This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
What about if they only think you've committed a crime? Should they be able to access your private data then? TBH I'm firmly in the camp of if you have nothing to hide then its never an issue. If you're not guilty and there's nothing in the data that would prove otherwise its not an issue. If you are and the data will help prove your guilt then that's exactly why they should have access.
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
What about if they only think you've committed a crime? Should they be able to access your private data then? Quite agree. Information should only be available on the production of a warrant for that data and information. The blurring of the lines between how Security Services operate and how Law Enforcement operate, along with increasing collusion between them, is a bigger threat to society than terrorism is. Traditionally Security Services have operated in a manner distanced from general law enforcement, focusing entirely on counter-espionage and counter-terrorism - and as such they have operated under greater freedom, because they are not capable of bringing criminal charges, and focused entirely on real threats to national security. The US also has bad history for this, during the 60s and 70s, with the FBI's COINTPRO and similar schemes, rather than resolve genuine social problems.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Quite agree. Information should only be available on the production of a warrant for that data and information. The blurring of the lines between how Security Services operate and how Law Enforcement operate, along with increasing collusion between them, is a bigger threat to society than terrorism is. Traditionally Security Services have operated in a manner distanced from general law enforcement, focusing entirely on counter-espionage and counter-terrorism - and as such they have operated under greater freedom, because they are not capable of bringing criminal charges, and focused entirely on real threats to national security. The US also has bad history for this, during the 60s and 70s, with the FBI's COINTPRO and similar schemes, rather than resolve genuine social problems. Clearly it'd have to be obtained via a warrant and with justifiable suspicion. I'm not for the services having cart blanche access only in criminal cases. The simple answer for people who are against this is not to have a phone or electronic device; remove themselves from the web and go back to pen paper and talking to people face to face...it was only 25 years ago where this was the norm!
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Lyons550
TBH I'm firmly in the camp of if you have nothing to hide then its never an issue. If you're not guilty and there's nothing in the data that would prove otherwise its not an issue. If you are and the data will help prove your guilt then that's exactly why they should have access. Problem in the US system, is no one is trying to prove you are innocent. They're trying to prove you are guilty, and things like texts, phone logs are very good at making people look like conspirators, even when they have done nothing of the sort. The kind of information they'll obtain isn't about proof of guilt or innocence, its about making you appear more guilty. Both in the UK, and US, the typical approach to terrorism is to load defendents up with charges, so as to ensure one will stick, and then look to getting the best conviction they can. And in a 'Conspiracy to commit terrorism' charge its down to the defendant to prove themselves Not Guilty, the prosecution only has to demonstrate a basis of joint association with someone engaged in, or known terrorist (or individuals associated with a prohibited group etc). Its very very hard to prove you are innocent.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Also what the FBI is asking Apple to do, is to also remove functions that protect innocent people. For example, an iPhone can be set to delete all information on 10 failed logins. That's a massive feature for anyone who stores personal information on their phone (banking apps, cash points, purchase) It also can only be unlocked manually. You can't electronically unlock it. Which means you have 10,000 combinations, an ten attempts to get it right. Where as if you use an electronic intrusion system, you get 10,000 attempts to get 10,000 combinations, in a matter of minutes. The thing is, if Apple do this for the FBI, it won't be too long before the demanded exploits are being used criminally.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Lyons550
Clearly it'd have to be obtained via a warrant and with justifiable suspicion. I'm not for the services having cart blanche access only in criminal cases. The simple answer for people who are against this is not to have a phone or electronic device; remove themselves from the web and go back to pen paper and talking to people face to face...it was only 25 years ago where this was the norm! Having re-read the case, that's not what is happening here. The FBI want to force Apple to change functionality on their phones that restrict the FBI from obtaining information on any Apple phone. Not just this particular phone. With a warrant, Apple would be legally obliged to provide them with the data requested. But what the FBI seem to want is Apple to remove the lockout and non-electronic login systems from all their phones. Which also means they'd be more vulnerable to exploitation and hacking.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Problem in the US system, is no one is trying to prove you are innocent. They're trying to prove you are guilty, and things like texts, phone logs are very good at making people look like conspirators, even when they have done nothing of the sort. The kind of information they'll obtain isn't about proof of guilt or innocence, its about making you appear more guilty. Both in the UK, and US, the typical approach to terrorism is to load defendents up with charges, so as to ensure one will stick, and then look to getting the best conviction they can. And in a 'Conspiracy to commit terrorism' charge its down to the defendant to prove themselves Not Guilty, the prosecution only has to demonstrate a basis of joint association with someone engaged in, or known terrorist (or individuals associated with a prohibited group etc). Its very very hard to prove you are innocent. Absolutely right. The notion of 'if you've done nothing wrong, you've nothing to hide' is ridiculous because firstly, the 'state' should have absolutely no right whatsoever to access your private information unless it can prove to a court otherwise and even then the reasons need to be pretty f*cking compelling. Supporting such a notion gives carte-blanche to the use of covert surveillance. Secondly, as Jamie rightly points out, the use of information so acquired can be used to make you appear 'more guilty' (or at least cast doubts over your innocence) even if you haven't actually done anything wrong. The default position, in a so-called 'free society', must always be that the individual's right to privacy is utterly paramount and inviolable unless there is irrefutable evidence to the contraryand that the bar should be set very, very high to allow that principle to be overridden.
|
|
|
In this case 'The Terrorists' are dead so I really cant see what the problem is if this is a one off.
Pro USA & Israel |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Jimenez
In this case 'The Terrorists' are dead so I really cant see what the problem is if this is a one off. It isn't. They could obtain all the information held by Apple etc via a warrant. But what they are trying to do seems to be aimed at getting Apple to change access to their phone system to benefit law enforcement - which is at a consequential threat to their users.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Having re-read the case, that's not what is happening here. The FBI want to force Apple to change functionality on their phones that restrict the FBI from obtaining information on any Apple phone. Not just this particular phone. With a warrant, Apple would be legally obliged to provide them with the data requested. But what the FBI seem to want is Apple to remove the lockout and non-electronic login systems from all their phones. Which also means they'd be more vulnerable to exploitation and hacking. That's not how I read it. I understand it being a special one-off OS amendment, installed only on this one phone, to prevent it erasing itself after 10 incorrect passcodes, to allow them to do a blunt attack on the phone and keep trying passcodes until one works and the phone is unlocked
|
|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
Absolutely right. The notion of 'if you've done nothing wrong, you've nothing to hide' is ridiculous because firstly, the 'state' should have absolutely no right whatsoever to access your private information unless it can prove to a court otherwise and even then the reasons need to be pretty f*cking compelling. Supporting such a notion gives carte-blanche to the use of covert surveillance. Secondly, as Jamie rightly points out, the use of information so acquired can be used to make you appear 'more guilty' (or at least cast doubts over your innocence) even if you haven't actually done anything wrong. The default position, in a so-called 'free society', must always be that the individual's right to privacy is utterly paramount and inviolable unless there is irrefutable evidence to the contraryand that the bar should be set very, very high to allow that principle to be overridden. completely take on board the points that Jamie and you have made. However the stance that privacy should be paramount just in case there's a million to 1 shot that an individual could be wrongly locked up as a result is just as absurd as the "if you've nothing to hide then there's no issue". About the rights to privacy...they exist just simply done use services that store your data...that way you have the privacy. That's why I'd be open to a change in the terms and conditions for services that state if you are a slave to fashion and want the coolest device because everyone has it but don't want to retain your right to privacy then you have a choice...choose this product or don't...whats more important to you... I'm sure there would be a 'middle ground' found that both sides will agree to...this is just the start of the 'sparring'. Edited by Lyons550 (18 Feb 2016 2.59pm)
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Lyons550
completely take on board the points that Jamie and you have made. However the stance that privacy should be paramount just in case there's a million to 1 shot that an individual could be wrongly locked up as a result is just as absurd as the "if you've nothing to hide then there's no issue". Except its not a million to one chance at all. Even death row doesn't have a million to one ratio for innocent vs guilty. The problem is compounded by the fact it might take a year to get to trial, if you don't plead out (and get a criminal record). During which time you may lose your job. You'll also have to spend a fortune in legal fees, unless you want a public defender (who'll probably has little experience). In fact if you plead not guilty, you'll probably spend more than a few nights in lockup - waiting for the bail hearing, because the States Attorney will likely refuse. And lock up in US cities can be more dangerous than prison. The prosecution and police, once they've decided its you, will only present evidence towards your guilt. For many the option is plead guilty to something they wouldn't be proven guilty of, or face several nights in lock up, possible loss of employment and bankrupting legal costs. The legal system in the US is massively unfair to the poor and ordinary man. Originally posted by Lyons550
About the rights to privacy...they exist just simply done use services that store your data...that way you have the privacy. That's why I'd be open to a change in the terms and conditions for services that state if you are a slave to fashion and want the coolest device because everyone has it but don't want to retain your right to privacy then you have a choice...choose this product or don't...whats more important to you... Its not practical really to do that. I believe that sufficient provision exists in law that the Law Enforcement have sufficient power to pursue criminals and to protect the publics interest. Its impossible not to produce a digital footprint, which is why terrorists and criminals tend to go to very extreme lengths to 'hide in plain sight' or disappear. Plus do you know what happens to people who live like that, they get flagged up as terrorist suspects by algorithms, because they're also the kind of people who tend to obfuscate themselves within society, keep as low a profile online and digitally as possible. The lack of information and presence of information are both systems by which you detect 'suspects'. Plus, we 'champion freedom' and the idea of innocent until proven guilty, free speech and the right to avoid self incrimination. In fact the UK is one of the most monitored countries in the world. Cameras in the streets, security services monitoring emails, phone calls, spending patterns and so o The irony is that in the face of terrorism that promotes an impossible to achieve tyranny, we have massively surrendered the ideas of our own freedom and trust in the face of a very occasional fear. Originally posted by Lyons550
I'm sure there would be a 'middle ground' found that both sides will agree to...this is just the start of the 'sparring'. I would say the middle ground has long since been crossed in the US, thanks to the Patriot Act and mission creep, where by organisations like the NSA are routinely passing information on to other Federal Agencies that isn't of interest to the NSA - And said Federal Agencies creating 'pet Criminal Informants' to then legitimise the information. Essentially you have a situation where the government is effectively spying on its citizens, passing information on to other agencies about them, and they want more access. Governments should trust and respect the people they represent, target the guilty and promote the values that they extoll
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by npn
That's not how I read it. I understand it being a special one-off OS amendment, installed only on this one phone, to prevent it erasing itself after 10 incorrect passcodes, to allow them to do a blunt attack on the phone and keep trying passcodes until one works and the phone is unlocked Sounds expensive, as an IT contractor, I'd imagine that's not just a 'quick fix', given the phone is locked. Wonder what they want off of it. Basically, the FBI can't hack it. That's pretty sad given they've got a massive counter-terrorist and cybercrimes responsibility.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| Inapickle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Lyons550
Clearly it'd have to be obtained via a warrant and with justifiable suspicion. I'm not for the services having cart blanche access only in criminal cases. The simple answer for people who are against this is not to have a phone or electronic device; remove themselves from the web and go back to pen paper and talking to people face to face...it was only 25 years ago where this was the norm! ..arrhh blackmail.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Inapickle
..arrhh blackmail. Not at all is a choice
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
If a document was in a safe they'd have to break in, rather than ask the company who made it to crack it.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by npn
That's not how I read it. I understand it being a special one-off OS amendment, installed only on this one phone, to prevent it erasing itself after 10 incorrect passcodes, to allow them to do a blunt attack on the phone and keep trying passcodes until one works and the phone is unlocked I wouldn't like to be the intern who has to do that
interviewer " iggy , do you think you influenced anybody?" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.