This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Rich people buy their way out of trouble for a change.
|
|
|
A Prince operating at a level lower than a snake.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Extreme left wing 'antifa' maybe. I am not discussing, let alone defending, extreme left wing attitudes which I detest every bit as much as I do the extreme right. They though are not evident here. Nor much, so far as I can tell, elsewhere in the UK. I am primarily talking about attitudes, rather than activities, although I disagree with you over the EDL or Football Lads Alliance, who I recall being involved in some pretty unpleasant behaviour. Whether enough to be described as a "riot" hardly matters. No-one is stopping anyone holding opinions. The only issue is unlawful behaviour, which these days includes using "hate speech". That isn't just "hurty words" which is a right-wingers excuse and no reason. It is unlawful. Politics is very far from one-sided. Just look at the current government for evidence of that.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Yep, you don't see the right of any type trying to light the union flag alight on the Cenotaph. You don't see the right spray painting Churchill's statue. You didn't see the right rioting in US cities for 18 months and having their criminal activists being released back onto the streets. The dissident right have no power and no political representation, they are harried and persecuted......You have seen them attacked on these boards and called all the names under the sun. The communist party have a headquarters in London.....it's been there for many decades and Labour figures have visited it many times. Police are not sent to its door....no damage is caused to it. Yet if you are on the dissident right, morons send Police to your door if you even mention them and no doubt consider themselves self righteous. Edited by Stirlingsays (03 Jan 2022 7.06pm) The only people who do things like that are nutcases. Nobody seriously interested in politics would ever do it. We are far too removed from the troubles in the US cities to come to any kind of informed opinion. My instinct is to dismiss the kind of statement above simply because it's the kind of thing Trump used to say, and he lied every time he opened his mouth. I fail to see why the "dissent right" should expect to have any power or political representation unless and until they are strong enough to achieve it the same way everyone else does. Through the ballot box. The communist party is an irrelevancy in the UK in 2022. Right wing extremism is seen as more of a threat than that from the left.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The only people who do things like that are nutcases. Nobody seriously interested in politics would ever do it. We are far too removed from the troubles in the US cities to come to any kind of informed opinion. My instinct is to dismiss the kind of statement above simply because it's the kind of thing Trump used to say, and he lied every time he opened his mouth. I fail to see why the "dissent right" should expect to have any power or political representation unless and until they are strong enough to achieve it the same way everyone else does. Through the ballot box. The communist party is an irrelevancy in the UK in 2022. Right wing extremism is seen as more of a threat than that from the left. So left wing extremists are now just nutters with no political interest. ( I bet they vote) Strange how you also say muslims grooming and raping girls are just criminals. (I bet they read that dopey book) With both of these you are stating the obvious. Of course the name of nutter and criminal fits both but try breaking it down a bit and be more literal.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
So left wing extremists are now just nutters with no political interest. ( I bet they vote) Strange how you also say muslims grooming and raping girls are just criminals. (I bet they read that dopey book) With both of these you are stating the obvious. Of course the name of nutter and criminal fits both but try breaking it down a bit and be more literal. They aren't left, or right, anything. They are just nutcases. People who do stupid things like that haven't got political views that can be taken seriously. So why do you refer to it again? And anyone who grooms and exploits children are certainly criminal nutcases, whatever kind of distorted religious justification they might use as an excuse. Persistently using epithets like "Muslim" or "Asian" tends to distort and encourage a focus on the wrong target. They are evil men, who need to be stopped. We don't need to punish Muslims. We need to detect criminals, using every possible avenue available. Including the Muslim community.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The guy who is on these boards for years pushing the Trump/Russia conspiracy theory thinks that we are 'too far removed from the troubles in the US cities to come to any kind of informed opinion.'.
I have removed the bulk of this post as it's not worth a reply. It's all been dealt with before. The above though needs to be corrected. There is a world of difference between what has happened in the US cities and Trump. With the former none of us have any first-hand knowledge. We reply on media reports, which often present very different accounts, especially those from right leaning observers, who have sought to politicise the events. I have heard reports of rightish activists seeking to exploit peaceful protests, alongside looters doing so. Even my friends in the USA don't really know the truth, so how can we? With the latter we have more than enough evidence. Much it from Trump's own mouth and hand. More from Mueller. Still more from his former associates and appointees. The whole world has the evidence of their own eyes and ears. i am not "pushing a conspiracy". Conspiracies are just theories. I know, just as well as everyone else who thinks objectively about this, that Trump was involved in accepting assistance from Russia in the 2016. What's missing is not the knowledge. It's the proof needed to pass over the legal high bar. This though may pass into history. If Trump is eventually brought to book for attempting to illegally overturn the 2020 election then there will no longer be a need to investigate 2016. We'll see.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
No specifics. Just disingenuous BS. Personally I regard a person who wants to see all religion restricted and basically removed and someone promoting authoritarianism over and above what we're seen....seemingly gleefully hoping for it over a vaccine status. Those are specifics that people can recognise from your posts on here. That's more extreme than anything I've come across. What's different from what the dissentient right say now that wasn't said in the right's past.....nothing.
When making a general observation of your lifelong perceptions giving specifics is hardly on the agenda. I have repeatedly corrected the assertion that I want to restrict religion and see it removed. I want to free people from being presented with religion when they don't want it, but to ensure that those who do, can participate freely and fully. I want all religions to be free to use their places of worship, but not in places shared with others. Like schools or the public square. As we, via the state, have the duty to educate all children in their civil responsibilities that means no religion ought to be involved in any way. That's neither authoritarian nor extreme. It's simple common sense. As is the need for everyone to be able to prove their vaccination status in a world which increasingly demands it. There is nothing to fear, so those who object must have another agenda. I welcome it as a sensible way of quickly ensuring that the places I go are safe. Easy entry to places to eat, be entertained or board a plane? What's not to like? Let's restore as much normality as possible as soon as possible.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
While I am personally an agnostic I pride myself on my knowledge of Christianity and view that as a pre-requisite to being a reasonably educated Englishmen....nay British or European. It is our culture and it is our history and I don't take it lightly nor belittle or look to diminish that. Indeed, if you don't understand it, you don't really correctly understand much of our past. I certainly view attempts to remove it from view as an attack on our culture. It is clear that religion's fall from public life has seen an equal fall in our morality, community and resulted in adding to our greater individual atomization. As Nietzsche was right to fear, in killing God, its replacement in the godless may certainly be self congratulatory but in reality it's a pathetically bad downgrade. As Blur once famously opined, 'modern life is....'. Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jan 2022 1.44pm) There is much that I agree with here, but I think that I am being misunderstood. I don't want religion removed from view. I want it being available to be viewed, if people want to view it. I also want its contribution to our culture taught to ALL schoolchildren. As that is primarily the Christian faith this is especially important, and the primary reason I think no faith ought to be involved in the running of any school. I want all our children to learn how to be proud British citizens.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
There is much that I agree with here, but I think that I am being misunderstood. I don't want religion removed from view. I want it being available to be viewed, if people want to view it. I also want its contribution to our culture taught to ALL schoolchildren. As that is primarily the Christian faith this is especially important, and the primary reason I think no faith ought to be involved in the running of any school. I want all our children to learn how to be proud British citizens. If I were a Muslim I think I'd want that to be the primary religion and history I'd want my child to know. I can see an argument for faithless schools, just not one for forcing that onto people who want faith ones. This is part of the problem....you can't say that you want diversity and inclusion (something I regard as b0llocks) but then say that you want a standardised system where everyone is taught the same.....which in reality is anti diversity and anti inclusion. Religion is as much identity as ethnicity is for many people. Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jan 2022 9.28pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jan 2022 9.28pm) This was partially the point i was trying to make prior to this site's censorship. It is not just religion but even more the violence between sects within a religion, just look at the Irish as well as the Muslims. It depends on the point of view.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Grumbles
This was partially the point i was trying to make prior to this site's censorship. It is not just religion but even more the violence between sects within a religion, just look at the Irish as well as the Muslims. It depends on the point of view.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
If I were a Muslim I think I'd want that to be the primary religion and history I'd want my child to know. I can see an argument for faithless schools, just not one for forcing that onto people who want faith ones. This is part of the problem....you can't say that you want diversity and inclusion (something I regard as b0llocks) but then say that you want a standardised system where everyone is taught the same.....which in reality is anti diversity and anti inclusion. Religion is as much identity as ethnicity is for many people. Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jan 2022 9.28pm) I expect I would as well. Nothing I am suggesting stops that. Their children can attend Mosque, religious classes and be taught at home. What I want is for them is not to be excluded from learning about British values and culture. I want every child to be taught these things, hopefully in the company of children from other cultures. This ought to take place now, as it is required by the national curriculum. However, any faith based school, and especially one where religious leaders are actively involved, is likely to lack commitment and face a conflict of interest. So I think they all need to be consigned to history and replaced by a strong message from us, the majority viewpoint. I want children to receive the messages from their parents too, and then be encouraged to think for themselves. I also want religion to be taught at school, but not a religion to be taught at school. I want all children to learn about the good, and the bad, impacts of religion and about all the major religions, their development and their contexts.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I expect I would as well. Nothing I am suggesting stops that. Their children can attend Mosque, religious classes and be taught at home. What I want is for them is not to be excluded from learning about British values and culture. I want every child to be taught these things, hopefully in the company of children from other cultures. This ought to take place now, as it is required by the national curriculum. However, any faith based school, and especially one where religious leaders are actively involved, is likely to lack commitment and face a conflict of interest. So I think they all need to be consigned to history and replaced by a strong message from us, the majority viewpoint. I want children to receive the messages from their parents too, and then be encouraged to think for themselves. I also want religion to be taught at school, but not a religion to be taught at school. I want all children to learn about the good, and the bad, impacts of religion and about all the major religions, their development and their contexts.
A school system that excludes faith schools within a state system is a valid argument, even if I only partially agree with it...I can't say that Christian state schools, which are the only ones I know about, are anything other than an improvement to the system. Anyway, state schools are one thing but when it comes to private ones....that's one sticky road to travel down. I just don't think it's a realistic argument from where we are...this was an argument from decades ago.....your 'global village' politics has created a problem that you can't realistically solve without conflict. Your obvious position of wanting to 'move religion' away from the centre of communities might work with the ever compromising Christians but it's just not going to swing elsewhere. Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Jan 2022 10.30pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
|
|
|
I read that interview and that was my first reaction. This guy clearly should not have been on the jury if he was molested.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
While I am personally an agnostic I pride myself on my knowledge of Christianity and view that as a pre-requisite to being a reasonably educated Englishman....nay British or European. It is our culture and it is our history and I don't take it lightly nor belittle or look to diminish that. Indeed, if you don't understand it, you don't really correctly understand much of our past. I certainly view attempts to remove it from view as an attack on our culture. It is clear that religion's fall from public life has seen an equal fall in our morality, community and resulted in adding to our greater individual atomization. As Nietzsche was right to fear, in killing God, its replacement in the godless may certainly be self congratulatory but in reality it's a pathetically bad downgrade. As Blur once famously opined, 'modern life is....'. Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jan 2022 9.21pm) Our culture and history are important but that is an everchanging thing. 200 years ago, no Scot had any attachment to Tartan, bagpipes or clans. To them it was just stupid northern balls that had no bearing on the modern day, it wasnt until some guy wanted to impress a new king and he fell in love with highland culture that Scots had any attatchment to that stuff. Suddenly Scotland has new and improved culture and history. It evolves. Its only ifg you believe that culture and history should stop where it is and not move again that it would be relevant. Who knows what crazy nonsense from now will be considered important British traditions. In 200 years from now it could be someone like you, shouting from your space pods that lefties are trying to take away your traditional Grime music or boxing day premiership football. The future is crazy and you will only drive yourself crazy trying to stop it from happening. Also worrying about what society will do once they stop worshipping god is silly, the most successful countries in history became successful by thinking about what's around or in front of them, not looking up...
|
|
|
Originally posted by Beanyboysmd
Our culture and history are important but that is an everchanging thing. 200 years ago, no Scot had any attachment to Tartan, bagpipes or clans. To them it was just stupid northern balls that had no bearing on the modern day, it wasnt until some guy wanted to impress a new king and he fell in love with highland culture that Scots had any attatchment to that stuff. Suddenly Scotland has new and improved culture and history. It evolves. Its only ifg you believe that culture and history should stop where it is and not move again that it would be relevant. Who knows what crazy nonsense from now will be considered important British traditions. In 200 years from now it could be someone like you, shouting from your space pods that lefties are trying to take away your traditional Grime music or boxing day premiership football. The future is crazy and you will only drive yourself crazy trying to stop it from happening. Also worrying about what society will do once they stop worshipping god is silly, the most successful countries in history became successful by thinking about what's around or in front of them, not looking up... You are pitching up strawmen here on traditionalism. Do we really want to have this tired debate on history....surely you know many Scotsman still couldn't give a fig about tartan, bagpipes or clans and how important they were to their past is far removed from what most think.....it's a debate for historians and like most re-readings of history differs depending upon the person. In terms of the society's relationship to religion, my point is that its replacement is a downgrade and quite a serious failure....and not a reflection upon what is and isn't true.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.