This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Agreed with Marco and Sophie. I think it shows how much we've changed as a nation - and bitching about it on here won't do a lot!
FFS MURRAY |
|
|
Well, without wishing to reopen the entire debate, I have been doing some reading on the subject of Ancient Britain, and have found a very interesting section of the BBC website entitled "Peoples of Britain, By Dr Simon James". He seems to agree with Pete that there has been a continuity of "British" population, that the gene pool hasn't shifted greatly and that after the Romans left, life went back to traditional patterns. But also I believe he backs up the thrust of my argument, that there was no unified pre-Roman British culture and that the 'Celts' weren't the united group he sugested. Here are some quotes from the site: "Substantial genetic continuity of population does not preclude profound shifts in culture and identity. It is actually quite common to observe important cultural change, including adoption of wholly new identities, with little or no biological change to a population. Millions of people since Roman times have thought of themselves as 'British', for example, yet this identity was only created in 1707 with the Union of England, Wales and Scotland." "Before Roman times 'Britain' was just a geographical entity, and had no political meaning, and no single cultural identity. Arguably this remained generally true until the 17th century, when James I of England sought to establish a pan-British monarchy." "Throughout recorded history the island has consisted of multiple cultural groups and identities. Many of these groupings looked outwards, across the seas, for their closest connections - they did not necessarily connect naturally with their fellow islanders, many of whom were harder to reach than maritime neighbours in Ireland or continental Europe." "From an early stage, the constraints and opportunities of the varied environments of the islands of Britain encouraged a great regional diversity of culture. Throughout prehistory there were myriad small-scale societies, and many petty 'tribal' identities, typically lasting perhaps no more than a few generations before splitting, merging or becoming obliterated. These groups were in contact and conflict with their neighbours, and sometimes with more distant groups - the appearance of exotic imported objects attest exchanges, alliance and kinship links, and wars." "However, there is one thing that the Romans, modern archaeologists and the Iron Age islanders themselves would all agree on: they were not Celts. This was an invention of the 18th century; the name was not used earlier" "...island 'Celtic' identity was born, like Britishness, in the 18th century." "anyway, no one knows how or when the languages that we choose to call 'Celtic', arrived in the archipelago - they were already long established and had diversified into several tongues." "Archaeologists widely agree on two things about the British Iron Age: its many regional cultures grew out of the preceding local Bronze Age, and did not derive from waves of continental 'Celtic' invaders. And secondly, calling the British Iron Age 'Celtic' is so misleading that it is best abandoned. Of course, there are important cultural similarities and connections between Britain, Ireland and continental Europe, reflecting intimate contacts and undoubtedly the movement of some people, but the same could be said for many other periods of history. " "...the continuous development of a shifting mosaic of societies..." "Contrary to the traditional idea that Britain originally possessed a 'Celtic' uniformity, which first Roman, then Saxon and other invaders disrupted, in reality Britain has always been home to multiple peoples. While its population has shown strong biological continuity over millennia, the identities the islanders have chosen to adopt have undergone some remarkable changes. Many of these have been due to contacts and conflicts across the seas, not least as the result of episodic, but often very modest, arrivals of newcomers." Here's a link to the site: [Link] And this is Dr Simon James' homepage, which also has further detailed information and links on the subject: [Link] Such as this: [Link]
"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down" |
|
|
I wondered howlong it would be before you pulled that chesnut out of the bag Seth, do me a favour will you, now you are clutching at straws if you are using that to dictate the argument.
As for Romans, they were made up of people from all over the Roman Empire, including large parts of North Africa and Asia [Link] There are many documented cases of dark-skinned people coming to these shores centuries before the last 50-100 years you state. "Black and Asian presence in the North East of England can be traced back to Septimius Severus, a North African Libyan, who ruled England as Roman Emperor between 193-211 AD." [Link] Edited by Seth (06 Jan 2005 11:41pm) Edited by Seth (06 Jan 2005 11:46pm)
My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs |
|
|
Quote reborn at 11 Jan 2005 2:03pm
I wondered howlong it would be before you pulled that chesnut out of the bag Seth, do me a favour will you, now you are clutching at straws if you are using that to dictate the argument.
As for Romans, they were made up of people from all over the Roman Empire, including large parts of North Africa and Asia [Link] There are many documented cases of dark-skinned people coming to these shores centuries before the last 50-100 years you state. "Black and Asian presence in the North East of England can be traced back to Septimius Severus, a North African Libyan, who ruled England as Roman Emperor between 193-211 AD." [Link] Edited by Seth (06 Jan 2005 11:41pm) Edited by Seth (06 Jan 2005 11:46pm)
Anyway, if you had read the many pages of debate between Pete & I, you'd have seen that the argument had moved on from there to a discussion of ancient British culture, which I have been doing some more research on, as my post above demonstrates. Do you have any references to dispute any of this? Can you tell me your theory of human evolution, if the "Out of Africa" theory is wrong, as you imply? Edited by Seth (11 Jan 2005 2:31pm)
"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down" |
|
|
On the contrary Seth I was not disputing this point as it is I believe irrefutable. Rather highlighting the fact that I expected you to bring it up as those of your particular political leanings generally do. Quote Seth at 11 Jan 2005 2:10pm
Quote reborn at 11 Jan 2005 2:03pm
I wondered howlong it would be before you pulled that chesnut out of the bag Seth, do me a favour will you, now you are clutching at straws if you are using that to dictate the argument.
As for Romans, they were made up of people from all over the Roman Empire, including large parts of North Africa and Asia [Link] There are many documented cases of dark-skinned people coming to these shores centuries before the last 50-100 years you state. "Black and Asian presence in the North East of England can be traced back to Septimius Severus, a North African Libyan, who ruled England as Roman Emperor between 193-211 AD." [Link] Edited by Seth (06 Jan 2005 11:41pm) Edited by Seth (06 Jan 2005 11:46pm)
Anyway, if you had read the many pages of debate between Pete & I you'd have seen that the argument had moved on from there to a discussion of ancient British culture, which I have been doing some more research on, as my post above demonstrates. Do you have any references to dispute any of this? Can you tell me your theory of human evolution, if the "Out of Africa" theory is wrong, as you imply? Edited by Seth (11 Jan 2005 2:11pm)
My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs |
|
|
Seth, in the field of ancient history, there are complete movements of belief that all completely conflict with each other. The people behind these movements have all the same credentials and letters after their names and all claim to be the leading light of their field, but in truth, you will never find ALL the answers in any ONE movement or any ONE so-called 'expert'. Most of these 'experts' come from the 'Oxbridge' school of half-truth, lies and bulls***. British history was re-written by the German Hanoverians and their ruling class of the day in order to make their (foreign) rule more acceptable to the British people and 'Oxbridge’ has been towing their line ever since. The Hanoverians invented the pro-Saxon myth that the Celts were a rabble of barbarians undeserving of such land as the island of Britain, so giving credence to the German Saxon subjugation of Celtic culture and life. The Oxbridge version of British history is extremely flawed and consequently so is the theoretical argument of the majority of 'leading lights' who’re churned from Oxbridge's bowels. Like politics, you have to read a ton of the stuff before you can even begin to form your own ideas and opinions on what you believe to be most likely the truth, you have to question stuff and take nothing as gospel. You cannot take one person (this Dr Simon Oojamaflip of the BBC and formerly Oxbridge no doubt), quote sections of his theory and stand behind that as 'the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.' History by it's very nature is political. It's written by the victors and is far from being an exact science. Over the course of two thousand years truth and fact has become extremely blurred, and until the arrogant Oxbridge elite have the guts to stand up and admit that much of what they’ve been preaching, is at best extremely flawed and almost certainly wrong, then the truth will continue to be ignored. Check out the work of Alan Wilson and Baram Blackett if you really want to begin to understand just how much of our taught history is wrong, these chaps throw the entire history of Britain on it's arse and I place a lot of stock in what they claim to be the truth. Archaeological fact: All Celtic remains found in all regions of Britain and Gaul point to the fact that in an age when mankind was slight in stature, the Celts were very tall, whatever their tribal group! Wherever you roamed in so-called Dark-Age Britain, life - and the people themselves - would have looked pretty much the same everywhere. Edited by Petealiator (11 Jan 2005 4:18pm)
My Rocksteady band... |
|
|
Quote jcreedy at 11 Jan 2005 4:20pm
This thread should have died ages ago. Surely the best thing to do is forget it now? Who gives a toss what names are in Britain's top 20?? Me.... Mine's 13th in the list - WAHOO
Twitter! [Tweet Link]
Justin Bieber: the singing amoeba |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.