You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Spurs v Palace match thread
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Spurs v Palace match thread


Page 9 of 11 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 15 Sep 19 12.38pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

In the interview by Hodgson that is referred to he talked of more heartache and struggle for the fans and spoke almost fondly about Palace’s days in the old Third Division South.
It could be argued that he is being realistic and dampening expectations of the fans so that a mid table position would seem like winning the Champions League.
I can’t subscribe to that view.
For me the real crime is to aim low and miss which is where we could be heading with this negative philosophy.
Hodgson often gives the impression that he is happy with a narrow 1-0 defeat and his main annoyance yesterday was probably conceding 4 goals.
With a solid defence and two holding midfield players I am sure we could still be sound defensively and offer more threat up front.
Instead we play with 9 behind the ball every week.

In the post match conference he clearly wasn't at all happy with the 1st half. Also he did make a valid point that we could easily be on 3 points and not 7. Think he was saying that we haven't dominated any game this season, all very nervy. Last season we rarely did as well and with such a small improvement in the squad over the summer quite possibly we will do the same again. Agree with the tactics, as they seem to be one dimensional throughout any match. As a result as others have said 17th or above seems the sole goal. Think we have been winging it most of this PL tenure to be honest, boosting results with managerial changes and a sense of luck with major players. AWB was a bonus and if ManUre had bothered to give Wilf a go and nurtured him he wouldn't be back here now. This has been mixed up with some gutsy players who have given everything that they have but a fair few duffers, some expensive, along the way to negate them. Let's hope we can weather the storm presently and come out with a stronger squad in the future.

Edited by Booted Eagle (15 Sep 2019 12.40pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

OldFart Flag By the sea 15 Sep 19 1.18pm

A bad result but if we'd been offered 3 points from away games to Man U and Spurs, I'd have been happy with that.
We are also point behind 3rd place in the league. Surely not all doom and gloom.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 15 Sep 19 1.39pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

One word - shambolic.

PS Hilariously enough, that word hasn't been heard of by Google.

So you believe being fouled every time you move the ball forward is Shambolic, What I watched was one team being highly clinical with opportunities and the other being professionally fouled with special treatment to it's star player, the ultimate moment was when Kane actually sat on Zaha and the so called ref allowed play to continue for yet another Spurs attack! ..what was it nineteen fouls and they were the ones actually counted for!! ..probably about another ten or eleven ignored, if one team cannot mount enough good attacking opportunities to worry the oppositions defence and keeper then the result is always going to be about four nil against an attacking force the likes of Spurs have ..we had no chance whatsoever ..remember that FA cup game against Man.U with MR Clatterbang as ref!!

Edited by Tickled pink (15 Sep 2019 1.40pm)

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 15 Sep 19 1.44pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

In the interview by Hodgson that is referred to he talked of more heartache and struggle for the fans and spoke almost fondly about Palace’s days in the old Third Division South.
It could be argued that he is being realistic and dampening expectations of the fans so that a mid table position would seem like winning the Champions League.
I can’t subscribe to that view.
For me the real crime is to aim low and miss which is where we could be heading with this negative philosophy.
Hodgson often gives the impression that he is happy with a narrow 1-0 defeat and his main annoyance yesterday was probably conceding 4 goals.
With a solid defence and two holding midfield players I am sure we could still be sound defensively and offer more threat up front.
Instead we play with 9 behind the ball every week.

One was a very fortunate deflection don't forget and at a terrible time.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 15 Sep 19 2.18pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Leaving aside yesterday, the defensive coaching drills of Hodgson are there for all to see and in fairness this is a key part of the game.
What I can never see, however, is any evidence of coaching on the attacking side of the game.
Basically it’s give the ball to Zaha and see what happens.
If he’s not on song for whatever reason we’re unlikely to score too many.
It’s too simplistic to say this is just down to the lack of
quality in the strikers that we have.

Is it ?

So are you saying that Hodgson has sufficient attacking options available to him and he should be getting more out of them ??

And of course we are trying to get the ball to our best player as often as we can. Any team in a similar position to ours would.

Roy has his limitations but I still defend him because he is not being given the resources to do anything much beyond what he has and is achieving. Which actually is a lot in any case.

I sense increasing frustration on his part because actually it must get
difficult to operate at this level in a financial straighjacket and I’m pretty sure he would not have wanted to go into this season with the likes of Benteke and Wickham as two of his three striking options.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

EddieMac Flag 15 Sep 19 2.26pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Is it ?

So are you saying that Hodgson has sufficient attacking options available to him and he should be getting more out of them ??

And of course we are trying to get the ball to our best player as often as we can. Any team in a similar position to ours would.

Roy has his limitations but I still defend him because he is not being given the resources to do anything much beyond what he has and is achieving. Which actually is a lot in any case.

I sense increasing frustration on his part because actually it must get
difficult to operate at this level in a financial straighjacket and I’m pretty sure he would not have wanted to go into this season with the likes of Benteke and Wickham as two of his three striking options.

Well said Neillo. I agree completely.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 15 Sep 19 3.09pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Is it ?

So are you saying that Hodgson has sufficient attacking options available to him and he should be getting more out of them ??

And of course we are trying to get the ball to our best player as often as we can. Any team in a similar position to ours would.

Roy has his limitations but I still defend him because he is not being given the resources to do anything much beyond what he has and is achieving. Which actually is a lot in any case.

I sense increasing frustration on his part because actually it must get
difficult to operate at this level in a financial straighjacket and I’m pretty sure he would not have wanted to go into this season with the likes of Benteke and Wickham as two of his three striking options.

Yes and we did get the ball successfully to him didn't we ..only for him to be promptly fouled nine times out of ten, the game came down to clinical finishing after awful positional play from us and brutal treatment being professionally dished out every single time we threatened. Awful positional play has absolutely nothing to do with Hodgson.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 15 Sep 19 3.16pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Is it ?

So are you saying that Hodgson has sufficient attacking options available to him and he should be getting more out of them ??

And of course we are trying to get the ball to our best player as often as we can. Any team in a similar position to ours would.

Roy has his limitations but I still defend him because he is not being given the resources to do anything much beyond what he has and is achieving. Which actually is a lot in any case.

I sense increasing frustration on his part because actually it must get
difficult to operate at this level in a financial straighjacket
and I’m pretty sure he would not have wanted to go into this season with the likes of Benteke and Wickham as two of his three striking options.

Good post and I sensed that yesterday from him in the post match conference. Also poor guy's face looked very strained. If the bags under his eyes get any bigger his eyeballs might fall out.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 15 Sep 19 3.27pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Leaving aside yesterday, the defensive coaching drills of Hodgson are there for all to see and in fairness this is a key part of the game.
What I can never see, however, is any evidence of coaching on the attacking side of the game.
Basically it’s give the ball to Zaha and see what happens.
If he’s not on song for whatever reason we’re unlikely to score too many.
It’s too simplistic to say this is just down to the lack of
quality in the strikers that we have.

We are quite average and yesterday we played a team that fits very nicely in the top six, if our players could run and pass the ball as well as Spurs and also execute the cute little niggling fouls to break up attacking play without attracting the attention of the ref we would also be sitting nicely in the top six and in any case if any of our players had the cheek to play as consistently and well as any of the players Spurs have they'd be off as quick as Wan-Bissaka! ...and you know that!!

 

PatrickA Flag London 15 Sep 19 4.05pm

I accept I’m in a minority where Hodgson is concerned and it’s a case of having to agree to differ.
Yesterday was our worst performance at Tottenham since promotion.
We are playing with 9 behind the ball regardless of the opposition.
When Pulis did this at least he had the excuse of an inferior squad.
We have a better and more experienced squad now and at times have played decent football.
Hodgson distrusts ball players in midfield and that’s part of the reason why the passing is so woeful.
As to having no strikers for him to pick there must be those in power at the club who disagree.
Wickham’s contract has been extended, we’re in negotiations to extend Benteke’s contract and apparently we want to do the same with Sorloth.
One can only assume that Hodgson is not part of these discussions/decisions.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 15 Sep 19 4.17pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I accept I’m in a minority where Hodgson is concerned and it’s a case of having to agree to differ.
Yesterday was our worst performance at Tottenham since promotion.
We are playing with 9 behind the ball regardless of the opposition.
When Pulis did this at least he had the excuse of an inferior squad.
We have a better and more experienced squad now and at times have played decent football.
Hodgson distrusts ball players in midfield and that’s part of the reason why the passing is so woeful.
As to having no strikers for him to pick there must be those in power at the club who disagree.
Wickham’s contract has been extended, we’re in negotiations to extend Benteke’s contract and apparently we want to do the same with Sorloth.
One can only assume that Hodgson is not part of these discussions/decisions.

Having someone who is competent with passing requires someone who is competent with receiving it, also it does require someone competent on the ball to be able to actually give the ball to the competent ball player in the first place, this requires a little more thought and a massive huge purse.
Teams in the top six are there for a reason, we are not part of it.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 15 Sep 19 4.19pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I accept I’m in a minority where Hodgson is concerned and it’s a case of having to agree to differ.
Yesterday was our worst performance at Tottenham since promotion.
We are playing with 9 behind the ball regardless of the opposition.
When Pulis did this at least he had the excuse of an inferior squad.
We have a better and more experienced squad now and at times have played decent football.
Hodgson distrusts ball players in midfield and that’s part of the reason why the passing is so woeful.
As to having no strikers for him to pick there must be those in power at the club who disagree.
Wickham’s contract has been extended, we’re in negotiations to extend Benteke’s contract and apparently we want to do the same with Sorloth.
One can only assume that Hodgson is not part of these discussions/decisions.

Worst result not performance.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 15 Sep 19 4.20pm

Spurs stopped us performing.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 15 Sep 19 4.23pm

They stopped us by clinically cheating whilst we attacked, all the top teams do it ..all the other attempts we ruined ourselves through poor passing ability.

Edited by Tickled pink (15 Sep 2019 4.26pm)

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 15 Sep 19 4.47pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

They stopped us by clinically cheating whilst we attacked, all the top teams do it ..all the other attempts we ruined ourselves through poor passing ability.

Edited by Tickled pink (15 Sep 2019 4.26pm)

We were crap in defence, midfield and attack. Even Guaita was rubbish. You can't get more comprehensively bad than that. I might also add the tactics were wrong too. Spurs scored with route one stuff - they didn't need to be a top side to do that. Shown up for lack of pace at the back and lack of movement all over the pitch.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 15 Sep 19 4.56pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

We were crap in defence, midfield and attack. Even Guaita was rubbish. You can't get more comprehensively bad than that. I might also add the tactics were wrong too. Spurs scored with route one stuff - they didn't need to be a top side to do that. Shown up for lack of pace at the back and lack of movement all over the pitch.

The Beast was the only viable option due to injuries and looked rusty returning himself. Hopefully he will improve game to game. Seem to have a lot of injuries at the back. They are obviously worked hard, producing one of our strengths. Not sure about the attack though.

Edited by Booted Eagle (15 Sep 2019 4.56pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 15 Sep 19 8.47pm

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

The Beast was the only viable option due to injuries and looked rusty returning himself. Hopefully he will improve game to game. Seem to have a lot of injuries at the back. They are obviously worked hard, producing one of our strengths. Not sure about the attack though.

Edited by Booted Eagle (15 Sep 2019 4.56pm)

I'm sure we can improve. Would be pretty hard to concede softer goals.
If we had played anybody as a sweeper a lot of their play would not have been possible, so clever tactics could have helped too. Would not have needed to be a specialist sweeper - just someone to make the ball over the top too risky for them.
Every other team will have noticed how bad we were and just play long ball against us. Our thirty year old plus centre backs and aging/ poor full backs will struggle to get back. Obvious and will be happening match after match now.
Those saying Spurs were good are incorrect - they just identified an obvious flaw, whilst that was compounded by us being poor.

 


Red and Blue Army!

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 15 Sep 19 9.33pm

W

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I'm sure we can improve. Would be pretty hard to concede softer goals.
If we had played anybody as a sweeper a lot of their play would not have been possible, so clever tactics could have helped too. Would not have needed to be a specialist sweeper - just someone to make the ball over the top too risky for them.
Every other team will have noticed how bad we were and just play long ball against us. Our thirty year old plus centre backs and aging/ poor full backs will struggle to get back. Obvious and will be happening match after match now.
Those saying Spurs were good are incorrect - they just identified an obvious flaw, whilst that was compounded by us being poor.

Yes, we all got it wrong including the critics and the commentators and the Press. Not.

People accuse Hodgson of being a tactical dinosaur and then you suggest playing with a “ non specialist sweeper “ and employing “ clever tactics “ ( whatever that actually means ). Genius. Out of interest, who would you play in the sweeper role ?

Not every team in the league has players capable of moving the ball as quickly and accurately as Spurs have. Better teams than us will lose to them this season.

Performance wise I agree with you, we can and need to improve. As good as Spurs were, our own level of performance was well short of what is required to be competing against top opposition.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 15 Sep 19 9.47pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

W

Yes, we all got it wrong including the critics and the commentators and the Press. Not.

People accuse Hodgson of being a tactical dinosaur and then you suggest playing with a “ non specialist sweeper “ and employing “ clever tactics “ ( whatever that actually means ). Genius. Out of interest, who would you play in the sweeper role ?

Not every team in the league has players capable of moving the ball as quickly and accurately as Spurs have. Better teams than us will lose to them this season.

Performance wise I agree with you, we can and need to improve. As good as Spurs were, our own level of performance was well short of what is required to be competing against top opposition.

If anybody is saying we weren't crap then they are wrong. As for people saying Spurs were great, as I already said they weren't. They played direct and we couldn't handle it.
Fair enough, there was a degree of accuracy and urgency about what they did. I will say that. They could be in the top four at the end of the season but they don't seem as good as last season to me anyway.
Could have played Woods as a sweeper or Kouyate as a central defender. We lack pace at the back even if everyone was fit. Or am I also so wrong there? And yes some innovative tactics would not go amiss.
No point in not conceding anymore when you're already well down. You have to change things, you have to try to outscore them if you can't defend. Our team and manager seem literally unable to adapt at all.
I hardly think I'm the only one saying it. As for pundits - it doesn't make that much difference to me what Andy Gray or even Gary Neville thinks. I'm pretty sure I'm also not the only one who ignores them either.
We are Palace and the pundits have basically ignored us for years except to condescend us on the odd occasion.

 


Red and Blue Army!

palace chick Flag South Croydon 15 Sep 19 10.18pm

One main problem yesterday was that Sakho played so poorly. Hopefully by next week he will be back to his old self? The other problem will then be do you bring back Tompkins to play alongside him or does Cahill keep his place? Not sure a Sakho / Cahill partnership works and that may also have been a problem yesterday? If it is them two, does Tompkins switch to right back where Ward doesn’t look good enough at, other than as a squad player. Not sure how this is going to work out. And, what’s our best midfield now? We look a long way off in having a settled team in my opinion :-(

 

Page 9 of 11 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Spurs v Palace match thread