You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Charlie Gard
November 21 2026 11.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Charlie Gard


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 11 Jul 17 10.27am

What are people's opinions on this case?

Didn't follow it from the very start but having picked the story up I am starting to have very strong thoughts on this.

1. The parents and their supporters are starting to turn this into a circus and about themselves rather than what is best for this child

2. Trump , the pope et al should keep their opinions to themselves

3. Why is it being dragged out all over the media. Should be kept private between the hospital, family and courts.

4. The very good name of GOSH is being dragged through the mud and trampled on. I had a child of mine treated there as a day old baby . The work they do is fantastic. It's a hospital like no other when you walk through the door and see some of the sites in there you cannot help but feel utterly humbled by what they are dealing with on an hourly basis there.

They clearly love their son but I feel they are being selfish and have a mentality that he's theirs, they own him and can do what they like with him. It leaves a bad taste in the mouth.

Thoughts?

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 11 Jul 17 10.35am

Agree with point no.1...I cant help but think they're blinded by their own selfishness...they will never be able to move on until they accept the poor little mite would be better off at peace.

To say his 'fighting' is to ignore the fact that its machines that are keeping him alive.

Also...if they get take this risk who will they expect the to foot the bill for the rest of his life?

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Harpo Flag Oxfordshire 11 Jul 17 10.38am

Two things bother me.

1) It's the media that have turned this into a circus. They have paved the way to sell more copy.

2) I only read the headlines, but I fail to see why a judge should be the one to make a decision on the treatment that the child receives.

Forgive me, but wasn't the death penalty abolished in the sixties?

It is the NHS that should be making the decisions, but alas, the simply don't have the balls to make it.

 

Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 11 Jul 17 10.45am

Originally posted by Harpo

Two things bother me.

1) It's the media that have turned this into a circus. They have paved the way to sell more copy.

2) I only read the headlines, but I fail to see why a judge should be the one to make a decision on the treatment that the child receives.

Forgive me, but wasn't the death penalty abolished in the sixties?

It is the NHS that should be making the decisions, but alas, the simply don't have the balls to make it.

In the situation where the nhs and parents cannot agree that's where the court come in. Someone has to look at both sides and make the decision. Whole thing has turned into a farce

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

Mr Palaceman Flag 11 Jul 17 10.50am

The parents should be allowed to do everything they can for their child.

Ashya King would not be alive today if the doctors had had their way.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Harpo Flag Oxfordshire 11 Jul 17 10.54am

Originally posted by Lyons550

Agree with point no.1...I cant help but think they're blinded by their own selfishness...they will never be able to move on until they accept the poor little mite would be better off at peace.

To say his 'fighting' is to ignore the fact that its machines that are keeping him alive.

Also...if they get take this risk who will they expect the to foot the bill for the rest of his life?


I think you ought to can't help but know.

My next door neighbour has a girl of a similar age.
She has to be admitted to hospital 3/4 days each week, and is permanently tubed up. And just to make life that little bit more interesting, the parents, just this weekend, have been advised that their daughter has been diagnosed both blind and deaf.

Admirably, (and I'm not sure how I would cope under those circumstances) the parents sacrifice everything for their little mite.

So I do have sympathy for the Gard's. I cannot claim to understand what they are going through, but I couldn't criticise them for a single moment.

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 11 Jul 17 11.07am

Originally posted by Lyons550

Agree with point no.1...I cant help but think they're blinded by their own selfishness...they will never be able to move on until they accept the poor little mite would be better off at peace.

To say his 'fighting' is to ignore the fact that its machines that are keeping him alive.

Also...if they get take this risk who will they expect the to foot the bill for the rest of his life?

Wasn't 1.3 million raised on their behalf for the treatment?

Even if that wasn't the case, what difference would that make. There are many sick children that will need support for the rest of their lives. Do you think that they should not get that support?

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Spiderman Flag Horsham 11 Jul 17 11.23am

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

The parents should be allowed to do everything they can for their child.

Ashya King would not be alive today if the doctors had had their way.

I agree totally with this. As a parent I would not want to live forever thinking "what if".

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 11 Jul 17 11.25am

I have followed this case closely. As a father of a boy born 4 months premature weighing only 1lb 12ozs I can relate in some way to this case.

We were asked on several occasions in the first few weeks to give some real thought to turning off his machine. I can't explain what it's like to be given something like that to think about... Essentially being asked to play god with your child's life.

Myself and my Wife talked, cried and had some very hard decisions to make. The hospital seemed certain that he would have no quality of life due to a severe brain bleed he had suffered at 2 days old but they could not tell us for DEFINITE that this would be the case. So we kept going and he is now a happy little 3 year old. Yes he has some strength and sight issues and he has epilepsy but on the whole he will lead a relatively normal life.

I really do feel for his parents bit I do hate the way that this poor little boys life has turned into a media circus.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

thegreatlardino Flag crawley/selsey 11 Jul 17 11.44am

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

The parents should be allowed to do everything they can for their child.

Ashya King would not be alive today if the doctors had had their way.

agree with this as well, I cant even imagine what they are going through, as for the press well what do we expect?

 


Sometimes I set out for Ludlow
Sometimes I end up in Chepstow

Mr Palaceman Flag 11 Jul 17 11.47am

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

I have followed this case closely. As a father of a boy born 4 months premature weighing only 1lb 12ozs I can relate in some way to this case.

We were asked on several occasions in the first few weeks to give some real thought to turning off his machine. I can't explain what it's like to be given something like that to think about... Essentially being asked to play god with your child's life.

Myself and my Wife talked, cried and had some very hard decisions to make. The hospital seemed certain that he would have no quality of life due to a severe brain bleed he had suffered at 2 days old but they could not tell us for DEFINITE that this would be the case. So we kept going and he is now a happy little 3 year old. Yes he has some strength and sight issues and he has epilepsy but on the whole he will lead a relatively normal life.

I really do feel for his parents bit I do hate the way that this poor little boys life has turned into a media circus.

Must have been an extremely tough time for you, glad your son is a happy child...

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 11 Jul 17 11.50am

Originally posted by Spiderman

I agree totally with this. As a parent I would not want to live forever thinking "what if".

This is the thing and it's a very difficult area to discuss. But it's so they don't live with the what if. What about the child. He is being kept alive by a machine and has absolutely no quality of life and never will have. The treatment may help some of the symptoms but it will not cure him or make him get better in that sense. His mother keeps talking about him being able to ride a bike. I can understand she had that dream for her child when she gave birth but eventually reality and rational thinking needs to be paramount over your emotions. Anyone can be kept going by a machine doesn't mean it's the right thing to do.

I can't be alone in thinking the time they have left with him could be spent actually being at his side instead of doing the rounds of t.v. shows and shouting out in court rooms.

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

Mr Palaceman Flag 11 Jul 17 11.52am


In regards to the claims of circus, I don't see any clowns here. It's an on-going story in the media because there is public interest. That is why this thread is here.

I wouldn't describe this story as a circus. Another post said the parents are selfish. Their is nothing selfish about trying to save you child. There's no blame to be attributed.

My thoughts and prayers are with Charlie and his family.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Jul 17 12.08pm

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman


Another post said the parents are selfish. Their is nothing selfish about trying to save you child. There's no blame to be attributed.

Surely that depends on why the parents are so insistent on keeping the child alive. Is it for their benefit or his?

The lad is severely brain damaged, cannot move arms or legs, is deaf and blind and cannot exist without a ventilator.

Even the Americans who are offering him this experimental drug treatment agree that it can't reverse his brain damage.

His quality of life is absolutely zero and unlikely to improve so surely it's in the child's best interests to let him die with dignity, especially as the doctors don't even know if he can feel pain

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 11 Jul 17 12.23pm

Originally posted by Michaelawt85

This is the thing and it's a very difficult area to discuss. But it's so they don't live with the what if. What about the child. He is being kept alive by a machine and has absolutely no quality of life and never will have. The treatment may help some of the symptoms but it will not cure him or make him get better in that sense. His mother keeps talking about him being able to ride a bike. I can understand she had that dream for her child when she gave birth but eventually reality and rational thinking needs to be paramount over your emotions. Anyone can be kept going by a machine doesn't mean it's the right thing to do.

I can't be alone in thinking the time they have left with him could be spent actually being at his side instead of doing the rounds of t.v. shows and shouting out in court rooms.

This is the point, you can't know that.

I would be shouting outside the courts if a doctor had used the court to deny my child a right to further treatment. When there are those out they saying that they can help.

What are we actually talking about here? Allowing parents to take their child to another hospital, where the doctors have a more positive outlook.

Sorry to say it but your a long time dead, so a few more months of treatment, even if it is a slim chance, is a chance worth taking. If the treatment does not work, then the parents can say, we tried our very best.

I bring up again the case of Ashya King. They took the parents to court and they were jailed in Spain. Imagine if they had forced through the extradition and brought the child home, so they could stop his treatment.

When Ashya started to repond to his treatment, what did they say? Well done, that is great news? No, they made a statement still trying to justify their stance. They said, it wouldn't last and there's still a chance of a relapse

Think if those parents had not been so strong and fought for their child..

How many other parents have been told there is no hope.

If nothing else there is always hope and while there is still some hope the parents should have the right to try and if some are offended by the fact that they are on t.v. in their efforts to give a chance to Charlie, so be it.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 11 Jul 17 12.28pm

Very tragic for the parents but am sick of hearing about this. Mums that know feck all about the medical aspect of this protesting outside Great Ormond Street is just wrong.
Let the medical experts decide, they have the childs welfare at heart. Whatever happens the press should back off and the Pope and Trump ignored.

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 11 Jul 17 12.35pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Surely that depends on why the parents are so insistent on keeping the child alive. Is it for their benefit or his?

The lad is severely brain damaged, cannot move arms or legs, is deaf and blind and cannot exist without a ventilator.

Even the Americans who are offering him this experimental drug treatment agree that it can't reverse his brain damage.

His quality of life is absolutely zero and unlikely to improve so surely it's in the child's best interests to let him die with dignity, especially as the doctors don't even know if he can feel pain

You say that like it's a crime. How about for the benefit of the child and the parents.

There are unfortunatly many children alive who have an exremely challenging life. They still have worth.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 11 Jul 17 12.37pm

Originally posted by Harpo


I think you ought to can't help but know.

My next door neighbour has a girl of a similar age.
She has to be admitted to hospital 3/4 days each week, and is permanently tubed up. And just to make life that little bit more interesting, the parents, just this weekend, have been advised that their daughter has been diagnosed both blind and deaf.

Admirably, (and I'm not sure how I would cope under those circumstances) the parents sacrifice everything for their little mite.

So I do have sympathy for the Gard's. I cannot claim to understand what they are going through, but I couldn't criticise them for a single moment.

At least your neighbours child has a working brain and has a 'quality' of life...if Charlie Gard had that I'd think differently...but experts far far more experienced in this field suggest that its not the case.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 11 Jul 17 12.39pm

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

This is the point, you can't know that.

I would be shouting outside the courts if a doctor had used the court to deny my child a right to further treatment. When there are those out they saying that they can help.

What are we actually talking about here? Allowing parents to take their child to another hospital, where the doctors have a more positive outlook.

Sorry to say it but your a long time dead, so a few more months of treatment, even if it is a slim chance, is a chance worth taking. If the treatment does not work, then the parents can say, we tried our very best.

I bring up again the case of Ashya King. They took the parents to court and they were jailed in Spain. Imagine if they had forced through the extradition and brought the child home, so they could stop his treatment.

When Ashya started to repond to his treatment, what did they say? Well done, that is great news? No, they made a statement still trying to justify their stance. They said, it wouldn't last and there's still a chance of a relapse

Think if those parents had not been so strong and fought for their child..

How many other parents have been told there is no hope.

If nothing else there is always hope and while there is still some hope the parents should have the right to try and if some are offended by the fact that they are on t.v. in their efforts to give a chance to Charlie, so be it.

Ashya king wasn't being kept alive by a ventilator with severe irreversible brain damage that for me is the key difference.

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 11 Jul 17 12.43pm

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

Wasn't 1.3 million raised on their behalf for the treatment?

Even if that wasn't the case, what difference would that make. There are many sick children that will need support for the rest of their lives. Do you think that they should not get that support?


I work in Social Services and i see all manner of services being provide for young and old; the cost of which is horrifying...but...it's not about the cost for a child that can be taken to rehabilition units...or sensory centers is it..it's about the practicalities and cost of keeping a child alive solely through machines...for what purpose? What quality of life is that for the child?

As I say...in my eyes its selfish to have the poor child suffer.

I appreciate it's certainly one of those morale scenarios that see's those commenting on it in one of two camps....which is why I guess it's best for the Courts to decide based on the evidence and come to a pragmatic decision.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Charlie Gard