You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mr Zaha,,,, A word,,please.
November 16 2026 11.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Mr Zaha,,,, A word,,please.


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Glazier#1 Flag 01 Nov 16 9.56pm

Wilf? Defend? I wish he would!

I tell you, I am seriously worried on that score.

It's a modern game and I think he needs to realise that he cannot afford to switch off defensively the way he has been doing.

He ball-watched and lost his attacker for the first goal on Saturday and I even saw him half turn his back on the shot for Leicester's third strike.

I remember Gabbidon turning his back on a shot - it is never good.

Lackadaisical is indeed the word.

I want to see Zaha acting in a far more mature and professional way.

Stop whinging, look sharp on and off the ball and be a man.

You're not a starlet anymore.

(dons helmet).

 

Eewires Flag Guildford 01 Nov 16 10.11pm

Originally posted by Glazier#1

Wilf? Defend? I wish he would!

I tell you, I am seriously worried on that score.

It's a modern game and I think he needs to realise that he cannot afford to switch off defensively the way he has been doing.

He ball-watched and lost his attacker for the first goal on Saturday and I even saw him half turn his back on the shot for Leicester's third strike.

I remember Gabbidon turning his back on a shot - it is never good.

Lackadaisical is indeed the word.

I want to see Zaha acting in a far more mature and professional way.

Stop whinging, look sharp on and off the ball and be a man.

You're not a starlet anymore.

(dons helmet).

Don't think he's bad, but if he wants to see how it should be done he should watch Victor Moses performance against Soton om Sunday.

 

Mad4palace Flag 01 Nov 16 10.15pm

Zaha does far more defensive work than Townsend. He's come on leaps and bounds in terms of his defensive application. I don't recall him being at fault for any of the goals on Saturday. He ducked out of blocking for the Fuchs goal against Leicester but Tomkins practically dived away from the ball which was far worse.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 01 Nov 16 10.37pm

Hiya Mad4.

On Saturday I think that Wilf lost his man who then was left to cross in for the goal. Ball watching and losing his man.

And yes; it may not have been as bad as the Tomkins effort but 'duck out' he did.

I just feel he needs to liven up all round, if I'm honest,

Mind you - great cross into jimmy mac for the goal. That is what we need to see more of; bright, penetrating; not languid and sulking.

Edited by Glazier#1 (01 Nov 2016 10.39pm)

 

bicycle repair man 01 Nov 16 10.48pm

Wilf has matured into an excellent footballer with a little help from Super Al.
He works his socks off every time,and he really cares.
If all the players showed the same commitment we'd have no problems.
I'm astonished that some fans find time to criticise him.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 02 Nov 16 3.50am

Disagree I think he's come on leaps and bounds with his defensive efforts.

I was actually thinking on Saturday, I wish he'd have a go more often.

He now seems to pass backwards and infield a lot...whereas naturally he'd want to get into the full back and take him on. That's the Wilf we know and love.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 02 Nov 16 6.46am

On the contrary, I wish he would be relieved of defensive duties. Look at Chelsea with Hazard, he struggled for over a year until Conte had the wisdom to implement a system which has given him the defensive freedom to flourish and he has been virtually the best player in the league recently as a result. Well, we're not Chelsea and Zaha isn't Hazard but he remains our most creative outlet by a mile and I'd like to see Pardew set the team up with the intention of letting Wilf express himself without having to worry about getting back and defending.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 02 Nov 16 7.18am

Originally posted by Eewires

Don't think he's bad, but if he wants to see how it should be done he should watch Victor Moses performance against Soton om Sunday.


I'd hope he defended a bit as conte is using him as a wing back.

 

kennys boots 79 Flag Keston 02 Nov 16 9.02am

Originally posted by Eewires

Don't think he's bad, but if he wants to see how it should be done he should watch Victor Moses performance against Soton om Sunday.

The problem is Zaha's build. Too lanky and not enough leg strength. Antonio and Moses have a lot of of that, and a build similar to say Kenny Sansom (back in the 80's!) is ideal for a wing back. You could have had a go with Bolasie as a wing back as he has the all round body strength, but don't think he'll ever have the fitness to do constant shutlles back and forth. The same with Wilf really.

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 02 Nov 16 9.11am

I agree that the defensive side of his game has improved however, a few times of late, he's got a block or tackle in but not then chased down the loose ball despite it being within his range. He did it a couple of times against the bin-dippers & could have been away if he'd just kept going & nicked the ball past Moreno (their weakest defender).

That said, as a team we don't seem to be winning the second ball as much as we used to.

Edited by Nobbybm (02 Nov 2016 9.11am)

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

victor43 Flag St. Albans 02 Nov 16 9.33am

Some of these comments are just crazy.

Of course he's not going to be as defensive as Moses in that Chelsea system - he's not playing as a wing back.

Yes he had a couple of defensive lapses where he switched off for half a second, but that happens a lot and he was unfortunate that he was punished for it. There were a lot of other occasions where Palace players switched off but Liverpool didnt quite put the ball in the back of the net.

His defending and tracking back has come on leaps and bounds - he is averaging 3 successful tackles a game and more than one interception. He definitely is putting in the work.

Plus he is by far our most creative player in open play, we are very lucky to have him. Tbh I hope he keeps going under the radar as he could play at a better team than ours.

Someone also mentioned he needs to get back to his natural game and take players on - in the last 2 games he had 11 completed dribbles vs Leicester and 7 vs Liverpool - he is one of the most prolific dribblers in the league

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 02 Nov 16 9.44am

He needs to work on his strength a bit more. Yannick is a much stronger player and holds players off well. Wilf goes down quite often. Dont think he is too bad regarding his defensive duties, its hardwork getting up and down the line when you use the pace he has.

 

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 02 Nov 16 11.03am

If we're really going to call him out on losing his man for the first goal let's say that McArthur also didn't track Can who scored.

But we shouldn't do either, it happens and they both more than made up for it at the other end of the pitch. For me, Zaha has improved so much this year, he's learning when to pass, dribble, cross and shoot. It's the last bit of his game that really needed to make the step up for him to be a top Prem player.

I voted for him as POTY last year despite his faults, feels like this year is his year that he's going to really push on. 1 goal and 3 assists in 8 games, keep it up Wilf.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

slubglurge Flag welling 02 Nov 16 11.43am

Originally posted by We are goin up!

If we're really going to call him out on losing his man for the first goal let's say that McArthur also didn't track Can who scored.

But we shouldn't do either, it happens and they both more than made up for it at the other end of the pitch. For me, Zaha has improved so much this year, he's learning when to pass, dribble, cross and shoot. It's the last bit of his game that really needed to make the step up for him to be a top Prem player.

I voted for him as POTY last year despite his faults, feels like this year is his year that he's going to really push on. 1 goal and 3 assists in 8 games, keep it up Wilf.

Correct. McArthur did not pick up the scorer (Can) and he also failed to pick up Lanzini for W Hams winner too. He needs to work on the defensive side more than Wilf does

 

Glazier#1 Flag 02 Nov 16 3.50pm

Thanks for all the responses. Some great comments written without biting my head off which is a relief, for sure.

It looks like I'm in a minority of one on this point, doesn't it?

I do agree that Wilf has improved his game over the last couple of seasons and he makes the right choice more often these days, without a doubt.

However, I do stick with my assertion about his defending. Some may well say that he shouldn't be defending, we should concentrate on his strong points.

That's all very well but the game has changed enormously recently and sides are producing teams that press with more intensity when the other team are in possession. With Wilf I feel that it is not enough to simply go to your man and stand in front of them; the presence needs to be more urgent and 'in your face'. These days, once you lose the offensive role, the whole team must assume defensive duties even if your biggest strength is an attacker.

I know that our lad has gained a reputation as one who goes down easily and to some extent I agree. I've become so used to seeing those knitted eyebrows and the constant looking around because it's all so unfair. This is part of his game that he needs to lose, in my opinion.

This young man has talent to burn but I feel he needs to up his profile considerably if he wishes to progress to the next level.

 

victor43 Flag St. Albans 02 Nov 16 3.55pm

Originally posted by Glazier#1

Thanks for all the responses. Some great comments written without biting my head off which is a relief, for sure.

It looks like I'm in a minority of one on this point, doesn't it?

I do agree that Wilf has improved his game over the last couple of seasons and he makes the right choice more often these days, without a doubt.

However, I do stick with my assertion about his defending. Some may well say that he shouldn't be defending, we should concentrate on his strong points.

That's all very well but the game has changed enormously recently and sides are producing teams that press with more intensity when the other team are in possession. With Wilf I feel that it is not enough to simply go to your man and stand in front of them; the presence needs to be more urgent and 'in your face'. These days, once you lose the offensive role, the whole team must assume defensive duties even if your biggest strength is an attacker.

I know that our lad has gained a reputation as one who goes down easily and to some extent I agree. I've become so used to seeing those knitted eyebrows and the constant looking around because it's all so unfair. This is part of his game that he needs to lose, in my opinion.

This young man has talent to burn but I feel he needs to up his profile considerably if he wishes to progress to the next level.

So he frowns to much for you and needs to 'up his profile'. What does this even mean?

His defending is good these days. Just switched off a couple times. We have much bigger issues than Wilf's defending

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

Glazier#1 Flag 02 Nov 16 4.50pm

What does this even mean?

Well, it's not about just having a frown, is it? He is not 'frowning too much for me', as you put it. It is the general demeanour of doing the sulk and feeling hard done by rather than getting on with the game in a professional manner and that, my friend, is what the 'profile' is all about.

I think he needs to up his professionalism.

Particularly, he needs to be in the opponents face a lot more when we are on the offensive, to be more urgent and intense in his tracking back, not losing concentration and his man, being less languid when he is on the ball in an attacking mode and looking more urgent and bright when on the ball.

We may have 'much bigger issues than Wilf's defending' but that doesn't mean that he doesn't have issues, does it? Not fulfilling defensive duties effectively and even turning away from an incoming shot may seem like small beer to you, my friend but we are obviously not cut from the same cloth.

Just because he has improved does that mean he can't improve further and get to where he wants? ie right to the top. Because, believe me, it may not bother you but it will bother other potential managers.

And if Wilf really wants to progress then he certainly does need to up his profile, if I dare use that phrase now that we've established what I mean.

Are you clear about what I mean now?

Edited by Glazier#1 (02 Nov 2016 4.52pm)

 

cpj Flag Kent 02 Nov 16 5.17pm

Three assists already this season, which about equals the whole of last season. Needs to improve his scoring rat though. Has had quite a few efforts but keeps shooting from the angle at the keeper's near post where it is very hard to beat him. Instead, needs to shoot across the keeper.

 

bicycle repair man 02 Nov 16 8.47pm

Wilf shines again

IMG_20161102_204324.jpg Attachment: IMG_20161102_204324.jpg (79.77Kb)

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 02 Nov 16 10.48pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

Wilf has matured into an excellent footballer with a little help from Super Al.
He works his socks off every time,and he really cares.
If all the players showed the same commitment we'd have no problems.
I'm astonished that some fans find time to criticise him.

No end product

 


Bring back Brolin

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mr Zaha,,,, A word,,please.