You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Signings On The Way
November 22 2026 3.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Signings On The Way


Page 99 of 161 < 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 >
nead1 Flag 09 Sep 20 11.40am

I think the facts are indisputable since the 2010 acquisition. After 3 years, a PL club with virtually no debt, and now about to embark on an 8th season in the PL. So, on those facts alone it certainly constitutes success in terms of the history of Palace.
That said, of course there have been some mistakes along the way as happens in any business. However, the strategy in this window has been clear and there seems to be a clear plan which is being implemented.
Personally, I don't think the past few windows were a disaster - look at last summer with McCarthy, Cahill and Ayew for minimal outlay. It was probably that conservatism that has allowed a more expansive approach this time around and credit to all involved - Hodgson, Freedman and Parish in particular.

 

Ian-VI Flag Vicenza 09 Sep 20 11.46am

Originally posted by palace chick

My glass is half empty ;-)

LOL yes, that anyway (not aimed at you, I talk in general) I keep reading about this aging squad unable to carry on playing games.

Random match picked from transfermarkt, our loss against Villa in the middle of the bad run.

GK excluded as age is not so relevant we had:
Van Aanholt (29), Dann (33), Sakho (30), Ward (30)
Luka (29). Kouyate (30), McArthur (32), Wilf (27), Ayew (2, Benteke (29).

Surely we need to rejuvenate our team for the future sustainability of the club, but is that a team unable to play matches? 2 players over 30? That's a team in the peak of their ability in my opinion! 27 to 30 is the age where they all should peak!

 


The best footie management game: [Link]

dazza Flag Wallington 09 Sep 20 11.49am

What an exciting window this is turning out:

Ferguson - Completed
Eze - Completed
Batshuayi - Announcement in-coming
Gallagher - was completed but cancelled due to Batshuayi
BAS - In talks
Benrhama - Club in talks
Kotchup - Club in talks
Downes - Club in talks

No bids as of yet for Zaha - Everton have definitely not made any buds or moves yet.

Players to likely move on:

Wickham
Sakho
McCarthy
Sorloth

 

slubglurge Flag welling 09 Sep 20 11.49am

Originally posted by HerneBayPalace

Yes, that is what I was getting at.

He was pictured in a Palace training top a few months ago.

Sauce FC would be in full swing with :

Zaha
Ayew
Benrahma
Eze
Batshuayi

If we can pull it off, we need to be aiming for top 10.

Attacking flair doesnt mean a thing without a solid defence. Im glad we are concetrating on flair but for Sat we have basically a back four who conceded shedloads of goals in the last 8 games

 

mattteo Flag 09 Sep 20 12.04pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Your comments about Eze and Brewster baffle me. They have both completed seasons in the very competitive Championship and are young sought after prospects. I am baffled because you always give names of young players who have never played in England, as being the ideal signings for Palace.

How can this bafffle? They may be good players for their age, but none will have a 1st season in the PL offering as much as Zaha offers.

I spoke in the context that the only transfers left would be Zaha out and Brewster (or Osay Samuel) in.

Last season we were just 1 step away from relegation. Worst scoring team in the league. We are definitely relegation candidates with about 9 other teams (for 3 places) even if Zaha stays. With Zaha gone, we are frontrunners.

Zaha contributes to 10-20 goals per season (depending on his season). A 21 year old will contribute to 2-10 goals and given that this is what they did in the Championship, I wouldn't expect more from Eze or Brewster in the top league. We need to be patient with them. But also,if Zaha were to go, he should be replaced by someone at his level.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 09 Sep 20 12.15pm

Originally posted by thechaddyboy

According to Twitter this morning that's who we're concentrating on but will switch for Bright Osayi-Samuel if it doesn't come off

Brentford will be under no pressure to sell both Watkins and Benrahma, so I imagine they will want 25m+. I can't see us forking that out unless Wilf goes, but we can dream.

 

oghash Flag 09 Sep 20 12.17pm

Originally posted by mattteo

How can this bafffle? They may be good players for their age, but none will have a 1st season in the PL offering as much as Zaha offers.

I spoke in the context that the only transfers left would be Zaha out and Brewster (or Osay Samuel) in.

Last season we were just 1 step away from relegation. Worst scoring team in the league. We are definitely relegation candidates with about 9 other teams (for 3 places) even if Zaha stays. With Zaha gone, we are frontrunners.

Zaha contributes to 10-20 goals per season (depending on his season). A 21 year old will contribute to 2-10 goals and given that this is what they did in the Championship, I wouldn't expect more from Eze or Brewster in the top league. We need to be patient with them. But also,if Zaha were to go, he should be replaced by someone at his level.

It doesn't really matter what you expect, what matters is what happens in reality which could be more or less. I trust the club's judgement over yours.

 


Why would anyone chose to be a Seagull? The Eagle is a far superior creature.

The Seagull lives under it's damp pier meekly looking out, blinded by the sheer quality of the Eagle's palace.

dazza Flag Wallington 09 Sep 20 12.28pm

Why do people have to be negative, it’s been clear for a while that Palace needed more attacking minded players that can create as this has been an issue over the last few seasons.

Absolutely this means you could concede more but we have a solid back 5 when all fit.

It’s been a good window let’s get behind the club instead of keep trying to find fault.

 

Omph Flag Liverpool 09 Sep 20 12.31pm

Originally posted by mattteo

How can this bafffle? They may be good players for their age, but none will have a 1st season in the PL offering as much as Zaha offers.

I spoke in the context that the only transfers left would be Zaha out and Brewster (or Osay Samuel) in.

Last season we were just 1 step away from relegation. Worst scoring team in the league. We are definitely relegation candidates with about 9 other teams (for 3 places) even if Zaha stays. With Zaha gone, we are frontrunners.

Zaha contributes to 10-20 goals per season (depending on his season). A 21 year old will contribute to 2-10 goals and given that this is what they did in the Championship, I wouldn't expect more from Eze or Brewster in the top league. We need to be patient with them. But also,if Zaha were to go, he should be replaced by someone at his level.

Last season we were effectively safe by week 29 - 40 points is a myth.

Don't disagree that we are candidates this time but so are another 10 teams. A lot to be said for stability and established team ethic and not a random transfer policy bringing in 12 newbies as you typically call for. It is a team game - something RH recognises.

Haven't bothered to check what you've been suggesting this year.

 

Jacey Flag 09 Sep 20 12.34pm

Originally posted by dazza

Why do people have to be negative, it’s been clear for a while that Palace needed more attacking minded players that can create as this has been an issue over the last few seasons.

Absolutely this means you could concede more but we have a solid back 5 when all fit.

It’s been a good window let’s get behind the club instead of keep trying to find fault.

Totally agree,a good window and thank you dazza for your excellent insight,much appreciated.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 09 Sep 20 12.37pm

Originally posted by dazza

What an exciting window this is turning out:

Ferguson - Completed
Eze - Completed
Batshuayi - Announcement in-coming
Gallagher - was completed but cancelled due to Batshuayi
BAS - In talks
Benrhama - Club in talks
Kotchup - Club in talks
Downes - Club in talks

No bids as of yet for Zaha - Everton have definitely not made any buds or moves yet.

Players to likely move on:

Wickham
Sakho
McCarthy
Sorloth


Thanks Dazza very informative. The only concern I would have is with McCarthy, who played well enough to keep Luka out of the team. None of the incomings so far seem to be for a DM. Any thoughts on that?

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 09 Sep 20 12.53pm

Originally posted by dazza

What an exciting window this is turning out:

Ferguson - Completed
Eze - Completed
Batshuayi - Announcement in-coming
Gallagher - was completed but cancelled due to Batshuayi
BAS - In talks
Benrhama - Club in talks
Kotchup - Club in talks
Downes - Club in talks

No bids as of yet for Zaha - Everton have definitely not made any buds or moves yet.

Players to likely move on:

Wickham
Sakho
McCarthy
Sorloth

I’m very sceptical regarding our ability to get deals over the line however if this is all true it would represent the first time in a long time a promising and understandable show of intent from the club, for me anyways.

Batshauyi, benrahma and/or BOS and Bella ketchup for me would be fantastic


Edited by Nicholas91 (09 Sep 2020 12.54pm)

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

coulsdoneagle Flag London 09 Sep 20 1.04pm

Originally posted by dazza

What an exciting window this is turning out:

Ferguson - Completed
Eze - Completed
Batshuayi - Announcement in-coming
Gallagher - was completed but cancelled due to Batshuayi
BAS - In talks
Benrhama - Club in talks
Kotchup - Club in talks
Downes - Club in talks

No bids as of yet for Zaha - Everton have definitely not made any buds or moves yet.

Players to likely move on:

Wickham
Sakho
McCarthy
Sorloth

Osay-Samuel and Benrahma are they exclusive of each other or are we aiming for one? Also what’s the news with Ibe?

 

Bullhorn76 Flag Darlington 09 Sep 20 1.08pm

Originally posted by dazza

What an exciting window this is turning out:

Ferguson - Completed
Eze - Completed
Batshuayi - Announcement in-coming
Gallagher - was completed but cancelled due to Batshuayi
BAS - In talks
Benrhama - Club in talks
Kotchup - Club in talks
Downes - Club in talks

No bids as of yet for Zaha - Everton have definitely not made any buds or moves yet.

Players to likely move on:

Wickham
Sakho
McCarthy
Sorloth

Some on twitter seem to think it’s benrhama 1st then delefeou then bas as third choice

 

Painter Flag Croydon 09 Sep 20 1.15pm

Originally posted by Petereagle


Thanks Dazza very informative. The only concern I would have is with McCarthy, who played well enough to keep Luka out of the team. None of the incomings so far seem to be for a DM. Any thoughts on that?

People kept saying we have too many DM and need some attacking flair in the team, now you want more DMs.
We have 3 with Luca, McArthur and Reidewald.

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 09 Sep 20 1.42pm

Curious about these links to Benrhama.

You would think that with the fee it will take that this is either a clue to Zaha leaving or the fact we have loaned a striker this season the striker budget has now been made available for a different position.

My guess would be that Zaha is potentially leaving...but that’s just my guess.

 

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 09 Sep 20 1.51pm

If Zaha isn’t leaving and Benhrama and Bats come in, I will be very excited for the new season


Originally posted by Hudsoneagle

Curious about these links to Benrhama.

You would think that with the fee it will take that this is either a clue to Zaha leaving or the fact we have loaned a striker this season the striker budget has now been made available for a different position.

My guess would be that Zaha is potentially leaving...but that’s just my guess.

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 09 Sep 20 1.52pm

Originally posted by dazza

What an exciting window this is turning out:

Ferguson - Completed
Eze - Completed
Batshuayi - Announcement in-coming
Gallagher - was completed but cancelled due to Batshuayi
BAS - In talks
Benrhama - Club in talks
Kotchup - Club in talks
Downes - Club in talks

No bids as of yet for Zaha - Everton have definitely not made any buds or moves yet.

Players to likely move on:

Wickham
Sakho
McCarthy
Sorloth

Looking good

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 09 Sep 20 1.55pm

Originally posted by rossboss29

If Zaha isn’t leaving and Benhrama and Bats come in, I will be very excited for the new season


Personally I don’t buy it...it sounds like it’s on twitter but I haven’t seen anything else anywhere that we are in for him.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 09 Sep 20 2.04pm

Originally posted by mattteo

How can this bafffle? They may be good players for their age, but none will have a 1st season in the PL offering as much as Zaha offers.

I spoke in the context that the only transfers left would be Zaha out and Brewster (or Osay Samuel) in.

Last season we were just 1 step away from relegation. Worst scoring team in the league. We are definitely relegation candidates with about 9 other teams (for 3 places) even if Zaha stays. With Zaha gone, we are frontrunners.

Zaha contributes to 10-20 goals per season (depending on his season). A 21 year old will contribute to 2-10 goals and given that this is what they did in the Championship, I wouldn't expect more from Eze or Brewster in the top league. We need to be patient with them. But also,if Zaha were to go, he should be replaced by someone at his level.

We were not 1 step away were we? We were not the worst scoring team in the PL were we? Very poor but not the worst. I am baffled because you say we should sign young players from abroad who would offer so much but seem to suggest those who have played in the Championship would not.
Can I ask how you have come to the conclusion regarding a 21 year old only contributing 2 -10 goals per season, given that they are playing with better players and in better teams. Are you psychic?
Maybe there are more than 1 transfer left, if rumours are to be believed, I am not psychic so do not know


Edited by Spiderman (09 Sep 2020 2.06pm)

 

Page 99 of 161 < 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Signings On The Way