You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Our (US et al) failed strategy in the Middle East
November 22 2026 1.48am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Our (US et al) failed strategy in the Middle East


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
sydtheeagle Flag England 20 Oct 15 3.23pm

Interesting article:

US contemplates failure in the Middle East as Russia rises
OCTOBER 20, 20159:58PM

Air strikes carried out by Russia’s air force in the Syrian province of Hama.

Charis Changnews.com.au
RUSSIA’S power play in Syria appears to be paying off with the superpower making inroads against Islamic State and other extremist groups, leaving its American rivals looking ineffective and highlighting US failures in the region.

When Russia decided to involve itself in the war in Syria, American officials accused it of “pouring gasoline on the fire” in Syria and being “unprofessional” for only giving the US an hour’s notice of its intention to launch air strikes.

But just weeks later, Russia’s provocative move seems to be paying off.

Professor Clive Williams of Macquarie University’s Centre for Policing, Intelligence and Counter Terrorism told news.com.au that Russia’s support had helped Syrian armed forces make advances in some contested areas and “clearly it has made a difference for them”.

Russia continues airstrikes in Homs and Damascus after period of ease

Earlier this year, commentators were writing off the Syrian army and suggesting that the government’s days were numbered.

With Russian air support, Syrians have been able to hit back against Islamic State in central and north-western regions, in a war that has stretched out for four years under the US’s watch.

The US is opposed to the Syrian regime headed by brutal President Bashar al-Assad and has so far refused to help its troops, but Prof Williams said it was better for the Assad regime to be in power, than for the likely alternative of jihadist groups Islamic State and Jabhat al-Nusra to prevail.

“We know what Islamic State is capable of, they are obviously ruthless and clearly have an agenda to dominate other opposition groups,” he said.

He said Russia’s success highlighted the US’s lack of strategy.

“America doesn’t really have a strategy but Russia’s is clear cut,” he said, adding that Russia aimed to support Assad’s regime and its own strategic interests.

While the US’s aim was to support Iraq and counter Islamic State, Prof Williams said what it was doing “was not really making much of a difference on the ground”.

This was partly because the US did not want to put American boots on the ground and was limited in what it could achieve through air strikes.

Iraqi forces backed by the US had corrupt leaders and were poorly motivated, and seemed to be militarily incapable of making advances against Islamic State.

“They rely mainly on the Kurds to do the ground fighting and they are really only interested in establishing their own state,” Prof Williams said.

HAS AMERICA FAILED?

Earlier this month, US President Barack Obama admitted that his efforts to help resolve the Syria crisis had so far failed, but defended his strategy and dismissed assertions that Russian President Vladimir Putin was now the dominant world leader.
But Putin has shown leadership in fight against IS.

“I didn’t say it was going to be done in a year,” Obama said in a US 60 Minutes interview. “Syria has been a difficult problem for the entire world community. What we have not been able to do so far — and I’m the first to acknowledge this — is to change the dynamic inside of Syria.”

But this week former US secretary of state Henry Kissinger argued in The Wall Street Journal that Russia’s military action was the latest symptom of the “disintegration of the American role in stabilising the Middle East order”.

He said the geopolitical alliances in the region were now in “shambles” and that four countries — Libya, Yemen, Syria and Iraq — had ceased to function.

“American policy has sought to straddle the motivations of all parties and is therefore on the verge of losing the ability to shape events,” Kissinger wrote.

“The US is now opposed to, or at odds in some way or another with, all parties in the region: with Egypt on human rights, with Saudi Arabia over Yemen, with each of the Syrian parties over different objectives.”

He said the US wanted to remove Assad but had been unwilling to generate effective political or military leverage to achieve that aim, or to put forward an alternative political structure to replace him. This had allowed Russia, Iran, Islamic State and other terrorist organisations to move into the vacuum.

When asked whether America had failed, Prof Williams said: “I don’t think its strategy in the Middle East is very effective”. “It has involved itself in the war between Shia and Sunni Islam without understanding the dynamics of the situation.

“In the longer term whatever America does isn’t going to be very effective.”

He said the US needed to rethink its approach more generally in the Middle East, including its relationship with Israel and Saudi Arabia, and whether there was a more effective way to counter
Islamic State, by supporting Iranian and Shia militia forces in Iraq, for example.

Overall if you looked at American involvement in the Middle East since the 1990s, Prof Williams said: “it has all been pretty disastrous in terms of long term outcomes”.

Rather than having a clear objective, he said America seemed to “jump in” to conflicts in the Middle East and South Asia before pulling out after a few years.

“I’m not sure whether Western involvement in the Middle East against Islamic State is really the answer,” Prof Williams said.

“The situation in the Middle East is complicated and I think we need to step back and think about what sort of strategic outcomes we want and how best to achieve them.”

He said that America’s best move to combat Islamic State could actually be to withdraw from the conflict and let regional countries sort out what is essentially a regional problem.

“If we weren’t involved, Islamic State would also be less of a problem in Australia. They are attacking us at the moment because we are involved in attacking them,” he said.

“We could pull out and let the Saudis and Iranians get on with it. The Saudis are fighting through proxies and so is Iran. Maybe there’s not much to be gained by us from being involved in that situation.”

IS RUSSIA THE REAL WINNER?

Last month Russia announced an intelligence-sharing agreement with Syria, Iran, and Iraq in their fight against Islamic State, a move The New York Times says caught US officials completely off guard.

“It was another sign,” Michael Gordon wrote, that Russia “was moving ahead with a sharply different tack from that of the Obama administration in battling the Islamic State … by assembling a rival coalition that includes Iran and the Syrian government”.

On Monday, US Secretary of State John Kerry said the US would meet with Russian, Saudi and Turkish leaders to seek an end to the conflict in Syria.

Allowing Syria to become a haven for terrorist operations would not benefit any of the nations, including Russia, which would be concerned that the influence of the extremist groups could reach into Muslim regions along its southern border.

When asked whether Russia would be the winner in Syria, Prof Williams said it was in a much better position to be there in the longer term than the US.

He said Russia had been accessing a naval base in Syria since the 1970s and was there at the invitation of the Syrian regime. The naval facility in Tartus has been in use since 1971, and it was Russia’s only spot in the Mediterranean where warships could stop for repairs and replenishment. This year Russia also established a forward air base nearby, in Latakia.

“It’s not like they suddenly appeared on the scene to make life difficult for the Americans,” Prof Williams said, adding that Russia had an enduring strategic interest in Syria.

“If it wants to be seen as a world player it needs access to foreign bases, access to the port in Syria is very important in that context.”

Ultimately, he said Russia would probably be more effective against Islamic State because it had a clear mission to protect its military assets and support the Assad regime.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 20 Oct 15 3.46pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 3.23pm

Interesting article:

US contemplates failure in the Middle East as Russia rises
OCTOBER 20, 20159:58PM

Air strikes carried out by Russia’s air force in the Syrian province of Hama.

Charis Changnews.com.au
RUSSIA’S power play in Syria appears to be paying off with the superpower making inroads against Islamic State and other extremist groups, leaving its American rivals looking ineffective and highlighting US failures in the region.

When Russia decided to involve itself in the war in Syria, American officials accused it of “pouring gasoline on the fire” in Syria and being “unprofessional” for only giving the US an hour’s notice of its intention to launch air strikes.

But just weeks later, Russia’s provocative move seems to be paying off.

Professor Clive Williams of Macquarie University’s Centre for Policing, Intelligence and Counter Terrorism told news.com.au that Russia’s support had helped Syrian armed forces make advances in some contested areas and “clearly it has made a difference for them”.

Russia continues airstrikes in Homs and Damascus after period of ease

Earlier this year, commentators were writing off the Syrian army and suggesting that the government’s days were numbered.

With Russian air support, Syrians have been able to hit back against Islamic State in central and north-western regions, in a war that has stretched out for four years under the US’s watch.

The US is opposed to the Syrian regime headed by brutal President Bashar al-Assad and has so far refused to help its troops, but Prof Williams said it was better for the Assad regime to be in power, than for the likely alternative of jihadist groups Islamic State and Jabhat al-Nusra to prevail.

“We know what Islamic State is capable of, they are obviously ruthless and clearly have an agenda to dominate other opposition groups,” he said.

He said Russia’s success highlighted the US’s lack of strategy.

“America doesn’t really have a strategy but Russia’s is clear cut,” he said, adding that Russia aimed to support Assad’s regime and its own strategic interests.

While the US’s aim was to support Iraq and counter Islamic State, Prof Williams said what it was doing “was not really making much of a difference on the ground”.

This was partly because the US did not want to put American boots on the ground and was limited in what it could achieve through air strikes.

Iraqi forces backed by the US had corrupt leaders and were poorly motivated, and seemed to be militarily incapable of making advances against Islamic State.

“They rely mainly on the Kurds to do the ground fighting and they are really only interested in establishing their own state,” Prof Williams said.

HAS AMERICA FAILED?

Earlier this month, US President Barack Obama admitted that his efforts to help resolve the Syria crisis had so far failed, but defended his strategy and dismissed assertions that Russian President Vladimir Putin was now the dominant world leader.
But Putin has shown leadership in fight against IS.

“I didn’t say it was going to be done in a year,” Obama said in a US 60 Minutes interview. “Syria has been a difficult problem for the entire world community. What we have not been able to do so far — and I’m the first to acknowledge this — is to change the dynamic inside of Syria.”

But this week former US secretary of state Henry Kissinger argued in The Wall Street Journal that Russia’s military action was the latest symptom of the “disintegration of the American role in stabilising the Middle East order”.

He said the geopolitical alliances in the region were now in “shambles” and that four countries — Libya, Yemen, Syria and Iraq — had ceased to function.

“American policy has sought to straddle the motivations of all parties and is therefore on the verge of losing the ability to shape events,” Kissinger wrote.

“The US is now opposed to, or at odds in some way or another with, all parties in the region: with Egypt on human rights, with Saudi Arabia over Yemen, with each of the Syrian parties over different objectives.”

He said the US wanted to remove Assad but had been unwilling to generate effective political or military leverage to achieve that aim, or to put forward an alternative political structure to replace him. This had allowed Russia, Iran, Islamic State and other terrorist organisations to move into the vacuum.

When asked whether America had failed, Prof Williams said: “I don’t think its strategy in the Middle East is very effective”. “It has involved itself in the war between Shia and Sunni Islam without understanding the dynamics of the situation.

“In the longer term whatever America does isn’t going to be very effective.”

He said the US needed to rethink its approach more generally in the Middle East, including its relationship with Israel and Saudi Arabia, and whether there was a more effective way to counter
Islamic State, by supporting Iranian and Shia militia forces in Iraq, for example.

Overall if you looked at American involvement in the Middle East since the 1990s, Prof Williams said: “it has all been pretty disastrous in terms of long term outcomes”.

Rather than having a clear objective, he said America seemed to “jump in” to conflicts in the Middle East and South Asia before pulling out after a few years.

“I’m not sure whether Western involvement in the Middle East against Islamic State is really the answer,” Prof Williams said.

“The situation in the Middle East is complicated and I think we need to step back and think about what sort of strategic outcomes we want and how best to achieve them.”

He said that America’s best move to combat Islamic State could actually be to withdraw from the conflict and let regional countries sort out what is essentially a regional problem.

“If we weren’t involved, Islamic State would also be less of a problem in Australia. They are attacking us at the moment because we are involved in attacking them,” he said.

“We could pull out and let the Saudis and Iranians get on with it. The Saudis are fighting through proxies and so is Iran. Maybe there’s not much to be gained by us from being involved in that situation.”

IS RUSSIA THE REAL WINNER?

Last month Russia announced an intelligence-sharing agreement with Syria, Iran, and Iraq in their fight against Islamic State, a move The New York Times says caught US officials completely off guard.

“It was another sign,” Michael Gordon wrote, that Russia “was moving ahead with a sharply different tack from that of the Obama administration in battling the Islamic State … by assembling a rival coalition that includes Iran and the Syrian government”.

On Monday, US Secretary of State John Kerry said the US would meet with Russian, Saudi and Turkish leaders to seek an end to the conflict in Syria.

Allowing Syria to become a haven for terrorist operations would not benefit any of the nations, including Russia, which would be concerned that the influence of the extremist groups could reach into Muslim regions along its southern border.

When asked whether Russia would be the winner in Syria, Prof Williams said it was in a much better position to be there in the longer term than the US.

He said Russia had been accessing a naval base in Syria since the 1970s and was there at the invitation of the Syrian regime. The naval facility in Tartus has been in use since 1971, and it was Russia’s only spot in the Mediterranean where warships could stop for repairs and replenishment. This year Russia also established a forward air base nearby, in Latakia.

“It’s not like they suddenly appeared on the scene to make life difficult for the Americans,” Prof Williams said, adding that Russia had an enduring strategic interest in Syria.

“If it wants to be seen as a world player it needs access to foreign bases, access to the port in Syria is very important in that context.”

Ultimately, he said Russia would probably be more effective against Islamic State because it had a clear mission to protect its military assets and support the Assad regime.


Also the Russians aren't so sensitive to media/world opinion which is a massive plus when fighting a war

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Stuk Flag Top half 20 Oct 15 3.55pm

How is that "ours".

 


Optimistic as ever

chris123 Flag hove actually 20 Oct 15 3.55pm

Well Saudi wants Assad out.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 20 Oct 15 3.57pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 3.55pm

How is that "ours".


I think our policy towards Syria, Iraq and the Middle East generally falls in line with America's.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Stuk Flag Top half 20 Oct 15 3.58pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 3.57pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 3.55pm

How is that "ours".


I think our policy towards Syria, Iraq and the Middle East generally falls in line with America's.

Everything you have posted is nothing to do with us.

Mods change the thread title please.

 


Optimistic as ever

sydtheeagle Flag England 20 Oct 15 4.01pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 3.58pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 3.57pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 3.55pm

How is that "ours".


I think our policy towards Syria, Iraq and the Middle East generally falls in line with America's.

Everything you have posted is nothing to do with us.

Mods change the thread title please.

I haven't posted anything. Just an article about which I noted it was interesting but didn't add my own opinion. The thread title clearly says "US et al". Don't change the thread title: it's quite clear. If you disagree with it, please debate the issue.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Stuk Flag Top half 20 Oct 15 4.07pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 4.01pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 3.58pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 3.57pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 3.55pm

How is that "ours".


I think our policy towards Syria, Iraq and the Middle East generally falls in line with America's.

Everything you have posted is nothing to do with us.

Mods change the thread title please.

I haven't posted anything. Just an article about which I noted it was interesting but didn't add my own opinion. The thread title clearly says "US et al". Don't change the thread title: it's quite clear. If you disagree with it, please debate the issue.

Contradiction.

I don't care what you think the thread title clearly says. This had f*** all to do with the UK, i.e. "us", therefore it's not "our" anything.

Please change it mods, or delete it altogether.

 


Optimistic as ever

oldcodger Flag 20 Oct 15 4.25pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 4.07pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 4.01pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 3.58pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 3.57pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 3.55pm

How is that "ours".


I think our policy towards Syria, Iraq and the Middle East generally falls in line with America's.

Everything you have posted is nothing to do with us.

Mods change the thread title please.

I haven't posted anything. Just an article about which I noted it was interesting but didn't add my own opinion. The thread title clearly says "US et al". Don't change the thread title: it's quite clear. If you disagree with it, please debate the issue.

Contradiction.

I don't care what you think the thread title clearly says. This had f*** all to do with the UK, i.e. "us", therefore it's not "our" anything.

Please change it mods, or delete it altogether.

I assumed by 'us' he meant the West. We have certainly been part of a failed military strategy so it's hardly black and white and nothing to start swearing about or giving the mod more work to do. You've said your piece. If the mod wishes to make changes he will.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 20 Oct 15 4.42pm

Quote oldcodger at 20 Oct 2015 4.25pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 4.07pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 4.01pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 3.58pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 3.57pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 3.55pm

How is that "ours".


I think our policy towards Syria, Iraq and the Middle East generally falls in line with America's.

Everything you have posted is nothing to do with us.

Mods change the thread title please.

I haven't posted anything. Just an article about which I noted it was interesting but didn't add my own opinion. The thread title clearly says "US et al". Don't change the thread title: it's quite clear. If you disagree with it, please debate the issue.

Contradiction.

I don't care what you think the thread title clearly says. This had f*** all to do with the UK, i.e. "us", therefore it's not "our" anything.

Please change it mods, or delete it altogether.

I assumed by 'us' he meant the West. We have certainly been part of a failed military strategy so it's hardly black and white and nothing to start swearing about or giving the mod more work to do. You've said your piece. If the mod wishes to make changes he will.


I couldn't give a s*** what you assumed he meant.

Read the nonsense Syd has copied and pasted, you'll find it is nothing to do with the UK.

Then go and find someone else to follow around.

 


Optimistic as ever

sydtheeagle Flag England 20 Oct 15 4.53pm

Quote oldcodger at 20 Oct 2015 4.25pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 4.07pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 4.01pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 3.58pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 3.57pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 3.55pm

How is that "ours".


I think our policy towards Syria, Iraq and the Middle East generally falls in line with America's.

Everything you have posted is nothing to do with us.

Mods change the thread title please.

I haven't posted anything. Just an article about which I noted it was interesting but didn't add my own opinion. The thread title clearly says "US et al". Don't change the thread title: it's quite clear. If you disagree with it, please debate the issue.

Contradiction.

I don't care what you think the thread title clearly says. This had f*** all to do with the UK, i.e. "us", therefore it's not "our" anything.

Please change it mods, or delete it altogether.

I assumed by 'us' he meant the West. We have certainly been part of a failed military strategy so it's hardly black and white and nothing to start swearing about or giving the mod more work to do. You've said your piece. If the mod wishes to make changes he will.

Free speech isn't popular in these parts, is it? I mean, you post an article for discussion (the precise point of an Internet forum, I'd have thought) and someone immediately goes pre-menstrual in the most vitriolically personal of ways. The funniest thing is that he refers to the content of the article as "nonsense" as if that means it shouldn't be read. WTF? I didn't even say it wasn't nonsense; merely worth reading and responding to. Your interpretation of my general intent is absolutely correct, but I think most can probably discern that.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Stuk Flag Top half 20 Oct 15 5.00pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 4.53pm

Quote oldcodger at 20 Oct 2015 4.25pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 4.07pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 4.01pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 3.58pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 3.57pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 3.55pm

How is that "ours".


I think our policy towards Syria, Iraq and the Middle East generally falls in line with America's.

Everything you have posted is nothing to do with us.

Mods change the thread title please.

I haven't posted anything. Just an article about which I noted it was interesting but didn't add my own opinion. The thread title clearly says "US et al". Don't change the thread title: it's quite clear. If you disagree with it, please debate the issue.

Contradiction.

I don't care what you think the thread title clearly says. This had f*** all to do with the UK, i.e. "us", therefore it's not "our" anything.

Please change it mods, or delete it altogether.

I assumed by 'us' he meant the West. We have certainly been part of a failed military strategy so it's hardly black and white and nothing to start swearing about or giving the mod more work to do. You've said your piece. If the mod wishes to make changes he will.

Free speech isn't popular in these parts, is it? I mean, you post an article for discussion (the precise point of an Internet forum, I'd have thought) and someone immediately goes pre-menstrual in the most vitriolically personal of ways. The funniest thing is that he refers to the content of the article as "nonsense" as if that means it shouldn't be read. WTF? I didn't even say it wasn't nonsense; merely worth reading and responding to. Your interpretation of my general intent is absolutely correct, but I think most can probably discern that.

It's nothing to do with free speech, it's the inaccuracy and false attribution.

You two have fun w***ing each other off though.

 


Optimistic as ever

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 20 Oct 15 5.00pm

Should have nuked the c*nts back in the 70s.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

sydtheeagle Flag England 20 Oct 15 5.09pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 5.00pm

It's nothing to do with free speech, it's the inaccuracy and false attribution.

You two have fun w***ing each other off though.

What on earth are you going on about?

What's inaccurate? When I said I merely posted an article, what was implicit was there was no personal opinion attached. I merely posted an article. Obvious, really, as I simply said "interesting article" -- the only two words of mine in the post. Can't see what's inaccurate about that.

And yes, there was an attribution: Charis Changnews.com.au. An Australian news agency for whom Chang is an editorial writer. Doesn't really matter though as the opinion was what was interesting and can be discussed on its merits (or otherwise) regardless of the original source or who wrote it. But if the latter matters to you, the attribution was right there in the first two lines.

Your ranting is surreal.

Edited by sydtheeagle (20 Oct 2015 5.10pm)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 20 Oct 15 5.11pm

I don't want to go all conspiracy theory or anything but - how do we know the US policy (United States) has failed?
We don't really know their full intentions.
Perhaps they have no interest in peace in the Middle East, or in being the dominant military force, perhaps they just want to manipulate oil prices and manipulate the market for their defence contractors? Perhaps what is going on is exactly what they wanted - or will be? There are a myriad number of things they may have as their strategic goals in the region without telling us about it.
From a viewpoint of wanting stability in the region then policies have failed; but there could be an overall policy of undermning the region for other purposes that are not quite clear to the wider world at present.

 


Red and Blue Army!

sydtheeagle Flag England 20 Oct 15 5.12pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 5.00pm

You two have fun w***ing each other off though.

Should we choose to do so, at least it'll be abetted by an intelligent discourse. One imagines you specialise in the w***king without the insight, judging on contributions to this thread.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

DanH Flag SW2 20 Oct 15 5.27pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 5.00pm


It's nothing to do with free speech, it's the inaccuracy and false attribution.

You two have fun w***ing each other off though.


U OK hun?

 

oldcodger Flag 20 Oct 15 6.18pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 5.00pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 4.53pm

Quote oldcodger at 20 Oct 2015 4.25pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 4.07pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 4.01pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 3.58pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 20 Oct 2015 3.57pm

Quote Stuk at 20 Oct 2015 3.55pm

How is that "ours".


I think our policy towards Syria, Iraq and the Middle East generally falls in line with America's.

Everything you have posted is nothing to do with us.

Mods change the thread title please.

I haven't posted anything. Just an article about which I noted it was interesting but didn't add my own opinion. The thread title clearly says "US et al". Don't change the thread title: it's quite clear. If you disagree with it, please debate the issue.

Contradiction.

I don't care what you think the thread title clearly says. This had f*** all to do with the UK, i.e. "us", therefore it's not "our" anything.

Please change it mods, or delete it altogether.

I assumed by 'us' he meant the West. We have certainly been part of a failed military strategy so it's hardly black and white and nothing to start swearing about or giving the mod more work to do. You've said your piece. If the mod wishes to make changes he will.

Free speech isn't popular in these parts, is it? I mean, you post an article for discussion (the precise point of an Internet forum, I'd have thought) and someone immediately goes pre-menstrual in the most vitriolically personal of ways. The funniest thing is that he refers to the content of the article as "nonsense" as if that means it shouldn't be read. WTF? I didn't even say it wasn't nonsense; merely worth reading and responding to. Your interpretation of my general intent is absolutely correct, but I think most can probably discern that.

It's nothing to do with free speech, it's the inaccuracy and false attribution.

You two have fun w***ing each other off though.


Well I've heard it all now!

 

oldcodger Flag 20 Oct 15 6.21pm

The West's madcap 'dictator whack-a-mole' clearly made the middle east situation much worse and so it's harder to convince the public now that the latest bogeyman needs to be dethroned.

The Russians are doing what's in their strategic interest, just as the US did when it attempted to help further destablise Syria. Whether they'll get on any better is anyone's guess. Just another stage in a proxy war.


Edited by oldcodger (21 Oct 2015 12.35pm)

 

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 20 Oct 15 6.34pm

Our (US et al) failed strategy in the Middle East

It hasn't failed at all.
Creating fear from nothing has it's perks.

 


Time to move forward together.

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Our (US et al) failed strategy in the Middle East