You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is the Premier league all its cracked up to be?
November 16 2026 10.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is the Premier league all its cracked up to be?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Simon Jordan for PM Flag London 06 Feb 17 12.52pm

All the money we are earning as a club seems to be going into players' pockets and apart from anew training ground under soil heating and some new lights what have we got to show from our income generated in this league, not much!

Paying underperforming players vast amounts of money who have little or no affinity with the club is it any surprise we are in the position we are in? Despite having a player like Kai Kai on the periphery he is still not being given a chance instead Palace opt to stick with Puncheon why?

Taking a beating at home every week is not fun st least in the championship we will be able to blood our youngsters and okay players who want to play for the badge.

Relegation to the championship will not be all bad. The premier league is not the land of milk and honey everyone makes it out to be. 99% of people currently at palace just want to get as much money out of club as possible and if we are relegated will simply move on to another club to bleed dry.

Players,managers, owners, relegations, promotions and cup runs will come and go but the fans will remain do not lose sight of they!

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 06 Feb 17 12.58pm

If we get relegated, our squad will get picked apart, our club will be in immense financial jeopardy, and the club's infrastructure will go backwards.

I don't know why so many people love proclaiming that relegation will somehow cleanse this club for the better. It requires a complete mental block of how things actually were in the Championship.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 06 Feb 17 1.11pm

Originally posted by Bangell

If we get relegated, our squad will get picked apart, our club will be in immense financial jeopardy, and the club's infrastructure will go backwards.

I don't know why so many people love proclaiming that relegation will somehow cleanse this club for the better. It requires a complete mental block of how things actually were in the Championship.

I couldn't have put it better myself. As I've posted previously, if we are relegated it won't be like previous occasions, with a benevolent owner prepared to throw good money after bad. We now have multiple owners, at least two thirds of whom are in it to make a profit and, let's face it, three out of the original four weren't slow to reduce their holdings when the Americans came knocking. We wouldn't have the investment to 'do a Newcastle'; we'd be in real trouble with a League One infrastructure and I fear what the future would hold.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Painter Flag Croydon 06 Feb 17 1.58pm

Originally posted by Simon Jordan for PM

All the money we are earning as a club seems to be going into players' pockets and apart from anew training ground under soil heating and some new lights what have we got to show from our income generated in this league, not much!

Paying underperforming players vast amounts of money who have little or no affinity with the club is it any surprise we are in the position we are in? Despite having a player like Kai Kai on the periphery he is still not being given a chance instead Palace opt to stick with Puncheon why?

Taking a beating at home every week is not fun st least in the championship we will be able to blood our youngsters and okay players who want to play for the badge.

Relegation to the championship will not be all bad. The premier league is not the land of milk and honey everyone makes it out to be. 99% of people currently at palace just want to get as much money out of club as possible and if we are relegated will simply move on to another club to bleed dry.

Players,managers, owners, relegations, promotions and cup runs will come and go but the fans will remain do not lose sight of they!

What is the point of the Championship being in existence?

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 06 Feb 17 2.02pm

Lets be fare here, Parish and the owners have invested into the playing squad. They are all assetts. Some will of course go down but others will go up. Parachute payments will kick in so they will have the oney for the wages. Hardest part will be the majority of the team will probably be sold and we would need to rebuild. Pretty much like Villa and other relegated teams have to.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 06 Feb 17 2.03pm

Originally posted by Painter

What is the point of the Championship being in existence?

It's a league for second rate clubs to play in.

I know this because I've read it here many times that (insert name) found his level in the Championship as he just wasn't good enough to play in the top league

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 06 Feb 17 2.11pm

We would still have, on paper, a far stronger squad than most teams. We'd need to find about 40m (I would guess) to balance things out a bit, and Wilf is going regardless this summer, in my opinion. So that's 25m-30m right there.

The yanks are rich enough and smart enough not to accept a fire sale, or to accept players' requests to move just because they want to get back in the PL. They would act in their own financial interests, which would not include selling assets below what the otherwise could.

So it would come down to management of that squad. A few years of mismanagement and things really really could get hairy to the point of deep financial trouble.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Painter Flag Croydon 06 Feb 17 2.40pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

It's a league for second rate clubs to play in.

I know this because I've read it here many times that (insert name) found his level in the Championship as he just wasn't good enough to play in the top league

Is it the place where there are no greedy players, everyone is playing with pride and passion for the shirt. All teams are fielding as many youngsters as possible, nobody worrying about winning, as they don't want to go up into that nasty Premier League.
All the managers jobs are safe, as they are working for friendly old chairmen in sheepskins, who are bankrolling the club as a hobby with no ambition.
Why would any team ever want to leave as it sounds a fantastic place to be!

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 06 Feb 17 2.53pm

i agree that the premier league may sometimes be a poisoned chalice.

but when you reflect upon our population base, our wealthy housing market and hence wealthy fans buying season tickets ( compared to Stoke/middlesboro etc) and the demise of Millwall and Charlton.....

we deserve to be as big as West Ham / Newcastle / Sunderland / Everton etc.

North London manages to support 2 big prem clubs.

anything less than this and we are underperforming.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 06 Feb 17 9.16pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

i agree that the premier league may sometimes be a poisoned chalice.

but when you reflect upon our population base, our wealthy housing market and hence wealthy fans buying season tickets ( compared to Stoke/middlesboro etc) and the demise of Millwall and Charlton.....

we deserve to be as big as West Ham / Newcastle / Sunderland / Everton etc.

North London manages to support 2 big prem clubs.

anything less than this and we are underperforming.

It does, but down here you've got most people supporting either: Arsenal, Man Utd, Chelsea, Spurs or Liverpool, with a few West Ham thrown in the mix. I don't know what it was like back in the day, but I'll hazard a guess of Sky televising all of those games as having some impact.

To put this into perspective, when I left my all boys school in 2013, I was one of only 10ish Palace fans in the year (of 160)... and of that 10, I'd say 3 or 4 supported us and Man Utd or something.

The day after the Man Utd game this season, I went for a run around where I live wearing a Palace shirt, and some 14 year old made one of those "hurr Man Utd" noises in my direction. Sums up the sad state of English football at the moment.

Edited by Dan1994 (06 Feb 2017 9.18pm)

 


[Link]

bicycle repair man 06 Feb 17 9.24pm

There are plenty of greedy players in the Championship.
As for the Premier League it of course has plenty of faults but I would much prefer to stay there.
What is the alternative? To play in the Championship for eternity and avoid getting promotion every season.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Feb 17 9.52pm

Originally posted by bubble wrap

Lets be fare here, Parish and the owners have invested into the playing squad. They are all assetts. Some will of course go down but others will go up. Parachute payments will kick in so they will have the oney for the wages. Hardest part will be the majority of the team will probably be sold and we would need to rebuild. Pretty much like Villa and other relegated teams have to.

All the worthless players will be out of contract and out and all the players teams might want will be under contract. Financially beneficial until......

We won't be in a Villa situation with loads of cr&p nobody wants but we will have to rebuild the side and endure the 1st part of the season of them gelling. The worst might happen 3years from relegation if nobody buys the likes of Benteke and takes his £130k wage off us.

We will lose any quality:

Dann
Cabaye
MacArthur
Zaha
Townsend
PVA or Schlupp

all gone.

Then the unwanted and out of contract all going.

Hennessey
Ledley
Delaney
Puncheon (is he out of contract this June?)
Campbell
Mutch

Yep the Championship will be welcome. Instead of losing a 5 a side team we'll be losing 11 and completely changing the whole team strategy. Yeah we'll be enjoying it every second. Have a think again.

 


COYP

bashy2 Flag London 06 Feb 17 10.01pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

All the worthless players will be out of contract and out and all the players teams might want will be under contract. Financially beneficial until......

We won't be in a Villa situation with loads of cr&p nobody wants but we will have to rebuild the side and endure the 1st part of the season of them gelling. The worst might happen 3years from relegation if nobody buys the likes of Benteke and takes his £130k wage off us.

We will lose any quality:

Dann
Cabaye
MacArthur
Zaha
Townsend
PVA or Schlupp

all gone.

Then the unwanted and out of contract all going.

Hennessey
Ledley
Delaney
Puncheon (is he out of contract this June?)
Campbell
Mutch

Yep the Championship will be welcome. Instead of losing a 5 a side team we'll be losing 11 and completely changing the whole team strategy. Yeah we'll be enjoying it every second. Have a think again.


Do you really think we will lose that many players I would of thought 4 max

 

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 06 Feb 17 10.01pm

Originally posted by bubble wrap

Lets be fare here, Parish and the owners have invested into the playing squad. They are all assetts. Some will of course go down but others will go up. Parachute payments will kick in so they will have the oney for the wages. Hardest part will be the majority of the team will probably be sold and we would need to rebuild. Pretty much like Villa and other relegated teams have to.

We would certainly lose the following:

Benteke; Townsend; Zaha; Cabaye; Van Anholt; Schlupp; Milivojevic; Mandanda; Flamini and of course Sakho and Remy.

We might possibly also lose McArthur, Souare, Sako, Wickham and Lee.

Maybe I'm being a little pessimistic but seems a possibility to me - that's 14 of our current 25 plus two currently injured.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 06 Feb 17 10.04pm

Originally posted by Direwolf

We would certainly lose the following:

Benteke; Townsend; Zaha; Cabaye; Van Anholt; Schlupp; Milivojevic; Mandanda; Flamini and of course Sakho and Remy.

We might possibly also lose McArthur, Souare, Sako, Wickham and Lee.

Maybe I'm being a little pessimistic but seems a possibility to me - that's 14 of our current 25 plus two currently injured.

And campbell as his contract expires in june

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Direwolf Flag Lincoln 06 Feb 17 10.28pm

Originally posted by paperhat

And campbell as his contract expires in june

Would Palace offer a new contract if we were in the Championship?

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 06 Feb 17 10.42pm

Originally posted by Bangell

If we get relegated, our squad will get picked apart, our club will be in immense financial jeopardy, and the club's infrastructure will go backwards.

I don't know why so many people love proclaiming that relegation will somehow cleanse this club for the better. It requires a complete mental block of how things actually were in the Championship.

This is why i wished we kept the mentality 'we are lucky to be in this league, let's do our best to stay in here and develop the club'.

What does that mean? Gradually updating the playing squad, looking to getting to 40pts as quickly as possible, staying grounded and not let hype go to our head.
Then with extra money, focus on youth set up and the club infrastructure.

Where did we go wrong (hindsight is a wonderful thing) - talk of Europe, signing Bentekke for 30 million, saying that Cabaye was the bench mark people need to play at and be at to get his wages. Talk of transitions, wanting to pay free flowing attractive football.

If we had the mentality of securing status as quickly as possible and enjoying a good cup run.

You got to get a stable, defensive unit - draw every game you stay up, it's that simple, you win, you can afford a loss, i am being basic but you understand the 'pulis' philosophy.

Ward, Damo and Papa all should have had back ups this summer, it wouldn't broken the bank.

Pardew and Parish were each others own worst enemies.

 


This was once a quality forum....

meatpienz Flag brisbane 06 Feb 17 10.43pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

All the worthless players will be out of contract and out and all the players teams might want will be under contract. Financially beneficial until......

We won't be in a Villa situation with loads of cr&p nobody wants but we will have to rebuild the side and endure the 1st part of the season of them gelling. The worst might happen 3years from relegation if nobody buys the likes of Benteke and takes his £130k wage off us.

We will lose any quality:

Dann
Cabaye
MacArthur
Zaha
Townsend
PVA or Schlupp

all gone.

Then the unwanted and out of contract all going.

Hennessey
Ledley
Delaney
Puncheon (is he out of contract this June?)
Campbell
Mutch

Yep the Championship will be welcome. Instead of losing a 5 a side team we'll be losing 11 and completely changing the whole team strategy. Yeah we'll be enjoying it every second. Have a think again.

I think Puncheon signed a 3 year contract recently.

 


Zaha has some green grass in front of him here. Finds Ambrose
not a bad effort ooooooooooh! what a goal by Darren Ambrose absolutely stunning strike!!! And, Crystal Palace lead @ Old Trafford.

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 06 Feb 17 11.17pm

Originally posted by Vaibow

This is why i wished we kept the mentality 'we are lucky to be in this league, let's do our best to stay in here and develop the club'.

What does that mean? Gradually updating the playing squad, looking to getting to 40pts as quickly as possible, staying grounded and not let hype go to our head.
Then with extra money, focus on youth set up and the club infrastructure.

Where did we go wrong (hindsight is a wonderful thing) - talk of Europe, signing Bentekke for 30 million, saying that Cabaye was the bench mark people need to play at and be at to get his wages. Talk of transitions, wanting to pay free flowing attractive football.

If we had the mentality of securing status as quickly as possible and enjoying a good cup run.

You got to get a stable, defensive unit - draw every game you stay up, it's that simple, you win, you can afford a loss, i am being basic but you understand the 'pulis' philosophy.

Ward, Damo and Papa all should have had back ups this summer, it wouldn't broken the bank.

Pardew and Parish were each others own worst enemies.

That's what I hoped for. Stability. 'Learn to walk before you run.' I liked the way we played under Pardew, but he tried to get us running with joggers. We weren't ready. A nice idea, but far too early. If we stay in this league, I will despair, as I did last time, of talk about playing in Europe. That makes us as bad as all the other teams fans slagged off on here. Deluded, with a sense of entitlement.

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (06 Feb 2017 11.18pm)

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Feb 17 11.24pm

Originally posted by Vaibow

This is why i wished we kept the mentality 'we are lucky to be in this league, let's do our best to stay in here and develop the club'.

What does that mean? Gradually updating the playing squad, looking to getting to 40pts as quickly as possible, staying grounded and not let hype go to our head.
Then with extra money, focus on youth set up and the club infrastructure.

Where did we go wrong (hindsight is a wonderful thing) - talk of Europe, signing Bentekke for 30 million, saying that Cabaye was the bench mark people need to play at and be at to get his wages. Talk of transitions, wanting to pay free flowing attractive football.

If we had the mentality of securing status as quickly as possible and enjoying a good cup run.

You got to get a stable, defensive unit - draw every game you stay up, it's that simple, you win, you can afford a loss, i am being basic but you understand the 'pulis' philosophy.

Ward, Damo and Papa all should have had back ups this summer, it wouldn't broken the bank.

Pardew and Parish were each others own worst enemies.

Too much sense. Go and watch 35 mins of every Pardew 2nd half to skew your view again.

 


COYP

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is the Premier league all its cracked up to be?