You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Alexander Sörloth
November 22 2026 7.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Alexander Sörloth


Page 9 of 32 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 15 Aug 20 11.48am

Originally posted by Vincehair

Wrote off much in the same way as Murray was, and Benteke has persevered with

Probably a decision even Pardew regrets and we haven't really found a replacement since.

What I want to know is how can the club he plays for afford to buy him if they are subject to FFP breach and a Europe ban? Can they afford the 6m clause with loss of income after the 2 year loan?

FFP doesn't really mean anything you can be a billionaire and breach it which has happened with many clubs its a system to hold little teams down.

Players buy the contract out not clubs it's just the fees end up being passed back to players via signing on fee etc so with this loan club he is at lets say they dont have money well another club that wants to buy him can pay for him its all very shady.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 15 Aug 20 2.10pm

Originally posted by kev64

This^^^, yes he’s done well in a sub standard Turkish league and maybe the deal was to the other clubs advantage now he has shown he can play at this level.

While he was at Palace he showed all the class of Sonogaols and other dire signings we made. All this bs that Barca will pay 30 mill for him is just that bs .

The lad found his level which is not pl standard and good luck to him, at least we may recoup 6mill plus the loan cost, on the other hand another years loan and he’s back ..

Edited by kev64 (14 Aug 2020 10.25pm)

Yep, if he went to a big team then he would be emergency injury replacement only. Can you see him spearheading a top 4 team in any of the major leagues.......... er no.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 15 Aug 20 3.46pm

Originally posted by kev64

This^^^, yes he’s done well in a sub standard Turkish league and maybe the deal was to the other clubs advantage now he has shown he can play at this level.

While he was at Palace he showed all the class of Sonogaols and other dire signings we made. All this bs that Barca will pay 30 mill for him is just that bs .

The lad found his level which is not pl standard and good luck to him, at least we may recoup 6mill plus the loan cost, on the other hand another years loan and he’s back ..

Edited by kev64 (14 Aug 2020 10.25pm)

In all fairness, he was better than Sanogo - Benteke is too. That was our worst ever striker. Made Aylott look mercurial. Sorloth wasn't good for us but also wasn't massively bad, particularly in comparison to Benteke. I suspect he would have scored more goals than Benteke but frankly so would Pierrick, Gayle, Murray and [pick any striker in the league and in the conference and insert name here].

 


Red and Blue Army!

palace99 Flag New Mills 15 Aug 20 4.24pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Wrong

You need to look into this you don't understand how it works.

Palace have no power here the only thing they can get is that buy out clause money nothing else so if some one else wants him now its doesn't matter it's nothing to do with them.

A lot of people get confused with how it used to be in the old days the modern system is completely different.

If he was a Palace player as such we can bring him back but we can't he has a deal with another club so we need to wait for that to expire which is no good anyway reports state his contract expires that same year loan deal ends.

easiest way to look at it is the same as a release clause you hit it the parent cant do anything thing the player has released himself this is same with the loan so palace has no say because they put that release number in.



wrong - might as well be as arrogant as you!

Palace extended his contract by a year before he left on loan to ensure he still had value at the end of the loan if the buyout is not activated.

Whilst the loan has no release clause the buyout is only activate after year 2 if he plays x amount of games in year 2.

As i said if an offer came in for him now, after year 1, it would be complicated and both clubs would need to reach a compromise.

To state he is not a Palace player today is plainly inaccurate.

Don't bother replying Grumpy - i'm fed up with this thread

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 15 Aug 20 5.33pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

He was given opportunities but after missing a last minute chance to equalise against Spurs in November 2018 there were howls and catcalls about him from virtually everyone on this board. Personally I thought he never looked remotely like a Premier League player.

From December 18 we went on a good run of games and climbed the table without him. Batshuayi was brought in on loan at the end of January 19.

In the meantime AS failed to deliver against Grimsby in the cup.

Good luck to him but there is a lot of amnesia regarding how poor he was and why he had so few opportunities after.

Spot on!

The miss against Tottenham was shocking, the performance against Grimsby equally so!

He was poor, not even remotely PL standard and 20 goals in a Turkish league the equivalent to EFL Division 1 doesn’t suddenly change that.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 15 Aug 20 6.28pm


Reports he is having transfer talks with Leipzig, how does that work out ? He is still our player . So surely it’s Palace due a fee if this is true and happens. Does anyone know what the actual situation with him is regarding this .

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 15 Aug 20 6.53pm

Originally posted by palace99


wrong - might as well be as arrogant as you!

Palace extended his contract by a year before he left on loan to ensure he still had value at the end of the loan if the buyout is not activated.

Whilst the loan has no release clause the buyout is only activate after year 2 if he plays x amount of games in year 2.

As i said if an offer came in for him now, after year 1, it would be complicated and both clubs would need to reach a compromise.

To state he is not a Palace player today is plainly inaccurate.

Don't bother replying Grumpy - i'm fed up with this thread

I believe this to be correct. An interesting scenario emerging, if Leipzig agree terms and want to buy, technically he is a Palace player but Trabanzor can buy. Can Palace scupper any deal at this stage? Can we negotiate the fee and a %? Personally I think we probably can.
Another reason why loan deal was agreed by a f***wit

 

EddieMac Flag 15 Aug 20 7.15pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

I believe this to be correct. An interesting scenario emerging, if Leipzig agree terms and want to buy, technically he is a Palace player but Trabanzor can buy. Can Palace scupper any deal at this stage? Can we negotiate the fee and a %? Personally I think we probably can.
Another reason why loan deal was agreed by a f***wit[/quote]

Why Is that?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 15 Aug 20 7.17pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Originally posted by Spiderman

I believe this to be correct. An interesting scenario emerging, if Leipzig agree terms and want to buy, technically he is a Palace player but Trabanzor can buy. Can Palace scupper any deal at this stage? Can we negotiate the fee and a %? Personally I think we probably can.
Another reason why loan deal was agreed by a f***wit[/quote]

Why Is that?

A 2 year loan deal with no recall option is imo pretty amateurish.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 15 Aug 20 7.53pm


The detail of the loan deal has always been in question. But if the player is in serious talks with a third club. Then he is governed by one of three things. 1 . He is a free agent. 2, he needs Palace to sanction him even talking to another club. .3, The Turkish, team already are his club. And they are allowing a transfer to take place. If he was not sold to the Turks, and as his contract with Palace hasn’t run out . Palace should be due a fee directly from Leipzig,
Half way through a loan agreement he can’t be owned by both clubs .Was it a two year loan? Or was it actually , A deposit taken , with the rest payable after two years?
The Turks can’t sell an on loan player. So why would the player be in talks with a third club.

 

EddieMac Flag 15 Aug 20 11.19pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

A 2 year loan deal with no recall option is imo pretty amateurish.

But if he is being sold half way through a 2 year loan deal to a different club and we get the money then it just proves we wanted rid of him and nothing amateurish about it.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 16 Aug 20 9.32am

Parish demanded a full , independent investigation to find out how such a terrible deal was signed.......Brighty to head investigation hahahaha

See how much he gets sold for then deduct our pre agreed sale price

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 16 Aug 20 9.33am

Not sure how many on here have any real idea of the detail of the deal. I don't

Originally posted by EddieMac

But if he is being sold half way through a 2 year loan deal to a different club and we get the money then it just proves we wanted rid of him and nothing amateurish about it.

Edited by HKOwen (16 Aug 2020 9.37am)

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 16 Aug 20 9.38am

Originally posted by HKOwen

We won't get anything, Trabanspor will buy him first then sell him on

You are probably right but I thought there was a rule to stop players being bought and sold multiple times in one season?

No doubt someone on here can clarify that.

 


One more point

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 16 Aug 20 10.00am

We don’t know the inside story here but seems a massively naive deal to agree to doesn’t it? Yes he was awful at the time and many were not upset to see the back of him but no call back option on a 2 year loan? And apparently no reported sell on clause thats is just negligent, it’s that sits with the men at the top who signed it off. Makes palace look complete amateurs.

*disclaimer.. fingers crossed there is at least a sell on % for us.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 16 Aug 20 10.22am


If Sorloth, is still a Palace player Leipzig , have to have Palaces permission to even talk to the player. If this story is not fake, then Palace would have to be completely in on this. Which would give the impression everything is working in their own interests.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 16 Aug 20 10.29am

Eddie Newton, seems to confirm, Sorloth, is Palaces player to sell.
This could get interesting ,if the interest is real.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 16 Aug 20 11.36am

Originally posted by EddieMac

But if he is being sold half way through a 2 year loan deal to a different club and we get the money then it just proves we wanted rid of him and nothing amateurish about it.

I think we did want rid but no loan deal should be agreed without a recall option surely! Particularly in view of our striker/injury problems. IF we get the money and it may be a big IF it has ended well but I don’t anyone at Palace can take any credit for that.
I do wonder if this scenario has ever occurred before? Presumably had we got a recall option he would have returned whilst awaiting the possible transfer. It would be nice if fans were told the details of the loan deal

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 16 Aug 20 11.37am

Originally posted by Putitout

Eddie Newton, seems to confirm, Sorloth, is Palaces player to sell.
This could get interesting ,if the interest is real.

Oh, that will be interesting! Could we have a nice little windfall?!

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 16 Aug 20 11.37am

Originally posted by Putitout

Eddie Newton, seems to confirm, Sorloth, is Palaces player to sell.
This could get interesting ,if the interest is real.

Interesting do you have a link please?

 

Page 9 of 32 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Alexander Sörloth