This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
John Major weighing in today:- John Major has launched a scathing attack on Boris Johnson’s handling of Brexit, saying his administration agreed to the Northern Ireland protocol despite knowing it was unworkable. “That must be the first agreement in history that was signed by people who decided it was useless in the first place,” Major told a Westminster committee on Tuesday. The former Conservative prime minister did not name his successor but expressed astonishment at the acceptance of the protocol, which Johnson used to promote an “oven-ready” Brexit deal in the 2019 election. He said Britain’s exit from the EU was a “colossal mistake” that had left the UK outside the world’s main three power blocs. “There is America, there is China and there is the European Union. We should be in Europe.” To think that the country could be so misled and in particular, that the leader of the opposition actually whipped his MPs to support it !!!! Confirming that leaving was a great idea. I just had a look outside and the sky still isn't falling.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
John Major weighing in today:- John Major has launched a scathing attack on Boris Johnson’s handling of Brexit, saying his administration agreed to the Northern Ireland protocol despite knowing it was unworkable. “That must be the first agreement in history that was signed by people who decided it was useless in the first place,” Major told a Westminster committee on Tuesday. The former Conservative prime minister did not name his successor but expressed astonishment at the acceptance of the protocol, which Johnson used to promote an “oven-ready” Brexit deal in the 2019 election. He said Britain’s exit from the EU was a “colossal mistake” that had left the UK outside the world’s main three power blocs. “There is America, there is China and there is the European Union. We should be in Europe.” To think that the country could be so misled and in particular, that the leader of the opposition actually whipped his MPs to support it !!!! What weight does John Major have to weigh in with.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
If I have to concede a single point about Brexit, it will never be about the opportunities Brexit has offered the UK but rather the inherent lack of willingness of our political/institutional elites to make a success of it. I foolishly/naively expected, once Leave had won, to see the very people tasked with making it a success knuckle down and do so but that has patently failed to happen. Simply put, the very establishment forces that campaigned so hard to keep us inside it have conspired to effectively push us back in. Corporate interests, financial interests, political interests, all of them, for a variety of reasons (some of which are not actually even in the EU's interest), will effectively push us back into it within the next 10 years. The time scale I envisage is this. Starmer wins election based on a solid promise that he will not take us back in. Then, come the first Labour Party conference, a motion will be passed that instructs Labour to order a second referendum. Starmer will then throw his hands up in the air and proclaim that because he is such a stalwart of democracy, he has no choice. And there will be no viable Leave option on the table. Instead we will be given some kind of choice between a ludicrous new deal with the EU or being back inside it. Then choices have to be made. Is this a hill worth staking everything on? And it is now, in my opinion, inevitable for all kinds of reasons
If Starmer had not acted so foolishly in ordering his party to back the tory deal, which we know as a total con, he would be able to appeal to the voters and rejoin/re-negotiate. As it is, his 'we will make brexit work', nobody believes that. Offer it in an election manifesto, not a referendum everybody is sick of them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
If Starmer had not acted so foolishly in ordering his party to back the tory deal, which we know as a total con, he would be able to appeal to the voters and rejoin/re-negotiate. As it is, his 'we will make brexit work', nobody believes that. Offer it in an election manifesto, not a referendum everybody is sick of them. Offering it in the election manifesto would be the honourable thing to do, I concede. But he won't. It will be effectively hoisted on to us. And a second referendum will be offered on the back of a new 'deal' v Rejoin. Suspect there will be a boycott of it but it will not matter. Even a win for 'Rejoin' at less than 17.2 million votes will not matter because they can say that we did leave, as was promised. And then that is it. I genuinely held out hopes that Farage would re-enter the fray and lead 'Reform', which is not polling that badly, but it looks like he is sitting it out from now on. I genuinely cannot see anybody capable of leading a serious campaign to keep us out and the supposed new deal we will be offer will actually made it more sensible to be back on the inside. Which is the point of it. You lot get to win. The 'Last Man', as a mad old Kraut once waxed lyrical about, will triumph.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Confirming that leaving was a great idea. I just had a look outside and the sky still isn't falling. Ireland is still in the EU, and the sky is looking ominous
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
Ireland is still in the EU, and the sky is looking ominous
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
there are coachloads of unvetted Military-age men arriving into towns in the dead of night. Bussed into emergency make-shift accommodation. And all the locals in the towns & villages have started marching to as questions of our EU puppet Government. Rape statistics off the richter scale. Gay men in Sligo getting murdered. Possibility of new Anti-Semitism attacks...Governmental decisions made with zero popular support. And a militaristic attempt to dismantle our military Neutrality......Sinn Fein opposition are also AntiSemitic and March up and down in Uniforms . And our Political Elites are calling concerned citizens 'Hard Right Fanatics ?
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
there are coachloads of unvetted Military-age men arriving into towns in the dead of night. Bussed into emergency make-shift accommodation. And all the locals in the towns & villages have started marching to ask questions of our EU puppet Government. Rape statistics off the richter scale. Gay men in Sligo getting murdered. Possibility of new Anti-Semitism attacks...Governmental decisions made with zero popular support. And a militaristic attempt to dismantle our military Neutrality......Sinn Fein opposition are also AntiSemitic and March up and down in Uniforms . They tell us these economic migrants are Ukranian women & children. Yeah, and Brighton is a town in the Orkneys. And our Political Elites are calling concerned citizens 'Hard Right Fanatics ? Edited by PalazioVecchio (08 Feb 2023 9.19am)
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
But how do they get into Ireland? Are they flown in by the EU? you had better ask our Prime Minister, he might answer you when he is not being videod snogging the head off some bloke in a nightclub ( to the detriment of his husband ). Edited by PalazioVecchio (08 Feb 2023 10.11am)
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
you had better ask our Prime Minister, he might answer you when he is not being videod snogging the head off some bloke in a nightclub ( to the detriment of his husband ). Edited by PalazioVecchio (08 Feb 2023 10.11am) Wasn't he defended by the same people who also criticised Matt Hancock for the same? Apparently if you are a gay politician stepping out on your partner it's nobodies business and is homophobic to criticise but if you are a Tory minister .... Edited by Badger11 (08 Feb 2023 10.17am)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
there are coachloads of unvetted Military-age men arriving into towns in the dead of night. Bussed into emergency make-shift accommodation. And all the locals in the towns & villages have started marching to ask questions of our EU puppet Government. Rape statistics off the richter scale. Gay men in Sligo getting murdered. Possibility of new Anti-Semitism attacks...Governmental decisions made with zero popular support. And a militaristic attempt to dismantle our military Neutrality......Sinn Fein opposition are also AntiSemitic and March up and down in Uniforms . They tell us these economic migrants are Ukranian women & children. Yeah, and Brighton is a town in the Orkneys. And our Political Elites are calling concerned citizens 'Hard Right Fanatics ? Edited by PalazioVecchio (08 Feb 2023 9.19am) Sounds more like Everton than the EU.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Wasn't he defended by the same people who also criticised Matt Hancock for the same? Apparently if you are a gay politician stepping out on your partner it's nobodies business and is homophobic to criticise but if you are a Tory minister .... Edited by Badger11 (08 Feb 2023 10.17am) Can you point to one person making that point?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Offering it in the election manifesto would be the honourable thing to do, I concede. But he won't. It will be effectively hoisted on to us. And a second referendum will be offered on the back of a new 'deal' v Rejoin. Suspect there will be a boycott of it but it will not matter. Even a win for 'Rejoin' at less than 17.2 million votes will not matter because they can say that we did leave, as was promised. And then that is it. I genuinely held out hopes that Farage would re-enter the fray and lead 'Reform', which is not polling that badly, but it looks like he is sitting it out from now on. I genuinely cannot see anybody capable of leading a serious campaign to keep us out and the supposed new deal we will be offer will actually made it more sensible to be back on the inside. Which is the point of it. You lot get to win. The 'Last Man', as a mad old Kraut once waxed lyrical about, will triumph.
If a second referendum shows majority support for membership, what would be the issue with that? Democracy is a not a one-off snapshot - if opinion has changed, surely the state should act accordingly? We obviously differ in views on Brexit significantly so not too interesting in re-hashing that, but principally I don't understand your issue with the above
|
|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
We had a referendum and we voted to leave. But if the majority of the country now want to join, how is that democratic? (call this a hypothetical, I really don't want to debate whether people do or don't) Do we stick with it indefinitely? When would you consider reasonable to allow people to have a say again, given the EU being 'undemocratic' was one of the pillars of the Vote Leave campaign? Broadly, a situation where you don't put something to a vote because you don't like what the outcome would be does not feel a great precedent.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
But if the majority of the country now want to join, how is that democratic? (call this a hypothetical, I really don't want to debate whether people do or don't) Do we stick with it indefinitely? When would you consider reasonable to allow people to have a say again, given the EU being 'undemocratic' was one of the pillars of the Vote Leave campaign? Broadly, a situation where you don't put something to a vote because you don't like what the outcome would be does not feel a great precedent. If a party stand in a GE on a manifesto pledge of either a referendum or just taking us back in, then I have no issue with that. My fear, and I concede a certain level here of paranoia around Starmer (and Sunak) is that I harbour a fear that Starmer will not do so openly. He will win a GE based on proclaiming he will not revisit the Brexit question and then, possibly via the mechanism by which he effectively forced Labour's hand on a second referendum during their conference in November 2018, proclaim himself bound by similar again. I think he is the most underhand and pernicious politician in modern British politics (which is saying something) and a fully paid-up Washington stooge (as I believe Sunak to be as well). And more than capable of pulling this kind of stunt. But what is clear, from the painful lack of genuine progress in terms of making Brexit the success I believe it can/could be, is that our entire establishment are effectively looking to stall any kind of meaningful moves by way of keeping up poised for rejoining. Be it remaining in the ECHR to stalling the whole scale ditching of EU legislation then they are doing their desperate best to keep us tied to Europe politically and legally.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
If a party stand in a GE on a manifesto pledge of either a referendum or just taking us back in, then I have no issue with that. My fear, and I concede a certain level here of paranoia around Starmer (and Sunak) is that I harbour a fear that Starmer will not do so openly. He will win a GE based on proclaiming he will not revisit the Brexit question and then, possibly via the mechanism by which he effectively forced Labour's hand on a second referendum during their conference in November 2018, proclaim himself bound by similar again. I think he is the most underhand and pernicious politician in modern British politics (which is saying something) and a fully paid-up Washington stooge (as I believe Sunak to be as well). And more than capable of pulling this kind of stunt. But what is clear, from the painful lack of genuine progress in terms of making Brexit the success I believe it can/could be, is that our entire establishment are effectively looking to stall any kind of meaningful moves by way of keeping up poised for rejoining. Be it remaining in the ECHR to stalling the whole scale ditching of EU legislation then they are doing their desperate best to keep us tied to Europe politically and legally. Fair enough, that makes sense. For what it's worth, I completely agree on Starmer - the promises he made in his leadership bid are already distant memories and he's done a complete 180 on a lot of them. He'll say whatever he thinks people want to hear.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.