This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
But the lunatics are not Ministers. Not elected. Completely unregulated and answering to no one that is in any way capable of reining in their egos. All Civil Servants are subject to the civil service code and are answerable to places like the PAC and a wealth of regulatory bodies. They are there to deliver public services often under huge pressure. Let's remember stuff like all the measures to pay people affected by COVID was implemented by civil servants and OK might not be perfect but the country would have been very different without it. Edited by orpingtoneagle (28 Jun 2020 11.09pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Had it occurred to you that they might be routing out the people who stand in the way of progress? Or maybe have a little bit too much socialist in them? I assume you have met Mr Sedwell then and know his political leanings? Maybe he simply pointed out to those unelected advisors appointed by patronage that sometimes their grand plans may not work.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Had it occurred to you that they might be routing out the people who stand in the way of progress? Or maybe have a little bit too much socialist in them? Yes it had occurred to me. Then I looked at who was doing it When you have a massively complex machine only the terminally naive sack the people that best understand how it runs. You wouldn’t do it in a cannery let alone with a multi billion pound enterprise. We’ll see if the Mekon really does have a plan. It had better be brilliant. So not like the COVID debacle.
|
|
|
Originally posted by orpingtoneagle
All Civil Servants are subject to the civil service code and are answerable to places like the PAC and a wealth of regulatory bodies. They are there to deliver public services often under huge pressure. Let's remember stuff like all the measures to pay people affected by COVID was implemented by civil servants and OK might not be perfect but the country would have been very different without it. Edited by orpingtoneagle (28 Jun 2020 11.09pm) The lunatics to whom I refer are not the civil servants. It is those who currently are whispering ‘my precious’ as they wiggle the ring of power off the civil servants‘ dead fingers.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Had it occurred to you that they might be routing out the people who stand in the way of progress? Or maybe have a little bit too much socialist in them? The Civil Service has not faced a structural reform in along time. If you think about the rest of the economy it is hugely different from say the 1970's. If certain people are blocking reform of the service it is not only the responsibility of the government but the duty to move these people to one side. We have seen with the virus how flat footed the government response has been. One of the issues has been who is in charge as responsibility is spread around the service. The government is politically responsible but it is the job of the Civil Service to carry out the government's orders. If this needs a shakeup of the management structure that is not a bad thing.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
The Civil Service has not faced a structural reform in along time. If you think about the rest of the economy it is hugely different from say the 1970's. If certain people are blocking reform of the service it is not only the responsibility of the government but the duty to move these people to one side. We have seen with the virus how flat footed the government response has been. One of the issues has been who is in charge as responsibility is spread around the service. The government is politically responsible but it is the job of the Civil Service to carry out the government's orders. If this needs a shakeup of the management structure that is not a bad thing.
Ypu totally miss Maple's point, and you do not give any evidence that the civil service has not been carrying out the government's wishes, we could not get that lucky. A management shake-up from Johnson? The PM of the second worst corona response in the world? He couldn't run a piss-up in a brewery. It's about power, power of the unelected to rule the country.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Ypu totally miss Maple's point, and you do not give any evidence that the civil service has not been carrying out the government's wishes, we could not get that lucky. 1. A management shake-up from Johnson? The PM of the second worst corona response in the world? He couldn't run a piss-up in a brewery. It's about power, power of the unelected to rule the country. 2. 1. I didn't say that the service was not carrying out the governments orders I was complaining about the lack of speed and lack of accountability. What Cummings is trying to do is to create small management teams with specific responsibilities. The government is about to launch a major infrastructure spend to kick start the economy something most of us would think is a good thing. However there is a huge gap between announcing funding and actually breaking ground e.g. Heathrow Expansion and HS2. Whatever these projects are they need to be fast tracked so PR announcements become actual jobs. You don't need to tear down the Civil Service just re-organise the top management. I don't have any evidence as you say but other countries seem to get things done quicker. I am not saying the civil service is obstructive but I am saying it lacks focus when you have projects that cut across multiple areas of government. 2. Sounds to me like you are describing the Civil Service.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by m/k mick
The civil service is just a job for the boys, totally corrupt, very few of them would get jobs in the real world, dont like cummings, but we need guys like him, more than he needs us, same as the house of Lords, jobs for the same bunch of cronies What a load of b######s at a senior level most civil servants these days move between public and private sectors or have secondments to big business. I am a civil servant and have worked in industry and both a big accountancy practice and top legal firm in my career. Aa for accountability, far more public scrutiny than any MP or government adviser. Not sure about jobs for the boys either as I was born and bred in the tougher end of Croydon and have worked bloody hard to get where I am.
|
|
|
Originally posted by m/k mick
The civil service is just a job for the boys, totally corrupt, very few of them would get jobs in the real world, dont like cummings, but we need guys like him, more than he needs us, same as the house of Lords, jobs for the same bunch of cronies Sorry but that sweeping statement simply does not pass muster.When you hear that Cummings had granted the track and trace app to a mate of his worth millions of pounds and then it has to be scrapped because it was next to useless, that is being totally corrupt. The Civil Service is full of hard working, very averagely paid (although this has improved in recent years) staff who provide stability and order to the various government departments. You don't need mavericks in the Civil Service, you need safe pairs of hands who will move with the times, but only when it makes sense to do so. Basic GCSEs will get you into the Service if you are willing to start at the bottom and work up, so it is hardly jobs for the boys. It is also possible to go from the bottom to the very top if you are tenacious and talented enough.
|
|
|
Originally posted by orpingtoneagle
What a load of b######s at a senior level most civil servants these days move between public and private sectors or have secondments to big business. I am a civil servant and have worked in industry and both a big accountancy practice and top legal firm in my career. Aa for accountability, far more public scrutiny than any MP or government adviser. Not sure about jobs for the boys either as I was born and bred in the tougher end of Croydon and have worked bloody hard to get where I am. Is correct. The Civil Service often succeed in spite of the circumstances they are placed under but no commentary ever covers this. Ignorance around the CS, it's personnel and workings are generally quite shocking. I include myself in that statement before my dealings with the Public Sector over the last x amount of years.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by m/k mick
Funny how those that disagree live in the South East, the civil service is a law unto itself, those that work in it have a reason to defend it, wait till the government start moving departments out of the South East, the whinging will really start, because very few will find work in the private sector You obviously have no clue. I feel like you may have lost your job at the DWP or something at some point in time and decided it was because everybody else was stupid. Not saying that's the case of course, just how your comments come across.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by orpingtoneagle
What a load of b######s at a senior level most civil servants these days move between public and private sectors or have secondments to big business. I am a civil servant and have worked in industry and both a big accountancy practice and top legal firm in my career. Aa for accountability, far more public scrutiny than any MP or government adviser. Not sure about jobs for the boys either as I was born and bred in the tougher end of Croydon and have worked bloody hard to get where I am. I know, what an absolute load of tosh. He is talking about another world a whole generation ago or more.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
I know, what an absolute load of tosh. He is talking about another world a whole generation ago or more. Yes, more like 2 generations ago. That’s when going into the civil service was dependent on which school you went to. I could think of a lot worse things to complain about. His argument should have begun and rested at the House of Lords, as I don’t think there would be many arguing that point.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
There are around 430,000 people employed in the civil service. Of these, 83,500 are based in London Rupert McNeil is a very clever chap and is making a difference. He comes bang out of the private sector. You'd be surprised, but he has done a reasonable job.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by m/k mick
Nicholas, strange how you try to belittle someone, just because they have a different point of view, the answer is no, the DWP have never upset me, i have just always hated privilege, and the civil service and the Lords epitomises privilege The Civil Service is one of the most diverse employers in the UK. I am not trying to belittle you which is an ironic statement given there may be Civil Servants reading your posts where you claim they are unemployable outside of the Public Sector. Your posts are completely ignorant, laughably so, and I can claim that to be factual not just an opinion and quite frankly insulting to somebody like me who has family members, friends and colleagues who work within the Civil Service. I myself have worked with Civil Servants on numerous occasions so am speaking from experience. CPFC may be the only thing we share in common.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.