You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Labour and immigration
November 21 2026 11.59pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Labour and immigration


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 23 Feb 17 2.55pm

Why oh why do people keep saying that Labour are the party of mass immigration?

[Link]
Telegraph 2014
Also more up to date...

Enforced removals from the UK decreased by 8% to 11,637 in year ending March 2016 compared with the previous 12 month period (12,661).

In the year ending March 2016, there were 13,193 enforced returns. This includes 11,637 enforced removals and 1,556 other returns from detention. For more information see the Enforced returns section below.

The number of passengers refused entry at port and who subsequently departed has increased by 9% in year ending March 2016, to 17,752 from 16,302 in year ending March 2015. The number of passengers refused entry at port and subsequently departing has been increasing slowly since 2012.

In the year ending March 2016, provisional data show there were 5,692 returns of foreign national offenders (FNOs), using enforcement powers or via deportation. This was an 8% increase on the previous year (5,277). from [Link]

These figures are a lot lower than under the last labour lot.

 

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 23 Feb 17 4.21pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Why oh why do people keep saying that Labour are the party of mass immigration?

[Link]
Telegraph 2014
Also more up to date...

Enforced removals from the UK decreased by 8% to 11,637 in year ending March 2016 compared with the previous 12 month period (12,661).

In the year ending March 2016, there were 13,193 enforced returns. This includes 11,637 enforced removals and 1,556 other returns from detention. For more information see the Enforced returns section below.

The number of passengers refused entry at port and who subsequently departed has increased by 9% in year ending March 2016, to 17,752 from 16,302 in year ending March 2015. The number of passengers refused entry at port and subsequently departing has been increasing slowly since 2012.

In the year ending March 2016, provisional data show there were 5,692 returns of foreign national offenders (FNOs), using enforcement powers or via deportation. This was an 8% increase on the previous year (5,277). from [Link]

These figures are a lot lower than under the last labour lot.

Maybe because in 1997 net migration was 48,000 a year and rose rapidly, almost trebling in one year to 140,000 in 1998. It didn't to fall below 100,000 again. Between 1997 and 2010 (the New Labour years) net migration averaged 200,000 per year, five times higher than under the Major government of 1990-1996. The rate of inflow between 1997 and 2010 equated to one migrant arriving every minute.

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Feb 17 4.30pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Why oh why do people keep saying that Labour are the party of mass immigration?

[Link]
Telegraph 2014
Also more up to date...

Enforced removals from the UK decreased by 8% to 11,637 in year ending March 2016 compared with the previous 12 month period (12,661).

In the year ending March 2016, there were 13,193 enforced returns. This includes 11,637 enforced removals and 1,556 other returns from detention. For more information see the Enforced returns section below.

The number of passengers refused entry at port and who subsequently departed has increased by 9% in year ending March 2016, to 17,752 from 16,302 in year ending March 2015. The number of passengers refused entry at port and subsequently departing has been increasing slowly since 2012.

In the year ending March 2016, provisional data show there were 5,692 returns of foreign national offenders (FNOs), using enforcement powers or via deportation. This was an 8% increase on the previous year (5,277). from [Link]

These figures are a lot lower than under the last labour lot.

Don't make this about party politics again. Labour will lose Stoke and loads of other seats until they put the existing populations needs before the needs of immigrants.
They clearly don't.
Until governments start putting the majorities interests above the minority and people's quality of life above corporate interests, they are all in for a rough ride.
Mind you, Labour won't have to worry about being in government any time soon while Corbyn is trying to win the Derek Hatton Award for most unelectable party.

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 23 Feb 17 4.41pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Don't make this about party politics again. Labour will lose Stoke and loads of other seats until they put the existing populations needs before the needs of immigrants.
They clearly don't.
Until governments start putting the majorities interests above the minority and people's quality of life above corporate interests, they are all in for a rough ride.
Mind you, Labour won't have to worry about being in government any time soon while Corbyn is trying to win the Derek Hatton Award for most unelectable party.

And if Labour don't lose Stoke? I think they're more likely to lose Copeland aren't they?

Especially with Nuttall's "problems".*

It's fair enough people thinking Labour are the part of mass immigration really because the largest immigration obviously started under them. Under the coalition and Tories it has arguably become "worse", but Labour still started it.

*It's pretty low to claim you lost friends and even were at Hillsbrough when you weren't. Even now he claims he was there, when his friends from the time and teachers all say he never mentioned it and was never thought to have been there.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Feb 17 4.48pm

Originally posted by OknotOK

And if Labour don't lose Stoke? I think they're more likely to lose Copeland aren't they?

Especially with Nuttall's "problems".*

It's fair enough people thinking Labour are the part of mass immigration really because the largest immigration obviously started under them. Under the coalition and Tories it has arguably become "worse", but Labour still started it.

*It's pretty low to claim you lost friends and even were at Hillsbrough when you weren't. Even now he claims he was there, when his friends from the time and teachers all say he never mentioned it and was never thought to have been there.

Labour should easily be winning by elections at the moment and the fact that they are sweating on Stoke is an indication of their catastrophic standing.

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 23 Feb 17 5.04pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Labour should easily be winning by elections at the moment and the fact that they are sweating on Stoke is an indication of their catastrophic standing.

Not disagreeing with that but you said "Labour will lose Stoke". I'm not so sure they will - although you never know with polling being as it is - and if they don't I'm asking whether that calls into question the remainder of your conclusion?

It may not but I will be interested to hear the narrative on Jeremy Corbyn if they win both by-elections. It would actually be a decent achievement, but not sure it will be reported as such.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Pussay Patrol Flag 23 Feb 17 5.37pm

Originally posted by OknotOK

Not disagreeing with that but you said "Labour will lose Stoke". I'm not so sure they will - although you never know with polling being as it is - and if they don't I'm asking whether that calls into question the remainder of your conclusion?

It may not but I will be interested to hear the narrative on Jeremy Corbyn if they win both by-elections. It would actually be a decent achievement, but not sure it will be reported as such.

How will it be an achievement? It's been a safe labour seat since the beginning of time

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Feb 17 7.01pm

Originally posted by OknotOK

Not disagreeing with that but you said "Labour will lose Stoke". I'm not so sure they will - although you never know with polling being as it is - and if they don't I'm asking whether that calls into question the remainder of your conclusion?

It may not but I will be interested to hear the narrative on Jeremy Corbyn if they win both by-elections. It would actually be a decent achievement, but not sure it will be reported as such.

It really wont. It would normally be a minimum expectation in mid term. If they don't win convincingly they will surely be obliterated in the next general election

 

nobody Flag sussex 23 Feb 17 7.33pm

Great response Hedgehog.

It seems to have silenced our resident red !!

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 23 Feb 17 9.10pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

It really wont. It would normally be a minimum expectation in mid term. If they don't win convincingly they will surely be obliterated in the next general election

I disagree. Given

- they were sitting in second or third in polls on both constituencies at points
- they have been surrounded by possibly self fulfilling doom prophecies from the likes of yourself, the media, and moderate lefties like myself
- both MPs resigned deliberately to try and put pressure on citry and damage him
- the party is still struggling to come to terms with is post Brexit ideology
- they're facing an apparently strong UKIP

In light of the above retaining both seats (no idea if they'll do it or not) would represent a moderate success and definitely something they could build on.

Losing both seats would be a disaster. Winning both can only be seen as a success.

Edited by OknotOK (23 Feb 2017 9.11pm)

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

legaleagle Flag 23 Feb 17 9.36pm

Originally posted by hedgehog50

Maybe because in 1997 net migration was 48,000 a year and rose rapidly, almost trebling in one year to 140,000 in 1998. It didn't to fall below 100,000 again. Between 1997 and 2010 (the New Labour years) net migration averaged 200,000 per year, five times higher than under the Major government of 1990-1996. The rate of inflow between 1997 and 2010 equated to one migrant arriving every minute.

The Governments,of course,in the post war era that were in power during the greatest % increase in immigration (something that overall has greatly enriched our country not to mention kept the NHS going for 60 years) were The Tories, when it rose by over 4,500% from 1953-62.

 

elgrande Flag bedford 23 Feb 17 9.50pm

Originally posted by legaleagle

The Governments,of course,in the post war era that were in power during the greatest % increase in immigration (something that overall has greatly enriched our country not to mention kept the NHS going for 60 years) were The Tories, when it rose by over 4,500% from 1953-62.

Really I just looked at some figures,and between 1953 till 1962,the population rose from 50 million to 53 million....now I have never been any good at maths,but that doesn't sound like 4,500%

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Feb 17 9.56pm

Originally posted by legaleagle

The Governments,of course,in the post war era that were in power during the greatest % increase in immigration (something that overall has greatly enriched our country not to mention kept the NHS going for 60 years) were The Tories, when it rose by over 4,500% from 1953-62.

It was a total cluster f*** of policies.
Not training more British doctors and nurses. Not encouraging women to have more children in the wake of two world wars and a rapid decline in the post war birth rate. Failing to plan for an aging population and forcing wide scale immigration on a population who never wanted it.

 

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 23 Feb 17 10.01pm

Originally posted by legaleagle

The Governments,of course,in the post war era that were in power during the greatest % increase in immigration (something that overall has greatly enriched our country not to mention kept the NHS going for 60 years) were The Tories, when it rose by over 4,500% from 1953-62.

Dear oh dear, 4,500%! From what? From a negligible figure for immigration pre-war.
The total immigration figure for the period 1953-1962 was around 450,000. The current figure per year is around 330,000.
During the period 1953-62, medical staff in the NHS were never more than 5%, hardly 'kept the NHS going'.
Goodness knows what the meaning of 'something that overall has greatly enriched our country ' is.


Edited by hedgehog50 (23 Feb 2017 10.03pm)

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

legaleagle Flag 23 Feb 17 11.51pm

You haven't invalidated my point...The genesis of mass immigration was a Tory concept...and it's only because of that that the NHS has kept going as it has until now (now 26% of doctors,Stephen Nickell, who is on the board of the Office for Budget Responsibility, suggested 35% of "health professionals" came from outside the UK)...

The primary driver for widespread increased EU immigration in more recent years (which is what seems to exercise the minds of so many of those against immigration) was the expansion of the EU eastwards...who was one of the main proponents of that..oh yes,our old friend,Tory Maggie.

In your desire to do down "labour/the left" don't be blind to anything that makes your picture a little more complex and multi-party than the one you painted before...

If you are simply saying immigration has also at times gone up under a Labour government,I wouldn't disagree and nothing I posted is contrary to that...

If you don't understand the meaning (as opposed to agreeing or not agreeing) of "something that has greatly enriched our country",not sure I can help you further

As for your point about the NHS in the 1950's/60's:

"Staffing crises in British hospitals had been identified long before the establishment of the NHS in 1948 and concern over nurse shortages had been the subject of numerous government inquiries which blamed low recruitment on inadequate training, poor pay, and the marriage bar. .. staffing the new NHS was compromised by the national post-war labour shortage. The unprecedented increases in the medical and nursing workforce over the first decade of the NHS exacerbated the problem. Between 1949 and 1958 the medical workforce increased by 30 per cent in England and 50 per cent in Scotland; the nursing and midwifery workforce increased by 26 per cent across Britain. The most severe shortages were in unpopular areas of nursing such as hospitals for the chronically sick, mental hospitals and in geriatric nursing.

As early as 1949 the Ministries of Health and Labour, in conjunction with the Colonial Office, the General Nursing Council and the Royal College of Nursing launched campaigns to recruit hospital staff directly from the Caribbean. Recruitment was aimed at three main categories of worker: hospital auxiliary staff, nurses or trainee nurses, and domestic workers. Senior NHS staff from Britain travelled to the Caribbean to recruit, and vacancies were often published in local papers. In 1949, the Barbados Beacon advertised for nursing auxiliaries to work in hospitals across Britain; applicants were to be aged between 18 and 30, literate, and willing to commit to a three-year contract. By 1955 there were official nursing recruitment programmes across 16 British colonies and former colonies. Over the next two decades, the British colonies and former colonies provided a constant supply of cheap labour to meet staffing shortages in the NHS, and the number of women from the African Caribbean entering Britain to work in the NHS grew steadily until the early 1970s. By the end of 1965, there were 3,000-5,000 Jamaican nurses working in British hospitals, many of them concentrated in London and the Midlands. It has been estimated that by 1972, 10,566 students had been recruited from abroad, and that by 1977 overseas recruits represented 12 per cent of the student nurse and midwife population in Britain, of which 66 per cent came from the Caribbean".

Dear oh dear,indeed.

Edited by legaleagle (23 Feb 2017 11.58pm)

 

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 24 Feb 17 8.19am

Originally posted by legaleagle

You haven't invalidated my point...The genesis of mass immigration was a Tory concept

Nonsense - not mass immigration.

...and it's only because of that that the NHS has kept going as it has until now (now 26% of doctors,Stephen Nickell, who is on the board of the Office for Budget Responsibility, suggested 35% of "health professionals" came from outside the UK)...

Even if your 'suggestion' is true, why should the sacred cow that is the NHS be fed at the expense of the problems created by mass immigration.

The primary driver for widespread increased EU immigration in more recent years (which is what seems to exercise the minds of so many of those against immigration) was the expansion of the EU eastwards...who was one of the main proponents of that..oh yes,our old friend,Tory Maggie.

So Maggie was a champion of the EU in your eyes, dear, oh dear, oh dear. But I would agree that being in the EU has increased immigration - it is one of the more pernicious effects of being in that price-rigging, non-democratic, failing, cartel.

In your desire to do down "labour/the left" don't be blind to anything that makes your picture a little more complex and multi-party than the one you painted before...

The strongest evidence for conspiracy comes from one of Labour’s own. Andrew Neather, a speechwriter for Blair, Straw and Blunkett, in the Evening Standard in October 2009 he gave the game away. Immigration, he wrote, “didn’t just happen; the deliberate policy of Ministers from late 2000…was to open up the UK to mass immigration”. He added: "… a driving political purpose: that mass immigration was the way that the Government was going to make the UK truly multicultural.”
"I remember coming away from some discussions with the clear sense that the policy was intended – even if this wasn't its main purpose – to rub the Right's nose in diversity and render their arguments out of date."
The "deliberate policy", from late 2000 until "at least February last year", was to open up the UK to mass migration, he said.

If you are simply saying immigration has also at times gone up under a Labour government,I wouldn't disagree and nothing I posted is contrary to that...

I’m not simply saying – I am saying it has rocketed. It is a fact plain to see - despite all your smokescreen bluster.

If you don't understand the meaning (as opposed to agreeing or not agreeing) of "something that has greatly enriched our country",not sure I can help you further

Your 'greatly enriched' is just some trite slogan that the left continually churns out.

As for your point about the NHS in the 1950's/60's:

You made a post discussing the period 1953-1962, now you quote figures for the 1940s, and the 1970s! Quite understand your need to move the goalposts though.

"Staffing crises in British hospitals had been identified long before the establishment of the NHS in 1948 and concern over nurse shortages had been the subject of numerous government inquiries which blamed low recruitment on inadequate training, poor pay, and the marriage bar. .. staffing the new NHS was compromised by the national post-war labour shortage. The unprecedented increases in the medical and nursing workforce over the first decade of the NHS exacerbated the problem. Between 1949 and 1958 the medical workforce increased by 30 per cent in England and 50 per cent in Scotland; the nursing and midwifery workforce increased by 26 per cent across Britain. The most severe shortages were in unpopular areas of nursing such as hospitals for the chronically sick, mental hospitals and in geriatric nursing.

As early as 1949 the Ministries of Health and Labour, in conjunction with the Colonial Office, the General Nursing Council and the Royal College of Nursing launched campaigns to recruit hospital staff directly from the Caribbean. Recruitment was aimed at three main categories of worker: hospital auxiliary staff, nurses or trainee nurses, and domestic workers. Senior NHS staff from Britain travelled to the Caribbean to recruit, and vacancies were often published in local papers. In 1949, the Barbados Beacon advertised for nursing auxiliaries to work in hospitals across Britain; applicants were to be aged between 18 and 30, literate, and willing to commit to a three-year contract. By 1955 there were official nursing recruitment programmes across 16 British colonies and former colonies. Over the next two decades, the British colonies and former colonies provided a constant supply of cheap labour to meet staffing shortages in the NHS, and the number of women from the African Caribbean entering Britain to work in the NHS grew steadily until the early 1970s. By the end of 1965, there were 3,000-5,000 Jamaican nurses working in British hospitals, many of them concentrated in London and the Midlands. It has been estimated that by 1972, 10,566 students had been recruited from abroad, and that by 1977 overseas recruits represented 12 per cent of the student nurse and midwife population in Britain, of which 66 per cent came from the Caribbean".

There were around 254,000 nurses in the NHS in 1972, the immigrant contribution was not then that massive.

Dear oh dear,indeed.


Edited by legaleagle (23 Feb 2017 11.58pm)


Edited by hedgehog50 (24 Feb 2017 8.21am)

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

legaleagle Flag 24 Feb 17 9.31am


You are perhaps not the most unblinkered and open-minded poster to have put forward views on immigration here

I'm afraid we part at your initial contention that a 4,500% increase in immigration,in the context of 1950's UK,was not "mass immigration".Certainly bbc.co.uk refers to the immigration in the 50's as "mass immigration" as would many other people. The "nonsense" you refer to might be felt by some to be being spouted by a writer other than myself.

To take one of your other sweeping assertions,as an example:

If you look at reality rather than rhetoric,Maggie was indeed a big champion of the expansion eastwards of the EU (the key causual factor behind mass immigration from E Europe since 2004.. ...don't let blind prejudice and taking politicians' "soundbite" utterances cloud reality...

For example,in the view of Chatham House: ...

"Although the programme to push for the elimination in non-tariff barriers to trade within the European Community was not of Margaret Thatcher's own creation, she was an enthusiastic supporter of what came to be known as the Single Market Programme...

But perhaps Mrs Thatcher's most important legacy is on the 'other Europe': the Europe of transition in Central and Eastern Europe after 1989."

Or in the words of that well known liberal organ,The Telegraph,in 2004:

"The prophetic words of Margaret Thatcher's Bruges speech become reality today when the European Union expands to the former Soviet bloc and Britain celebrates a triumph in foreign policy".

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 24 Feb 17 10.21am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

It really wont. It would normally be a minimum expectation in mid term. If they don't win convincingly they will surely be obliterated in the next general election

Winning Stoke was a success - UKIP and many of its supporters expected to win until this week. But losing Copeland - and by that amount - was a disaster.

It certainly won't quell any of the disquiet in the Labour party over Corbyn's leadership. But it won't be enough to force him to resign either.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Hoof Hearted 24 Feb 17 11.08am

Blair fcuked up allowing the Poles in to the UK when every other EU nation wasn't....

[Link]

This link gives an admission from one of his aides that they fcuked up massively.... expecting about 13,000 Poles, but over a Million arrived FFS.

Tony Blair simply failed to comprehend the significance of new EU rules which dramatically expanded the number of people who could settle in the UK, his ex-advisor claimed.

The former Prime Minister presided over some of the biggest influxes of immigrants in British history after the EU was expanded to include a further eight eastern European countries in 2004.

The Blair government assured voters the number of new arrivals from eastern Europe would be around 13,000.

However, the figure rapidly topped ONE MILLION as Poles and other workers from eastern Europe were wooed by higher wages and improved job prospects.

Sir Stephen Wall, the former-PM’s chief adviser on Europe, has spoken out, claiming the last administration followed poor advice.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 24 Feb 17 11.55am

Originally posted by OknotOK

Winning Stoke was a success - UKIP and many of its supporters expected to win until this week. But losing Copeland - and by that amount - was a disaster.

It certainly won't quell any of the disquiet in the Labour party over Corbyn's leadership. But it won't be enough to force him to resign either.

Well Labour played a good hand with their character assassination of Nutall but We can;t say for sure how big a factor that was.
I think the problem for UKIP at the moment is that their potential voters are leavers and most leavers are Tories. All the time the EU deal is in the air, there is no reason to ditch the Tories for UKIP. If a hard Brexit is not achieved and they don't address immigration then UKIP will have a good shout at the next Election. Either way Labour are doomed to a wipe out if Corbyn does not resign and even if he does Labour have no potential leaders in the cabinet to replace him.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Labour and immigration