You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Newcastle Match Thread
November 16 2026 7.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Newcastle Match Thread


Page 9 of 10 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 23 Sep 18 10.26am

Originally posted by Bullhorn76

Just watched the highlights on motd and that Sakho miss is going to sting for a while , I even found myself (even though I watched the game live yesterday ) screaming at Sakho to leave it for Zaha to tap it in at the back post

Was there a flag though to save his blushes ? Said on the BBC text that one was raised, not mentioned on the highlights. Pretty much summed us up in the performance, an air of panic with no real composure in front of goal. Not burying anything at the moment.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

muffinbrucie Flag london 23 Sep 18 10.30am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Did Shelvey shoot' by Midlands Eagle

When we put the ball out and they were obliged to give it back to Wayne did Shelvey really shoot at goal or was he making sur it went for out for a goal kick. If it had gone in what would have happened ?

 


its a town full of losers, i,m pulling outta here to win

chateauferret Flag 23 Sep 18 10.42am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Did Shelvey shoot' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by muffinbrucie

When we put the ball out and they were obliged to give it back to Wayne did Shelvey really shoot at goal or was he making sur it went for out for a goal kick. If it had gone in what would have happened ?

ISTR many years ago Arse scored a goal they weren't "supposed" to in circumstances like these. A quick Google reminds me that it was Kanu in 1999 who played on and Overmars who scored against Sheffield United in the Fifth Round of the FA Cup; the match was replayed at the suggestion of Arsene Wenger. The excuse was made for Kanu that he had recently arrived on the banana boat and didn't know the custom; Overmars could legitimately make no such claim. Arsenal won the rematch 2-1.

The answer to the OP's question is that the goal of course would have stood. The situation of "giving the ball back" is an unwritten rule of etiquette and isn't covered by the Laws.


Edited by chateauferret (23 Sep 2018 10.46am)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 23 Sep 18 11.09am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Did Shelvey shoot' by Midlands Eagle

I suspect Arsenal discribed it slightly different than a banana boat...

But thanks none the less.

On a side note, if Newcastle go down id be more than happy having Shelvey off them. Recon him and RLC could be two key targets. Although hopefully RLC will be back here in Jan already...

 

Username Flag Horsham 23 Sep 18 11.13am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Did Shelvey shoot' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by muffinbrucie

When we put the ball out and they were obliged to give it back to Wayne did Shelvey really shoot at goal or was he making sur it went for out for a goal kick. If it had gone in what would have happened ?


He didn't shoot, and he apologised for slicing it wide of Wayne. The minute it went out for a goal kick Lascelles also waved all the other Newcastle players back from the high press they were normally doing on our goal kicks. Pretty sure it was just an accident.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Username Flag Horsham 23 Sep 18 11.17am

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

Was there a flag though to save his blushes ? Said on the BBC text that one was raised, not mentioned on the highlights. Pretty much summed us up in the performance, an air of panic with no real composure in front of goal. Not burying anything at the moment.

The flag was just giving the goal kick surely?

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Username Flag Horsham 23 Sep 18 11.24am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I’m concerned about the lack of goals in the team.There were plenty of chances created against Newcastle but no finisher.
For all his bad form and terrible record over the last year Benteke still looks the best option which is a worry.
Townsend never looks like scoring and there is too much reliance on Zaha.
It’s a shame Sako didn’t rejoin because he does offer something different, can go past people and score goals.
If we go back to the loan market in January I hope it’s more inspiring than the recent list - Sanogo,Bamford,Adebayor,Doyle,Remy,Ameobi

Thing is, with the other players in the team we really should be contributing more goals from elsewhere.

Zaha is obviously the focal point, but there aren't many teams who have a 20 goal striker who gets them out of trouble. Players like Townsend and PVA have shown they can finish but they seem a bit shot-shy at the moment.

As big as Benteke's problems are, it's starting to look like there is also a lack of confidence throughout the team.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Bangell Flag Oxford 23 Sep 18 11.27am

Originally posted by Username

The flag was just giving the goal kick surely?

Raising his hands in the air in disbelief

 

steph_eagle Flag Thornton Heath 23 Sep 18 11.58am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Did Shelvey shoot' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by chateauferret

ISTR many years ago Arse scored a goal they weren't "supposed" to in circumstances like these. A quick Google reminds me that it was Kanu in 1999 who played on and Overmars who scored against Sheffield United in the Fifth Round of the FA Cup; the match was replayed at the suggestion of Arsene Wenger. The excuse was made for Kanu that he had recently arrived on the banana boat and didn't know the custom; Overmars could legitimately make no such claim. Arsenal won the rematch 2-1.

The answer to the OP's question is that the goal of course would have stood. The situation of "giving the ball back" is an unwritten rule of etiquette and isn't covered by the Laws.


Edited by chateauferret (23 Sep 2018 10.46am)

No need for that comment, out of order

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 23 Sep 18 12.06pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Did Shelvey shoot' by Midlands Eagle

No, he didn't shoot however it is customary to kick the ball gently back to the keeper and not whack it as hard as you can in his general direction. the idea is supposed to be that you give him the ball in hand when he has just kicked it out of play for your benefit.

Anyway he looked suitably embarrassed after doing it.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 23 Sep 18 12.17pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Did Shelvey shoot' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by chateauferret

ISTR many years ago Arse scored a goal they weren't "supposed" to in circumstances like these. A quick Google reminds me that it was Kanu in 1999 who played on and Overmars who scored against Sheffield United in the Fifth Round of the FA Cup; the match was replayed at the suggestion of Arsene Wenger. The excuse was made for Kanu that he had recently arrived on the banana boat and didn't know the custom; Overmars could legitimately make no such claim. Arsenal won the rematch 2-1.

The answer to the OP's question is that the goal of course would have stood. The situation of "giving the ball back" is an unwritten rule of etiquette and isn't covered by the Laws.


Edited by chateauferret (23 Sep 2018 10.46am)

When Wenger made the suggestion the FA had never previously agreed to replay a game that had a result. Was Wenger being sincere or was he surprised when the FA said yes?

 


One more point

andyg Flag york 23 Sep 18 12.17pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Did Shelvey shoot' by Midlands Eagle

Didn’t Millwall accidentally score like this once and let the opposition striker just run through and score a reply?

 

PalacePhotoMan Flag Wallington 23 Sep 18 12.44pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Did Shelvey shoot' by Midlands Eagle

He didn't shoot, he was hitting to Hennessey and sliced it. He was embarrassed by it and it was obvious he didn't try to "score".

 


Zaha, Williams, Murray, Ambrose, Scannell.

A 5-man forward line who scored 3 goals in 10 minutes on 27th September 2011 at .......................

fifainspected Flag Michigan - USA 23 Sep 18 2.21pm

Week in and week out I watch the team play and wonder why they seem to make it look so difficult. Simple passes to players in space, a decent cross from the wing.. We just seem to prefer to make the game harder than it needs to be.

Per Meyer.. I agree with many in that I think he looks good and adds a much-needed element in the midfield. However, once he came on we continued to play the ball down the wings and his touches were limited. I too would like to see him in the starting 11.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Sep 18 2.51pm

I am worried about us this season. We have created very few chances despite decent possession and I don't see how that will change. I see us near the relegation zone this time and it is once again because our board has not spent money on the necessary players. Another striker was essential and not some relegated twice, loan makeweight. Just not good enough if you want to stay in the Prem.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 23 Sep 18 3.03pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I am worried about us this season. We have created very few chances despite decent possession and I don't see how that will change. I see us near the relegation zone this time and it is once again because our board has not spent money on the necessary players. Another striker was essential and not some relegated twice, loan makeweight. Just not good enough if you want to stay in the Prem.

Play Meyer

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 23 Sep 18 5.03pm

Personally I think we look unbalanced at ghd moment. At the start of the season, we had benteke up front with wilf playing off him ( more central. And schlupp on the left side if midfield, with a great little triangle of him PVA and wilf going forward one side and andros, Aaron and macca on the other side.

Looking at yesterday, we were all over the place. Ayews a center forward who doesn't stay in the center. Wilf is playing too wide and having to track back because macca was playing left midfield leaving pva exposed...looked so unbalanced. Meyer/schlupp should havd started on the left, kayoute/macca should havd started right side and Ayew told to stay center or play Sorloth.

 

ogloc19 Flag 23 Sep 18 5.19pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Personally I think we look unbalanced at ghd moment. At the start of the season, we had benteke up front with wilf playing off him ( more central. And schlupp on the left side if midfield, with a great little triangle of him PVA and wilf going forward one side and andros, Aaron and macca on the other side.

Looking at yesterday, we were all over the place. Ayews a center forward who doesn't stay in the center. Wilf is playing too wide and having to track back because macca was playing left midfield leaving pva exposed...looked so unbalanced. Meyer/schlupp should havd started on the left, kayoute/macca should havd started right side and Ayew told to stay center or play Sorloth.


Ayew kinda reminded me of the Cameron Jerome/Frazier Campbell role of mainly running down the wings and never going to get a sniff of a chance.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 23 Sep 18 5.21pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I am worried about us this season. We have created very few chances despite decent possession and I don't see how that will change. I see us near the relegation zone this time and it is once again because our board has not spent money on the necessary players. Another striker was essential and not some relegated twice, loan makeweight. Just not good enough if you want to stay in the Prem.

Just stop and think that if we had buried (as we should have) three easy headers, Ward v Watford 1 point, Benteke v Soton 1 point and Sakho v Newcastle 2 points we would have been in 6th position with 11 points and above Man Utd. Such fine margins in football. Can't understand why you think we are relegation fodder yet.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 23 Sep 18 5.36pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Just stop and think that if we had buried (as we should have) three easy headers, Ward v Watford 1 point, Benteke v Soton 1 point and Sakho v Newcastle 2 points we would have been in 6th position with 11 points and above Man Utd. Such fine margins in football. Can't understand why you think we are relegation fodder yet.

Because we didn't take any of them, and yes wd should have. ...you answered your own question..

 

Page 9 of 10 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Newcastle Match Thread