You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Anyone But Freedman !!!
November 16 2026 8.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Anyone But Freedman !!!


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Croydonlad Flag sydenham 28 Aug 17 9.56pm

So finally it seems that Parish is gonna pull the trigger on FDB
As you know I wanted it done after the Huddersfield game , but het whats another 6 points to lose !!
So thoughts please on who you would like to come in next
My thoughts would be to buy Sakho and tempt Sam back , Im sure the reason he retired is because he was told there was no money
ANYONE but Freedman please ~ he's a bad Championship manager who is way out of depth in the Premiership ( Like FDB is )
What would Freedman say to Premiership players or International players such as Cabaye , or Benteke , at least FDB andSammy Lee won player honors of the highest calibre !!

 

Reknaw Flag 28 Aug 17 10.00pm

For starters i don't want FDB gone, but i agree anyone but Freedman, please oh please.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Aug 17 10.01pm

I can stomach freedman sourcing players in the background. He has a talent there. But grassing on the club after walking out? The walking out is one thing, but grassing on us? He wasn't even under questioning. He was forthcoming and proactive in grassing us up.

 


COYP

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 28 Aug 17 10.03pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

So finally it seems that Parish is gonna pull the trigger on FDB
As you know I wanted it done after the Huddersfield game , but het whats another 6 points to lose !!
So thoughts please on who you would like to come in next
My thoughts would be to buy Sakho and tempt Sam back , Im sure the reason he retired is because he was told there was no money
ANYONE but Freedman please ~ he's a bad Championship manager who is way out of depth in the Premiership ( Like FDB is )
What would Freedman say to Premiership players or International players such as Cabaye , or Benteke , at least FDB andSammy Lee won player honors of the highest calibre !!

And if sam doesn't come back (which he won't ), who else would you suggest. No one available at the moment who I can think of. So you're looking at poaching someone else's manager. Who's going to leave their existing club after 3 games to come to palace, who sack their manager after 3 games and don't seem to be able to hold onto a manager for very long. Add onto that compensation paid to FdB and compensation to another club for poaching their manager....

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 28 Aug 17 10.05pm

Guess what? Only desperate managerial failures like Freedman will be willing to come to us if the lunatics like you get your way and sack a manager after 3 games.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 28 Aug 17 10.08pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

So finally it seems that Parish is gonna pull the trigger on FDB
As you know I wanted it done after the Huddersfield game , but het whats another 6 points to lose !!
So thoughts please on who you would like to come in next
My thoughts would be to buy Sakho and tempt Sam back , Im sure the reason he retired is because he was told there was no money
ANYONE but Freedman please ~ he's a bad Championship manager who is way out of depth in the Premiership ( Like FDB is )
What would Freedman say to Premiership players or International players such as Cabaye , or Benteke , at least FDB andSammy Lee won player honors of the highest calibre !!

Is he going to "pull the trigger"?

I doubt we will sign Sakho, and BFS will not be coming back. No idea where you get the idea he was told there was no money.

I get that you dislike de Boer, and don't like Freedman, but at least make a rational suggestion, rather than just firing off irrational posts.

Get a grip.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 28 Aug 17 10.09pm

Oh dear oh dear one manager hasn't even packed his bags and the knives are already out for the next.... and he's not even been appointed.

Well HOL isn't anything but consistent.

I'd say no to Sammy Lee as his time as manager at Bolton was a disaster and I see him as a good coach and nothing more.

As for Freeman well if it's temporary to steady the ship while Parish sources a replacement then so be it. It's not great to know he'll have the wolves at his door from the get go.

Love the way the OP ends be praising FdB honours when he's been his most vocal critic until he's gone. lol couldn't make it up.

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 28 Aug 17 10.18pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Oh dear oh dear one manager hasn't even packed his bags and the knives are already out for the next.... and he's not even been appointed.

Well HOL isn't anything but consistent.

I'd say no to Sammy Lee as his time as manager at Bolton was a disaster and I see him as a good coach and nothing more.

As for Freeman well if it's temporary to steady the ship while Parish sources a replacement then so be it. It's not great to know he'll have the wolves at his door from the get go.

Love the way the OP ends be praising FdB honours when he's been his most vocal critic until he's gone. lol couldn't make it up.

What the hell are you talking about - Ive NEVER questioned his playing career , its his management career thats a joke . And as Im tired of saying , theres been many great players that are terrible mangers , and Im sorry to say FDB is ONE of them

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 28 Aug 17 10.21pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

And if sam doesn't come back (which he won't ), who else would you suggest. No one available at the moment who I can think of. So you're looking at poaching someone else's manager. Who's going to leave their existing club after 3 games to come to palace, who sack their manager after 3 games and don't seem to be able to hold onto a manager for very long. Add onto that compensation paid to FdB and compensation to another club for poaching their manager....

The compensation is peanuts to the money we would lose if relegated

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 28 Aug 17 10.23pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

What the hell are you talking about - Ive NEVER questioned his playing career , its his management career thats a joke . And as Im tired of saying , theres been many great players that are terrible mangers , and Im sorry to say FDB is ONE of them

I'm talking about your comment about Franks playing career in reference to Freedman not being able to talk to Prem players.

You slag him off for weeks on end and the day he's potentially gone you reference his playing career as a reason why he's more respected as a manager than Freeman.

I understand your reasoning but do find it slightly ironic. That's all.

Now calm down it sounds like Frank has gone so you of all people should at least pause breath and be pleased of that before your next crusade.

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 28 Aug 17 10.26pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

I'm talking about your comment about Franks playing career in reference to Freedman not being able to talk to Prem players.

You slag him off for weeks on end and the day he's potentially gone you reference his playing career as a reason why he's more respected as a manager than Freeman.

I understand your reasoning but do find it slightly ironic. That's all.

Now calm down it sounds like Frank has gone so you of all people should at least pause breath and be pleased of that before your next crusade.

Yes the players Im sure respected FDB playing career , thats what got him the job I suspect ~ Please tell me it weans winning trophies in Holland managing a monopoly side like Ajax ~ But they clearly don't listen or believe in him as a manager , and thats why its best he's gone , by the way , he will NEVER manage another Premiership team ,he has zero clue .

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 28 Aug 17 10.26pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Yes the players Im sure respected FDB playing career , thats what got him the job I suspect ~ Please tell me it wasn't winning trophies in Holland managing a monopoly side like Ajax ~ But they clearly don't listen or believe in him as a manager , and thats why its best he's gone , by the way , he will NEVER manage another Premiership team ,he has zero clue .


 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 28 Aug 17 10.32pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Yes the players Im sure respected FDB playing career , thats what got him the job I suspect ~ Please tell me it weans winning trophies in Holland managing a monopoly side like Ajax ~ But they clearly don't listen or believe in him as a manager , and thats why its best he's gone , by the way , he will NEVER manage another Premiership team ,he has zero clue .

I do agree if he's gone he'll never manage a top league team in England again.

I would disagree with the Ajax comment. When he took over at Ajax they wasn't a monopoly as they hadn't won a trophy in somethingn like six years and haven't won one since he left. But that's another story not worth discussing now.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 28 Aug 17 10.35pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Yes the players Im sure respected FDB playing career , thats what got him the job I suspect ~ Please tell me it weans winning trophies in Holland managing a monopoly side like Ajax ~ But they clearly don't listen or believe in him as a manager , and thats why its best he's gone , by the way , he will NEVER manage another Premiership team ,he has zero clue .

You have zero clue you mean!

Read McArthurs piece in the Guardian, he states de Boer has not insisted they stick to 343, but adapt to the opposition. The cancer in the club goes way back, Sam only papered over the cracks.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 28 Aug 17 11.00pm

Well prepared to get slated for this but if FdB is to go would DF along with Sammy be put in temporary charge surely?

If that would be the case although all very hypothetical is it really that bad? We are in desperate need of a GK, a Sakho and a CF at least I would assume that's not contentious but with current players I do believe there is enough there to put out a decent and competitive starting XI.

I would hope a Sammy n DF temporary appointment would aim to start playing a better suited formation with players in the right positions and sorry for this but 'go back to basics'.

If that were the case I would be quite happy with that and although admittedly a Freedman fan I would hope Palace fans would get behind the two of them until a more constructive decision was taken on the clubs future?

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Medway Eagle Flag Whitstable Kent 28 Aug 17 11.14pm

Originally posted by Painter

You have zero clue you mean!

Read McArthurs piece in the Guardian, he states de Boer has not insisted they stick to 343, but adapt to the opposition. The cancer in the club goes way back, Sam only papered over the cracks.

Good post I agree that the problems are deep rooted within the make up of the club, Can't put my finger on the problem, But For ages our squad has underperformed

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 29 Aug 17 4.41am

Originally posted by Painter

You have zero clue you mean!

Read McArthurs piece in the Guardian, he states de Boer has not insisted they stick to 343, but adapt to the opposition. The cancer in the club goes way back, Sam only papered over the cracks.

No your right , I mean playing Huddersfield and Swansea with our players we would expect to concede 5 goals at home and score none right ??
I rate McArthur highly , but what do you expect him to say " Oh yeah DeBoer hasnt got a clue " ~ If he's adapting then he's not adapting very well is he ???

 

simonmdt Flag x 29 Aug 17 7.40am

Originally posted by Croydonlad

So finally it seems that Parish is gonna pull the trigger on FDB
As you know I wanted it done after the Huddersfield game , but het whats another 6 points to lose !!
So thoughts please on who you would like to come in next
My thoughts would be to buy Sakho and tempt Sam back , Im sure the reason he retired is because he was told there was no money
ANYONE but Freedman please ~ he's a bad Championship manager who is way out of depth in the Premiership ( Like FDB is )
What would Freedman say to Premiership players or International players such as Cabaye , or Benteke , at least FDB andSammy Lee won player honors of the highest calibre !!


Christ almighty, why bother reading anymore?

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 29 Aug 17 8.28am

FdB won with Ajax, but Dutch football is not the same as in the Cruyff years. For H...sake, even Steve "Wolly" McLaren won the Dutch shampionship not long ago....

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 30 Aug 17 5.19pm

Originally posted by thai-eagle

FdB won with Ajax, but Dutch football is not the same as in the Cruyff years. For H...sake, even Steve "Wolly" McLaren won the Dutch shampionship not long ago....

Absolutely 100% agree

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Anyone But Freedman !!!