You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 3-5-2 formation, God I hate it.....
November 16 2026 10.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

3-5-2 formation, God I hate it.....


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
mattteo Flag 21 Jan 17 5.10pm

Every wannabe manager who wants to claim "I changed something" goes from the 4 back line to the 5 back back line. If it worked for Juventus and, until now, for Chelsea, it doesn't mean it will work for everyone.
Juventus dominates an Italian football because they spend the most money, they could play whatever system. In Alegri's first year they played 4-4-2 and still came first (with a midfield of Pirlo, Marchisio, Pogba and Vidal)

This 3-5-2 formation basically puts in an extra center back. That's it. You take out an attacking player and put in an extra central defender. Not even a side defender, but a CENTRAL DEFENDER. It's a great tactic when you meet better teams, when you play qualifying matches or away games.

But when you play in a championship and you'd rather have a win and a loss from 2 games instead of 2 draws (cause 3 points are better than 2) then having an extra center back in the first 11 is not what you want.

What was the team against Everton? No Townsend or Zaha, Remy came on and Tomkins got a start. Notice? Remy for Townsend, offensive player for offensive player. Tomkins for Zaha, defensive player for offensive player.

Yes, Schlupp was a great improvement from Ward, because he's basically a left wing and Ward wasn't even left footed.

Whoever was around in 2002 remembers that this had happened before. The Italian teams were highly regarded and their 5 defenders system was exported in all the world. Pretty much every team at the 2002 World Cup played 3-5-2.

But after that....everyone woke up. People saw that teams scored a lot less. Everywhere. So pretty much every team gave up that extra defender for an extra attacking man.

It doesn't work for Sunderland, it doesn't work for Hull, it doesn't work for Watford.
It only works for Chelsea and it's been recently tried at Everton too, though we'll see in the long term. They have very offensive fullbacks though in Baines and Coleman.

 

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 21 Jan 17 5.13pm

Get lost, admins can you just give this guy his second yellow and ban him?

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 21 Jan 17 5.13pm

Our Back 4 has been the main reason we are where we are, trying to sure it up with an extra man and matching the team you're playing makes sense and to be fair it did work whilst the game was 11 v 11.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

tonymikejoe Flag UK 21 Jan 17 5.32pm

Zaha was not dropped today.

Who is this fool?

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 21 Jan 17 5.49pm

Are you ever going to say anything positive. I thought the system worked really well for us today and we almost got a point against a very good everton side who put 4 past city last week. What was more important to me was that every player gave 10% today and were shattered at the end. Something I haven't seen for a long while. If we play like we did today against the 'lower ' reams I feel confident we will pick up points.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 21 Jan 17 5.52pm

Probably not the long-term solution for us but it seriously improved us today. We're trying to force our measly squad into an optimal line-up and today we got our best 11 onto the pitch.

 

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 21 Jan 17 5.58pm

Thought we looked good at 3-5-2. Was only when Remy went off knackered we had to go back to the usual s*** scared suicidal deep defending and looked s***e again.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 21 Jan 17 6.02pm

If this is the way we are going to play then Wilf will be the right wing back so i think Townsend will leave in the window. There is no place for him with this system

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 21 Jan 17 6.03pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Every wannabe manager who wants to claim "I changed something" goes from the 4 back line to the 5 back back line. If it worked for Juventus and, until now, for Chelsea, it doesn't mean it will work for everyone.
Juventus dominates an Italian football because they spend the most money, they could play whatever system. In Alegri's first year they played 4-4-2 and still came first (with a midfield of Pirlo, Marchisio, Pogba and Vidal)

This 3-5-2 formation basically puts in an extra center back. That's it. You take out an attacking player and put in an extra central defender. Not even a side defender, but a CENTRAL DEFENDER. It's a great tactic when you meet better teams, when you play qualifying matches or away games.

But when you play in a championship and you'd rather have a win and a loss from 2 games instead of 2 draws (cause 3 points are better than 2) then having an extra center back in the first 11 is not what you want.

What was the team against Everton? No Townsend or Zaha, Remy came on and Tomkins got a start. Notice? Remy for Townsend, offensive player for offensive player. Tomkins for Zaha, defensive player for offensive player.

Yes, Schlupp was a great improvement from Ward, because he's basically a left wing and Ward wasn't even left footed.

Whoever was around in 2002 remembers that this had happened before. The Italian teams were highly regarded and their 5 defenders system was exported in all the world. Pretty much every team at the 2002 World Cup played 3-5-2.

But after that....everyone woke up. People saw that teams scored a lot less. Everywhere. So pretty much every team gave up that extra defender for an extra attacking man.

It doesn't work for Sunderland, it doesn't work for Hull, it doesn't work for Watford.
It only works for Chelsea and it's been recently tried at Everton too, though we'll see in the long term. They have very offensive fullbacks though in Baines and Coleman.

Number 1, it frees up more attacking wingbacks which suits Schlupp down to the ground and Ward has his moments going forwards. For a team leaking goals it adds an extra man whilst defending but also allowed us to play 2 strikers and keep a relatively solid midfield.

Number 2, we were playing a better team who also deployed the same system so we tried to nullify them whilst getting our strongest 11 out. On both counts it worked until we were down to 10 but then, 10 vs 11 is always a disadvantage.

All in all, whether you like the system or not we stopped a form team, who had banged 4 goals past one of the best in the league, from battering us and nearly got a vital point that we desperately need.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Aray Flag South London 21 Jan 17 6.08pm

I sometimes wonder about the posters on here. We have no left back of any quality and it's clearly been a problem all season. Playing 3 at the back provides a solution. Jeez

 

Happiness Stan Flag Itchycoo Park 21 Jan 17 6.20pm

One of my favourite palace squads played 3-5-2 under Harry Bassett back in the 90s. Lovely football we played then. Hopkin was on fire that season behind the front two.

 


"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"

MR200% Flag 21 Jan 17 6.26pm

Best display by Palace I've seen from ages Heart and soul ,Players looked very comfortable with the setup Remy and Benteke will score goals for us in that set up

 

mattteo Flag 21 Jan 17 6.44pm

Originally posted by MR200%

Best display by Palace I've seen from ages Heart and soul ,Players looked very comfortable with the setup Remy and Benteke will score goals for us in that set up

LOL, yeah....that's why there was 1 shot on target the entire 90 minutes

 

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 21 Jan 17 7.06pm

Originally posted by mattteo

LOL, yeah....that's why there was 1 shot on target the entire 90 minutes

That just means our shooting was s***.we had 8 goal attempts and 8 corners.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 21 Jan 17 7.35pm

Originally posted by mattteo

LOL, yeah....that's why there was 1 shot on target the entire 90 minutes

You're wrong. Again

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 21 Jan 17 7.59pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

You're wrong. Again

Don't...he gets....touchy

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 21 Jan 17 8.01pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

You're wrong. Again

Yep needs to get his facts right...
I seriously can't see how anyone doesn't think this was a much better performance today. When you look at the way we played against Swansea and West ham, this was miles better. If we play like this against bournemouth Sunderland and Middlesborough we will surely pick up ppints. ..

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 21 Jan 17 8.03pm

Originally posted by mattteo

LOL, yeah....that's why there was 1 shot on target the entire 90 minutes

Is that why the BBC and the commentators said two? Also, one shot hit the post too.

[Link]

Was your latest claim like your previous one, about knowing for a fact that there were over 200+ players who were unhappy?

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 21 Jan 17 8.04pm

Originally posted by Icepick Tony

Don't...he gets....touchy

I'd not noticed that.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

mattteo Flag 21 Jan 17 9.29pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Are you ever going to say anything positive.


Sure, when I'll see positive things.

 

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 3-5-2 formation, God I hate it.....