You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We need a keeper
November 16 2026 9.55am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

We need a keeper


Page 9 of 12 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
bicycle repair man 25 Jan 17 8.52pm

I don't recall Speroni ever making "endless mistakes",especially last season when I don't think he played any league games.

 

srh Flag london 25 Jan 17 8.52pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Yeah must be that the standard is poor. Not like the French league produces many top attacking players for him to have to deal with after all, is it.

Edited by Brentmiester_General (25 Jan 2017 8.50pm)

That's true. I can't even name one decent French player let alone an attacking player.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 25 Jan 17 8.57pm

Originally posted by Painter

I would prefer him to save shots going in his net and catch the ball from corners and crosses.

Id like Hennessey to do that too

 

Painter Flag Croydon 25 Jan 17 9.20pm

Originally posted by the silurian

Id like Hennessey to do that too

Its a basic requirement of a keeper, all this he distributes the ball well is boll_cks. Bravo at Citeh is an example of a so called great distributor of the ball from European football no good if you cannot save goals going in.
Hennessey has his critics, but Mandanda is no better.

Edited by Painter (25 Jan 2017 9.41pm)

 

srh Flag london 25 Jan 17 9.43pm

Originally posted by Painter

Its a basic requirement of a keeper, all this he distributes the ball well is boll_cks. Bravo at Citeh is an example of a so called great distributor of the ball from European football no good if you cannot save goals going in.
Hennessey has his critics, but Mandanda is no better.

Edited by Painter (25 Jan 2017 9.41pm)

That's a laughable comment. Only a fool would suggest Hennessy and Mandanda are the same standard.

Edited by srh (25 Jan 2017 9.44pm)

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 25 Jan 17 9.53pm

wayne is good enough...him & mandanda will battle it out well. good competition

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Painter Flag Croydon 25 Jan 17 9.56pm

I agree only Pardew thought Mandanda was better.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 25 Jan 17 10.51pm

Hennessey has played approaching thirty league games over the last year of which we have won three. He's left countless question marks against his performances during this same period.

We've picked up three wins with Mandanda in eight league games.

Jury's still out with Mandanda but Hennessey's had his chance.

 

cpj Flag Kent 25 Jan 17 11.34pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

I don't recall Speroni ever making "endless mistakes",especially last season when I don't think he played any league games.

He meant the season before.

 

cpj Flag Kent 26 Jan 17 9.18am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Hennessey has played approaching thirty league games over the last year of which we have won three. He's left countless question marks against his performances during this same period.

We've picked up three wins with Mandanda in eight league games.

Jury's still out with Mandanda but Hennessey's had his chance.

You are surely not blaming WH for our poor win record over the last year? If you want to compare stats for this season, WH averages 3.1 saves per games and concedes 1.84 goals per games; SM averages 2.64 saves per game and concedes 1.88 goals. And before anyone starts saying that Speroni is better, just remember that he hasn't had a clean sheet in any of his last 14 league games.

To be honest, none of the keepers is perfect - they all have their pros and cons. Speroni is the best instinctive shot-stopper from close range, but his back-spin kicking is poor, he gets beaten too easily from distance, doesn't dominate his area and his penalty record is woeful. Hennessey is the best for dominating his area and his kicking is good, but he's worse at free-kick positioning, can be slow getting down to low shots and he hasn't got near a penalty yet either. From what I've seen of Mandanda he doesn't dominate his area and his quick distribution caused several problems with players not expecting the ball.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 26 Jan 17 9.36am

Originally posted by cpj

You are surely not blaming WH for our poor win record over the last year? If you want to compare stats for this season, WH averages 3.1 saves per games and concedes 1.84 goals per games; SM averages 2.64 saves per game and concedes 1.88 goals. And before anyone starts saying that Speroni is better, just remember that he hasn't had a clean sheet in any of his last 14 league games.

To be honest, none of the keepers is perfect - they all have their pros and cons. Speroni is the best instinctive shot-stopper from close range, but his back-spin kicking is poor, he gets beaten too easily from distance, doesn't dominate his area and his penalty record is woeful. Hennessey is the best for dominating his area and his kicking is good, but he's worse at free-kick positioning, can be slow getting down to low shots and he hasn't got near a penalty yet either. From what I've seen of Mandanda he doesn't dominate his area and his quick distribution caused several problems with players not expecting the ball.

Sorry but Hennessey never dominates his area at all.....Rarely comes for crosses and for a tall man never looks confident catching high balls

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 26 Jan 17 9.36am

Originally posted by srh

That's a laughable comment. Only a fool would suggest Hennessy and Mandanda are the same standard.

Edited by srh (25 Jan 2017 9.44pm)

Only a fool would pass judgement on Mandanda either way.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

cpj Flag Kent 26 Jan 17 10.05am

Originally posted by the silurian

Sorry but Hennessey never dominates his area at all.....Rarely comes for crosses and for a tall man never looks confident catching high balls

Have you actually seen any games? Hennessey often comes for crosses and takes them cleanly. Sometimes he stays back - depends on whether he thinks he can get there or not, same as any keeper.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 26 Jan 17 10.06am

Originally posted by cpj

Have you actually seen any games? Hennessey often comes for crosses and takes them cleanly. Sometimes he stays back - depends on whether he thinks he can get there or not, same as any keeper.

At corners, he rarely comes out and touches anything, let alone catch it. He's glued to his line most times behind a phalanx of scared defenders.

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


cpj Flag Kent 26 Jan 17 10.20am

Originally posted by paperhat

At corners, he rarely comes out and touches anything, let alone catch it. He's glued to his line most times behind a phalanx of scared defenders.

You can't have been there on Saturday then.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 26 Jan 17 11.35am

Originally posted by cpj

You can't have been there on Saturday then.

actually i was. I saw him make several saves (he's a goalkeeper, clap clap) and also saw him make several heart in mouth spills to. As I say, rarely does the man come out to dominate his 6 yd box at corners, nor does he dominate at said set pieces. Although one of his better games, Saturday was no different.

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


cpj Flag Kent 26 Jan 17 12.09pm

Originally posted by paperhat

actually i was. I saw him make several saves (he's a goalkeeper, clap clap) and also saw him make several heart in mouth spills to. As I say, rarely does the man come out to dominate his 6 yd box at corners, nor does he dominate at said set pieces. Although one of his better games, Saturday was no different.

The spills were from low down shots. He took cleanly all the crosses he came for. Made a European team of the week - but, hey, you don't rate him so what does a good performance matter?

 

OhthisbloodyPC Flag 26 Jan 17 12.15pm

I must say I think Hennessy is under rated.

He's an international. A great shot stopper. And he's huge.

The players seem to like him too.

His biggest mistake is he's not Julian Speroni. I don't think that's his fault.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 26 Jan 17 12.19pm

Originally posted by cpj

The spills were from low down shots. He took cleanly all the crosses he came for. Made a European team of the week - but, hey, you don't rate him so what does a good performance matter?

as i said in my post, it was one of his better games but no, I don't rate him. Too frequently he makes the wrong decisions either costing the team goals or at worst leaving them unsettled. I couldn't care less whether he spills something low down or high up, he's still spilling it rather than keeping hold of it. One italian paper puts him in the team of the week but no UK sports article did - who's right/wrong there then?

taking ALL the crosses he came for is all a bit subjective. If he only came for one, what did he do with the rest?

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Mo Sizlak Flag 26 Jan 17 12.25pm

He's not perfect - we can't afford one of those but he's the best we've got.
The Speroni groupies have to get used to that.

 


Babs and Clean Willie were in love they said....

Page 9 of 12 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We need a keeper