You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Burnley v Palace match thread
November 22 2026 12.10pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Burnley v Palace match thread


Page 9 of 11 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Red Al Flag Reading 05 Nov 23 6.20pm

The job yesterday was to get the win. Burnley were desperate to get their first home win and climb out of the relegation zone. They were always going to give it their best shot against a Palace team without its creative players.

Palace made sure they got the win so job done. They did it by scoring two excellent goals as well. Ayew’s persistence to win the ball & cross for Schlupp to knock in was commendable. And Eze’s calm pass into the path of Mitchell (though I don’t think it was meant for him) for the second goal was sublime. It reminded of Pele’s pass for Jairzinho in the 1970 World Cup final…

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 05 Nov 23 6.23pm

Originally posted by Red Al

The job yesterday was to get the win. Burnley were desperate to get their first home win and climb out of the relegation zone. They were always going to give it their best shot against a Palace team without its creative players.

Palace made sure they got the win so job done. They did it by scoring two excellent goals as well. Ayew’s persistence to win the ball & cross for Schlupp to knock in was commendable. And Eze’s calm pass into the path of Mitchell (though I don’t think it was meant for him) for the second goal was sublime. It reminded of Pele’s pass for Jairzinho in the 1970 World Cup final…

I always did say that Eze is a certainty for the Ballon D'or...

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 05 Nov 23 6.56pm

Also at Brentford re Ward.
Maybe Ferguson was the hope to come in, but that boat has now sailed.
We definitely need a new RB in January. In the meantime Schluppie can play there. Richards?
Yesterday was very clear that this is the wrong level for Ward. The pace beats him all the time now.

 

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 05 Nov 23 7.03pm

Originally posted by ripleyeagle

Can you explain how Brentford a smaller club than us does not have this inferiority complex and expects to take on and beat the top clubs and regularly does. They have beaten Chelsea three times in a row away from home also this time without Toney, why can’t we aspire to be more like them as they are playIng attractive football and getting results too..There scouting system is light years better than ours, in my opinion if we improve in that department we can also be more competitive in this league on similar resources.

how many times have we turned over the top teams , Man city took 233mins to score against us , see were brentford are in 10 years they have had 2 seasons , Bournemonth started of with no fears then one to many players sold , back to the championship they went , and looks like there going that way again , so to say there light years ahead of us you need to look at the big picture not a tiny window

 

Painter Flag Croydon 05 Nov 23 7.27pm

Originally posted by adelaar

Credit due there on those ones. However they also bought Riedewald, Marange, Sorloth, Mutch, Mandanda and many other deadwood players. We also paid significantly for those, except Johnstone as he was initially just back up for Guaita.
They're supposed to be finding the gems like Koloeosho (2.6m) plus any Brighton player you want to pick under 6m.
Also the same scouting department that thought we should spend 20m on a goalkeeper when a decent right back like Timothy Castagne was available for 17m.

Marange how far do you want to go back? Every club has transfers that dont work out, even your beloved Brighton.
Try looking at positives, rather than dwelling on negatives, as your arent going to change anything.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 05 Nov 23 8.31pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I believe yesterday was possibly one of the first times (if not the first) that Ward was taken off as a tactical substitution by Roy.
He was struggling against the winger and despite his good positioning and physical strength he can’t deal with raw pace or clever footwork.
I think this could be his last season at first team level, but he has been a brilliant player for the club.
Richards has featured in a couple of cameos as a full back and hasn’t impressed being all at sea positionally.
It might be something he could learn, but you wouldn’t want him exposed at Premier League level.
He’s athletic, competitive and decent in the air and I like him as a player but only as a centre back where he can best display his attributes.

Don't disagree but ward back from injury and given his age returning to full match fit takes longer.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 05 Nov 23 8.39pm

Originally posted by pssguy

We all know they should have bought a right back in the summer but we are where we are. Ward has been up against two very fast wingers. Gordon and Amdouni, in the latest games and the latter went off soon after Ward so Clyne got a break. It is McNeil at Evrton next week who is a very different type of winger whom Ward should match up better against

I don't know if Doucoure was a tactical sub - he hadn't been booked - but it was odd to see last year's POTY giving way for Eze rather than the inffective Hughes. We may find out that he and Edouard had picked up the prevalent hamstring injuries at the club

Eze had to come on.

Somebody had to come off.

Burnley were knocking at the door but Roy must have judged them to be of little effect.

Lerma and Hughes could hold the middle.

He was right.

 

Vectis Flag 05 Nov 23 8.39pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


FDB was never given a proper chance not a good example to use.

Pardew got us to a cup final something we had not achieved in a very long time and you could say it was with Championship level players.

Roy took one of those teams down so did Sam.

People are looking at how we played towards the end of last season and enjoyed it so why cant we play like that now again these teams that are at bottom of the league not the boring stuff which is why so many wanted Roy gone before.

Football is suppose to be entertaining

Out of interest would you be happy if Palace next season chose to go with Sam or Pullis?

As both are out of circulation and officially retired (I acknowledge so was Roy) it’s probably a moot question. However I would be happy with a manager that has a successful record of managing in the Premier or a top European league, can command the respect of the players and can get them well organised, disciplined and capable of consistently winning games. If that isn’t in a free-flowing style of football I can happily live with that.

Should such a manager get the team into the Champions League but some find the style of play boring, then really I don’t mind. Much better than plummeting down to the Championship or worse while attempting to play like peak Brazil as a number of teams have previously done and arguably as Palace did under Big Mal who laudably tried to play the game ‘the right way’. That was a painful personal experience. The continual expectation and crushing disappointment week after week was far worse than grinding out a dull 2-0 away win like yesterday. Unless you have a squad of superstars/‘Galacticos’ like Man City, Barcelona et al it appears extremely difficult to make it work and win enough points to succeed, so thus why we have someone like Roy running things

 

EddieMac Flag 05 Nov 23 9.44pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Well, the way I saw it, we looked like an experienced Premier League team playing against a willing and enthusiastic newcomer lacking in quality.

Burnley are consistently making mistakes at the back. So it was no surprise that they conceded two cheap goals. They also struggle to turn possession into goals. I think our gameplan was to pick them off and win the match which we duly did. Burnley could certainly not be considered unlucky, just not good enough.

Palace will probably play better in other games and lose. But yesterday did enough to get the points.

While it's true that the team have reverted back to a more pragmatic style, you can't expect to lose Olise, Zaha and Eze without there being an impact.

Exactly how I saw it. We were in cruise control for most of the game. Not our best performance by any stretch but even without having much of the ball you could see the gulf in class.

 

pssguy Flag 05 Nov 23 9.56pm


In spite of the gripes, Hodgson does deserve some credit. The 15 points after 11 games is only one fewer than our best ever at this stage. Interestingly, our worst has been 4 points (twice) but on both these occasions we recovered to finish the season in 11th spot.

We already have three away wins in which the opponents have failed to score. That is better than the team has achieved in any of the most recent four full seasons and just one off the record for a year

Looking at the expected GF vs expected GA, this game was just the third when we have a better expected goals than our opponents - and only marginally in this case (1.3 v 1.1). The only two games where we were significantly better than the opposition were the wins against Sheffield United and Wolves and we could probably expect to have been on 11 or 12 points. Everton, next up, would be on around 18 if they could put the ball in the net

 

Glazier#1 Flag 05 Nov 23 10.42pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Well, the way I saw it, we looked like an experienced Premier League team playing against a willing and enthusiastic newcomer lacking in quality.

Burnley are consistently making mistakes at the back. So it was no surprise that they conceded two cheap goals. They also struggle to turn possession into goals. I think our game plan was to pick them off and win the match which we duly did. Burnley could certainly not be considered unlucky, just not good enough.

Palace will probably play better in other games and lose. But yesterday did enough to get the points.

While it's true that the team have reverted back to a more pragmatic style, you can't expect to lose Olise, Zaha and Eze without there being an impact.

Agree with all of this, Neillo. Good post, mate.

We out-noused them, didn't we. Another three points: well nice.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 05 Nov 23 11.03pm

Originally posted by Red Al

The job yesterday was to get the win. Burnley were desperate to get their first home win and climb out of the relegation zone. They were always going to give it their best shot against a Palace team without its creative players.

Palace made sure they got the win so job done. They did it by scoring two excellent goals as well. Ayew’s persistence to win the ball & cross for Schlupp to knock in was commendable. And Eze’s calm pass into the path of Mitchell (though I don’t think it was meant for him) for the second goal was sublime. It reminded of Pele’s pass for Jairzinho in the 1970 World Cup final…

Yes, nice comparison: perfectly weighted and saying "Hit me!"

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 06 Nov 23 6.51am

Reading the negative comments on the performance takes my back to the last game FDB was in charge. We played away to Burnley totally dominated the game created the most chances played great football but lost. I felt Saturday's performance was controlled and at no stage did we have to come out of our initial defensive shape to go and try and force the game and try and score. The only change in terms of shape was when we brought on Richards to play 3 centre backs and push up the full backs to restrict the room for their wide players. This snuffed out any remaining threat and got Mitchell forward to secure the 3 points.
Think we are in a good position now to kick on with Eze and hopefully Olise coming back to full fitness.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 06 Nov 23 8.35am

The big question is whether we'll continue to play like that once Olise and Eze are both fit and starting again. If we do then I'll be at the front of the queue complaining, but as it is we have very little to offer going forward without them and the three points was necessary to put further space between us and the bottom three.

Aside from a relatively solid defensive display I thought Ahamada provided some real energy when when he came on.

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 06 Nov 23 8.38am

Please do not forget to take into account when considering Palace's expected goals statistics, that we have Edouard and Mateta up front. Expectations should be adjusted accordingly.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Nov 23 9.01am

Originally posted by viveasheagle

Reading the negative comments on the performance takes my back to the last game FDB was in charge. We played away to Burnley totally dominated the game created the most chances played great football but lost. I felt Saturday's performance was controlled and at no stage did we have to come out of our initial defensive shape to go and try and force the game and try and score. The only change in terms of shape was when we brought on Richards to play 3 centre backs and push up the full backs to restrict the room for their wide players. This snuffed out any remaining threat and got Mitchell forward to secure the 3 points.
Think we are in a good position now to kick on with Eze and hopefully Olise coming back to full fitness.

Given the outpouring of joy on the sidelines after Mitchell scored it would appear that Mr Hodgson was 'Tickled pink' that his change of shape worked.

Edited by Willo (06 Nov 2023 9.12am)

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 06 Nov 23 9.28am

I've thought that 3 at the back could be a viable alternative if necessary. Good to see Mitchell venturing forward rather than staying behind the halfway line. Which leads me to an oft repeated refrain from myself: if Parish genuinely wants to fill his shiny new stand and welcome 34000 fans, he ought to see to it that the team offers a bit more entertainment value to sitting deep, offering 65% possession to the opposition. I venture that fans want to see Palace players on the ball, not the other way round.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 06 Nov 23 9.41am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I've thought that 3 at the back could be a viable alternative if necessary. Good to see Mitchell venturing forward rather than staying behind the halfway line. Which leads me to an oft repeated refrain from myself: if Parish genuinely wants to fill his shiny new stand and welcome 34000 fans, he ought to see to it that the team offers a bit more entertainment value to sitting deep, offering 65% possession to the opposition. I venture that fans want to see Palace players on the ball, not the other way round.

I would venture that Palace fans want to see their team win. If that means having less possession than the opposition but being more effective with it, I for one am happy with that.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Nov 23 9.44am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I would venture that Palace fans want to see their team win. If that means having less possession than the opposition but being more effective with it, I for one am happy with that.

I for one am 'Wedded to' this viewpoint.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 06 Nov 23 9.45am

Originally posted by Willo

Given the outpouring of joy on the sidelines after Mitchell scored it would appear that Mr Hodgson was 'Tickled pink' that his change of shape worked.

Edited by Willo (06 Nov 2023 9.12am)

Without meaning to be patronising to our manager it's nice to see such enjoyment from someone who's been involved in the game for his whole life and Roy seems to radiate joy in our achievements rather than any kind of triumphalism over the opponents.

 

Page 9 of 11 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Burnley v Palace match thread