You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > John McDonnell says -Trust Labour with the economy
November 22 2026 1.17am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

John McDonnell says -Trust Labour with the economy


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Hoof Hearted 12 Mar 16 10.01am

[Link]

.......mmmmmm..... should we?

And in other news - Gary Glitter and Rolf Harris say "Trust us with your children!"

Yeah..... right oh lads... we'll overlook the previous bad experiences and give it a whirl again.... LOL

-.-'

 

becky Flag over the moon 12 Mar 16 11.30am

Funny coincidence.....I was just reading about that this morning

[Link]


 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Hoof Hearted 12 Mar 16 11.52am

Originally posted by becky

Funny coincidence.....I was just reading about that this morning

[Link]


I didn't dare put a link to the Daily Mail becks.... that's why I chose the Guardian's report.

Bert the Head would have crucified me!

I expected the Mail to trash Labour on this, but interesting to note that the Guardian wasn't that positive either?

Says a lot about Corbyn's team and their credibility if a pro left paper isn't bigging them up on a story like this?

 

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 12 Mar 16 12.40pm

Hmmm. By the time of the next election, George Osbourne will have been in control of the economy for 10 years.

Perhaps time for the Tories to stand on their own merits, perhaps?

Let's see how far that would get them.

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Mar 16 4.20pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

[Link]

.......mmmmmm..... should we?

And in other news - Gary Glitter and Rolf Harris say "Trust us with your children!"

Yeah..... right oh lads... we'll overlook the previous bad experiences and give it a whirl again.... LOL

-.-'

Of course they also had the longest period of economic growth. The problem for labour, in terms of the economy was outside their control. Take the crunch out of the equation, and they were remarkably successful in terms of the economy.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 12 Mar 16 5.36pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Of course they also had the longest period of economic growth. The problem for labour, in terms of the economy was outside their control. Take the crunch out of the equation, and they were remarkably successful in terms of the economy.


Just don't leave them with any of your gold though eh?


Edited by Lyons550 (12 Mar 2016 5.36pm)

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

matt_himself Flag Matataland 12 Mar 16 5.38pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Of course they also had the longest period of economic growth. The problem for labour, in terms of the economy was outside their control. Take the crunch out of the equation, and they were remarkably successful in terms of the economy.

Interesting revision of history there.

They weren't 'remarkably successful in terms of the economy'. They rode a wave of a property boom and cheap credit plus inherited a structurally sound economy.

They failed because they over borrowed and has nothing in the tank for when the bust happened. Gordon Brown bragging that 'the era of boom and bust is over' was pure hubris.

The fact is that they got lucky and then were exposed. No amount of revisionist clap trap will change that.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 13 Mar 16 8.58am

Originally posted by Lyons550


Just don't leave them with any of your gold though eh?


Edited by Lyons550 (12 Mar 2016 5.36pm)

Or your pension......

 

Hoof Hearted 13 Mar 16 10.40am

Originally posted by matt_himself

Interesting revision of history there.

They weren't 'remarkably successful in terms of the economy'. They rode a wave of a property boom and cheap credit plus inherited a structurally sound economy.

They failed because they over borrowed and has nothing in the tank for when the bust happened. Gordon Brown bragging that 'the era of boom and bust is over' was pure hubris.

The fact is that they got lucky and then were exposed. No amount of revisionist clap trap will change that.

Labour have it in their DNA to overspend when in government.

Not one chancellor has left the books balanced when leaving office after a General Election defeat. In 2010 Liam Byrne left a note at the Treasury "jokingly" apologising for spending all the money...."

Fuller details here....

[Link]

And still the left think that Labour can be trusted with the economy...... Priceless.... -.-'

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 13 Mar 16 11.41am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Labour have it in their DNA to overspend when in government.

Not one chancellor has left the books balanced when leaving office after a General Election defeat. In 2010 Liam Byrne left a note at the Treasury "jokingly" apologising for spending all the money...."

Fuller details here....

[Link]

And still the left think that Labour can be trusted with the economy...... Priceless.... -.-'

Fullerer details here...

One of the most oft repeated "economic" arguments posited by Tory party supporters is the "didn't Labour leave a note admitting there was no money left?" question, which is often used in conjunction with the absurdly counter-factual "Labour bankrupted Britain" narrative.

The first thing to note about this question is that the note that was left by Liam Byrne saying that "there's no money" was intended as a joke, not as a serious statement of fact. The joke being a reiteration of the 1965 note left by the Tory Chancellor Reginald Maudling for his successor Jim Callaghan that said "good luck old cock, sorry to leave it in a mess".

If the crux of your economic argument is a joke note written five years ago by a fool like Liam Byrne, then it's absolutely clear that you don't have the faintest regard for genuine economic analysis, and prefer to rote learn economic fairy stories from the employees of right wing press barons like Rupert Murdoch (S*n, Times, Sky TV), Jonathan Harmsworth (Daily Mail, Metro), the Barclay brothers (Telegraph, Spectator) and RIchard Desmond (Express, Star).

It's hard to believe that anyone could be credulous enough to believe that the proposition that "there's no money" was an accurate one rather than a joke, but apparently lots of Tory supporters do, and even use it as the keystone of their argument in favour of reelecting the Conservatives!

It's hard to not feel like I'm being patronising in explaining what is to come in the next paragraph, but there are apparently a heck of a lot of Tories out there who honestly don't seem to understand this stuff.

The idea that there ever was "no money left" is a childlike fantasy. The United Kingdom has a central bank called the Bank of England that can just create new money out of nothing via a process known as Quantitative Easing. Since the global financial sector meltdown of 2007-08 the Bank of England has created £375 billion in this way. When a country has a sovereign central bank that can create new money, the idea that there is "no money left" is economic baby talk.

One of the things that this Tory reliance upon the "no money left" arguments illustrates is the incredible selectivity of the Tory mind. It seems that they have perfect recall of events in 2010 when it comes to stupid joke notes left in the treasury by an embodiment of uselessness like Liam Byrne, but when it comes to all of the promises and predictions made by Tory politicians back in 2010, they've managed to completely forget.

They can remember Liam Byrne's stupid note perfectly, but they can't seem to remember stuff like George Osborne promising not to raise VAT (then raising it just 2 months later), David Cameron promising "no more top-down reorganisations of the NHS" (then launching the biggest top-down reorganisation in the entire history of the NHS) and they can't remember George Osborne predicting his ideological austerity experiment would have completely eliminated the deficit by now (it hasn't even been halved).

Whenever you hear anyone use Liam Byrne's "there's no money" note as the crux of their economic argument, you can be absolutely sure that you're communicating with someone who is an economic illiterate who prefers to rote learn their opinions about the economy from the pages of the right-wing press in lieu of making the slightest effort to actually understand economic issues for themselves.

[Link]

 

Hoof Hearted 13 Mar 16 11.49am

Nice try Nick, but the electorate made up their mind about Labour's credentials to run our economy at the last election... they include normal working people, not just "Tories".

Like the little boy who cried Wolf - Labour will never shake off this tainted reputation of being reckless with our money.

And the final note of that extract you posted is so smug as to make me vomit - no one bases their opinions on one event like that note, but it is included within a raft of factors that demonstrate Labour's incompetence... eg Brown's Gold Gaffe, heralding an end to boom bust, Balls incomprehensible Budget responses... etc etc.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (13 Mar 2016 11.54am)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 13 Mar 16 12.45pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Fullerer details here...

One of the most oft repeated "economic" arguments posited by Tory party supporters is the "didn't Labour leave a note admitting there was no money left?" question, which is often used in conjunction with the absurdly counter-factual "Labour bankrupted Britain" narrative.

The first thing to note about this question is that the note that was left by Liam Byrne saying that "there's no money" was intended as a joke, not as a serious statement of fact. The joke being a reiteration of the 1965 note left by the Tory Chancellor Reginald Maudling for his successor Jim Callaghan that said "good luck old cock, sorry to leave it in a mess".

If the crux of your economic argument is a joke note written five years ago by a fool like Liam Byrne, then it's absolutely clear that you don't have the faintest regard for genuine economic analysis, and prefer to rote learn economic fairy stories from the employees of right wing press barons like Rupert Murdoch (S*n, Times, Sky TV), Jonathan Harmsworth (Daily Mail, Metro), the Barclay brothers (Telegraph, Spectator) and RIchard Desmond (Express, Star).

It's hard to believe that anyone could be credulous enough to believe that the proposition that "there's no money" was an accurate one rather than a joke, but apparently lots of Tory supporters do, and even use it as the keystone of their argument in favour of reelecting the Conservatives!

It's hard to not feel like I'm being patronising in explaining what is to come in the next paragraph, but there are apparently a heck of a lot of Tories out there who honestly don't seem to understand this stuff.

The idea that there ever was "no money left" is a childlike fantasy. The United Kingdom has a central bank called the Bank of England that can just create new money out of nothing via a process known as Quantitative Easing. Since the global financial sector meltdown of 2007-08 the Bank of England has created £375 billion in this way. When a country has a sovereign central bank that can create new money, the idea that there is "no money left" is economic baby talk.

One of the things that this Tory reliance upon the "no money left" arguments illustrates is the incredible selectivity of the Tory mind. It seems that they have perfect recall of events in 2010 when it comes to stupid joke notes left in the treasury by an embodiment of uselessness like Liam Byrne, but when it comes to all of the promises and predictions made by Tory politicians back in 2010, they've managed to completely forget.

They can remember Liam Byrne's stupid note perfectly, but they can't seem to remember stuff like George Osborne promising not to raise VAT (then raising it just 2 months later), David Cameron promising "no more top-down reorganisations of the NHS" (then launching the biggest top-down reorganisation in the entire history of the NHS) and they can't remember George Osborne predicting his ideological austerity experiment would have completely eliminated the deficit by now (it hasn't even been halved).

Whenever you hear anyone use Liam Byrne's "there's no money" note as the crux of their economic argument, you can be absolutely sure that you're communicating with someone who is an economic illiterate who prefers to rote learn their opinions about the economy from the pages of the right-wing press in lieu of making the slightest effort to actually understand economic issues for themselves.

[Link]

And I thought comedy was dead.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 13 Mar 16 12.49pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Of course they also had the longest period of economic growth. The problem for labour, in terms of the economy was outside their control. Take the crunch out of the equation, and they were remarkably successful in terms of the economy.

In large part due to the Tories in the previous administrations.

See how easy it is?

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 13 Mar 16 1.47pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Fullerer details here...

One of the most oft repeated "economic" arguments posited by Tory party supporters is the "didn't Labour leave a note admitting there was no money left?" question, which is often used in conjunction with the absurdly counter-factual "Labour bankrupted Britain" narrative.

The first thing to note about this question is that the note that was left by Liam Byrne saying that "there's no money" was intended as a joke, not as a serious statement of fact. The joke being a reiteration of the 1965 note left by the Tory Chancellor Reginald Maudling for his successor Jim Callaghan that said "good luck old cock, sorry to leave it in a mess".

If the crux of your economic argument is a joke note written five years ago by a fool like Liam Byrne, then it's absolutely clear that you don't have the faintest regard for genuine economic analysis, and prefer to rote learn economic fairy stories from the employees of right wing press barons like Rupert Murdoch (S*n, Times, Sky TV), Jonathan Harmsworth (Daily Mail, Metro), the Barclay brothers (Telegraph, Spectator) and RIchard Desmond (Express, Star).

It's hard to believe that anyone could be credulous enough to believe that the proposition that "there's no money" was an accurate one rather than a joke, but apparently lots of Tory supporters do, and even use it as the keystone of their argument in favour of reelecting the Conservatives!

It's hard to not feel like I'm being patronising in explaining what is to come in the next paragraph, but there are apparently a heck of a lot of Tories out there who honestly don't seem to understand this stuff.

The idea that there ever was "no money left" is a childlike fantasy. The United Kingdom has a central bank called the Bank of England that can just create new money out of nothing via a process known as Quantitative Easing. Since the global financial sector meltdown of 2007-08 the Bank of England has created £375 billion in this way. When a country has a sovereign central bank that can create new money, the idea that there is "no money left" is economic baby talk.

One of the things that this Tory reliance upon the "no money left" arguments illustrates is the incredible selectivity of the Tory mind. It seems that they have perfect recall of events in 2010 when it comes to stupid joke notes left in the treasury by an embodiment of uselessness like Liam Byrne, but when it comes to all of the promises and predictions made by Tory politicians back in 2010, they've managed to completely forget.

They can remember Liam Byrne's stupid note perfectly, but they can't seem to remember stuff like George Osborne promising not to raise VAT (then raising it just 2 months later), David Cameron promising "no more top-down reorganisations of the NHS" (then launching the biggest top-down reorganisation in the entire history of the NHS) and they can't remember George Osborne predicting his ideological austerity experiment would have completely eliminated the deficit by now (it hasn't even been halved).

Whenever you hear anyone use Liam Byrne's "there's no money" note as the crux of their economic argument, you can be absolutely sure that you're communicating with someone who is an economic illiterate who prefers to rote learn their opinions about the economy from the pages of the right-wing press in lieu of making the slightest effort to actually understand economic issues for themselves.

[Link]

Typical liberal lefty elitist boll1cks. "if you dont agree with us you're to stupid to understand". Guess what vast swaithes of the electorate understood all to well that labour policy an the economy had us going to hell in a hand cart and had enough.

Not stupid, just not blinkered.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Sportyteacher Flag London 13 Mar 16 3.42pm

Originally posted by becky

Funny coincidence.....I was just reading about that this morning

[Link]


And who trusts the Daily Mail....the paper guilty of more court settlements than any other news paper re: mistruths

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 13 Mar 16 4.07pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Fullerer details here...

One of the most oft repeated "economic" arguments posited by Tory party supporters is the "didn't Labour leave a note admitting there was no money left?" question, which is often used in conjunction with the absurdly counter-factual "Labour bankrupted Britain" narrative.

The first thing to note about this question is that the note that was left by Liam Byrne saying that "there's no money" was intended as a joke, not as a serious statement of fact. The joke being a reiteration of the 1965 note left by the Tory Chancellor Reginald Maudling for his successor Jim Callaghan that said "good luck old cock, sorry to leave it in a mess".

If the crux of your economic argument is a joke note written five years ago by a fool like Liam Byrne, then it's absolutely clear that you don't have the faintest regard for genuine economic analysis, and prefer to rote learn economic fairy stories from the employees of right wing press barons like Rupert Murdoch (S*n, Times, Sky TV), Jonathan Harmsworth (Daily Mail, Metro), the Barclay brothers (Telegraph, Spectator) and RIchard Desmond (Express, Star).

It's hard to believe that anyone could be credulous enough to believe that the proposition that "there's no money" was an accurate one rather than a joke, but apparently lots of Tory supporters do, and even use it as the keystone of their argument in favour of reelecting the Conservatives!

It's hard to not feel like I'm being patronising in explaining what is to come in the next paragraph, but there are apparently a heck of a lot of Tories out there who honestly don't seem to understand this stuff.

The idea that there ever was "no money left" is a childlike fantasy. The United Kingdom has a central bank called the Bank of England that can just create new money out of nothing via a process known as Quantitative Easing. Since the global financial sector meltdown of 2007-08 the Bank of England has created £375 billion in this way. When a country has a sovereign central bank that can create new money, the idea that there is "no money left" is economic baby talk.

One of the things that this Tory reliance upon the "no money left" arguments illustrates is the incredible selectivity of the Tory mind. It seems that they have perfect recall of events in 2010 when it comes to stupid joke notes left in the treasury by an embodiment of uselessness like Liam Byrne, but when it comes to all of the promises and predictions made by Tory politicians back in 2010, they've managed to completely forget.

They can remember Liam Byrne's stupid note perfectly, but they can't seem to remember stuff like George Osborne promising not to raise VAT (then raising it just 2 months later), David Cameron promising "no more top-down reorganisations of the NHS" (then launching the biggest top-down reorganisation in the entire history of the NHS) and they can't remember George Osborne predicting his ideological austerity experiment would have completely eliminated the deficit by now (it hasn't even been halved).

Whenever you hear anyone use Liam Byrne's "there's no money" note as the crux of their economic argument, you can be absolutely sure that you're communicating with someone who is an economic illiterate who prefers to rote learn their opinions about the economy from the pages of the right-wing press in lieu of making the slightest effort to actually understand economic issues for themselves.

[Link]


But really, the fact that the numbers were far worse than anyone outside the Treasury and Ministers realised, isn't funny is it?

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 13 Mar 16 4.42pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Fullerer details here...

One of the most oft repeated "economic" arguments posited by Tory party supporters is the "didn't Labour leave a note admitting there was no money left?" question, which is often used in conjunction with the absurdly counter-factual "Labour bankrupted Britain" narrative.

The first thing to note about this question is that the note that was left by Liam Byrne saying that "there's no money" was intended as a joke, not as a serious statement of fact. The joke being a reiteration of the 1965 note left by the Tory Chancellor Reginald Maudling for his successor Jim Callaghan that said "good luck old cock, sorry to leave it in a mess".

If the crux of your economic argument is a joke note written five years ago by a fool like Liam Byrne, then it's absolutely clear that you don't have the faintest regard for genuine economic analysis, and prefer to rote learn economic fairy stories from the employees of right wing press barons like Rupert Murdoch (S*n, Times, Sky TV), Jonathan Harmsworth (Daily Mail, Metro), the Barclay brothers (Telegraph, Spectator) and RIchard Desmond (Express, Star).

It's hard to believe that anyone could be credulous enough to believe that the proposition that "there's no money" was an accurate one rather than a joke, but apparently lots of Tory supporters do, and even use it as the keystone of their argument in favour of reelecting the Conservatives!

It's hard to not feel like I'm being patronising in explaining what is to come in the next paragraph, but there are apparently a heck of a lot of Tories out there who honestly don't seem to understand this stuff.

The idea that there ever was "no money left" is a childlike fantasy. The United Kingdom has a central bank called the Bank of England that can just create new money out of nothing via a process known as Quantitative Easing. Since the global financial sector meltdown of 2007-08 the Bank of England has created £375 billion in this way. When a country has a sovereign central bank that can create new money, the idea that there is "no money left" is economic baby talk.

One of the things that this Tory reliance upon the "no money left" arguments illustrates is the incredible selectivity of the Tory mind. It seems that they have perfect recall of events in 2010 when it comes to stupid joke notes left in the treasury by an embodiment of uselessness like Liam Byrne, but when it comes to all of the promises and predictions made by Tory politicians back in 2010, they've managed to completely forget.

They can remember Liam Byrne's stupid note perfectly, but they can't seem to remember stuff like George Osborne promising not to raise VAT (then raising it just 2 months later), David Cameron promising "no more top-down reorganisations of the NHS" (then launching the biggest top-down reorganisation in the entire history of the NHS) and they can't remember George Osborne predicting his ideological austerity experiment would have completely eliminated the deficit by now (it hasn't even been halved).

Whenever you hear anyone use Liam Byrne's "there's no money" note as the crux of their economic argument, you can be absolutely sure that you're communicating with someone who is an economic illiterate who prefers to rote learn their opinions about the economy from the pages of the right-wing press in lieu of making the slightest effort to actually understand economic issues for themselves.

[Link]

Ahhh...the very Tory press barons still not paying their tax. Add to Barclay Bros. 'The Ritz' that they own where Thatcher spent her final months and ...hey ho, no tax again either.

 

Hoof Hearted 14 Mar 16 9.50am

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

And who trusts the Daily Mail....the paper guilty of more court settlements than any other news paper re: mistruths

I notice you never mentioned my link in the first post from the Guardian - saying pretty much the same stuff about this as the Daily Mail.

I used the Guardian link because I knew lefty dreamers like you would have criticised my source if it was a right wing paper and I was right wasn't I.

Priceless........-.-'

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 14 Mar 16 11.37am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

In large part due to the Tories in the previous administrations.

See how easy it is?

Probably true to an extent, given that New Labour adopted a right of centre position, and favoured corporations over the electorate.

However, one could argue, if the Conservatives were doing such a good job, they wouldn't have suffered such a humiliating defeat in 1997.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 14 Mar 16 11.40am

Originally posted by Mr_Gristle

Hmmm. By the time of the next election, George Osbourne will have been in control of the economy for 10 years.

Perhaps time for the Tories to stand on their own merits, perhaps?

Let's see how far that would get them.

Notably, in that 10 year period, the Conservatives would probably rank far behind Gordon Brown's period in the treasury. Credit where credits due, one of the countries longest periods of economic prosperity was under New Labour.

Then again, the myth of generations, is that Government actually have any control over the economy of the UK, at best they have minor influence - arguably New Labour just did what the Conservatives did, and will do, appeal to the financial markets and corporations over the needs of the electorate.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > John McDonnell says -Trust Labour with the economy