This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
I think referees should have to have a testicle examination to qualify for the PL, as clearly many of them don't have the balls to give decisions against the big teams. Thoroughly agree. I don't really buy into the 'bribes, corruptions etc.' malarkey however I can see some internal pressure being applied and perhaps a lack of metal on behalf of referees which influence supposed impartiality. Ward's back pass, Silva staying on the pitch etc are obviously huge decisions but just about everything went their way for those at the match. I recall at one point Wilf (I think) early second half knocking the ball down the side of the penalty area but still quite centrally, behind the back line (for a good position) and being bundled over. Not given of course, whereas every slight coming together seemed to amount to a Chelsea FK. In a game as tight as that against opponents with far more financial might these small things are critical and can't help but leave you questioning. It's not an old trope in my book it's a very logical destination to arrive at.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Thoroughly agree. I don't really buy into the 'bribes, corruptions etc.' malarkey however I can see some internal pressure being applied and perhaps a lack of metal on behalf of referees which influence supposed impartiality. As I mentioned earlier, it's the subconscious element that kicks in - knowing how the gravy train rolls along smoothly and being a part of it. Another example is a business meal entertaining the client, common place activity in business circles, no one seeks to question it, or call it bribery or corrupt - it is in plain view and a free meal is to be had. All aboard the gravy train!
|
|
|
Possibly also the Referee & family getting lambasted on all of the various types of social media - they probably get more crap thrown at them ( from fans in all corners of the world) if they give decisions against big teams Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
As I mentioned earlier, it's the subconscious element that kicks in - knowing how the gravy train rolls along smoothly and being a part of it. Another example is a business meal entertaining the client, common place activity in business circles, no one seeks to question it, or call it bribery or corrupt - it is in plain view and a free meal is to be had. All aboard the gravy train!
|
|
|
Originally posted by the silurian
should have NOTHING to do with it....so are you saying if it had been Wilf instead of Ayew involved Silva would have been sent off? It was an intentional decision by the corrupt referee ! Edited by the silurian (03 Oct 2022 8.11am) Garth Crooks has picked Silva for his team of the week, and he says: “ I'm inclined to agree that Thiago Siva was lucky to stay on the pitch. The last man in defence rule was designed to stop the cynical foul and yet referee Chris Kavanagh elected to leave the Chelsea defender on the pitch regardless of his deliberate handball. However, when players make a late challenge in a desperate attempt to win the ball but are beaten due to the speed or ingenuity of the opponent, no latitude is often given.” So he is saying it wasn’t a red because “it was only Jordan Ayew” (as others are saying), and he seems to be condoning this. No wonder there is big club bias.
RGW |
|
|
Originally posted by whatton
Garth Crooks has picked Silva for his team of the week, and he says: “ I'm inclined to agree that Thiago Siva was lucky to stay on the pitch. The last man in defence rule was designed to stop the cynical foul and yet referee Chris Kavanagh elected to leave the Chelsea defender on the pitch regardless of his deliberate handball. However, when players make a late challenge in a desperate attempt to win the ball but are beaten due to the speed or ingenuity of the opponent, no latitude is often given.” So he is saying it wasn’t a red because “it was only Jordan Ayew” (as others are saying), and he seems to be condoning this. No wonder there is big club bias. So a defender who is caught out of position and nearly gets sent off for a deliberate foul is worth a place in the team of the week. Blimey Harry Maguire is a shoe in for player of the season. Edited by Badger11 (03 Oct 2022 11.43am)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
As fans we are heavily prone to bias, so I would be interested to see a tally of how many times contentious decisions go the way of Liverpool, Man Utd, Man City and Chelsea when they play everyone else. Of course it is hard as often it is just the repeated smaller fouls they get away with, which is now the preferred tactic of these teams to stop the counter. Kovacic was the main offender for Chelsea yesterday and the referee waited until about his sixth foul before finally, and reluctantly, booking him. On a side note, I know the Edouard booking was soft, but he does keep getting booked for that same lazy trip which serves no purpose. Either smash into them Ayew style, or just don't bother. Some years ago now a PhD researcher looked into big club bias and decisions. Surprisingly for them, in their findings there was a big club bias that basically represented the table. At the time, I believe Arsenal and Man U were the big rivals. Unsurprisingly to everyone else it was them that got the most decisions, had the most extra time when behind etc. It was quite an interesting piece of research - you might find it online. It came off the back of Wenger's comments that Arsenal never got anything - and proved him wrong.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
This would make an interesting, and ‘doable’ research project: identify contentious and contested events where red cards had, or had not bee awarded (would need to find quite a lot to get a statistically significant result). Tabulate the outcomes showing which team had benefited from the outcome. We’d then be able to see if the ‘big’ teams were benefiting disproportionately from refereeing decisions. Originally posted by taylors lovechild
As fans we are heavily prone to bias, so I would be interested to see a tally of how many times contentious decisions go the way of Liverpool, Man Utd, Man City and Chelsea when they play everyone else. Of course it is hard as often it is just the repeated smaller fouls they get away with, which is now the preferred tactic of these teams to stop the counter. Kovacic was the main offender for Chelsea yesterday and the referee waited until about his sixth foul before finally, and reluctantly, booking him. On a side note, I know the Edouard booking was soft, but he does keep getting booked for that same lazy trip which serves no purpose. Either smash into them Ayew style, or just don't bother.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
So a defender who is caught out of position and nearly gets sent off for a deliberate foul is worth a place in the team of the week. Blimey Harry Maguire is a shoe in for player of the season. Edited by Badger11 (03 Oct 2022 11.43am) Really I wonder what Garth Crooks is smoking.
|
|
|
Originally posted by whatton
Garth Crooks has picked Silva for his team of the week, and he says: “ I'm inclined to agree that Thiago Siva was lucky to stay on the pitch. The last man in defence rule was designed to stop the cynical foul and yet referee Chris Kavanagh elected to leave the Chelsea defender on the pitch regardless of his deliberate handball. However, when players make a late challenge in a desperate attempt to win the ball but are beaten due to the speed or ingenuity of the opponent, no latitude is often given.” So he is saying it wasn’t a red because “it was only Jordan Ayew” (as others are saying), and he seems to be condoning this. No wonder there is big club bias. I'm not even sure what that means. what has Latitude got to do with it? is he saying that the desperate Player should be given leniency because he acted in desperation? The more and more I watch the incident the more of a nailed on Red it is. Sport is something where cheating should be, and is outlawed. So whether it's by the letter of the law or not, blatant cheating should be punished wherever possible in it's harshest form. And you can't get much More blatant than what Silva did. Edited by CrazyBadger (03 Oct 2022 1.52pm) Edited by CrazyBadger (03 Oct 2022 1.53pm)
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by Helmet46
I’m more pissed off that I was surrounded by Chelsea fans in the Holmesdale lower. [/quote The same in the Arthur Block U where I was with my son.. heard from a Palace fan in BLock W that Chelsea in there too.. I spoke to some stewards after the game when it was more obvious that these b*stards were in the wrong areas and am I'm so still pissed off that I'm writing to Palace to complain and ask for an explanation.. how and why this happened..
|
|
|
Originally posted by becky
Several posts have mentioned the pressure (on the pitch and via social media) that refs are under from the 'top' clubs & fans, so here's a thought to take the pressure off them over their decisions (right or wrong ones)..... make it a bookable offence for any player other than the Team Captain to approach and remonstrate with the referee during a match. Might mean several games having to be abandoned because their aren't enough players left on the pitch after a contentious tackle/goal/play, but they'd soon get the hang of it.... Of course it'd work a treat. It's been needed for feckin years but will it get implemented? Not a snowball's chance in the fires of hell. The FA are too gutless to bring in such a sensible rule.
I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything. |
|
|
Originally posted by Helmet46
I’m more pissed off that I was surrounded by Chelsea fans in the Holmesdale lower. There was a geezer sitting near me who I see regularly at Selhurst but got very over-excited when CG scored...
|
|
|
Originally posted by Terry Ven
There was a geezer sitting near me who I see regularly at Selhurst but got very over-excited when CG scored... Maybe he's just into cuckolds?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Terry Ven
There was a geezer sitting near me who I see regularly at Selhurst but got very over-excited when CG scored... I got very excited also , but not in a good way
|
|
|
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
I'm not even sure what that means. what has Latitude got to do with it? is he saying that the desperate Player should be given leniency because he acted in desperation? The more and more I watch the incident the more of a nailed on Red it is. Sport is something where cheating should be, and is outlawed. So whether it's by the letter of the law or not, blatant cheating should be punished wherever possible in it's harshest form. And you can't get much More blatant than what Silva did. Edited by CrazyBadger (03 Oct 2022 1.52pm) Edited by CrazyBadger (03 Oct 2022 1.53pm) Don't shoot me down here but as a qualified referee I'll give my take on the Silva incident. Now clearly it was an obvious handball and it was what is known as a DOGSO (Denying a goal or an Obvious Goal Scoring Opportunity) When you get taught about this on your course you're told to take into account the Distance to the goal, the Direction the attacker is travelling and the distance of the defenders. I'll admit this one was a tough one but taking my Palace glasses off and putting my referee glasses on Ayew was to the left hand side of the pitch. His direction of travel was to the left and not towards the goal. His distance from goal was still about 35 yards and there was another defender, apart from Silva level with him or just behind him when the foul occurred. I think taking all that into consideration I can see why a yellow was given and not a red. However it was a tight one I'll admit. I hope this explains things a little bit for everyone. Edited by kennybrowns leftfoot (04 Oct 2022 11.48pm)
Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!! |
|
|
Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot
Don't shoot me down here but as a qualified referee I'll give my take on the Silva incident. Now clearly it was an obvious handball and it was what is known as a DOGSO (Denying a goal or an Obvious Goal Scoring Opportunity) When you get taught about this on your course you're told to take into account the Distance to the goal, the Direction the attacker is travelling and the distance of the defenders. I'll admit this one was a tough one but taking my Palace glasses off and putting my referee glasses on Ayew was to the left hand side of the pitch. His direction of travel was to the left and not towards the goal. His distance from goal was still about 35 yards and there was another defender, apart from Silva level with him or just behind him when the foul occurred. I think taking all that into consideration I can see why a yellow was given and not a red. However it was a tight one I'll admit. I hope this explains things a little bit for everyone. Edited by kennybrowns leftfoot (04 Oct 2022 11.48pm) But surely the cynical nature of it HAS to come into it. Or some common sense. Or something. It was filthy. It seems so cruel that a complete accidental handball on a shot that may've been on target would be penalised with a red...but that from Silva gets a yellow.
|
|
|
Hi Kenny - Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot
Don't shoot me down here but as a qualified referee I'll give my take on the Silva incident. Now clearly it was an obvious handball and it was what is known as a DOGSO (Denying a goal or an Obvious Goal Scoring Opportunity) When you get taught about this on your course you're told to take into account the Distance to the goal, the Direction the attacker is travelling and the distance of the defenders. I'll admit this one was a tough one but taking my Palace glasses off and putting my referee glasses on Ayew was to the left hand side of the pitch. His direction of travel was to the left and not towards the goal. His distance from goal was still about 35 yards and there was another defender, apart from Silva level with him or just behind him when the foul occurred. I think taking all that into consideration I can see why a yellow was given and not a red. However it was a tight one I'll admit. I hope this explains things a little bit for everyone. Edited by kennybrowns leftfoot (04 Oct 2022 11.48pm)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.