You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Everton vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread
November 16 2026 4.02am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Everton vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread


Page 9 of 15 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
palace chick Flag South Croydon 22 Oct 22 8.32pm

Originally posted by Willo

I perused at the starting line-up and concluded that we would get totally overrun in midfield.
Milivojevic given a starting birth was ridiculous, I have lost all faith in him.
Poor team selection from Vieira.

Edited by Willo (22 Oct 2022 6.32pm)

I disagree, but only because if Luka had Hughes and Reidewald alongside him then our midfield would have been stronger. Perhaps even Schlup in place if one of them. Not saying that’s a strong midfield but it’s not full of players like Ayew, Olise, Eze or Zaha who just aren’t midfielders. Vieira is picking just one known midfielder and it just won’t work and the midfield will be overrun. Even with Dacoure back for next game we will still only have one midfielder that can play in the middle. The balance will just not be there. It’s not rocket science ;-)

 

Mathers Flag 22 Oct 22 9.18pm

I wish people would stop defending Luka. The bloke is clearly not good enough and that is putting it mildly. He has been 5 yards off the pace for well over 2 years and offers zero to the team. It’s a f***ing disgrace our recruitment has resulted in a 1 man midfield. Absolutely no coincidence that the game he’s suspended for ends up in a thumping.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 22 Oct 22 9.23pm

Originally posted by Mathers

I wish people would stop defending Luka. The bloke is clearly not good enough and that is putting it mildly. He has been 5 yards off the pace for well over 2 years and offers zero to the team. It’s a f***ing disgrace our recruitment has resulted in a 1 man midfield. Absolutely no coincidence that the game he’s suspended for ends up in a thumping.

I’m only defending him because to single him out today isn’t fair. Every player from 1-11 was woeful…yet it’s fashionable to single him out. Where’s the hate for Mitchell or Guehi (at fault for first) or Zaha or anyone else?

He’s an easy scape goat.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 22 Oct 22 9.32pm

Originally posted by sprites

I’m only defending him because to single him out today isn’t fair. Every player from 1-11 was woeful…yet it’s fashionable to single him out. Where’s the hate for Mitchell or Guehi (at fault for first) or Zaha or anyone else?

He’s an easy scape goat.

Agreed, there was a lot going wrong with other players including the manager than just Luka today

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 22 Oct 22 9.53pm

Originally posted by sprites

I’m only defending him because to single him out today isn’t fair. Every player from 1-11 was woeful…yet it’s fashionable to single him out. Where’s the hate for Mitchell or Guehi (at fault for first) or Zaha or anyone else?

He’s an easy scape goat.

I have articulated my concern about the vitriol aimed at Luka before and whilst I retain that stance, especially in light of what I perceive to be his massive contribution to us being a PL team still despite worse days, I think there’s a difference between subjective ire aimed at him and objective criticism of his inclusion in our team. The problem is it’s the whole midfield atm:

Hughes: Probably not good enough
Riedewald: Probably not good enough
Luka: Almost definitely not good enough these days
Doucoure: Great player but new to league and not 3 players
McArthur: Injured and at the end of his career
Eze: A luxury player and perhaps needs the function with him to justify his inclusion
Olise: not a central midfielder
Schlupp: not a central midfielder
Ayew: definitely not a central midfielder

It’s fair to say Luka’s inclusion in an XI is worrying but I think perhaps this is exacerbated by, and only worsens, a worrying situation. The ‘beef’ is probably far more to do with us not having resourced that area of the pitch effectively prior to this season starting and that chicken coming home to roost, exhibited painfully today.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

barrie2301 Flag crystal palace 22 Oct 22 9.59pm

For me this has been brewing for some time, PV's tactics are dodgy..

The lack of hunger in the semi final last year with the dodgy set up in tactics with Ward being put into RB over NC only then to have CK constantly moving across in front of JW to cover him even though Chelsea were just as s*** as us the first half.. He didnt even see that and try to adjust the plan..

Arsenal: The team still had the mentality they could beat them we started slow but the 2nd half was good we were all over them.

Liverpool: they go down to 10 men looking weak and he still continued to play the team deep and not go after the win

City: played deep went 2 up but continued to keep them very deep and not allow them to express themselves, tried to hold on for the draw. But its City so let that slide..

Brentford: All over them went 1 up. 67 mins in against a team we are in charge off and likely will get another goal. He switches RB over to LB, moves RB in RM brings on LB along with CM to try to see out the draw.. Tactical shambles..

Chelsea: 1-1 sits us deep and they score 90min

Leeds: felt like a battle

Leicester: shambolic lucky not to lose

Wolves: Ref makes dodgy calls, fans fired up, team get fired up and feel to prove something 2nd half.
Post match Wilf asked if the words of PV are ringing in his ears from half time, he replies no he doesn't get like that.

For me what's he bringing?
its a Dougie Freedman team with OR calling the tactics.
Thought he would be the one to get them going but he backs down every time..

Edited by barrie2301 (23 Oct 2022 12.35pm)

Edited by barrie2301 (23 Oct 2022 12.37pm)

 

NE14T Flag 22 Oct 22 10.03pm

No one here hates Milo. He’s been a great player and loyal servant. The frustration lies when we see Veira play him isolated at central midfield. Everyone knows that’s going to be disastrous and ripple through the team. At the very least he needed Hughes in support but for some reason Veira and that waste of space Roberts don’t see it.
Incredibly frustrating and this isn’t hindsight as we all shuddered when team and Milo position was announced.
If Veira has ambitions about managing Arsenal he’s utterly deluded as he’s proving tactically poor. His big + is attracting players but that doesn’t make a summer.

Roberts has got to stop being such a lame duck yes man and start helping Veira with better decisions.

Edited by NE14T (22 Oct 2022 10.04pm)

Edited by NE14T (22 Oct 2022 10.06pm)

 


The beatings will stop when morale improves.

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 22 Oct 22 10.39pm

Originally posted by sprites

I’m only defending him because to single him out today isn’t fair. Every player from 1-11 was woeful…yet it’s fashionable to single him out. Where’s the hate for Mitchell or Guehi (at fault for first) or Zaha or anyone else?

He’s an easy scape goat.

People aren't singling him out. Nobody has said that everybody else was decent because that clearly wasn't the case. But Luka has been consistently crap for quite some time now and is nowhere near good enough for Premiership football.

I've seen plenty of other players on this thread being criticised for their performance today.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Oct 22 10.48pm

Originally posted by Mathers

I wish people would stop defending Luka. The bloke is clearly not good enough and that is putting it mildly. He has been 5 yards off the pace for well over 2 years and offers zero to the team. It’s a f***ing disgrace our recruitment has resulted in a 1 man midfield. Absolutely no coincidence that the game he’s suspended for ends up in a thumping.

Hear Hear.

Milivojevic has performed with some aplomb but that was in bygone days in a different approach to the game, alas in my humble opinion he has now become a liability.

Edited by Willo (22 Oct 2022 10.51pm)

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 22 Oct 22 10.58pm

Having a go at Luka is just glossing over the real problems and it would be better if everyone focused on that rather than one player. As a squad player I believe he has a role until either his contract is up or he moves on before that. Vieira’s lack of playing a complete midfield with two or perhaps three midfielders who actually are midfielders is the problem not Luka!

 

palacefan4life Flag Croydon 22 Oct 22 11.22pm

Originally posted by Willo

Hear Hear.

Milivojevic has performed with some aplomb but that was in bygone days in a different approach to the game, alas in my humble opinion he has now become a liability.

Edited by Willo (22 Oct 2022 10.51pm)

This ^

 


Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 22 Oct 22 11.39pm

Viera, Either sack him or back him. A lot of this mess lays at the feet of the board & I don't want to hear that 'Palace can only afford to shop at Lidl's bollocks' we have two owners worth 5 Billion & 2 Billion.
Viera couldn't do anything at the MLS with NYCFC which has no promotion or relegation & with players like Lampard, Pirlo, (Midfielders) & David Villa so he isn't going to do much with what he has at Palace.

 


Pro USA & Israel

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 22 Oct 22 11.40pm

Maybe it's time for Parishto have a word with PV in the club car park.

 


Pro USA & Israel

palacefan4life Flag Croydon 22 Oct 22 11.40pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

Viera, Either sack him or back him. A lot of this mess lays at the feet of the board & I don't want to hear that 'Palace can only afford to shop at Lidl's bollocks' we have two owners worth 5 Billion & 2 Billion.
Viera couldn't do anything at the MLS with NYCFC which has no promotion or relegation & with players like Lampard, Pirlo, (Midfielders) & David Villa so he isn't going to do much with what he has at Palace.

Delete again.

 


dreamwaverider Flag London 22 Oct 22 11.43pm

Originally posted by Willo

Hear Hear.

Milivojevic has performed with some aplomb but that was in bygone days in a different approach to the game, alas in my humble opinion he has now become a liability.

Edited by Willo (22 Oct 2022 10.51pm)

How was dinner Willo?
Or did you really cancel?
Not a great day today. Awful in fact.

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 22 Oct 22 11.45pm

Originally posted by palacefan4life

Delete again.

So you're not keen on Viera being given the tools to compete?

 


Pro USA & Israel

palacefan4life Flag Croydon 22 Oct 22 11.50pm

We beat you just accept it.

 


Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 22 Oct 22 11.53pm

Originally posted by palacefan4life

We beat you just accept it.

Sorry fella, you've lost me there. Maybe lay off the sherbert & get to bed? Night,Night !!

 


Pro USA & Israel

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Oct 22 11.55pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

How was dinner Willo?
Or did you really cancel?
Not a great day today. Awful in fact.

Reservation was cancelled.
I was steaming akin to a cooked clam and was in no mood to honour my booking.
I was self-combusting and my dear wife decided to pay a visit to her chum as she had no desire to be in my company.
Awful performance, the players and management need to hang their heads in shame.

Edited by Willo (22 Oct 2022 11.59pm)

 

Rogers the legend Flag Auckland 23 Oct 22 1.01am

I'm convinced you cant have Eze, Zaha, Olise, Edouard and Ayew, all in the same team, not unless you are desperate and throwing caution to the wind to get a result.

The first three are great flair players and on their day turn a game on its head. Edouard is too light weight, cant seem to hold onto the ball, it just bounces off him. facing the goal fine, but with his back to the goal he is next to useless. Ayew is a bench player at best, fantastic work rate, unselfish, but doesn't seem to fit anywhere.
As everybody knows Doucoure is doing an outstanding job, but he cant hold things up alone, we need a similar working type player, with an engine (maybe with a bit more passing ability) helping him out. We don't have anybody in the first team who can fill that position (a young McArthur would be ideal but...)

Having flair players is great, but you need people around them feeding them the ball and doing the donkey work. PV must know this, after all he was the the player we now need. Come on PV either train a youngster up or someone in or I fear for the worst.

 


It's not the size of the dog in the fight, but the size of the fight in the dog.

Archie Griffen

Hating Brighton since 1974

Page 9 of 15 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Everton vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread