You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > West Ham Pen - MOTD analysis
November 22 2026 8.41pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

West Ham Pen - MOTD analysis


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 17 Apr 16 10.58pm

I assume Shearer was moaning as much about the Watford penalty Jedi gave away as much as he was moaning about West Hams pen against Leicester today. He was saying as it was 34th game it shouldn't be a pen as Leicester had been fouling people in the box at corners all season long with nothing given.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Apr 16 11.19pm

I mentioned to someone recently Leicester have been getting lucky with refs when discussing our luck with refs and he had no idea. Huth has been very lucky/used his experience this season. That's why he didn't get the pen that should've been when he was grabbed round the chest from behind. The ref then realised he'd messed that and gave a pen for a non foul by Carroll. League 1 ref just about made the match result correct.

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Apr 16 11.28pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I mentioned to someone recently Leicester have been getting lucky with refs when discussing our luck with refs and he had no idea. Huth has been very lucky/used his experience this season. That's why he didn't get the pen that should've been when he was grabbed round the chest from behind. The ref then realised he'd messed that and gave a pen for a non foul by Carroll. League 1 ref just about made the match result correct.

Huth said himself that he didn't think the incident warranted a penalty.

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 18 Apr 16 7.06am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I mentioned to someone recently Leicester have been getting lucky with refs when discussing our luck with refs and he had no idea. Huth has been very lucky/used his experience this season. That's why he didn't get the pen that should've been when he was grabbed round the chest from behind. The ref then realised he'd messed that and gave a pen for a non foul by Carroll. League 1 ref just about made the match result correct.

I was just incredulous that Shearer was moaning about it when a virtually identical set of incidents happened at Selhurst against Watford, minus the soft pen for us in the last minute.

 

richard shaw (og)65 Flag my minds eye 18 Apr 16 12.23pm

the ref did get the vardy dive spot on though , but the carroll pen decision was a shocker but as some one else said he was evening it up which is shiiite

 


interviewer " iggy , do you think you influenced anybody?"
iggy pop " I think I wiped out the 60`S "

johnny the eagle Flag wivenhoe 18 Apr 16 12.36pm

As reported on the BBC sports web site, Andy Carroll was supposed to have said the ref gave leicester their last penalty to even things up. I tend to agree with Andy Carroll, the ref was weak and lost his bottle throughout the game. Carroll will get done by the old fossils in the F. A. for speaking the truth.

 


South London born and bred
red and blue till im dead.

Stuk Flag Top half 18 Apr 16 12.47pm

To be fair to Huth Dann took his shirt off and we didn't get penalised.

The ref had a terrible game all round at Leicester v Wham though.

 


Optimistic as ever

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Apr 16 12.48pm

Originally posted by johnny the eagle

As reported on the BBC sports web site, Andy Carroll was supposed to have said the ref gave leicester their last penalty to even things up. I tend to agree with Andy Carroll, the ref was weak and lost his bottle throughout the game. Carroll will get done by the old fossils in the F. A. for speaking the truth.

I really don't think he can be accused of being "Weak" after awarding a penalty against the home team and deciding Vardy was guilty of simulation which of course led to his dismissal.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 18 Apr 16 12.53pm

Originally posted by Willo

I really don't think he can be accused of being "Weak" after awarding a penalty against the home team and deciding Vardy was guilty of simulation which of course led to his dismissal.

You can, because he then gave some of it back to the home team with an extremely weak penalty, in the last minute.

 


Optimistic as ever

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Apr 16 1.00pm

Originally posted by Stuk

You can, because he then gave some of it back to the home team with an extremely weak penalty, in the last minute.

We have NO idea what was in the mindset of the referee apropos the late penalty but what we DO know is that he awarded some key decisions against the Home team and the reaction of the Leicester supporters was not one of positivity towards the official ! He certainly never "Bottled" the decisions against Morgan and Vardy !

 

Stuk Flag Top half 18 Apr 16 1.34pm

Originally posted by Willo

We have NO idea what was in the mindset of the referee apropos the late penalty but what we DO know is that he awarded some key decisions against the Home team and the reaction of the Leicester supporters was not one of positivity towards the official ! He certainly never "Bottled" the decisions against Morgan and Vardy !

Yes we do. I've watched football enough to know when the ref gives an "I've f***ed up here, I'd better give them something" decision.

He did it with the Wham penalty as he should of given the earlier one, then he did it again with the last minute one for not giving the Huth one.

The only good decision he made was the 2nd Vardy yellow. The rest was terrible.

PGMO should be like a rolling stone and gather no Moss.

 


Optimistic as ever

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Apr 16 2.13pm

Originally posted by Stuk


Yes we do. I've watched football enough to know when the ref gives an "I've f***ed up here, I'd better give them something" decision.

This is all speculation. We really don't know what was in the mindset of the referee.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 18 Apr 16 2.28pm

Originally posted by Willo

This is all speculation. We really don't know what was in the mindset of the referee.

No it isn't. Giving that penalty to the home side in the last minute after a plethora of bad decisions is weakness, plain and simple.

The earlier ones you could label mistakes, but the last one was a "get me out of this" decision.

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Apr 16 2.35pm

Referee made two questionable decisions, one which benefitted West Ham, one that benefitted Leicester. Most of us would be happy with that.

The issue Leicester fans have is with Vardy being sent off. It was an excellent decision. Vardy engineered the foul to get a penalty and a certain red card advantage, then went down theatrically, and rightly got booked. Then abused the referee.

The person Leicester fans should be angry with isn't the referee, its Vardy. He was on a yellow, and dived, and could face further sanction for then having a hissy fit at the referee.

Both of Vardy's cards were yellow card offences. The second yellow, the referee either gives a penalty and red card, or a second yellow for simulation. There isn't really an alternative.

West Ham, might well feel aggrieved at the penalty, but then they were utterly robbed against Arsenal the week before, and no one seemed to care. I thought it was soft, but f**k it, they happen - And Leicester probably should have had a penalty five to ten minutes before hand.

The problem the referee created for himself, was letting far too much go early in the game.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Apr 16 2.40pm

Originally posted by Stuk

No it isn't. Giving that penalty to the home side in the last minute after a plethora of bad decisions is weakness, plain and simple.

The earlier ones you could label mistakes, but the last one was a "get me out of this" decision.

See it quite a lot though, a referee doesn't give a penalty they probably should have, and then gives a soft one, that they probably wouldn't have done.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 18 Apr 16 3.13pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Referee made two questionable decisions, one which benefitted West Ham, one that benefitted Leicester. Most of us would be happy with that.

The issue Leicester fans have is with Vardy being sent off. It was an excellent decision. Vardy engineered the foul to get a penalty and a certain red card advantage, then went down theatrically, and rightly got booked. Then abused the referee.

The person Leicester fans should be angry with isn't the referee, its Vardy. He was on a yellow, and dived, and could face further sanction for then having a hissy fit at the referee.

Both of Vardy's cards were yellow card offences. The second yellow, the referee either gives a penalty and red card, or a second yellow for simulation. There isn't really an alternative.

West Ham, might well feel aggrieved at the penalty, but then they were utterly robbed against Arsenal the week before, and no one seemed to care. I thought it was soft, but f**k it, they happen - And Leicester probably should have had a penalty five to ten minutes before hand.

The problem the referee created for himself, was letting far too much go early in the game.

Both sets of fans seem to be in agreement that the only decision the ref got right was Vardy's second yellow.

 


Optimistic as ever

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Apr 16 3.19pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Both sets of fans seem to be in agreement that the only decision the ref got right was Vardy's second yellow.

Wes Morgan didn't complain when a penalty was awarded against him so this would suggest that it was the right decision.

Edited by Willo (18 Apr 2016 3.19pm)

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 18 Apr 16 3.25pm

Originally posted by Willo

Wes Morgan didn't complain when a penalty was awarded against him so this would suggest that it was the right decision.

Edited by Willo (18 Apr 2016 3.19pm)

The club blocked Morgan from talking to the press after the game for fear of him getting himself into trouble.

Andy Carroll also quoted Morgan saying to him; "He doesn't know what he's doing, he's been bad all game." [Link]

Hardly the actions of someone who felt it was the right decision.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 18 Apr 16 3.26pm

Originally posted by Willo

Wes Morgan didn't complain when a penalty was awarded against him so this would suggest that it was the right decision.

Edited by Willo (18 Apr 2016 3.19pm)

Oh yeah.

That well known body language of hands on his head in utter disbelief really backs up your assertation.

[Link]

Stop blindly trying to defend a referee that has cocked up.

 


Optimistic as ever

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Apr 16 3.35pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Oh yeah.

That well known body language of hands on his head in utter disbelief really backs up your assertation.

[Link]

Stop blindly trying to defend a referee that has cocked up.

I think he was absolutely right to award a penalty for the Morgan incident, indeed both Morgan and Huth had been warned beforehand about their grappling in the box.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > West Ham Pen - MOTD analysis