This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
IS and their like are to Islam what the Klan is to Christianity. Borrowed from the West Wing 9/11 episode. This is a crap analogy. The KKK don't immigrate to Arabic countries and then kill at random. They're f***ing idiots but the comparison isn't valid.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by legaleagle
Let's take your example of the Balkans at face value Danny. Where precisely is it kicking off there now and why? When it did all kick off ,was it(1) because of muslims? or (2) because of gutter carve up power games by the Serbian nationalists (Orthadox Christians) and the Croatian nationalists (Catholics) which started things off so the muslim community ended up having to defend itself from massacres such as Srebrenica and radicalising much of that community . If that's not enough for you,look up the previous round of inter religious/ethnic killings in the region in 1941-45 and look up the mass killings Jasenovac concentration camp.Was it run by (1) muslims or (2) Croatian fascists in alliance with the local Catholic church? There is plainly a problem we face from sulafist jihadi ideology...but to be too simplistic can be worse than pretending the issue doesn't exist ... In terms of N Ireland,where arguably we could have dealt with things a lot better in say 1968-75 in winning over the hears and minds of the wider Catholic community rather than letting the Provos make so many inroads. Our armed forces gained a reputation for being good at counter insurgency in Malaya in the 1950's (a reputation we lived off until Iraq and Afghanistan) precisely because "hearts and minds" was recognised as very important in relation to the peaceful majority of an ethnic group from within which a violent extreme had taken up arms.A lesson the Americans so ignored in Vietnam. We forget those lessons/reminders now at our peril. Edited by legaleagle (20 Jul 2016 11.39am) I would suggest that there are many different lessons we could learn from history and which ones we choose to learn say something about us.
|
|
|
Originally posted by legaleagle
Well,ignoring the lessons of former Yugoslavia,counter-insurgency strategy in the former British Empire, and N Ireland would certainly say something about the person ignoring them,I can agree that... Well I wouldn't claim to be an expert on military strategy or history but you clearly would.
|
|
| legaleagle |
|
|---|---|
|
now now
|
|
|
Originally posted by legaleagle
Let's take your example of the Balkans at face value Danny. Where precisely is it kicking off there now and why? When it did all kick off ,was it(1) because of muslims? or (2) because of gutter carve up power games by the Serbian nationalists (Orthadox Christians) and the Croatian nationalists (Catholics) which started things off so the muslim community ended up having to defend itself from massacres such as Srebrenica and radicalising much of that community . If that's not enough for you,look up the previous round of inter religious/ethnic killings in the region in 1941-45 and look up the mass killings Jasenovac concentration camp.Was it run by (1) muslims or (2) Croatian fascists in alliance with the local Catholic church? There is plainly a problem we face from sulafist jihadi ideology...but to be too simplistic can be worse than pretending the issue doesn't exist ... In terms of N Ireland,where arguably we could have dealt with things a lot better in say 1968-75 in winning over the hears and minds of the wider Catholic community rather than letting the Provos make so many inroads. Our armed forces gained a reputation for being good at counter insurgency in Malaya in the 1950's (a reputation we lived off until Iraq and Afghanistan) precisely because "hearts and minds" was recognised as very important in relation to the peaceful majority of an ethnic group from within which a violent extreme had taken up arms.A lesson the Americans so ignored in Vietnam. We forget those lessons/reminders now at our peril. Edited by legaleagle (20 Jul 2016 11.39am) Much of what has been written about Malaya has been debunked, and the British were pretty brutal in their treatment of the ethnic Chinese. Furthermore, the US did use British expertise in Vietnam, and it backfired as the lessons from the Malayan conflict did not translate well to the far more complex situation in Vietnam. Where the lessons of Malaya were false can best be seen with the fact that the communists almost exclusively came from the minority ethic Chinese population who were easily (forcibly) separated from the ethnic majority and from the communist insurgents. The same policy in Vietnam was disastrous.
If you come to a fork in the road, take it. |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by dannyh
Is that a fact ? well I suggest you visit Afghan, Western Africa, Iran, Iraq, the Balkans, basically everywhere were the Muslim faith is the ruling religion there is trouble,(bar the kingdom of saudi and we all know why that it.) there is no getting away from it Jamie, as unpalatable as it may be for some, the religion of Islam has no place in a modern progressive society that tolerates all. Difference is Muslims are fighting on both sides in that (incidentally Saudi Arabia is also engaged in fighting in Yemen) - Which is why the Nazi analogy with Germans and Nazi's was incorrect (a good example of the complexity is that in Syria you have). So whilst you have Muslims fighting in those countries, its kind of important to remember that those are also a) civil wars and internal conflicts and b) they're Muslim countries where most of the population is Muslim. In Afghanistan, the government forces and the various opposition forces are Muslims. Same as in Iraq and Syria, and we're supporting one side in both conflicts. Its too much of a simplification to say Islam is war - You could probably say the same of Secular UK (been involved in five wars r conflicts in 17 years). Or Christianity, given that lots of Christians are fighting in different countries (as well as part of the UK and US forces). You could say Jews, and point out that Israeli has been fighting war, pretty much since its inception. Islam doesn't come down to a simple equation, nothing does.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stuk
This is a crap analogy. The KKK don't immigrate to Arabic countries and then kill at random. They're f***ing idiots but the comparison isn't valid. That's why its an analogy, rather than a comparison.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
That's why its an analogy, rather than a comparison. One and the same, and still a crap one.
Optimistic as ever |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
What you are proposing is changing British law to pander to religious nonsense. The guilt or innocence of Muslims with regard to terrorism is secondary.
Sorry what expense of the vast majority. It would be at no expense of the majority. When some nutbars burned poppies, it resulted in a change of law (its now an offence). Its mearly extending the same courtesy that exists for other religious groups in the UK. Its noteworthy that publications of such material whilst not illegal in the UK, have resulted in warnings that doing so, would breach existing law on incitement and public order offences, if done 'for its own sake'. Interestingly, prior to 1998 and the human rights act, it would have been illegal, as a result of the 1998 act was free expression, which required that the public order offence laws be changed to removing insulting or offensive behaviour. Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
As far as comparisons with the IRA, we are back to appeasement again. You are either suggesting this in a misguided effort to be "inclusive" or you you are appeasing terrorists. Which one is it? Neither, its a practical methodology for choking off the support basis for such groups. In NI, the focus on treating Republicanism, and Catholic Community movements are 'IRA sympathetic' resulted in increased support for the PIRA. In fact, the Bloody Sunday massacre of the civil rights movement, did more for the Provisional IRA than anything they could have done themselves. Its a reality of terrorist conflicts, is that in order to resolve them, you have to deal with the legitimate complaints that are at their heart - Not because we're weak, but because otherwise the conflict goes on generation on generation. Similarly, the demise of left wing terrorism in Germany and Italy was largely attributed to increasing success of Left Wing and Environmental politics, creating an affective outlet for change. Yes, you have to fight the terrorists, but to achieve a reasonable long term strategy, you also have to deal with the issues that are causing people to drift into our become radicalised. Otherwise every time you pretty much deal with the problem, you're just taking time out before it raises its head. Whilst some people are radicalised by the big things, most are drawn into radicalism at first by fairly reasonable things, step by step. Some people will see IS and fall in love most people who be turned against society, by their experience from society and how it regards them. Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Either would be a disastrous mistake.This country has a history of resisting religious. I'm very grateful to Henry VIII for his marriage issues and that I'm not subject to Catholicism as a result. I sure don't want to become an honorary Muslim through any law. Muslims should no more expect to be pandered to in this country than I would if I wanted to open a bacon sandwich shop in Mecca. I think we have all compromised enough already. Except of course it resulted in the bloodiest period of British religious history, which is still felt today in parts of the UK in the bitter feuding between protestant and catholic communities, as well as exasperating the situation in the Troubles in NI - and has regularly resulted in violence and murder. It was probably the single worst decision he made, politically, and he put in place the commons, and events that led to the English Civil War.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| legaleagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by NickinOX
Much of what has been written about Malaya has been debunked, and the British were pretty brutal in their treatment of the ethnic Chinese. Furthermore, the US did use British expertise in Vietnam, and it backfired as the lessons from the Malayan conflict did not translate well to the far more complex situation in Vietnam. Where the lessons of Malaya were false can best be seen with the fact that the communists almost exclusively came from the minority ethic Chinese population who were easily (forcibly) separated from the ethnic majority and from the communist insurgents. The same policy in Vietnam was disastrous. Agreed,much about Malaya can be legitimately argued over,but essentially the British (while I agree being quite brutal at various times in their counter insurgency tactics) successfully "won over" many hearts and minds in the Chinese community and kept them attuned to a pro-Western tack rather than the Malayan Communist Party/Malayan National Liberation Army. That wasn't so much about ethnic segregation, communities were pretty separate in reality pre "the Emergency",more about stopping support for the MCP/MNLA within its main target "hinterland" the Chinese community. I do think the US failed to learn some of the lessons from Malaya re "hearts and minds" not least supporting/bolstering pro western politicians who were not innately corrupt/divise and so had some change of garnering genuine local support. Edited by legaleagle (20 Jul 2016 2.08pm)
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by legaleagle
Agreed,much about Malaya can be legitimately argued over,but essentially the British (while I agree being quite brutal at various times in their counter insurgency tactics) successfully "won over" many hearts and minds in the Chinese community and kept them attuned to a pro-Western tack rather than the Malayan Communist Party/Malayan National Liberation Army. That wasn't so much about ethnic segregation, communities were pretty separate in reality pre "the Emergency",more about stopping support for the MCP/MNLA within its main target "hinterland" the Chinese community. I do think the US failed to learn some of the lessons from Malaya re "hearts and minds" not least supporting/bolstering pro western politicians who were not innately corrupt/divise and so had some change of garnering genuine local support. Edited by legaleagle (20 Jul 2016 2.08pm) Its like an incurable disease. You isolate the infected, who are beyond help. Then you vaccinate those who are vulnerable against the disease and eliminate the factors that are causing the pathogen to spread infection. You have to do all three to effectively beat a disease, and fundamentalism is a disease of religious thinking and political ambition.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Except of course it resulted in the bloodiest period of British religious history, which is still felt today in parts of the UK in the bitter feuding between protestant and catholic communities, as well as exasperating the situation in the Troubles in NI - and has regularly resulted in violence and murder. It was probably the single worst decision he made, politically, and he put in place the commons, and events that led to the English Civil War. Your suggestion was images of the prophet. There are , as you say, existing laws that cover deliberate incitement to violence and they are more than enough. Henry VIII might have had selfish intensions and short sighted but as it turned out, the upheaval in the past was worth it to rid ourselves of the Pope. Sometimes achieving the right outcome requires some negatives along the way. I'm not sure I see Norther Ireland history quite the same way either. We stood up to the IRA, especially during the Thatcher era and despite a heavy price paid, we arrived at a peace. One can speculate as to what would have happened if we had taken softer approach.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Your suggestion was images of the prophet. There are , as you say, existing laws that cover deliberate incitement to violence and they are more than enough. Henry VIII might have had selfish intensions and short sighted but as it turned out, the upheaval in the past was worth it to rid ourselves of the Pope. Sometimes achieving the right outcome requires some negatives along the way. I'm not sure I see Norther Ireland history quite the same way either. We stood up to the IRA, especially during the Thatcher era and despite a heavy price paid, we arrived at a peace. One can speculate as to what would have happened if we had taken softer approach. No speculation required to say that there would have been less incidents without the freedom of movement between the UK and Ireland though.
Optimistic as ever |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Your suggestion was images of the prophet. There are , as you say, existing laws that cover deliberate incitement to violence and they are more than enough. Yeah, but sometimes its good to get some specific good will in a subculture or group and appeal to them directly. I wouldn't say that all of the issues of the Islamic community could be incorporated into UK law, but there was some interesting stuff on Sharia law I read recently, which if you're talking about the more moderate, every day Muslim, wouldn't even require changes to British Law to accept. And in the long term, our community will always consist of groups outside the 'will of the majority', and part of the responsibility of a democracy is to represent not just those that win you votes, but everyone. Even the stuff you don't like (I'm probably about as anti-religious as you can get, but I do get that most religious people in the UK are generally normal law abiding folk, and need to be represented as well). Granted, give me an ideal world, and there would be no room for religion... Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Henry VIII might have had selfish intensions and short sighted but as it turned out, the upheaval in the past was worth it to rid ourselves of the Pope. Sometimes achieving the right outcome requires some negatives along the way. Really though you can thank Elizabeth the I and Francis Walsingham especially for that. But of course the purge of Catholics power in the UK, was achieved in a manner not dissimilar to that of IS. Although Henry the VIIIth was really just resolving a long dispute, common in the monarchy of England between the Divine Right of Kings and Papal authority. England was always a 'troublesome' and often 'less than friendly' authority to the Church. Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I'm not sure I see Norther Ireland history quite the same way either. We stood up to the IRA, especially during the Thatcher era and despite a heavy price paid, we arrived at a peace. One can speculate as to what would have happened if we had taken softer approach. Thatcher was holding talks with the Provisional IRA throughout the 80s, or at least by proxy - The British Secret Service also functioned in Ireland to preserve Sinn Feins position as well as acting on at least two occasions to prevent the assassination of Gerry Adams by loyalists, and to keep him in position as the lead republican voice in the Provisional IRA - He and the UK saw the future of Republicanism as ultimately unachievable by violence - and the UK could deal and compromise on a basis of him bringing about the peace process Competition to the Provisionals, such an INLA, were dealt with, isolated and effectively destroyed with far more efficiency, than was shown to the Provos. Also increasing peace meant prosperity, and improvement in the conditions of the Catholic community, and by encouraging and supporting moderate protestant voices like Trimble, the hardline on both the republican and loyalist sides were increasingly being over taken by 'more reasonable representatives' who you could make 'a deal with'. Adams manipulation of the IRA increasingly saw more 'acceptable' people in the organisation, and increasingly less violent actions, especially on the UK mainland. In the end, Sinn Fein ended up in the UK parliament, and with a considerable voice in the NI assembly, and the troubles more or less, have been put to bed. Increased prosperity in NI was directed towards the Catholic communities. Catholics increased in representation in the RUC, local government and income and the appeal of 'A war with the British' diminished as life opportunities for Catholics increased (and the protestant moderates were also key in assuring this happened). Its distasteful, and arguably morally wrong, but the end result was effective. The end result though does seem to have been successful. The appeal of groups like the Real IRA etc are very limited, and more localised to rural areas and more geared around organised crime positioning, than political ambitions. A lot of what happened, like the freedom of prisoners, I didn't like, but it also was necessary to establish a lasting peace, and compromise is inevitable - But the really important thing, was not winning over the IRA, UVF but managing to isolate their appeal from the Protestant and Catholic communities. Whilst we were still fighting the Provisional IRA and UVF, the British Government in the 80s and 90s, were working to change the communities, and engage the people - You can't beat an idea, but you can make that idea less and less appealing, by offering alternatives and eliminating the frustration and alienation that leads to people seeing violence as the only response. Even if it means a c**t like Gerry Adams, better him than some c**t you can't make a deal with.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Thatcher was holding talks with the Provisional IRA throughout the 80s, or at least by proxy - The British Secret Service also functioned in Ireland to preserve Sinn Feins position as well as acting on at least two occasions to prevent the assassination of Gerry Adams by loyalists, and to keep him in position as the lead republican voice in the Provisional IRA - He and the UK saw the future of Republicanism as ultimately unachievable by violence - and the UK could deal and compromise on a basis of him bringing about the peace process Competition to the Provisionals, such an INLA, were dealt with, isolated and effectively destroyed with far more efficiency, than was shown to the Provos. Also increasing peace meant prosperity, and improvement in the conditions of the Catholic community, and by encouraging and supporting moderate protestant voices like Trimble, the hardline on both the republican and loyalist sides were increasingly being over taken by 'more reasonable representatives' who you could make 'a deal with'. Adams manipulation of the IRA increasingly saw more 'acceptable' people in the organisation, and increasingly less violent actions, especially on the UK mainland. In the end, Sinn Fein ended up in the UK parliament, and with a considerable voice in the NI assembly, and the troubles more or less, have been put to bed. Increased prosperity in NI was directed towards the Catholic communities. Catholics increased in representation in the RUC, local government and income and the appeal of 'A war with the British' diminished as life opportunities for Catholics increased (and the protestant moderates were also key in assuring this happened). Its distasteful, and arguably morally wrong, but the end result was effective. The end result though does seem to have been successful. The appeal of groups like the Real IRA etc are very limited, and more localised to rural areas and more geared around organised crime positioning, than political ambitions. A lot of what happened, like the freedom of prisoners, I didn't like, but it also was necessary to establish a lasting peace, and compromise is inevitable - But the really important thing, was not winning over the IRA, UVF but managing to isolate their appeal from the Protestant and Catholic communities. Whilst we were still fighting the Provisional IRA and UVF, the British Government in the 80s and 90s, were working to change the communities, and engage the people - You can't beat an idea, but you can make that idea less and less appealing, by offering alternatives and eliminating the frustration and alienation that leads to people seeing violence as the only response. Even if it means a c**t like Gerry Adams, better him than some c**t you can't make a deal with.
....I'm very happy to add Queen Elizabeth I or anyone else to the list of people I would thank for the process that allowed Britain to become a largly secular country. .... The process that lead to peace in NI required all sorts of compromise and ground laying but any negotiation is better had from a position of strength. The key here is that weakness is not acceptable. There is a difference between manipulation and capitulation. In that regard, how your enemy interprets your actions are all important. We tried kissing Hitler's arse and I see Islam as a much bigger potential threat to our way of life than Hitler ever was. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (20 Jul 2016 4.22pm)
|
|
| legaleagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Dude?! Hrolf,I am worried that corrosive external forces may be permeating your cerebal hygiene!
|
|
|
Originally posted by legaleagle
Dude?! Hrolf,I am worried that corrosive external forces may be permeating your cerebal hygiene! Ha! I feel I need to throw in the odd coloquialism just to fit in.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Dude, you make it sound like people wander about with T-shirts of the Prophet to piss off Muslims. The vast majority don't want to offend anyone, Muslim, Catholic, Trekie. whoever. What most people don't like is to be made to feel awkward in their own country by a minority. You seem to think that the onus is on the majority to show good will but I would argue it is the reverse. The minority should compromise. Minority and majorities must compromise, but the majority hold a great sway of influence over minorities. To find a common ground, between the averages in society, everyone has to compromise. We extend many religious exemptions to assorted religions, whilst remaining primarily secular, in doing so we compromise with minority groups as a process that includes those groups into society. Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
.... The process that lead to peace in NI required all sorts of compromise and ground laying but any negotiation is better had from a position of strength. The key here is that weakness is not acceptable. There is a difference between manipulation and capitulation. In that regard, how your enemy interprets your actions are all important. We tried kissing Hitler's arse and I see Islam as a much bigger potential threat to our way of life than Hitler ever was. Picture the England team giving Nazi salutes to Hitler, because we were essentially trying to avoid offending the might of Nazi Germany, and then remember how well that worked out. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (20 Jul 2016 4.22pm) The important issue in Ireland wasn't compromising with the IRA, but dealing with the social issues and complaints of the Catholic community and creating the possibility of a political solution. As I've said countless times, its not about compromise with IS, Al-Qaeda et al. That's never an option, because their issues and basis are largely undeliverable for us (primarily the creation of an Islamic state for the first, and the second a series of issues revolving around Saudia Arabia and Middle Eastern geo-politics we have no real influence over. The issue, is about greater integration of the Muslim community into the wider mainstream, creating a public political means of raising and addressing issues,rather than increasing isolation and demonization, whilst simultaneously targeting IS, and those who recruit for them, finance them and provide real support to such groups. At present there aren't really any political parties that address issues from the Muslim community in our democratic process, arguably Respect (the f**king farce) were the only outlet. And that's how significant a political outlet is, that George F**king Galloway was elected. You often talk about the success of UKIP, but remember that Galloway won a seat in parliament, for Respect, on the basis of support from 4.4% of the population - By addressing issues specifically from the Muslim community (and against a popular Labour opposition).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger .... The process that lead to peace in NI required all sorts of compromise and ground laying but any negotiation is better had from a position of strength. The key here is that weakness is not acceptable. There is a difference between manipulation and capitulation. In that regard, how your enemy interprets your actions are all important. We tried kissing Hitler's arse and I see Islam as a much bigger potential threat to our way of life than Hitler ever was.
Picture the England team giving Nazi salutes to Hitler, because we were essentially trying to avoid offending the might of Nazi Germany, and then remember how well that worked out. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (20 Jul 2016 4.22pm) Only relevant if you consider all Muslims to be extremist supporters. We cannot compromise with IS and terrorism, but we can with those who aren't which is, conservatively, at least 95% of UK Muslims.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.