You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Views on PV
November 16 2026 3.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Views on PV


Page 9 of 17 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 13 Feb 23 11.46am

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

[Link]

Makes you wonder what they do in training ?

Top level professional footballers should be able control a ball and pass to own team surely ?

Just for my own amusement if nothing else CC - one of my fondest memories of what was an unhappy time in my youth was my uncles taking me to the Den at every available opportunity as an albeit futile attempt at conversion. One of them used to consistently, and constantly, scream the phrase 'What do you do all week?' at his own team when the simplest mistakes were made.

Still makes me laugh but I have always maintained that he had a point.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

taylors lovechild Flag 13 Feb 23 11.48am

I know it might seem unfair to put so much blame on one player but Mateta was terrible on Saturday. Brighton were always going to have more of the ball but the number of times good opportunities to break broke down due to his inability to control even a simple pass was staggering. Edouard came on but you could have been forgiven for not noticing such was his impact. Obviously we have no input, but I genuinely don't know what the answer is up top:

Mateta - can't control the ball, pass or head
Edouard - looks a bit lazy and disinterested
Ayew - carries no attacking threat

Personally against Brentford I would play Ayew up top but solely on the basis that at least he works hard and retains possession and is better with his back to goal. Mateta and Edouard's inability to hold the ball up and bring others into play is becoming a serious issue. Hopefully Lokonga and/or Ahamada can at least add a bit more dynamism to the midfield, while McArthur will bring some talking back to the pitch.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 13 Feb 23 11.58am

Originally posted by Willo

I have engaged in this debate outside of HOL and the view was expressed that nigh on £100 Mill has been spent on players on Vieira's 'Watch'.


Context Willo is everything. £100m over FOUR windows is not great in PL terms for clubs outside the big 6/7. Fulham spent that in one window on a previous occasion they came up and went straight down again.

Last summer (2022) alone:
- W Ham spent £160m (nett £147m)
- Forest £141m (nett £135m)
- Wolves £123m (nett £71m)

We had gone several years before then, as you well know, spending virtually nothing and allowing a mature squad to age to crisis point in Summer 2021 when we spent the grand total of £66m.

Our current 5 year nett spend places us 16th in the table of current PL members. Of those below us two (Bournemouth and Brentford) are clubs with only 2 or 3 years in the PL and the other two are clubs who are further along the development road than us, namely Leicester and Brigh...

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 13 Feb 23 12.02pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I know it might seem unfair to put so much blame on one player but Mateta was terrible on Saturday. Brighton were always going to have more of the ball but the number of times good opportunities to break broke down due to his inability to control even a simple pass was staggering. Edouard came on but you could have been forgiven for not noticing such was his impact. Obviously we have no input, but I genuinely don't know what the answer is up top:

Mateta - can't control the ball, pass or head
Edouard - looks a bit lazy and disinterested
Ayew - carries no attacking threat

Personally against Brentford I would play Ayew up top but solely on the basis that at least he works hard and retains possession and is better with his back to goal. Mateta and Edouard's inability to hold the ball up and bring others into play is becoming a serious issue. Hopefully Lokonga and/or Ahamada can at least add a bit more dynamism to the midfield, while McArthur will bring some talking back to the pitch.

Yep, you read that back and it's little wonder we've only scored 20 goals this season.

I agree, play Ayew up top. He will at least press, keep the ball and draw fouls. I'd consider playing Eze behind him, although he's hardly been setting the world on fire.

Hopefully Macca will stay fit and play a part and the new boys make a difference

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 13 Feb 23 12.06pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I know it might seem unfair to put so much blame on one player but Mateta was terrible on Saturday. Brighton were always going to have more of the ball but the number of times good opportunities to break broke down due to his inability to control even a simple pass was staggering. Edouard came on but you could have been forgiven for not noticing such was his impact. Obviously we have no input, but I genuinely don't know what the answer is up top:

Mateta - can't control the ball, pass or head
Edouard - looks a bit lazy and disinterested
Ayew - carries no attacking threat

Personally against Brentford I would play Ayew up top but solely on the basis that at least he works hard and retains possession and is better with his back to goal. Mateta and Edouard's inability to hold the ball up and bring others into play is becoming a serious issue. Hopefully Lokonga and/or Ahamada can at least add a bit more dynamism to the midfield, while McArthur will bring some talking back to the pitch.

I'm 'fanboying' some of your posts this morning TL and like this one again.

I honestly must of missed where the criticisms of Mateta came from previously so somewhat 'stood up' for him however he was beyond awful vs Brighton. At one point he actually knocked over Webster, completely outmuscling him, retained the ball and made some ground. ST holder next to me said 'why doesn't he do that more often' and I suggested I think he just lacks the coordination to physically achieve what he mentally intends the majority of the time.

Edouard I'd argue still looks lacking in confidence/assurance of his position more than disinterested to me. Still better than Mateta but I don't think Ayew is a bad shout at all. The only argument there is his lack of goals but in current company not an issue. He'd at least win/retain the ball more often and God forbid we might actually start building something constituting attacks from open play.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 13 Feb 23 12.11pm

Originally posted by doombear


Context Willo is everything. £100m over FOUR windows is not great in PL terms for clubs outside the big 6/7. Fulham spent that in one window on a previous occasion they came up and went straight down again.

Last summer (2022) alone:
- W Ham spent £160m (nett £147m)
- Forest £141m (nett £135m)
- Wolves £123m (nett £71m)

We had gone several years before then, as you well know, spending virtually nothing and allowing a mature squad to age to crisis point in Summer 2021 when we spent the grand total of £66m.

Our current 5 year nett spend places us 16th in the table of current PL members. Of those below us two (Bournemouth and Brentford) are clubs with only 2 or 3 years in the PL and the other two are clubs who are further along the development road than us, namely Leicester and Brigh...

I understand your comments, however the fact remains that the club have spent nigh on £100 Mill whilst Vieira has been at the helm so he has been supported in the transfer market.

Suffice to say that despite this expenditure there are still glaring deficiencies in the squad.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 13 Feb 23 12.34pm

Originally posted by doombear


Context Willo is everything. £100m over FOUR windows is not great in PL terms for clubs outside the big 6/7. Fulham spent that in one window on a previous occasion they came up and went straight down again.

Last summer (2022) alone:
- W Ham spent £160m (nett £147m)
- Forest £141m (nett £135m)
- Wolves £123m (nett £71m)

We had gone several years before then, as you well know, spending virtually nothing and allowing a mature squad to age to crisis point in Summer 2021 when we spent the grand total of £66m.

Our current 5 year nett spend places us 16th in the table of current PL members. Of those below us two (Bournemouth and Brentford) are clubs with only 2 or 3 years in the PL and the other two are clubs who are further along the development road than us, namely Leicester and Brigh...

No, we have spent 132.4M Euros since 4th July 2021, PVs 1st day, with 14 players in, at a deficit of 127.2m euros

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

taylors lovechild Flag 13 Feb 23 12.41pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Edouard I'd argue still looks lacking in confidence/assurance of his position more than disinterested to me. Still better than Mateta but I don't think Ayew is a bad shout at all. The only argument there is his lack of goals but in current company not an issue. He'd at least win/retain the ball more often and God forbid we might actually start building something constituting attacks from open play.

You may be right about Edouard, although towards the end of his time at Celtic their fans were also criticising him for being lazy (rightly or wrongly). Vieira keeps giving both Edouard and Mateta opportunities, but neither is making a compelling case. I actually said JPM should start against Brighton simply by virtue of his willingness to run around like a Spaniel, but his lack of ability really stuck out on Saturday and I'm on the verge of giving up on him (I think his effort means I forgive him more than others). I do think if his sole job was a goal poacher he'd be good as most of his shots are on target, but the way play means we need more than that as we create so few chances! I will also point out that despite advocating for Ayew to start up top the last time I suggested that Vieira duly obliged and he was rubbish

 

Skip Flag 13 Feb 23 12.41pm

I really can't see why Mateta was selected. Absolutely dreadful on Saturday. I imagine he was picked so Tomkins could go long if he needed to but he just doesn't win anything in the air. He didn't close anyone down and he ball control is Sunday league. He's supposed to be an footballer in top condition but looks so unfit. There were times where Dunk just walked out with the ball and had so much time.

That's three home draws on the trot. Credible on paper but in reality we got away with all three.

 

pssguy Flag 13 Feb 23 1.23pm

I don't feel Vieira has any connection to the club. There was absolutely no reaction from him when Tonkins scored against our bitter rivals. He just stood there with no hint of pleasure on his face
I reckon he thought after our and Arsenal's standings last year he might be in with a shot at the job back at his old club. That dream has gone and he has no passion, which a team of moderate resources needs from its manager and players

 

taylors lovechild Flag 13 Feb 23 1.37pm

Originally posted by pssguy

I don't feel Vieira has any connection to the club. There was absolutely no reaction from him when Tonkins scored against our bitter rivals. He just stood there with no hint of pleasure on his face
I reckon he thought after our and Arsenal's standings last year he might be in with a shot at the job back at his old club. That dream has gone and he has no passion, which a team of moderate resources needs from its manager and players

I think that's more a reflection of our performance. When we equalised against United he was punching the air and normally is quite animated when we score. He's not daft, celebrating wildly after a ridiculous mistake when we've been outplayed would have been a bit embarrassing. I think as someone else alluded to, we probably got the media post-match face, whereas the team may have gotten a different one. It's not like Pulis who always referred to the team and the club as if he wasn't part of it, never using we or us. God I disliked that man despite what he achieved for us in his short spell. Whether it was genuine or not I think Warnock was the king of making you think he really cared.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 13 Feb 23 1.46pm

Originally posted by pssguy

I don't feel Vieira has any connection to the club. There was absolutely no reaction from him when Tonkins scored against our bitter rivals. He just stood there with no hint of pleasure on his face
I reckon he thought after our and Arsenal's standings last year he might be in with a shot at the job back at his old club. That dream has gone and he has no passion, which a team of moderate resources needs from its manager and players

-.-'

 


Old, Ungifted and White

PatrickA Flag London 13 Feb 23 2.46pm

There is evidence that Vieira has changed tactics in recent games to try and introduce more solidity, although it has not been wholly successful in terms of producing better performances.
Hughes has started to feature more playing alongside Doucoure to try and be a bit more solid.
On Saturday we played a version of 442 with Ayew playing slightly behind Mateta trying to stop the deep Brighton midfield players commence moves.
In fact two tackles from Ayew led to the two half chances for Mateta .
Ayew as usual competed well without offering the cleverness on the ball necessary in the final third.
In my view if we stay up and Vieira continues in the role we will have to strengthen considerably for Vieira’s methods to work.
It would mean signing the likes of AWB, Gallagher and a speedy powerful forward.

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 13 Feb 23 2.48pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I think that's more a reflection of our performance. When we equalised against United he was punching the air and normally is quite animated when we score. He's not daft, celebrating wildly after a ridiculous mistake when we've been outplayed would have been a bit embarrassing. I think as someone else alluded to, we probably got the media post-match face, whereas the team may have gotten a different one. It's not like Pulis who always referred to the team and the club as if he wasn't part of it, never using we or us. God I disliked that man despite what he achieved for us in his short spell. Whether it was genuine or not I think Warnock was the king of making you think he really cared.

pretty much spot on.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 13 Feb 23 3.11pm

'NewsShopper' headlines with Vieira building an exciting young team.
Dear oh dear.

I would get greater excitement from watching a protracted game of Chess than I do watching the dirge on display.

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 13 Feb 23 3.14pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

I Realy don't understand d what's going on rhe moment. In the transfer window I felt we needed a battered old war horse, to play along side our promising young midfielders. We have no leader on the pitch. But we loan 2 youngsters. As far as the playing style. We used to defend deep and counter attack with paste. Now we defend deep and counter attack slowly. The moveme t in the side is non existent, we must be a joy to play against. I think we are very lucky to still be in 12th place, but cant see us staying there long. Still, could be worse, we could support Liverpool....

We obviously ran out of paste. Typical of how badly the club is run to not get enough in the first place. Hummmphh

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

Uphill Flag Bedford 13 Feb 23 3.14pm

We are in the middle of a long series of testing fixtures with another five tough ones to come.

I fear that unless PV can start motivating the team we could well be much nearer the relegation zone come a month from now.

If that proves to be the case the manager's position will begin to look very uncomfortable and it is not encouraging that our stats for distance covered by players is the worst in the PL suggesting we need another Derry to start cracking the whip.

Perhaps PV is 'too nice' but at the moment he is repeating the 'second season decline' he suffered with all his previous clubs and his demise may be inevitable.

 


Man and boy Palace since my first game in 1948 sitting on my dad's shoulders

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 13 Feb 23 4.11pm

Originally posted by Uphill

We are in the middle of a long series of testing fixtures with another five tough ones to come.

I fear that unless PV can start motivating the team we could well be much nearer the relegation zone come a month from now.

If that proves to be the case the manager's position will begin to look very uncomfortable and it is not encouraging that our stats for distance covered by players is the worst in the PL suggesting we need another Derry to start cracking the whip.

Perhaps PV is 'too nice' but at the moment he is repeating the 'second season decline' he suffered with all his previous clubs and his demise may be inevitable.


??
His first season with Nice saw them improve one place to 7th and the second season saw them move up to 5th (I think it was). He was sacked in the December of the third season after a poor run of results, since when the club has sacked THREE further managers (Including Lucien Favre after his second stint) and are on an interim (4th) manager - which IMO says more about Nice than about Vieira.

Having said that, I reserve my position regarding his performance at Palace until the end of the season. IMO the club are unlikely to sack him UNLESS we fail to win any of the last 10 games (8 of which are against teams currently below us) a scenario that would inevitably lead to relegation. I don't believe it will come to that, though.

 

pssguy Flag 13 Feb 23 4.29pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild


He's not daft, celebrating wildly after a ridiculous mistake when we've been outplayed would have been a bit embarrassing.cared.


Well Tomkins and the rest of team (sans Olise of course) seemed pretty pumped. How do you think they feel when they see their boss with a "Who gives a f***'" look on his face.
Not expecting him to do an Arteta but a fist pump at least.
I could understand if it was a consolation goal at 5-0 down but that might be the point that keeps us up

 

hammer7 Flag London 13 Feb 23 6.49pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I think that's more a reflection of our performance. When we equalised against United he was punching the air and normally is quite animated when we score. He's not daft, celebrating wildly after a ridiculous mistake when we've been outplayed would have been a bit embarrassing. I think as someone else alluded to, we probably got the media post-match face, whereas the team may have gotten a different one. It's not like Pulis who always referred to the team and the club as if he wasn't part of it, never using we or us. God I disliked that man despite what he achieved for us in his short spell. Whether it was genuine or not I think Warnock was the king of making you think he really cared.

Couldn't agree more. I don't think you can assess a manager's passion for their club by how they celebrate or don't on the touchline. I think he's been dedicated to the club throughout his tenure, but it's also just natural that managers will come and go.

 

Page 9 of 17 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Views on PV