You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Singing Section
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Singing Section


Page 9 of 18 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
Alex1991 Flag Ashford 22 Sep 19 7.51pm

At least when the game isn't great they keep going. Watched a bit of Newcastle v Weed last night and it was almost silent.

Also one person with a drum is infinitely better than 30,000 people with clackers.

 


"Brighton are talking about how they're coming for us. And it's like, we've been waiting in the Premier League for you for ages." Wilfried Zaha, 2017.

gerry theagle Flag newbury 22 Sep 19 10.04pm

I like the HF but think they were more effective when they were in Block B, the Arthur joined in a lot then but now they are isolated.
The overall effect is that the noise only comes from behind the goal and half the stuff they sing nobody in general knows the words to join in.

 

cpj Flag Kent 23 Sep 19 10.44am

I sit near them and watched them for a while during the first half (nothing much else was going on!). Tne bloke with the megaphoine and his mate were leading the singing with their backs to the match for the whole time. I just cannot understand why you would pay £25+ to go to a match and not watch it at all.

My main problem with the singing section is that their singing bears no relation to what is happening in the match. If we're struggling then we need the crowd to react and get behind the team. Instead we just get a constant wall of noise regardless of the state of play. Also, yet again our home form is poor - so if this really working?

 

EddieMac Flag 23 Sep 19 10.48am

Originally posted by cpj

I sit near them and watched them for a while during the first half (nothing much else was going on!). Tne bloke with the megaphoine and his mate were leading the singing with their backs to the match for the whole time. I just cannot understand why you would pay £25+ to go to a match and not watch it at all.

My main problem with the singing section is that their singing bears no relation to what is happening in the match. If we're struggling then we need the crowd to react and get behind the team. Instead we just get a constant wall of noise regardless of the state of play. Also, yet again our home form is poor - so if this really working?

Our home form is poor? I don't agree with that. It was a very even game against Everton, we were the much better team against Villa and should have beaten Wolves.

 

RyWa Flag Beckenham 23 Sep 19 2.16pm

Originally posted by cryrst

He got told to bang his drum elsewhere by some chav.
He did leave and go back to the top though.

The drummer in the Arthur?

He has annoyed me so much in the last 2 games.

Both drums going at the same time and 2 different rhythms is surely enough to send anyone stir crazy

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Sep 19 2.32pm

Originally posted by gerry theagle

I like the HF but think they were more effective when they were in Block B, the Arthur joined in a lot then but now they are isolated.
The overall effect is that the noise only comes from behind the goal and half the stuff they sing nobody in general knows the words to join in.

You could argue the isolation is because of the HF’s choice of songs. But they could also be better with the back of B being next to them (no chance), and bits of C nearer the corner being next to the HF.

I wouldn’t want to be near that new drum though. Fvck that. Unnecessarily loud and look at the effect. They need to have a rethink of what they’ve done and are doing. Getting everyone involved by singing songs nobody else sings doesn’t show much sense to me.

 


COYP

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 23 Sep 19 4.24pm

Have been informed by a long standing HOLer(no names, no pack drill), that an 'ordinary' Palace fan got beaten up by 'allegedly' HF because 'only the HF can start songs, not anyone else'.

IF, true & I have no cause to doubt this person, why is this happening? Someone mentioned that the wheels may becoming off the rails due to factions between 2005 & new members.

As for the drums/drummers . . . Fcuk Off. Out of sync, out of tune, out of ideas.

Rant over(phew, im fine/calm)

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Sep 19 4.32pm

It’s been proven you need a drum, but not one so fecking loud. No need to be louder than the previous one.

 


COYP

Mapletree Flag Croydon 23 Sep 19 5.25pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Have been informed by a long standing HOLer(no names, no pack drill), that an 'ordinary' Palace fan got beaten up by 'allegedly' HF because 'only the HF can start songs, not anyone else'.

IF, true & I have no cause to doubt this person, why is this happening? Someone mentioned that the wheels may becoming off the rails due to factions between 2005 & new members.

As for the drums/drummers . . . Fcuk Off. Out of sync, out of tune, out of ideas.

Rant over(phew, im fine/calm)

I saw two strange altercations.

First, a guy came down the steps between E and F just after half time and appeared to be having a rant. He was told to 'go away' but I saw nobody attack him.

Then after the match a guy came up the steps between D and E, with a child in his arms, and also seemed to be having a rant. Again I didn't see anyone attack him but there was some shouting. There were Stewards in attendance.

Edited by Mapletree (23 Sep 2019 6.53pm)

 

bicycle repair man 23 Sep 19 8.50pm

I never noticed the guy with the megaphone before, but what is the point of him, I'm sure his fellow Ultras know the words to the songs.
Even more pointless is his assistant standing next to him clapping his hands.
They both spend almost the entire 90 mins with their backs to the pitch, very strange.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 23 Sep 19 9.30pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

I never noticed the guy with the megaphone before, but what is the point of him, I'm sure his fellow Ultras know the words to the songs.
Even more pointless is his assistant standing next to him clapping his hands.
They both spend almost the entire 90 mins with their backs to the pitch, very strange.

Ah, you mean Eric.

Cheerleader Photo.jpeg Attachment: Cheerleader Photo.jpeg (128.08Kb)

 

Jasmine Flag Croydon 23 Sep 19 9.47pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Have been informed by a long standing HOLer(no names, no pack drill), that an 'ordinary' Palace fan got beaten up by 'allegedly' HF because 'only the HF can start songs, not anyone else'.

IF, true & I have no cause to doubt this person, why is this happening? Someone mentioned that the wheels may becoming off the rails due to factions between 2005 & new members.

As for the drums/drummers . . . Fcuk Off. Out of sync, out of tune, out of ideas.

Rant over(phew, im fine/calm)

I had a perfect view of this, Some absolute wolly in a yellow stone island stormed into a bunch of presumably fanatic guys whilst holding a young child! highly irresponsible whatever his issue was with them, This guy was then bouncing around for around 5 minutes screaming about his child whilst still trying to fight everyone including my dad who tried to calm him down and also club stewards.
Deserves a ban and hopefully club have him on cctv.

 

Dan Flag London 23 Sep 19 10.34pm

Originally posted by Jasmine

I had a perfect view of this, Some absolute wolly in a yellow stone island stormed into a bunch of presumably fanatic guys whilst holding a young child! highly irresponsible whatever his issue was with them, This guy was then bouncing around for around 5 minutes screaming about his child whilst still trying to fight everyone including my dad who tried to calm him down and also club stewards.
Deserves a ban and hopefully club have him on cctv.


Was a strange sight for sure. We were all pissed off with a late minute goal, but that bloke wearing stone island looked like he was off his head on something, the stewards saw to him though and marched him off. What a way to act in front of his child - probably woke up regretting that one!

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 23 Sep 19 10.35pm

Originally posted by Jasmine

I had a perfect view of this, Some absolute wolly in a yellow stone island stormed into a bunch of presumably fanatic guys whilst holding a young child! highly irresponsible whatever his issue was with them, This guy was then bouncing around for around 5 minutes screaming about his child whilst still trying to fight everyone including my dad who tried to calm him down and also club stewards.
Deserves a ban and hopefully club have him on cctv.

Thanks Jasmine. I saw some of that. I’d be intrigued to find out what his problem was.

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 24 Sep 19 7.31am

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

I never noticed the guy with the megaphone before, but what is the point of him, I'm sure his fellow Ultras know the words to the songs.
Even more pointless is his assistant standing next to him clapping his hands.
They both spend almost the entire 90 mins with their backs to the pitch, very strange.

He reminded me of when I holidayed in Turkey and i heard the prayer call from the local mosque over a loudspeaker!

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 24 Sep 19 9.36am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

It’s been proven you need a drum, but not one so fecking loud. No need to be louder than the previous one.

I can't tell if this is a serious comment. For decades we managed without a drum, as do most football grounds, and it didn't prohibit getting a song going. Perhaps new generations of fans just don't have the rhythm of yester-folk.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 24 Sep 19 9.55am

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

I can't tell if this is a serious comment. For decades we managed without a drum, as do most football grounds, and it didn't prohibit getting a song going. Perhaps new generations of fans just don't have the rhythm of yester-folk.

You don’t need a drum on a terrace but you do in seated stadiums. That’s been proven at Selhurst or all you’ll get is ‘Eagles’ or ‘ole ole ole’ at a corner. Look at Arsenal at home. One song. ‘Are-a-nal’. Nothing else gets going or lasts.

 


COYP

milka Flag Norfolk 24 Sep 19 3.00pm

Just came up on Facebook, I’m guessing it’s all related .........

Originally posted by Mapletree

Thanks Jasmine. I saw some of that. I’d be intrigued to find out what his problem was.

E8AB7154-A8FE-4F32-AA11-FC3B35E7D3AD.png Attachment: E8AB7154-A8FE-4F32-AA11-FC3B35E7D3AD.png (342.44Kb)

 


That is all !

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 24 Sep 19 3.12pm

Originally posted by milka

Just came up on Facebook, I’m guessing it’s all related .........

His posts are private on his Facebook page. Maybe a good idea.

He’s going to meet them instead of agreeing with cpfc to impose a ban on them. Good on him. Make it one by one, hey!

Starting trouble because someone else started a song. Jesus. I’m not on their side like I used to be. Actually I never was, but the case to improve the atmosphere was there. Unfortunately they’ve just decided to sing their own songs but in a different space so it isn’t what was it was pitched as it supposed to be. My stance has changed this season. They can pull it back but if they want their own thing then I really am not interested in them one bit now.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (24 Sep 2019 3.13pm)

 


COYP

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 24 Sep 19 3.12pm

Originally posted by milka

Just came up on Facebook, I’m guessing it’s all related .........

We're so hard we fight ourselves

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 9 of 18 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Singing Section