This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| citizensmudge |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
You are a self confessed football thug so I hardly expect you to agree with the opinions of ordinary decent people Honestly dude your embarrassing.
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 23 Sep 16 10.03am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by citizensmudge
They were kids who probably go to the game and then go clubbing later on so it is part of their ritual.Its important to them and they held a banner up,they didn't grab a steward and behead them or handcuff themselves to the goalposts during the game.When you talk about self-importance do you not see that the arguments being thrown about here by some wannabe Victorian Headmasters are the most self-important comments to come out of this bollox.A lot of them kids probably live for Palace at Selhurst and then out on the razz with their besties and its what memories are made of and how lifelong friendships are formed.If you, Hoof or any of the other posters who are whining about a bedsheet with some writing on it missed out on those memories and frienships then I pity you and understand your complete ignorance for what those kids did and why.IF however you watched games when you were in your late teens/early twenties and went out on the pi$$ after at Studio,Cinderellas,Sinatras etc etc and remember those nights to this day then you need to take your head for a crap and lighten the f@ck up. Hold on a minute and go back to my first post on this matter. I said "I couldn't give a fcuk what they get up to...." Basically my message was I go to football to watch football first and foremost.... all the other stuff that makes up the day is secondary. For holding that view it seems that you and other HF obsessives regard me as a Victorian Headmaster, a pant wetter, a tool, a helmet, etc. I'll repeat my views again just incase anyone is confused.... the HF are at their best whipping up the crowd to join in with songs of support and that is what the Media have picked up on and complimented our fans for (not just the HF but our fans in general). In a nutshell I like watching football without distractions particularly when Palace are/were playing well like we were last Sunday. Can I make one further request? Cut out the insults on here... we're all adults and it is common practice for individuals to hold opposing views. It is childish and moronic to give personal abuse to another person just because he/she disagrees with you. Just agree to disagree and move on.
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 23 Sep 16 10.13am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by laddo
Said it before, say it again, the attack on HF is simply out of jealousy. 'We go to football for football'. Rubbish, and completely misrepresents what the game means deep down in the heart. Yes, on the face of it we go to watch the game. But to identify with something, to live and breath it, to follow a common cause is extremely empowering. If using the platform to make political points too then fine. Saying football isn't political is grossly naive and shows complete ignorance. Ask Boban if football is political. Ask the west Brom lad who gets pelters for not wearing a poppy, ask Liverpool fans who fought for justice for the 96 from the terraces if football isn't political. To then ask why don't the HF campaign about fcuking rhinos tells you all you need to know about their critics. I'm no big fan of the face covering. That's it. Apart from that the atmosphere they create is superb and I've never been offended by any political message they've shared. If they turned out to be neo-nazis I'd be for driving them out, but looking at the cross section of who is involved I'm sure that won't ever happen. The fact that I was taking the p1ss completely went over your head did it? Young kids that want to save a nightclub famed for drugs wouldn't even be aware of Rhinos being slaughtered in Africa or care two hoots about it.... that was the point I was making... as a 62 year old I also wasn't aware of "Fabric" or care two hoots about it. However I wasn't holding up a bedsheet with Rhino written on it in the middle of our game with Stoke. As I keep saying the HF are a welcome addition to the matchday experience, but cut out the politics and keep on singing the songs, banging the drum, jumping up and down etc.... we love that! Edited by Hoof Hearted (23 Sep 2016 10.22am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
The fact that I was taking the p1ss completely went over your head did it? Young kids that want to save a nightclub famed for drugs wouldn't even be aware of Rhinos being slaughtered in Africa or care.... that was the point I was making... as a 62 year old I also wasn't aware of Fabric or care. However I wasn't holding up a bedsheet with Rhino written on it in the middle of our game with Stoke. As I keep saying the HF are a welcome addition to the matchday experience, but cut out the politics and keep on singing the songs, banging the drum, jumping up and down etc.... we love that! The rhinos along with my rather long post was satire and a bit of a piss take anyone would realise that. If they want to protest about fabric then yes at the end of the day that's up to them but at a game of football completely unconnected to it seems rather odd. Just think about it for a minute if every one turned up with a banner at the next home game with a slogan or a cause written on it which was close to our hearts it would get silly. I also find it a bit hypocritical that the same group of people who complain about sky would use the same corporation to get their message out to a global audience and then a couple of them at the front (if you sit front row your own brain tells yo u the camera might go on you at some stage) get upset when the camera goes on them after the goal was scored. Now you must admit that's a bit bloody odd
When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC |
|
| Hoof Hearted 23 Sep 16 10.34am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Michaelawt85
The rhinos along with my rather long post was satire and a bit of a piss take anyone would realise that. If they want to protest about fabric then yes at the end of the day that's up to them but at a game of football completely unconnected to it seems rather odd. Just think about it for a minute if every one turned up with a banner at the next home game with a slogan or a cause written on it which was close to our hearts it would get silly. I also find it a bit hypocritical that the same group of people who complain about sky would use the same corporation to get their message out to a global audience and then a couple of them at the front (if you sit front row your own brain tells yo u the camera might go on you at some stage) get upset when the camera goes on them after the goal was scored. Now you must admit that's a bit bloody odd You're making a dangerous assumption there Michaela. I'm not sure what childish abuse they'll target you with... I've already bagged Victorian Headmaster, pant wetter, tool and helmet.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
The fact that I was taking the p1ss completely went over your head did it? Young kids that want to save a nightclub famed for drugs wouldn't even be aware of Rhinos being slaughtered in Africa or care two hoots about it.... that was the point I was making... as a 62 year old I also wasn't aware of "Fabric" or care two hoots about it. However I wasn't holding up a bedsheet with Rhino written on it in the middle of our game with Stoke. As I keep saying the HF are a welcome addition to the matchday experience, but cut out the politics and keep on singing the songs, banging the drum, jumping up and down etc.... we love that! Edited by Hoof Hearted (23 Sep 2016 10.22am) Probably because Rhino's aren't relevant right now to a crowd of 18-25's. However, Fabric IS shutting down right now. So they have the potential to do something about it.. the picture has been shared all over social media and the group have brought a lot of attention to the cause. I don't think "Save the Rhino's" would do much as it's not as specific a cause.. What do the "older" generation do for fun? If they were shutting down that Bingo hall in Croydon, I'm sure the HF wouldn't mind if you waved a little banner.. there definitely wouldn't be a thread about it!!
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 23 Sep 16 11.09am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by CJr94
Probably because Rhino's aren't relevant right now to a crowd of 18-25's. However, Fabric IS shutting down right now. So they have the potential to do something about it.. the picture has been shared all over social media and the group have brought a lot of attention to the cause. I don't think "Save the Rhino's" would do much as it's not as specific a cause.. What do the "older" generation do for fun? If they were shutting down that Bingo hall in Croydon, I'm sure the HF wouldn't mind if you waved a little banner.. there definitely wouldn't be a thread about it!! Do you know what proportion of the crowd the 18-25 age group is? I don't... but I'll take an educated guess that it's less than 20%. Maybe you should remember that a cross section of our society go to watch Palace across all ages and social groups. Of that 20% I mentioned above, probably less than 10% of them would be likely to go to Fabric, so we're actually talking about 2% of the Selhurst crowd being interested or concerned about that particular cause. You ask what the 'Older Generation' do for fun? Well part of it is following the club you have loved and supported for 50+ years and to be able to watch them win 4-1 at home at a canter without having to have some political demonstrations imposed upon us when all we want to do is celebrate. I've never played bingo in my life nor intend to start so you'll have to think of another pastime associated with the elderly to try and undermine my argument. All you are doing is burdening the rest of us with your sad disappointment about your precious club closing... as you get older you'll learn to overcome what life throws at you and bounce back... but you won't if you just dwell on the misery.
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 23 Sep 16 11.17am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Dan1994
Firstly, Fabric shutting down affects a fair amount of our support as well as the HF, why aren't they allowed to put a banner up? No one's stopping you from doing the same. Secondly, bemoaning the banner when there have been loads made. Clearly no one remembers the banner when 7 lads in Croydon got stabbed in as many days, and they called on the council to sort it out. But yeah, what a s***e message that is, and they only stick up fot the youth. Edited by Dan1994 (23 Sep 2016 10.58am) I think all banners that aren't related to Palace are crap.... but if I had support for any of them then one calling for Croydon Council to take action over 7 stabbings might get my support but I would favour one calling for the Police to take action as surely they are better suited to the task than the Council? Maybe the HF ought to run their banner strategy by me first as I seem to have my finger on the pulse of what might be acceptable at Selhurst than they have?
|
|
|
Can someone please explain to me what the HF think will happen because they held a piece of fabric up with save fabric on?
|
|
|
Originally posted by steph_eagle
Can someone please explain to me what the HF think will happen because they held a piece of fabric up with save fabric on? Bring awareness to the cause.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
Do you know what proportion of the crowd the 18-25 age group is? I don't... but I'll take an educated guess that it's less than 20%. Maybe you should remember that a cross section of our society go to watch Palace across all ages and social groups. Of that 20% I mentioned above, probably less than 10% of them would be likely to go to Fabric, so we're actually talking about 2% of the Selhurst crowd being interested or concerned about that particular cause. You ask what the 'Older Generation' do for fun? Well part of it is following the club you have loved and supported for 50+ years and to be able to watch them win 4-1 at home at a canter without having to have some political demonstrations imposed upon us when all we want to do is celebrate. I've never played bingo in my life nor intend to start so you'll have to think of another pastime associated with the elderly to try and undermine my argument. All you are doing is burdening the rest of us with your sad disappointment about your precious club closing... as you get older you'll learn to overcome what life throws at you and bounce back... but you won't if you just dwell on the misery. I understand what you're saying. However, what I don't understand is why the banner upsets you so much? How is it "burdening" you? Why would the view represent the whole of the club? The banner wasn't waved through the streets among the masses.. it was brought out by an easily identifiable group of young men.. Anybody who follows premier league football are probably aware of the HF. So lets hop back over to your statistical analysis. What percentage would you say acknowledge that the HF are an independent entity that follow the club, and do not identify as official club spokesmen? I'd say 80% at least.. Let them wave a banner, why don't you bring your own saying "I just want to watch the football, f*#k fabric" (or words of your own choosing to that affect) to WH @ home? Why don't you tell me what you do for fun then? Drink in the Clifton Arms? What if the council were going to shut down your favourite matchday pub that you've been visiting for years!! To many young people, Fabric isn't just a nightclub. It is to do with youth culture. It's part of their identity. I don't see how waving a bedsheet with some paint on is really that traumatizing lol.. Edited by CJr94 (23 Sep 2016 11.48am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by CJr94
Bring awareness to the cause. Lol ok. The fact it's been in the newspapers and on the news would surely help more. I'm sure the police and council will think differently about it now the HF have got involved...
|
|
|
Originally posted by steph_eagle
Lol ok. The fact it's been in the newspapers and on the news would surely help more. I'm sure the police and council will think differently about it now the HF have got involved... Very shallow argument "lol". Any publicity is good publicity?
|
|
|
Originally posted by CJr94
Very shallow argument "lol". Any publicity is good publicity? That wasn't an argument, I was just laughing. As for the publicity part, I've only seen their little banner mentioned on here and mainly just people taking the piss. Seems very pointless to me. Did they really expect Sky to show the banner?
|
|
|
Originally posted by CJr94
Very shallow argument "lol". Any publicity is good publicity? I do agree with you that for any cause you want as much publicity as possible. But on a general note there are pubs and clubs closing down all over the place, up and down the country, in croydon loads have gone. I am not old but can't help think just find another club , if your with mates having it large it doesn't really matter where you are. Edited by Michaelawt85 (23 Sep 2016 12.07pm)
When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC |
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
You're making a dangerous assumption there Michaela. I'm not sure what childish abuse they'll target you with... I've already bagged Victorian Headmaster, pant wetter, tool and helmet. So far nothing ... maybe I am being broken in gently
When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC |
|
|
Originally posted by steph_eagle
That wasn't an argument, I was just laughing. As for the publicity part, I've only seen their little banner mentioned on here and mainly just people taking the piss. Seems very pointless to me. Did they really expect Sky to show the banner? The banner was shown though?? and it was posted by Billboard (I think) on facebook and got masses of likes and shares. "Pointless" - that all falls down to your view on the overall topic. Assume you couldn't care less. That's just like me, I don't care either if they shut it down. To them, it isn't pointless. To them, it is a worthy cause. Looking at the momentum behind the overall "Save Fabric" campaign.. I'd say that a lot of people agree with them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Michaelawt85
I do agree with you that for any cause you want as much publicity as possible. But on a general note there are pubs and clubs closing down all over the place, up and down the country, in croydon loads have gone. I am not old but can't help think just find another club , if your with mates having it large it doesn't really matter where you are. Edited by Michaelawt85 (23 Sep 2016 12.07pm) Agreed. Don't get me wrong, I couldn't care less about Fabric. Too dark, too trippy.. don't like it anyway so it's no loss to me. As I said before to them it's about culture. Fabric as a brand represents them. In essence, it doesn't matter why they put a banner up.. Why are people upset? I've not actually had a response to that.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.