This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Cucking Funt at 01 Dec 2015 11.46am
Bombing on its own won't work. It should be opposed simply on the grounds of military pointlessness. Quite. I see no beneficiaries of this other than the companies that provide the ordinance dropped. They should maybe go after the oil smuggling operation, take out the captured oil fields, target those who are brokering the sale of IS oil, those that are laundering it and reselling it. Target the banks that are transferring the funds, and those who are managing their funds. Ultimately, that could cost IS 2-3m per day, plus for the most part, its all 'outside' Syria, and doesn't revolve around blowing people up. Of course it could expose a number of European Companies, Shipping Firms and Allies that are directly profiting from the money made from the black market oil provided by IS.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote npn at 01 Dec 2015 11.52am
Quote Cucking Funt at 01 Dec 2015 11.46am
Bombing on its own won't work. It should be opposed simply on the grounds of military pointlessness.
Especially given that the US and others, have spent the last year or so bombing the f**k out of targets in Syria. It'll make no difference to UK safety or IS, especially given we've been bombing targets in Syria under US command for over a year anyhow.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Kermit8 at 02 Dec 2015 9.13am
The military might of Nato ground troops v 30,000 of them. They'd all be seeing Allah a little bit quicker than they hoped. Won't happen, of course, but would make things a bit tidier in that part of Syria. The country is going to have to be partitioned sooner or later anyway. Optimistic, its astonishing what 30,000 fighters, in a guerrilla conflict, can actually establish. Plus the estimate varies for 30,000 to 70,000 fighters. You have to remember that behind that figure will sit a lot of logistical, command and support individuals as well. 30,000 people actually doing the fighting is a pretty large figure. I think for NATO for each person actually fighting, there are at least five to eight people ensuring that capacity. So if IS has 30,000 in the field it wouldn't be a stretch to imagine it has up to 150,000 active members.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Kermit8 at 02 Dec 2015 11.29am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Dec 2015 10.57am
Quote Kermit8 at 02 Dec 2015 9.13am
The military might of Nato ground troops v 30,000 of them. They'd all be seeing Allah a little bit quicker than they hoped. Won't happen, of course, but would make things a bit tidier in that part of Syria. The country is going to have to be partitioned sooner or later anyway. Optimistic, its astonishing what 30,000 fighters, in a guerrilla conflict, can actually establish. Plus the estimate varies for 30,000 to 70,000 fighters. You have to remember that behind that figure will sit a lot of logistical, command and support individuals as well. 30,000 people actually doing the fighting is a pretty large figure. I think for NATO for each person actually fighting, there are at least five to eight people ensuring that capacity. So if IS has 30,000 in the field it wouldn't be a stretch to imagine it has up to 150,000 active members.
The Kurds have retaken one or two places fairly comfortably. I think you may be over-estimating them. But the longer it is left the less I will be perhaps under-estimating them. Stalingrad? Arguably that was a military disaster for both sides. In fact Stalingrad and Lenningrad cost the Germans the war (and the soviets millions of casualties). Encirclement is a very difficult military strategy to maintain, as it essentially exposes both a front line to the enemy, and supply and logistical lines to partisan / guerrilla forces and reducing your capacity to pacify areas outside the encircled area, whilst still exposing your troops to hostile attacks inside the encircled area. Then you have to consider the civilian consequences. The problem of a modern army is it is utterly dependent on supply to continue to fight. By exposing your supply lines like this, you offer up soft targets to the enemy (essentially a front line is utilised to restrict the enemies capacity to utilise unpacified territory, to stage counter attacks and cut off supply lines. The Germans failed to pacify the areas outside of their 'sieges' despite utilising extermination policy (after the Soviets had utilised a scorched earth policy in retreat). The Kurds retook areas they lost, in open conflict, with total air dominance, but they did suffer significant casualties. In terms of casualties, a military campaign on the ground against IS would probably be reasonable to assume around 1000-3000 deaths of servicemen, and another 6000 significantly wounded.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Cucking Funt at 02 Dec 2015 1.59pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Dec 2015 12.01pm
Quote Kermit8 at 02 Dec 2015 11.29am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Dec 2015 10.57am
Quote Kermit8 at 02 Dec 2015 9.13am
The military might of Nato ground troops v 30,000 of them. They'd all be seeing Allah a little bit quicker than they hoped. Won't happen, of course, but would make things a bit tidier in that part of Syria. The country is going to have to be partitioned sooner or later anyway. Optimistic, its astonishing what 30,000 fighters, in a guerrilla conflict, can actually establish. Plus the estimate varies for 30,000 to 70,000 fighters. You have to remember that behind that figure will sit a lot of logistical, command and support individuals as well. 30,000 people actually doing the fighting is a pretty large figure. I think for NATO for each person actually fighting, there are at least five to eight people ensuring that capacity. So if IS has 30,000 in the field it wouldn't be a stretch to imagine it has up to 150,000 active members.
The Kurds have retaken one or two places fairly comfortably. I think you may be over-estimating them. But the longer it is left the less I will be perhaps under-estimating them. Stalingrad? Arguably that was a military disaster for both sides. In fact Stalingrad and Lenningrad cost the Germans the war (and the soviets millions of casualties). Encirclement is a very difficult military strategy to maintain, as it essentially exposes both a front line to the enemy, and supply and logistical lines to partisan / guerrilla forces and reducing your capacity to pacify areas outside the encircled area, whilst still exposing your troops to hostile attacks inside the encircled area. Then you have to consider the civilian consequences. The problem of a modern army is it is utterly dependent on supply to continue to fight. By exposing your supply lines like this, you offer up soft targets to the enemy (essentially a front line is utilised to restrict the enemies capacity to utilise unpacified territory, to stage counter attacks and cut off supply lines. The Germans failed to pacify the areas outside of their 'sieges' despite utilising extermination policy (after the Soviets had utilised a scorched earth policy in retreat). The Kurds retook areas they lost, in open conflict, with total air dominance, but they did suffer significant casualties. In terms of casualties, a military campaign on the ground against IS would probably be reasonable to assume around 1000-3000 deaths of servicemen, and another 6000 significantly wounded.
Current affairs and history interest me.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote matt_himself at 02 Dec 2015 2.19pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 02 Dec 2015 1.59pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Dec 2015 12.01pm
Quote Kermit8 at 02 Dec 2015 11.29am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Dec 2015 10.57am
Quote Kermit8 at 02 Dec 2015 9.13am
The military might of Nato ground troops v 30,000 of them. They'd all be seeing Allah a little bit quicker than they hoped. Won't happen, of course, but would make things a bit tidier in that part of Syria. The country is going to have to be partitioned sooner or later anyway. Optimistic, its astonishing what 30,000 fighters, in a guerrilla conflict, can actually establish. Plus the estimate varies for 30,000 to 70,000 fighters. You have to remember that behind that figure will sit a lot of logistical, command and support individuals as well. 30,000 people actually doing the fighting is a pretty large figure. I think for NATO for each person actually fighting, there are at least five to eight people ensuring that capacity. So if IS has 30,000 in the field it wouldn't be a stretch to imagine it has up to 150,000 active members.
The Kurds have retaken one or two places fairly comfortably. I think you may be over-estimating them. But the longer it is left the less I will be perhaps under-estimating them. Stalingrad? Arguably that was a military disaster for both sides. In fact Stalingrad and Lenningrad cost the Germans the war (and the soviets millions of casualties). Encirclement is a very difficult military strategy to maintain, as it essentially exposes both a front line to the enemy, and supply and logistical lines to partisan / guerrilla forces and reducing your capacity to pacify areas outside the encircled area, whilst still exposing your troops to hostile attacks inside the encircled area. Then you have to consider the civilian consequences. The problem of a modern army is it is utterly dependent on supply to continue to fight. By exposing your supply lines like this, you offer up soft targets to the enemy (essentially a front line is utilised to restrict the enemies capacity to utilise unpacified territory, to stage counter attacks and cut off supply lines. The Germans failed to pacify the areas outside of their 'sieges' despite utilising extermination policy (after the Soviets had utilised a scorched earth policy in retreat). The Kurds retook areas they lost, in open conflict, with total air dominance, but they did suffer significant casualties. In terms of casualties, a military campaign on the ground against IS would probably be reasonable to assume around 1000-3000 deaths of servicemen, and another 6000 significantly wounded.
I am sure this is a coincidence but sometimes Jamie's posts on a subject match, almost word for word, the Wikipedia entry on that particular subject. I wasn't aware that HOL Online required full Harvard Referencing. Sometimes I'll refer to Wikipedia, usually about something I'm not sure about, or where its a question of facts that are referenced. Often though, I'll use the Open University Library sources, as I'm a member (as a registered student), its nearly as quick, online and surprisingly vast. I generally won't use wikipedo unless the reference checks out. How about you, what sources do you use?
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 02 Dec 2015 2.41pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Dec 2015 12.01pm
Quote Kermit8 at 02 Dec 2015 11.29am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Dec 2015 10.57am
Quote Kermit8 at 02 Dec 2015 9.13am
The military might of Nato ground troops v 30,000 of them. They'd all be seeing Allah a little bit quicker than they hoped. Won't happen, of course, but would make things a bit tidier in that part of Syria. The country is going to have to be partitioned sooner or later anyway. Optimistic, its astonishing what 30,000 fighters, in a guerrilla conflict, can actually establish. Plus the estimate varies for 30,000 to 70,000 fighters. You have to remember that behind that figure will sit a lot of logistical, command and support individuals as well. 30,000 people actually doing the fighting is a pretty large figure. I think for NATO for each person actually fighting, there are at least five to eight people ensuring that capacity. So if IS has 30,000 in the field it wouldn't be a stretch to imagine it has up to 150,000 active members.
The Kurds have retaken one or two places fairly comfortably. I think you may be over-estimating them. But the longer it is left the less I will be perhaps under-estimating them. Stalingrad? Arguably that was a military disaster for both sides. In fact Stalingrad and Lenningrad cost the Germans the war (and the soviets millions of casualties). Encirclement is a very difficult military strategy to maintain, as it essentially exposes both a front line to the enemy, and supply and logistical lines to partisan / guerrilla forces and reducing your capacity to pacify areas outside the encircled area, whilst still exposing your troops to hostile attacks inside the encircled area. Then you have to consider the civilian consequences. The problem of a modern army is it is utterly dependent on supply to continue to fight. By exposing your supply lines like this, you offer up soft targets to the enemy (essentially a front line is utilised to restrict the enemies capacity to utilise unpacified territory, to stage counter attacks and cut off supply lines. The Germans failed to pacify the areas outside of their 'sieges' despite utilising extermination policy (after the Soviets had utilised a scorched earth policy in retreat). The Kurds retook areas they lost, in open conflict, with total air dominance, but they did suffer significant casualties. In terms of casualties, a military campaign on the ground against IS would probably be reasonable to assume around 1000-3000 deaths of servicemen, and another 6000 significantly wounded.
I am for air strikes but other action needs to happen eg targeting revenue and weapons supply. the Arab states need to take a greater involvement. The only UK troops I want to see on the ground are support ( inc special forces) not front line. This to me, makes more sense. The use of airpower has traditionally been better applied against the enemies capacity to wage war (resources, supply, logistics and financial capacity) than against individuals. Without resources, logistical and financial capacity, an organisation rapidly loses it capacity to hold itself togeather.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Tom-the-eagle at 02 Dec 2015 2.43pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Dec 2015 2.36pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 02 Dec 2015 1.59pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Dec 2015 12.01pm
Quote Kermit8 at 02 Dec 2015 11.29am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Dec 2015 10.57am
Quote Kermit8 at 02 Dec 2015 9.13am
The military might of Nato ground troops v 30,000 of them. They'd all be seeing Allah a little bit quicker than they hoped. Won't happen, of course, but would make things a bit tidier in that part of Syria. The country is going to have to be partitioned sooner or later anyway. Optimistic, its astonishing what 30,000 fighters, in a guerrilla conflict, can actually establish. Plus the estimate varies for 30,000 to 70,000 fighters. You have to remember that behind that figure will sit a lot of logistical, command and support individuals as well. 30,000 people actually doing the fighting is a pretty large figure. I think for NATO for each person actually fighting, there are at least five to eight people ensuring that capacity. So if IS has 30,000 in the field it wouldn't be a stretch to imagine it has up to 150,000 active members.
The Kurds have retaken one or two places fairly comfortably. I think you may be over-estimating them. But the longer it is left the less I will be perhaps under-estimating them. Stalingrad? Arguably that was a military disaster for both sides. In fact Stalingrad and Lenningrad cost the Germans the war (and the soviets millions of casualties). Encirclement is a very difficult military strategy to maintain, as it essentially exposes both a front line to the enemy, and supply and logistical lines to partisan / guerrilla forces and reducing your capacity to pacify areas outside the encircled area, whilst still exposing your troops to hostile attacks inside the encircled area. Then you have to consider the civilian consequences. The problem of a modern army is it is utterly dependent on supply to continue to fight. By exposing your supply lines like this, you offer up soft targets to the enemy (essentially a front line is utilised to restrict the enemies capacity to utilise unpacified territory, to stage counter attacks and cut off supply lines. The Germans failed to pacify the areas outside of their 'sieges' despite utilising extermination policy (after the Soviets had utilised a scorched earth policy in retreat). The Kurds retook areas they lost, in open conflict, with total air dominance, but they did suffer significant casualties. In terms of casualties, a military campaign on the ground against IS would probably be reasonable to assume around 1000-3000 deaths of servicemen, and another 6000 significantly wounded.
Current affairs and history interest me. As does Wikipedia Not particularly.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
how about we start holding the saudis responsible for their terrorist funding. or at least have them send some soldiers to do some of the dirty work.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.