This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Podyonkers
As we've seen lately, discussions about the manager seem to bring about a lot of tension and disagreement. Some love Pardew, some don't. But I wonder if we should be talking about the length of time we should be giving any manager of the club? Say what you will about Arsenal and Wenger, they have enjoyed a sustained period of competence/excellence. Man U. stuck with Ferguson, and were greatly rewarded for it - and they have struggled for stability ever since he left. Contrast that with, say, Newcastle or Villa who can't ever stick with a manager, and it seems to me that it's a good idea to aim for continuity. Let's say for the sake of argument we are not talking about Pardew but about any manager: how long is too long if we are struggling? Do we stick with a manager no matter what, or get rid of them if everything goes too far South? Personally, I have a lot of patience (and hope). But I understand if others are more demanding - that is not a bad thing. For me, I would stay with a manager even through relegation. I would be okay with allowing a manager to stay as long as they brought us right back up. After that, I'd knock it on the head and start again. The same could also be said of Moyes during his long spell at Everton. As is always the case during a long stint there are peaks and troughs...but that's largely due to the time it takes for a Manager to stamp his own identity on a club, its playing style, staff and recruitment.
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
Originally posted by Lyons550
The same could also be said of Moyes during his long spell at Everton. As is always the case during a long stint there are peaks and troughs...but that's largely due to the time it takes for a Manager to stamp his own identity on a club, its playing style, staff and recruitment. But as we know, managers are not afforded this "Time".
|
|
|
Originally posted by Podyonkers
As we've seen lately, discussions about the manager seem to bring about a lot of tension and disagreement. Some love Pardew, some don't. But I wonder if we should be talking about the length of time we should be giving any manager of the club? Say what you will about Arsenal and Wenger, they have enjoyed a sustained period of competence/excellence. Man U. stuck with Ferguson, and were greatly rewarded for it - and they have struggled for stability ever since he left. Contrast that with, say, Newcastle or Villa who can't ever stick with a manager, and it seems to me that it's a good idea to aim for continuity. Let's say for the sake of argument we are not talking about Pardew but about any manager: how long is too long if we are struggling? Do we stick with a manager no matter what, or get rid of them if everything goes too far South? Personally, I have a lot of patience (and hope). But I understand if others are more demanding - that is not a bad thing. For me, I would stay with a manager even through relegation. I would be okay with allowing a manager to stay as long as they brought us right back up. After that, I'd knock it on the head and start again. For what it's worth, and before anyone comes in with an emotive opinion, I completely agree with you. I'm more in the pro-Pardew camp than the anti, he still has a lot to do to prove himself in my eyes, but, like you, I agree with being a bit patient.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lyons550
The same could also be said of Moyes during his long spell at Everton. As is always the case during a long stint there are peaks and troughs...but that's largely due to the time it takes for a Manager to stamp his own identity on a club, its playing style, staff and recruitment. Yes, there are peaks and troughs and as a manager has a good season so any seasons after that where a club doesn't do as well then some fans aren't pleased but they would of been before that good season, the bar goes higher to what is deemed a successful season, especially now with social media. Wenger being a good example. A lot of the time the manager is in a no-win situation.
The pyramid to beat all pyramids!! Find out what team is in which division, eg which division is Coppull United in? |
|
|
With Fergie he was given a fair amount of time, but if he had continued to struggle at the beginning (and not beat us in the Cup), there's no way he would have last 20 odd years. Same for Wenger. I think it helps to be patient but to be patient you need to trust your manager that they have some sort of plan to improve things. Ideally you have a model like Southampton where regardless of the manager you have a consistent recruitment policy for players and try to get similar managers in. I've heard they always have a list of managers that can replace their current one if he leaves for whatever reason. The amount of player and manager turnover they've had in the last 5 years and continue to be the best of the rest in the prem is amazing.
Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link] Twitter: [Tweet Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by victor43
With Fergie he was given a fair amount of time, but if he had continued to struggle at the beginning (and not beat us in the Cup), there's no way he would have last 20 odd years. Same for Wenger. I think it helps to be patient but to be patient you need to trust your manager that they have some sort of plan to improve things. Ideally you have a model like Southampton where regardless of the manager you have a consistent recruitment policy for players and try to get similar managers in. I've heard they always have a list of managers that can replace their current one if he leaves for whatever reason. The amount of player and manager turnover they've had in the last 5 years and continue to be the best of the rest in the prem is amazing. In terms of managers they have had 4 managers in the last 5 years : Adkins, Pochettino, Koeman and now Puel. Their 'Director of football', Les Reed does very well behind the scenes. Also they have the infrastructure in place : Good ground, academy, scouting, analysis etc etc. Edited by Willo (23 Sep 2016 10.35am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
But as we know, managers are not afforded this "Time". I think that was the point the OP was making to be honest
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
Originally posted by Lyons550
I think that was the point the OP was making to be honest Yes I know the point he was making.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Selhurstboys
No league win since 2003/4 for Wenger. Ok they've won 2 FA cups in recent years but imo Arsenal would have done better with a change. It's tough but club owners can't be sentimental with who and when they appoint a manager. Wenger lasts because he runs it like a business, makes them a profit and never complains to the press that he needs more money, in fact does the opposite and claims there is money but he doesn't want to use it. He's pretty unique in that way.
|
|
|
the benzema deal keeps falling through because wengers been spending so much on wilsheres ps4 games
|
|
|
Originally posted by citizensmudge
If you haven't designed this to kick off another anti vs pro Pardew borefest then you must be new here or just felt like having some "Thank F@ck Its Friday" amusement for the day.I'm off to bed but I look forward to seeing where this has ended up later depending on whether someone is stupid enough to light the blue touch paper.Have a nice day everyone No, mate. Wow. If anything, I was bringing it up to try and calm the conversation not inflame it. I meant in light of all the arguing about the manager, maybe we should look at it differently and think about how much time we should give any manager. Sorry if it didn't come off that way.
Stealing their women and eating their food since 1987. |
|
| citizensmudge |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Podyonkers
No, mate. Wow. If anything, I was bringing it up to try and calm the conversation not inflame it. I meant in light of all the arguing about the manager, maybe we should look at it differently and think about how much time we should give any manager. Sorry if it didn't come off that way. I wasn't having a go at you I was just expecting it to descend into another pro/anti Pardew thread like so many that have gone before.You really don't have anything to apologise for if anything it should be me as I was wide of the mark on this occasion
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.