You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Marcus Rashford
November 21 2026 10.14pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Marcus Rashford


Page 9 of 14 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
Teddy Eagle Flag 24 Oct 20 11.39pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Which is another good reason to make sure they are given one healthy meal a day.

In 1906 the British parliament passed the permissive Education (Provision of Meals) Act allowing Local Education Authorities (LEAs) to provide free meals to elementary schoolchildren, funded out of the local rates. Rate-payer funded feeding programmes enabled under-nourished schoolchildren to benefit from the nation’s compulsory elementary education. 358,306 elementary schoolchildren were provided with free meals in 1912/13, about 7% of the elementary school population aged 3-11.

The point being poorly fed children don’t learn well.

Another left leaning newspaper puts it well

[Link]

Edited by Mapletree (24 Oct 2020 11.08pm)

Interesting total. Considerably lower than the current claimants.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 24 Oct 20 11.48pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Interesting total. Considerably lower than the current claimants.

If people are gaming the system as you imply, fix the system. The underlying problem remains

Recent figures suggest that amongst hospitalised children in the UK, 16% were severely stunted, 14% wasted and 20% at risk of severe malnutrition. Additionally, the National Child Measurement Programme determined that 11,317 children in the United Kingdom were underweight in 2010. The lasting effects of malnutrition on children include long term issues such as increased incidence of illness due to poor nutrition, and gastrointestinal infections, which compound and make it harder to fully absorb nutrients. As such, malnutrition combined with infection can undermine a child’s growth, and in the long term, can also undermine brain development, causing delays in motor and cognitive functions.

For these children action needs to be taken. It matters not by whom and I am not arguing any other point than don’t ignore UK child hunger and malnutrition.

Rashford has done an excellent job in pointing out a largely hidden scandal.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 24 Oct 20 11.49pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

If people are gaming the system as you imply, fix the system. The underlying problem remains

Recent figures suggest that amongst hospitalised children in the UK, 16% were severely stunted, 14% wasted and 20% at risk of severe malnutrition. Additionally, the National Child Measurement Programme determined that 11,317 children in the United Kingdom were underweight in 2010. The lasting effects of malnutrition on children include long term issues such as increased incidence of illness due to poor nutrition, and gastrointestinal infections, which compound and make it harder to fully absorb nutrients. As such, malnutrition combined with infection can undermine a child’s growth, and in the long term, can also undermine brain development, causing delays in motor and cognitive functions.

For these children action needs to be taken. It matters not by whom and I am not arguing any other point than don’t ignore UK child hunger and malnutrition.

Rashford has done an excellent job in pointing out a largely hidden scandal.

Pull your head in. That’s your inference not my implication.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 25 Oct 20 12.06am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Pull your head in. That’s your inference not my implication.

Ah, what was your implication?

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 25 Oct 20 12.20am

Originally posted by Mapletree

Ah, what was your implication?

What did I say? Interesting total. No implication or other connotation. Sometimes Sigmund a cigar is just a cigar.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 25 Oct 20 12.54am

Originally posted by Mapletree

If people are gaming the system as you imply, fix the system. The underlying problem remains

Recent figures suggest that amongst hospitalised children in the UK, 16% were severely stunted, 14% wasted and 20% at risk of severe malnutrition. Additionally, the National Child Measurement Programme determined that 11,317 children in the United Kingdom were underweight in 2010. The lasting effects of malnutrition on children include long term issues such as increased incidence of illness due to poor nutrition, and gastrointestinal infections, which compound and make it harder to fully absorb nutrients. As such, malnutrition combined with infection can undermine a child’s growth, and in the long term, can also undermine brain development, causing delays in motor and cognitive functions.

For these children action needs to be taken. It matters not by whom and I am not arguing any other point than don’t ignore UK child hunger and malnutrition.

Rashford has done an excellent job in pointing out a largely hidden scandal.


This is again just like the other post I replied to it's not being fed that is the issues its the type of food.

Giving free meals will not solve this because the NHS/GOVT give terrible nutrition advise not just about children but adults and this is why we have so many problems with ill health.

Anyone that has studied and understands about humans know we are not suppose to consume the processed plus wheat/grain food yet all you hear about is its a must have for health etc

Other factors as well for some of what you listed the lack of exercise has an impact as well and structure a lot of families now allow their kids to stay up late so they get limited sleep then load up on high sugar products.

Way more to this subject then people think

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

BlueJay Flag UK 25 Oct 20 1.09am

Originally posted by grumpymort


This is again just like the other post I replied to it's not being fed that is the issues its the type of food.

Giving free meals will not solve this because the NHS/GOVT give terrible nutrition advise not just about children but adults and this is why we have so many problems with ill health.

Anyone that has studied and understands about humans know we are not suppose to consume the processed plus wheat/grain food yet all you hear about is its a must have for health etc

Other factors as well for some of what you listed the lack of exercise has an impact as well and structure a lot of families now allow their kids to stay up late so they get limited sleep then load up on high sugar products.

Way more to this subject then people think

People and families are entitled to their own views on the best diet. All you can do in that regard is educate. You can also though, provide a few balanced square meals in the school holidays during a pandemic without the world spinning off its axis.

Edited by BlueJay (25 Oct 2020 1.16am)

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 25 Oct 20 1.29am

Originally posted by BlueJay


Rashford has played a pivotal role in raising £20 million for hungry kids, has donated a substantial sum himself and has shone a light on something is both well intentional and making a difference. I'm inclined to listen to real life examples of members on here who open up about their own troubled childhoods and how a leg up can often mean so much.

Realities extend beyond whose fault it is or 'maybe the parents will sell £15 vouchers to buy drugs'. Let's bring the conversation and likelihood back down to something remotely based in reality please. It's not kids fault if they have a bad parent, or as likely good parents who are struggling during these horrendous times and have lost their jobs due to government decisions. Where that happens is the idea of a voucher for hungry kids really that out there?


Ok, how many malnourished adults?

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 25 Oct 20 1.49am

My father would not allow the shame of accepting free school meals. My brother and I would take a tanner to school for dinner, if there was money spare. I remember fights over food at Kingsdown and then Dog Kennel Hill school when I was young. How come this is now big news?

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

BlueJay Flag UK 25 Oct 20 1.54am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3568558]

My father would not allow the shame of accepting free school meals. My brother and I would take a tanner to school for dinner, if there was money spare. I remember fights over food at Kingsdown and then Dog Kennel Hill school when I was young. How come this is now big news?

There is no shame in accepting a free school meal if it genuinely makes a difference to a child in need. Maybe kids having to 'fight over food' isn't optimal. Put down the styrofoam 'stone tablet' for a second, and realise that you don't get to speak for the struggles or character of every single parent out there - some of whom you imagine to be primed to sell their kids £15 vouchers (that they aren't going to get anyway) to 'buy drugs'. If you're so judgemental of free school meals that you would demonise families and consequently children, for doing so, the shame lies a little closer to home I'm afraid. All shaming children having free schools meals does is encourage the marginalisation and bullying (real 'bullying' Tim) of vulnerable and disadvantaged children.


Why is it an issue now? There's a once in a lifetime pandemic going on and some people are seriously struggling with their finances and to put food on the table. Possibly that is reason enough.

As practical advice for struggling families, I would say don't be in any way ashamed to accept free school meals or to visit a food bank if you really need to. And if you're in a more fortunate position and have worked from home of late, make sure you claim your work from home tax relief and consider donating it to one of these organisations. Then giftaid it as way of making the government at least pay a contribution towards providing the basics. 'Treat others as you'd like to be treated if you were down on your luck', isn't a bad rule to live by. It's more helpful and realistic than comforting yourself with sweeping ideas that everyone going that route is an addict, a bad parent, 'shameful', or otherwise on the make.


Edited by BlueJay (25 Oct 2020 2.09am)

 

BlueJay Flag UK 25 Oct 20 1.56am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3568554]

Ok, how many malnourished adults?

No, we're not playing pick a new subject to run away from the current one.

The fact of the matter is people contribute either in a positive or a negative manner, and in Marcus Rashford's own way he has certainly done more than his fair share to help. Many footballers, and more so most rich people do sod all to help anyone, and so someone actively doing good shouldn't be the first person to lay into (I'm not saying that you're personally doing this at all, you at least appear to recognise his good intentions). And as someone doing his best, it's a logical step for him to think that the government may want to help too. It appears that they are not but that others have stepped in, and so decency has found a way.

Edited by BlueJay (25 Oct 2020 1.12am)

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 25 Oct 20 12.26pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3568554]

Ok, how many malnourished adults?

If you knew anything about dementia you would realise.

 

jeeagles Flag 25 Oct 20 1.03pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

There is no shame in accepting a free school meal if it genuinely makes a difference to a child in need.

Edited by BlueJay (25 Oct 2020 2.09am)

There should be no shame.
But in reality there is.

A little bit of shame here and there isn't so much of a bad thing in some circumstances.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 25 Oct 20 6.33pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

No, we're not playing pick a new subject to run away from the current one.

The fact of the matter is people contribute either in a positive or a negative manner, and in Marcus Rashford's own way he has certainly done more than his fair share to help. Many footballers, and more so most rich people do sod all to help anyone, and so someone actively doing good shouldn't be the first person to lay into (I'm not saying that you're personally doing this at all, you at least appear to recognise his good intentions). And as someone doing his best, it's a logical step for him to think that the government may want to help too. It appears that they are not but that others have stepped in, and so decency has found a way.

Edited by BlueJay (25 Oct 2020 1.12am)


These people do it for their own interests don't think he is doing it because he is a nice guy.

You will find most footballers have some involvement with charities not all of them feel the need to show it off.

If he really cared he could of done this himself as a charity thing not trying to play the card that govt are bad and not helping the guy alone earns 200 thousand a week and why is he now suddenly pushing it it's because he has a team around him which control his image etc

When he first became a name he never mentioned any of this

Edited by grumpymort (25 Oct 2020 6.36pm)

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 25 Oct 20 6.43pm

This is the quandary.

You have the richest black (brown) people in the world (Obama, NFL players, Lewis Hamilton, PL players) moaning about injustice.

Skin colour is not a prejudice,...you morons,..., it is divisive by its suggestion.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 25 Oct 20 6.48pm

So a least educated, but most well-paid employee gets to talk about Government Policy. What a world we live in, ...innit,...

And don't get me started on that c-unit of a PM and the people that voted for it,...

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 25 Oct 20 6.53pm

And the charidee work is a tax dodge. I paid more tax than any PL player last year. Well done the accountants.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 25 Oct 20 7.20pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

There is no shame in accepting a free school meal(1) if it genuinely makes a difference to a child in need. Maybe kids having to 'fight over food' isn't optimal. Put down the styrofoam 'stone tablet' for a second,(2) and realise that you don't get to speak for the struggles or character of every single parent(3) out there - some of whom you imagine to be primed to sell their kids £15 vouchers (that they aren't going to get anyway) to 'buy drugs'. If you're so judgemental of free school meals(4) that you would demonise families and consequently children, for doing so, the shame lies a little closer to home I'm afraid.(5) All shaming children having free schools meals does is encourage the marginalisation and bullying (real 'bullying' Tim) of vulnerable and disadvantaged children.


Why is it an issue now? There's a once in a lifetime pandemic going on and some people are seriously struggling with their finances and to put food on the table. Possibly that is reason enough.

As practical advice for struggling families, I would say don't be in any way ashamed to accept free school meals or to visit a food bank if you really need to. And if you're in a more fortunate position and have worked from home of late, make sure you claim your work from home tax relief and consider donating it to one of these organisations. Then giftaid it as way of making the government at least pay a contribution towards providing the basics. 'Treat others as you'd like to be treated if you were down on your luck', isn't a bad rule to live by. It's more helpful and realistic than comforting yourself with sweeping ideas that everyone going that route is an addict, a bad parent, 'shameful', or otherwise on the make. ( 7 )


Edited by BlueJay (25 Oct 2020 2.09am)

<deep breath, count to ten>

1 I never said there was shame. But some people feel it.

2 Get off your high horse and stop making condescending remarks.

3 But Rashford, and yourself do?

4 I haven't judged anything

5 I demonised nobody, so suffer no shame. Trying to make someone feel guilty is extremely low.

6 It's been around since before Dickens came up with the name Twist, when poverty was really a thing in Britain, but now, because of a virus, it suddenly hits the headlines.

The highlight in blue I agree with completely.

7 This is where you fall down. Why would you think I need to "comfort myself", and where did I say "everyone"? The fact is that chidren are malnourished in the majority of cases because of bad parenting. Giving bad parents more money will not solve the problem. Which is pretty much the arsewipe gov's reply too.

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (25 Oct 2020 7.21pm)

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 25 Oct 20 7.27pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

No, we're not playing pick a new subject to run away from the current one.

The fact of the matter is people contribute either in a positive or a negative manner, and in Marcus Rashford's own way he has certainly done more than his fair share to help. Many footballers, and more so most rich people do sod all to help anyone, and so someone actively doing good shouldn't be the first person to lay into (I'm not saying that you're personally doing this at all, you at least appear to recognise his good intentions). And as someone doing his best, it's a logical step for him to think that the government may want to help too. It appears that they are not but that others have stepped in, and so decency has found a way.

Edited by BlueJay (25 Oct 2020 1.12am)

It's not a new subject. Let me join up the dots for you.

You were replying to an answer to a post by Mapletree in which he gave numbers of children malnourished. If those children are cared for by responsible parents, then why are their parents not also malnourished? So the question stands. I see that he has somehow managed to get mental illness involved since I asked. Right 'on topic'!

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 25 Oct 20 7.29pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

If you knew anything about dementia you would realise.

See above.

I also know enough that it is extremely rare for parents of young children to have dementia.....

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Page 9 of 14 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Marcus Rashford