You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The Recent Floods - Observations/Conclusions?
November 22 2026 1.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Recent Floods - Observations/Conclusions?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Hoof Hearted 09 Dec 15 10.44am

Carlisle, Lancaster and Keswick (and other minor Cumbrian towns) have been devastated by flooding from the torrential rain caused by "Storm Desmond".

It was about 10 years ago that a similar flood happened and despite preparing flood defences costing millions, it has happened again.

Firstly I find it odd that our government were quick to raise Billions for Bangla Desh and Bhutan flood disasters, but seem to be dallying about and not getting aid to our own. Some have been without basic services for days and many have no insurance because of previous flood damage rather than neglecting to take it out.

It's obvious that this recent flood is different to that of the Somerset Levels - there it was mainly a problem with poor maintenance of water channels by not dredging them and low lying areas that were basically a flood plain converted to agricultural land.

In Cumbria, the situation has been caused by rainwater running off the hills because of deforestation by farmers to allow sheep to graze there instead. This water then cascades through straightened water courses and onto towns like Carlisle where the defences can't cope and flood is inevitable. Apparently the highest level of water was 9" above the highest flood wall.... that's a huge margin.

It is impossible to build higher defences without ruining the ambience of these towns that rely on tourism for their economy.

Farmers should be forced to reinstate woodland on the hills to reduce the rainwater cascading down and water courses should be allowed to meander to reduce faster flow.

I blame rampant immigration - yes I do!

Without the pressure to build more houses and the necessary infrastructure to cope with a rapidly increasing population we wouldn't need to build on flood plains or encourage farmers to tend sheep on hill farms that were once woodlands.

Ignore the economic arguments and possible security threats from rampant immigration.... the fallout from this open door policy created by Blair and New Labour is now hitting the residents of Cumbria pretty hard.

Food for thought for those keen to stay in the EU and/or want to ship in asylum seekers/refugees from the middle east.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (09 Dec 2015 10.45am)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 09 Dec 15 10.51am

wow.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 09 Dec 15 11.39am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 09 Dec 2015 10.44am

Carlisle, Lancaster and Keswick (and other minor Cumbrian towns) have been devastated by flooding from the torrential rain caused by "Storm Desmond".

It was about 10 years ago that a similar flood happened and despite preparing flood defences costing millions, it has happened again.

Firstly I find it odd that our government were quick to raise Billions for Bangla Desh and Bhutan flood disasters, but seem to be dallying about and not getting aid to our own. Some have been without basic services for days and many have no insurance because of previous flood damage rather than neglecting to take it out.

It's obvious that this recent flood is different to that of the Somerset Levels - there it was mainly a problem with poor maintenance of water channels by not dredging them and low lying areas that were basically a flood plain converted to agricultural land.

In Cumbria, the situation has been caused by rainwater running off the hills because of deforestation by farmers to allow sheep to graze there instead. This water then cascades through straightened water courses and onto towns like Carlisle where the defences can't cope and flood is inevitable. Apparently the highest level of water was 9" above the highest flood wall.... that's a huge margin.

It is impossible to build higher defences without ruining the ambience of these towns that rely on tourism for their economy.

Farmers should be forced to reinstate woodland on the hills to reduce the rainwater cascading down and water courses should be allowed to meander to reduce faster flow.

I blame rampant immigration - yes I do!

Without the pressure to build more houses and the necessary infrastructure to cope with a rapidly increasing population we wouldn't need to build on flood plains or encourage farmers to tend sheep on hill farms that were once woodlands.

Ignore the economic arguments and possible security threats from rampant immigration.... the fallout from this open door policy created by Blair and New Labour is now hitting the residents of Cumbria pretty hard.

Food for thought for those keen to stay in the EU and/or want to ship in asylum seekers/refugees from the middle east.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (09 Dec 2015 10.45am)


I blame it on idiots living too close to rivers.

Edited by matt_himself (09 Dec 2015 11.41am)

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Hoof Hearted 09 Dec 15 11.41am

Quote matt_himself at 09 Dec 2015 11.39am

I am with that UKIP fella and blame the floods on Cameron's decision to oppose the scriptures and allow men to marry each other.

This is God's wrath people. Be afraid.


I forgot about that....

 

Holmesdale Nick Flag South Croydon 09 Dec 15 11.51am

Look at Purley and Kenley in the beginning of 2014.

Lots of flooding, Purley pond at tescos, too much land is concreted and tarmaced over and rainwater has nowhere to go.

 


Fitter Fans Group 2. No. 17

Superfly Flag The sun always shines in Catford 09 Dec 15 11.51am

Foreign sheep Coming over here! Eating our cud!

Grazy, wok-shy, lamby gits

 


Lend me a Tenor

31 May to 3 June 2017

John McIntosh Arts Centre
London Oratory School
SW6 1RX

with Superfly in the chorus
[Link]

DanH Flag SW2 09 Dec 15 12.08pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 09 Dec 2015 10.44am

Carlisle, Lancaster and Keswick (and other minor Cumbrian towns) have been devastated by flooding from the torrential rain caused by "Storm Desmond".

It was about 10 years ago that a similar flood happened and despite preparing flood defences costing millions, it has happened again.

Firstly I find it odd that our government were quick to raise Billions for Bangla Desh and Bhutan flood disasters, but seem to be dallying about and not getting aid to our own. Some have been without basic services for days and many have no insurance because of previous flood damage rather than neglecting to take it out.

It's obvious that this recent flood is different to that of the Somerset Levels - there it was mainly a problem with poor maintenance of water channels by not dredging them and low lying areas that were basically a flood plain converted to agricultural land.

In Cumbria, the situation has been caused by rainwater running off the hills because of deforestation by farmers to allow sheep to graze there instead. This water then cascades through straightened water courses and onto towns like Carlisle where the defences can't cope and flood is inevitable. Apparently the highest level of water was 9" above the highest flood wall.... that's a huge margin.

It is impossible to build higher defences without ruining the ambience of these towns that rely on tourism for their economy.

Farmers should be forced to reinstate woodland on the hills to reduce the rainwater cascading down and water courses should be allowed to meander to reduce faster flow.

I blame rampant immigration - yes I do!

Without the pressure to build more houses and the necessary infrastructure to cope with a rapidly increasing population we wouldn't need to build on flood plains or encourage farmers to tend sheep on hill farms that were once woodlands.

Ignore the economic arguments and possible security threats from rampant immigration.... the fallout from this open door policy created by Blair and New Labour is now hitting the residents of Cumbria pretty hard.

Food for thought for those keen to stay in the EU and/or want to ship in asylum seekers/refugees from the middle east.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (09 Dec 2015 10.45am)


I think you need to go for a lie down mate.

 

Hoof Hearted 09 Dec 15 12.10pm

Quote DanH at 09 Dec 2015 12.08pm

I think you need to go for a lie down mate.


My bed's wet Dan!

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 09 Dec 15 12.55pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 09 Dec 2015 12.10pm

Quote DanH at 09 Dec 2015 12.08pm

I think you need to go for a lie down mate.


My bed's wet Dan!


Dan forcing you to sleep in the wet patch?

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

DanH Flag SW2 09 Dec 15 1.20pm

Quote pefwin at 09 Dec 2015 12.55pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 09 Dec 2015 12.10pm

Quote DanH at 09 Dec 2015 12.08pm

I think you need to go for a lie down mate.


My bed's wet Dan!


Dan forcing you to sleep in the wet patch?


It's usually more sticky than wet.

 

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 09 Dec 15 2.38pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 09 Dec 2015 10.44am

Carlisle, Lancaster and Keswick (and other minor Cumbrian towns) have been devastated by flooding from the torrential rain caused by "Storm Desmond".

It was about 10 years ago that a similar flood happened and despite preparing flood defences costing millions, it has happened again.

Firstly I find it odd that our government were quick to raise Billions for Bangla Desh and Bhutan flood disasters, but seem to be dallying about and not getting aid to our own. Some have been without basic services for days and many have no insurance because of previous flood damage rather than neglecting to take it out.

It's obvious that this recent flood is different to that of the Somerset Levels - there it was mainly a problem with poor maintenance of water channels by not dredging them and low lying areas that were basically a flood plain converted to agricultural land.

In Cumbria, the situation has been caused by rainwater running off the hills because of deforestation by farmers to allow sheep to graze there instead. This water then cascades through straightened water courses and onto towns like Carlisle where the defences can't cope and flood is inevitable. Apparently the highest level of water was 9" above the highest flood wall.... that's a huge margin.

It is impossible to build higher defences without ruining the ambience of these towns that rely on tourism for their economy.

Farmers should be forced to reinstate woodland on the hills to reduce the rainwater cascading down and water courses should be allowed to meander to reduce faster flow.

I blame rampant immigration - yes I do!

Without the pressure to build more houses and the necessary infrastructure to cope with a rapidly increasing population we wouldn't need to build on flood plains or encourage farmers to tend sheep on hill farms that were once woodlands.

Ignore the economic arguments and possible security threats from rampant immigration.... the fallout from this open door policy created by Blair and New Labour is now hitting the residents of Cumbria pretty hard.

Food for thought for those keen to stay in the EU and/or want to ship in asylum seekers/refugees from the middle east.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (09 Dec 2015 10.45am)

I think Hoof's got a point though.

Virtually every one of these storms arrives from overseas.

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 09 Dec 15 6.59pm

Quote mezzer at 09 Dec 2015 2.38pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 09 Dec 2015 10.44am

Carlisle, Lancaster and Keswick (and other minor Cumbrian towns) have been devastated by flooding from the torrential rain caused by "Storm Desmond".

It was about 10 years ago that a similar flood happened and despite preparing flood defences costing millions, it has happened again.

Firstly I find it odd that our government were quick to raise Billions for Bangla Desh and Bhutan flood disasters, but seem to be dallying about and not getting aid to our own. Some have been without basic services for days and many have no insurance because of previous flood damage rather than neglecting to take it out.

It's obvious that this recent flood is different to that of the Somerset Levels - there it was mainly a problem with poor maintenance of water channels by not dredging them and low lying areas that were basically a flood plain converted to agricultural land.

In Cumbria, the situation has been caused by rainwater running off the hills because of deforestation by farmers to allow sheep to graze there instead. This water then cascades through straightened water courses and onto towns like Carlisle where the defences can't cope and flood is inevitable. Apparently the highest level of water was 9" above the highest flood wall.... that's a huge margin.

It is impossible to build higher defences without ruining the ambience of these towns that rely on tourism for their economy.

Farmers should be forced to reinstate woodland on the hills to reduce the rainwater cascading down and water courses should be allowed to meander to reduce faster flow.

I blame rampant immigration - yes I do!

Without the pressure to build more houses and the necessary infrastructure to cope with a rapidly increasing population we wouldn't need to build on flood plains or encourage farmers to tend sheep on hill farms that were once woodlands.

Ignore the economic arguments and possible security threats from rampant immigration.... the fallout from this open door policy created by Blair and New Labour is now hitting the residents of Cumbria pretty hard.

Food for thought for those keen to stay in the EU and/or want to ship in asylum seekers/refugees from the middle east.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (09 Dec 2015 10.45am)

I think Hoof's got a point though.

Virtually every one of these storms arrives from overseas.



As for a solution, create more waterways..........or move. Blaming any particular party seems harsh because it happens to have rained more than usual.

 


Time to move forward together.

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 09 Dec 15 7.15pm

I think Milli Vanilli have a better answer.

[Link]

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 09 Dec 15 9.05pm

Am fortunate I live in an area where flooding doesn't occur and feel extremely sorry for those who do and for those currently affected by flooding. However if I lived in such a venerable area think I would take some basic precautions to protect my own property. May be easier said than done but perhaps insurance companies could encourage/make recommendations in return for lower premiums - or at least some cover for those over wise uninsurable.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 10 Dec 15 8.58am

Cumbria is wet because it rains a lot, it has always been wet because it rains a lot, it will always be wet because it rains a lot.

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Hoof Hearted 10 Dec 15 10.44am

Quote The Sash at 10 Dec 2015 8.58am

Cumbria is wet because it rains a lot, it has always been wet because it rains a lot, it will always be wet because it rains a lot.


Cannot disagree Sash.... BUT... if you remove woodland from the Cumbrian hillsides all that rain cascades down the slopes rather than being absorbed by the tree roots and ends up in the rivers.

As I also said in my original post, the river courses have been straightened over the last few decades in mistaken belief it would help and now the flow of the river is much faster and creates more volume. If the original river courses were re-instated the flow would reduce and pools would form rather than a raging torrent of water over-topping futile flood defence systems.

 

Plane Flag Bromley 10 Dec 15 10.47am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 10 Dec 2015 10.44am

Quote The Sash at 10 Dec 2015 8.58am

Cumbria is wet because it rains a lot, it has always been wet because it rains a lot, it will always be wet because it rains a lot.


Cannot disagree Sash.... BUT... if you remove woodland from the Cumbrian hillsides all that rain cascades down the slopes rather than being absorbed by the tree roots and ends up in the rivers.

As I also said in my original post, the river courses have been straightened over the last few decades in mistaken belief it would help and now the flow of the river is much faster and creates more volume. If the original river courses were re-instated the flow would reduce and pools would form rather than a raging torrent of water over-topping futile flood defence systems.

...And rip up all that block paving in peoples gardens!

 

Hoof Hearted 10 Dec 15 10.51am

Quote Plane at 10 Dec 2015 10.47am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 10 Dec 2015 10.44am

Quote The Sash at 10 Dec 2015 8.58am

Cumbria is wet because it rains a lot, it has always been wet because it rains a lot, it will always be wet because it rains a lot.


Cannot disagree Sash.... BUT... if you remove woodland from the Cumbrian hillsides all that rain cascades down the slopes rather than being absorbed by the tree roots and ends up in the rivers.

As I also said in my original post, the river courses have been straightened over the last few decades in mistaken belief it would help and now the flow of the river is much faster and creates more volume. If the original river courses were re-instated the flow would reduce and pools would form rather than a raging torrent of water over-topping futile flood defence systems.

...And rip up all that block paving in peoples gardens!


Exactly Plane my wise old friend!

A lot of surface water would be absorbed into the ground if people retained front gardens as just that... rather than paving them over for car parking!

All this water gets directed to the storm drains then into the rivers increasing volume and flow!

It's not rocket salad guys!

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards so many memories Flag basingstoke 10 Dec 15 12.31pm

Environment agency on the case.
Job well done I think.

deerhurst-flood-gate.jpg Attachment: deerhurst-flood-gate.jpg (170.84Kb)

 


Get it on-get it in-F**K OFF ALAN HANSEN!!

Monkeyrush Flag London 22 Dec 15 3.23pm

The opening post was like my geography degree on acid. Amazing.

Basically, mother nature will always win. You protect one area at the cost of another. Clear the trees I want the price of lamb to go down.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The Recent Floods - Observations/Conclusions?