connection between those groups and other muslims populations, ultimately resulting in the idea of the international Jihadist, from Afghanistan in the 80s, to an grobal icon, a kind of Che Guevera for Islam. But its not just Muslims that are 'vulnerable' to this idealism, its a phenomena of young people, who are drawn to 'dramatic causes', and then from those dramatic causes into extremism.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote derben at 19 Jun 2015 11.44am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 19 Jun 2015 9.50am
Quote serial thriller at 18 Jun 2015 10.20pm
Quote dannyh at 18 Jun 2015 4.42pm
Serial answer me this then. In what religion in this country are you most at risk from radicalisation ? Before you answer consider : Although Jehovah’sitnesses are a pain in the arse, not a single one has knocked on my door, waited for me to answer and blew him self up all over my front gardenn, nor has the Bhuddist who lives next door, hacked my head off whilst I was off to the shops, even the mentalist catholic up the road decided not to set me on fire because I didnt agree with his sky fairy on gay marriage. As I said right at the start it is purely and simply risk management.
Second, how many Muslims do you know directly who have blown themselves up/hacked off their heads/set fire to you? This is the problem I was trying to explain to you Danny, you can accept that radical Islam is a problem AND not tar all Muslims with the same brush. Less than 0.1% of British Muslims have gone out to join IS, thus to make any assumptions on the faith in general is absolutely f*cking nuts. They aren't, its more that in a current generation the only really active, popular form of extremism is Islamist movements. The problem isn't really anything to do with Muslims being more prone to extremism, but that young people are. In previous generations, it was more far left and far right groups, all of which had their terrorist components, from the NF / Combat 18 through to the Angry Brigade, Class War and Baader Meinhof gangs, to the Provos and the UVF, one thing in common was the appeal to young men (primarily) and young women. Look at any revolution, and you'll find cadres of young men and women at the fore (even the armed and police services tends towards the recruitment of young men and women); and this is because young people are very prone towards idealism, over cynicism: they want to make a difference. Many muslim countries have been in a situation in our lifetimes of national liberation from colonial powers, and suffering from corrupt regimes (usually after national liberation) and this has fuelled a large number of movements of Muslims that were politically active and involved in armed struggles, and that tradition has continued on. During the 60s to early 80s, these were typically leftist movements, but the 80s saw the rise of Islamist movements (spurned on initially by the success of the Iranian Revolution, and then the defeat of the Soviet in Afghanistan). Consequently, that tradition of insurgency, continued into Chechnya, Palestine, Lebanon, Bosnia etc through the 90s, and saw the rise of groups such as Al-Qaeda etc bringing an ideological connection between those groups and other muslims populations, ultimately resulting in the idea of the international Jihadist, from Afghanistan in the 80s, to an grobal icon, a kind of Che Guevera for Islam. But its not just Muslims that are 'vulnerable' to this idealism, its a phenomena of young people, who are drawn to 'dramatic causes', and then from those dramatic causes into extremism. Why aren't non-Islamic young people joining organisations to behead and burn people alive. Were the not so young, professional and highly educated, Muslim doctors who tried to blow up Glasgow airport 'vulnerable' and easily led? There really aren't that many of them, I guess, and they're not recruiting. Of course in the 70s, young people were joining Baader-Meinhoff, the IRA, UVF, ETA, the black brigades, who were all well involved in the killing of people. I don't think its so much vulnerable and easily led, but a general fact of life that young adults are prone towards a idealistic and antagonistic view of the world, and a desire to change it. Its the folly of youth, and been going on for centauries. Its a thing people tend to fall into when young, extreme politics, and then extremist politics after wards Its worth noting both of those two doctors came from Jordan, a country with a very long history of Islamist and Secular terrorism (back as far as the early PLO). The actual numbers joining IS etc aren't very high as a percentage of the population, but at present if your, young, angry and muslim, there exists an entire network of organisations that are very well structured to benefit from that (largely thanks to the work of Al-Qaeda during the late 80s and throughout the 90s). No mistake, groups like IS aren't so much exploiting these people, as making a use of them, in the same way that organisations and states down the centauries have done.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| legaleagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Yes,I was responding to your post and expanding on it.Do try and keep completely up
|
|
| legaleagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Ummm..not sure I follow that.Hard to run out of arguments when nothing is actually being put to rebut.
|
|
|
Quote dannyh at 21 Jun 2015 3.29pm
Quote serial thriller at 19 Jun 2015 11.51pm
Quote dannyh at 19 Jun 2015 7.32am
Quote serial thriller at 18 Jun 2015 10.20pm
Quote dannyh at 18 Jun 2015 4.42pm
Serial answer me this then. In what religion in this country are you most at risk from radicalisation ? Before you answer consider : Although Jehovah’sitnesses are a pain in the arse, not a single one has knocked on my door, waited for me to answer and blew him self up all over my front gardenn, nor has the Bhuddist who lives next door, hacked my head off whilst I was off to the shops, even the mentalist catholic up the road decided not to set me on fire because I didnt agree with his sky fairy on gay marriage. As I said right at the start it is purely and simply risk management.
Second, how many Muslims do you know directly who have blown themselves up/hacked off their heads/set fire to you? This is the problem I was trying to explain to you Danny, you can accept that radical Islam is a problem AND not tar all Muslims with the same brush. Less than 0.1% of British Muslims have gone out to join IS, thus to make any assumptions on the faith in general is absolutely f*cking nuts. Why are Muslims more impressionable to extremism? As I said, I don't know for certain, but my guess would be they see comments like yours, where there is an implicit conflation of all Muslims with their radical terrorist associates and they feel like this country doesn't accept them. Why aren't we focusing on the thousands of Muslims in this country who dedicate their lives to helping people, or the millions who give to charity?
If someone doesnt like me, does that giveme the excuse to kill them ? Does it fcuk as like. And a point to note for you at virtually every Juncture possible I have made it clear that I do not tar all Muslims with the same brush.
There was a Muslim kid, about 14, outside the shop, and I was thinking Christ, what must he think when he sees these ridiculously hyperbolic scare-mongering headlines? Just put yourself in his shoes for a second: you're brought up being told that your religion is peaceful, charitable and tolerant, then all of a sudden you see headlines claiming that your religion is negligent and barbaric. Evidently most Muslims ignore it, given that 99.99% still live in this country in peace and harmony. But a tiny tiny minority must look at it and feel that their belief is sufficiently under attack for them to go and do something stupid. Where is Cameron even getting this message that the Muslim community isn't doing enough? When was the last time he even visited a mosque or spoke to an Imam? In the last post I accused you of generalising Muslims, and I felt like maybe I overstepped the mark. But then I remembered a post you made where you said you'd be fine if your daughter became a Buddhist, but not a Muslim. Why? There is, in this country, a 99.9% chance she would be a perfectly acceptable Muslim, just as there is a perfectly reasonable chance she'd be a very tolerant Buddhist. The chances of her going out to join ISIS are probably only slightly higher than her going out to Burma and joining the Rakhine who themselves are massacring the Muslims in the area. There's probably a better chance she'd actually go out and join the Kurds or the other foreign forces fighting against ISIS. Therefore for me, what that comment suggested was that you genuinely believed that just being a Muslim, regardless of what sect, was in itself a dangerous thing, and that's something I find really worrying, because it's just so untrue.
That is a fact. However much you don't like it. And as a bloke from a catholic irish background growing up in the 70's and eighties I know exactly how that kid felt. My best mates mum called the Catholics a bunch of terrorists to my face knowing I was one, I think I was about 12 at the time. And you know what, the catholic community in England did everything possible to distance themselves from the Provo's something we are not seeing with the poor hard done by Muslim council of great Britain.
As for your last paragraph, read this and tell me in what way the MCB could be more conclusive in their distancing from terrorists: [Link] They actually have more of a reason to chastise ISIS than most, given that they probably represent so many Muslims who have family being killed by ISIS.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4 |
|
| derben |
|
|---|---|
|
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.