This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Whenever someone uses a players’ salary to justify this sort of thing, I can’t help but switch off completely. The idea that rich people are fair game for any type of abuse, because they’re rich, is just so silly it’s difficult to comprehend. It's not about what is right and wrong, it is about how you deal with this stuff in the real world.
|
|
| Invalid user 2019 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Sky absolutely loving it today. They can spend all day on Raheem Sterling and Danny Rose getting monkey noises last night.
It seems that some eastern European countries still find it funny to abuse people for their ethnicity. I would suggest, as I have before, that zero reaction would be the best response. These people need to be ignored like you would ignore a badly behaved child at a restaurant. They like the attention so starve them of it. Comparing black players to monkeys would appear to be racist to me. It did the image of Cantona no harm by going crazy when someone was disrespectful to him. Imagine if Sterling did that, he'd be painted as feral. His race would be factored into his reaction in a way that it wasn't there. If it's water off a ducks back to some then that's preferable, but if the very act of acknowledging that something happened and complaining about it is taboo, that's hardly great either. Countries have different cultures and can domestically do as they wish, but if you're part of an international tournament you are expected to acknowledge and adhere to generally accepted international sporting norms. The fans of most countries do not behave this way which is exactly why it becomes an issue when one does.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Do you not think that there is a huge disproportion between how we handle racial abuse and other abuse already? Should the severity of abuse not be measured by the effect it has on the victim and not by politics? Abuse occurs at football, in the playground and online every day. We have sectarianism in Scotland which barely gets a mention. Are we really saying that making a special case for Black footballers is proportionate and reasonable?
I agree Sectarianism should be tackled more strongly, but that does nothing to dissuade my opinion on other forms of racial abuse. As above, I don’t think it should be a special case - those are your words.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
It's not about what is right and wrong, it is about how you deal with this stuff in the real world. Yes, and you believe you deal with it by doing nothing; I don’t agree. There is no huge cry of outrage; I’m not sure why people keep hinting at this. I saw a few players, and Southgate, speak on the issue yesterday and they all spoke very openly and sensibly in my opinion. Their message was much more one of ‘its a shame this still goes on’ rather than any major offence or outrage.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dollardays
Comparing black players to monkeys would appear to be racist to me. It did the image of Cantona no harm by going crazy when someone was disrespectful to him. Imagine if Sterling did that, he'd be painted as feral. His race would be factored into his reaction in a way that it wasn't there. If it's water off a ducks back to some then that's preferable, but if the very act of acknowledging that something happened and complaining about it is taboo, that's hardly great either. Countries have different cultures and can domestically do as they wish, but if you're part of an international tournament you are expected to acknowledge and adhere to generally accepted international sporting norms. The fans of most countries do not behave this way which is exactly why it becomes an issue when one does. I prefer to reserve the word racism for serious stuff like enforced segregation and oppression. For me, monkey noises at a football match fall into the behaviour of people with a mental age of primary school children category. It's always amazing that adults do that stuff but no one died. The response has to be proportionate. I know some will disagree.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
My view is if there are people who think it is ok to make monkey noises at a black player, then some moral outrage is perfectly justifiable - I won’t make any apologies for using words like ‘unacceptable’ when discussing an incident like that. Again, I don’t think this is about control or forcing groups of people to do things they don’t want to do - it’s expecting them not to make monkey noises at someone. In a hundred people statistically 15 will have IQs of around 85 and below. It won't only be them of course but I'm illustrating the reality that idiotic behaviour is always going to happen. You are talking from a different cultural perspective from the majority of this nation.....yet still it's a minority of them. It always is. I agree with you it would be better if it didn't happen. Every football match you have wallies shouting insults at opposing players. It's your cultural perspective to be highly offended at racial ones, yet all insults are intended to have the same result.....upset the opposition and gain the satisfaction that you had an impact. Anyway I've waffled on about this enough Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Mar 2019 3.48pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Yes, and you believe you deal with it by doing nothing; I don’t agree. There is no huge cry of outrage; I’m not sure why people keep hinting at this. I saw a few players, and Southgate, speak on the issue yesterday and they all spoke very openly and sensibly in my opinion. Their message was much more one of ‘its a shame this still goes on’ rather than any major offence or outrage.
|
|
| Invalid user 2019 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I prefer to reserve the word racism for serious stuff like enforced segregation and oppression. For me, monkey noises at a football match fall into the behaviour of people with a mental age of primary school children category. It's always amazing that adults do that stuff but no one died. The response has to be proportionate. I know some will disagree. They certainly have a very playground mentality to engage in such behaviour, that much I do agree with. Perhaps expecting a 'What would Jesus Do?' style reaction from the target of being compared to a monkey due to your race isn't very realistic either though.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dollardays
They certainly have a very playground mentality to engage in such behaviour, that much I do agree with. Perhaps expecting a 'What would Jesus Do?' style reaction from the target of being compared to a monkey due to your race isn't very realistic either though. People deal with abuse in their own way. I would argue that abuse is abuse. The racial element seems to give some people an opportunity to become disproportionately outraged in comparison to other abuse. I would argue that a culture that encourages this kind of selective outrage is one that encourages the use of that specific abuse. That seems inevitable if it appears effective in terms of antagonising the victim.
|
|
| Invalid user 2019 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
People deal with abuse in their own way. I would argue that abuse is abuse. The racial element seems to give some people an opportunity to become disproportionately outraged in comparison to other abuse. I would argue that a culture that encourages this kind of selective outrage is one that encourages the use of that specific abuse. That seems inevitable if it appears effective in terms of antagonising the victim. You appear to be more offended by a reaction to racist abuse, than the abuse itself. There will always be certain behaviour that people don't want to see in the game. Racist abuse would be at the top of a great many lists. That being the case it factors into peoples' thinking. If you want to be part of a club and share in their successes, you adhere to basic conventions along the way. As I stated if this is a norm in some countries domestically then okay. If that's the distasteful culture I'm not suggesting swooping in and changing the world, they can sort out their own problems. International tournaments differ though and if you wish to engage on that level the world is then your audience, not just those in the terraces.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dollardays
You appear to be more offended by a reaction to racist abuse, than the abuse itself. There will always be certain behaviour that people don't want to see in the game. Racist abuse would be at the top of a great many lists. That being the case it factors into peoples' thinking. If you want to be part of a club and share in their successes, you adhere to basic conventions along the way. As I stated if this is a norm in some countries domestically then okay. If that's the distasteful culture I'm not suggesting swooping in and changing the world, they can sort out their own problems. International tournaments differ though and if you wish to engage on that level the world is then your audience, not just those in the terraces. I don't know how you come to that conclusion. Whatever you say about the subject there still has to be a reasonable and practical approach that actually does something or else it is a waste of time and money. When you put racial abuse on a pedestal above other abuse and anti social behaviour, you have created a problem for yourself which you have no practical solution for.
|
|
| Invalid user 2019 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I don't know how you come to that conclusion. Whatever you say about the subject there still has to be a reasonable and practical approach that actually does something or else it is a waste of time and money. When you put racial abuse on a pedestal above other abuse and anti social behaviour, you have created a problem for yourself which you have no practical solution for. If I'm at a game with my family and someone is behaving like that to one of our players I won't be 'oh never mind' I'll tell you that much. I'll tell them exactly what I think. It cuts both ways. I appreciate that different cultures have various takes on things. On the international stage though, there is a standard you are expected to uphold. This isn't new, and what happened clearly was racist. People can behave how they wish, not just fans, players too. I'll take a dignified objection to being subject to racism, over mindless monkey chants as my measure of who's in the wrong.
|
|
| Pussay Patrol |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
Ever heard of a white person being called a monkey by a group of Africans? Watch "the last king of scotland" make sure to phone the Samaritans if u find it all too traumatic So this is the usual post that tries to justify racism by taking another tenuously related subject and suggesting if you can find an alternate wrong, both wrongs somehow make a right? It does make you wonder the motives of people who go to great length to deny or trivialise the race issue every time it appears
Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
You don't know that fistycuffs is a quaint term used to describe fighting usually where no blow is actually struck. And you expect me to take you seriously? Oh come on. Seriously? It’s Fisticuffs. I’m still keen to find out where your fisty cuff is though. I’d trademark that if I were you, before the sex toy industry gets a hold of it. And you expect me to take you seriously?
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by dollardays
If I'm at a game with my family and someone is behaving like that to one of our players I won't be 'oh never mind' I'll tell you that much. I'll tell them exactly what I think. It cuts both ways. I appreciate that different cultures have various takes on things. On the international stage though, there is a standard you are expected to uphold. This isn't new, and what happened clearly was racist. People can behave how they wish, not just fans, players too. I'll take a dignified objection to being subject to racism, over mindless monkey chants as my measure of who's in the wrong. Seconded. Sadly I’ve had to do that in the Holmesdale, 2 seasons ago. Complete yokels behind us. Thankfully they are no longer season ticket holders. Total pricks.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Oh come on. Seriously? It’s Fisticuffs. I’m still keen to find out where your fisty cuff is though. I’d trademark that if I were you, before the sex toy industry gets a hold of it. And you expect me to take you seriously? It's actually either and it was originally with the Y. A little knowledge.... Please don't reply unless you have something interesting to say.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dollardays
If I'm at a game with my family and someone is behaving like that to one of our players I won't be 'oh never mind' I'll tell you that much. I'll tell them exactly what I think. It cuts both ways. I appreciate that different cultures have various takes on things. On the international stage though, there is a standard you are expected to uphold. This isn't new, and what happened clearly was racist. People can behave how they wish, not just fans, players too. I'll take a dignified objection to being subject to racism, over mindless monkey chants as my measure of who's in the wrong. Well good for you. I can tell you that I have never witnessed any racism at a football match. I remember John Fashanu getting stick when his brother was revealed as gay but nothing beyond that.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Pussay Patrol
So this is the usual post that tries to justify racism by taking another tenuously related subject and suggesting if you can find an alternate wrong, both wrongs somehow make a right? It does make you wonder the motives of people who go to great length to deny or trivialise the race issue every time it appears Funny how people like you read trying to put things into perspective as trivialising and condoning. If the worst thing that ever happens to me is being verbally abused by a bunch of morons, I will be quite happy. That doesn't make it right or acceptable. Happens on here all the time.
|
|
| Invalid user 2019 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Well good for you.
On account that you don't view monkey chants aimed at black players to be racist, I certainly don't doubt that you haven't witnessed racism. What happened is an example of people being abused due to their race now. so nevermind the 70s. I've told you that if I saw it I'd say something. Apparently if you heard it you'd see it as childish and be unhappy at anyone voicing objection. Well, that's for you isn't it. The easy way out vs standing against something that most would and rightly do view as out of order.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.