You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > What's the point of General Talk?
November 21 2026 11.02pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What's the point of General Talk?


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
Pikester Flag Worthing 04 Oct 17 10.06am

Apart from the 'Dead' threads which usually come through quicker than the Beeb - what is the point of General Talk?

People with an opinion that they'll never change, will never climb down from, will never say "Now I've heard a few more facts I've changed my mind" - like it's a massive weakness to change a point of view - constantly sitting at keyboards typing the equivalent of:

"Yes it is"
"No it isn't"
"Yes it is"
"You're a w***er!"

Many times I've been on here and read something in the first post which I've agreed with and then someone else counters it and I change my mind and then someone else counters again and I revise my opinion further.

Why is that so difficult for some people?
This is an internet message board for a football team. There's no prizes. It's not a debating society. There's no shame in being wrong and no shame in changing your view when more facts come to light.

Threads on here reach 20 pages with the same arguments that are on page 1. If someone can't argue their opponent into agreement and can't beat them into it either they seem incredulous that another human being won't agree with them.

Knowing that it rarely, if ever, happens what's the point? I'd have so much more respect for people who admit they formed an opinion based on what they knew at the time and then changed it when they knew more facts - not just keep banging the same drum all the time.

The best example is probably Brexit - a decision so important it should never have been foisted on the general public with a "Here's a couple of leaflets from both sides, pop into a booth and make one of the most important political decisions in this country's history would you."
And now everyone is stuck with this label Brexiter, Remainer, Xenephobe, Little Englander, Europhile.

The truth was a lot of people were fed up that the country was seen to be propping up the likes of Greece and making large payments to French farmers etc. Slightly more than half the voters protested against this without being aware of the full consequences and mostly not believing it would make a blind bit of difference. They're not all suddenly racist bigots..... except in General Talk where everything is black or white.

There may as well be an agree or disagree button on every topic and just have a vote at the end of every week. Then the winner can go home and tell his family 'he WON' - because that's the most important thing on here, right?

 


You fed me, you bred me, I'll remember your name.

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 04 Oct 17 10.12am

Some of the jokes and put-downs are quite funny though.

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Oct 17 10.14am

When you see people putting their point of view it's easy to assume that they are trying to change the opinion of the person they talk to.

The point of general talk is to 'get an opinion' out there. The person you are debating with may not agree, but the debate isn't really for them. It's to that person reading whose viewpoint hasn't been decided.

Very few debates end with someone changing their mind....Some may alter later upon reflection...That's happened to me. But in general you are correct in stating that it looks silly and childish.

People in general wrap up their opinions within their self worth and image....So even if you could prove a person wrong about something they would most probably just double down on their original viewpoint.

Some people are self assured and open minded but they are a minority.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

chris123 Flag hove actually 04 Oct 17 10.15am

There should be a ban on imported content - so no clicking on links - original debate only - it would render some posters silent.

 

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 04 Oct 17 10.16am

Part of the problem is that we are not face to face. I'm sure we would be far more polite and reasonable if we were (well, with one or two exceptions!)

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Oct 17 10.19am

Originally posted by chris123

There should be a ban on imported content - so no clicking on links - original debate only - it would render some posters silent.

It would probably reduce some of the lazy political posts somewhat.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Oct 17 10.24am

What's the point of anything, its all a distraction from the inevitability of mortal existence. General talk, like having kids, or sniffing glue; it's just as way to temper the howl of the futility of human existence.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 04 Oct 17 10.27am

Originally posted by Pikester

Apart from the 'Dead' threads which usually come through quicker than the Beeb - what is the point of General Talk?

People with an opinion that they'll never change, will never climb down from, will never say "Now I've heard a few more facts I've changed my mind" - like it's a massive weakness to change a point of view - constantly sitting at keyboards typing the equivalent of:

"Yes it is"
"No it isn't"
"Yes it is"
"You're a w***er!"

Many times I've been on here and read something in the first post which I've agreed with and then someone else counters it and I change my mind and then someone else counters again and I revise my opinion further.

Why is that so difficult for some people?
This is an internet message board for a football team. There's no prizes. It's not a debating society. There's no shame in being wrong and no shame in changing your view when more facts come to light.

Threads on here reach 20 pages with the same arguments that are on page 1. If someone can't argue their opponent into agreement and can't beat them into it either they seem incredulous that another human being won't agree with them.

Knowing that it rarely, if ever, happens what's the point? I'd have so much more respect for people who admit they formed an opinion based on what they knew at the time and then changed it when they knew more facts - not just keep banging the same drum all the time.

The best example is probably Brexit - a decision so important it should never have been foisted on the general public with a "Here's a couple of leaflets from both sides, pop into a booth and make one of the most important political decisions in this country's history would you."
And now everyone is stuck with this label Brexiter, Remainer, Xenephobe, Little Englander, Europhile.

The truth was a lot of people were fed up that the country was seen to be propping up the likes of Greece and making large payments to French farmers etc. Slightly more than half the voters protested against this without being aware of the full consequences and mostly not believing it would make a blind bit of difference. They're not all suddenly racist bigots..... except in General Talk where everything is black or white.

There may as well be an agree or disagree button on every topic and just have a vote at the end of every week. Then the winner can go home and tell his family 'he WON' - because that's the most important thing on here, right?

Good post.

The best threads are when this happens without doubt...the problem is it takes a lot of effort to debate effectively as you have to listen to what the counter argument/point is in order to then propose an alternative....they are on here...just drowned out with the playschool stuff...and it always seems to be the same individuals as well.

Perhaps there should be a Politics board for them to exist on?

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 Oct 17 10.27am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

What's the point of anything, its all a distraction from the inevitability of mortal existence. General talk, like having kids, or sniffing glue; it's just as way to temper the howl of the futility of human existence.

Can I borrow your needle and brown?

 


COYP

Midlands Eagle Flag 04 Oct 17 10.30am

Originally posted by Pikester

Apart from the 'Dead' threads which usually come through quicker than the Beeb - what is the point of General Talk?

People with an opinion that they'll never change, will never climb down from, will never say "Now I've heard a few more facts I've changed my mind" - like it's a massive weakness to change a point of view -

The point of General Talk (which is what you asked) seems to be for the same half dozen people to try and verbally bash each other senseless on every single thread thus ensuring that the majority of HOLers who might have something to say, stay well away.

There should be two General Talk forums with the first exclusively for nickgusset, hedgehog50, Hrolf The Ganger and two or three more to argue with each other until the cows come home and a second forum for the rest of us who might want to discuss issues without the rabble rousers involved

 

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Oct 17 10.31am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

What's the point of anything, its all a distraction from the inevitability of mortal existence. General talk, like having kids, or sniffing glue; it's just as way to temper the howl of the futility of human existence.

That's true only in a creator-less universe....and I'm not talking about the almost certainly false 'personal gods' here. There could be a point...but perhaps we don't understand it...or like it... almost certainly we aren't the focus.

Besides we live on via those kids. That's half of you, minus the consciousness.

Besides, leaving the world a tiny bit better than you came in has a point to it.

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Oct 2017 10.34am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Pikester Flag Worthing 04 Oct 17 10.33am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

What's the point of anything, its all a distraction from the inevitability of mortal existence. General talk, like having kids, or sniffing glue; it's just as way to temper the howl of the futility of human existence.

Christ! I'm off to chuck myself under a bus.
But I think you're basically agreeing with my original post so I'll die happy.

Yes! winner!

pikester.png Attachment: pikester.png (54.11Kb)

 


You fed me, you bred me, I'll remember your name.

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 04 Oct 17 10.37am

General Talk gives an opportunity to argue/communicate with/have a go at and occasionally laugh with others of a mind that if it wasn't for here, or the workplace, you probably wouldn't interact with much at all.

It just wasn't possible 20 years ago except for dinner parties if no filtering took place. What clusterfvck evenings some of them were

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


chris123 Flag hove actually 04 Oct 17 10.48am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

What's the point of anything, its all a distraction from the inevitability of mortal existence. General talk, like having kids, or sniffing glue; it's just as way to temper the howl of the futility of human existence.

You need to go shopping.

 

Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 04 Oct 17 10.50am

I use it to post the occasional funny link or if there's something I want some advice on. Does seem a small handful follow each other round from thread to thread hurling insults and making a point of being in disagreement about everything but it's natural if you read or hear something you disagree with to respond with your own point of view.

Haven't had a decent derailed thread for ages here

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Oct 17 10.59am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

That's true only in a creator-less universe....and I'm not talking about the almost certainly false 'personal gods' here. There could be a point...but perhaps we don't understand it...or like it... almost certainly we aren't the focus.

In a creator universe its even worse, as free will is given, but to use it results in punishment; and because these 'sins' are tied to biological imperatives, the outcome is worse than simple oblivion.

Of course if we don't understand it, and its not dependent on us, our existence is even more futile.

Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Besides we live on via those kids. That's half of you, minus the consciousness.

No you don't - its your ancestors - At best only an tiny possibility of something unique that might be of you is in that DNA, if you happened to have some kind of genetic mutation that might contribute to an eventual evolutionary change.

And of course, who we are is our consciousness. At best you continue to exist as the ideas your children have of you, until they die, and possibly the memories of your grandchildren, until they die. Of course, its only their perception of you, not you.

Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Besides, leaving the world a tiny bit better than you came in has a point to it.

Except we won't, because better or worse, are simply perceptions of values, which are simply based on our hopes and wishes, rather than the reality of a universe that is vast, uncaring and unware - Even at best they exist until the next extinction level event crashes into the earth, wiping it clean of complex life - which is itself inevitable. Six of the seven established human sub species, are extinct. We're just the next in line.

Nihilism is freedom.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Oct 17 10.59am

Originally posted by chris123

You need to go shopping.

Or park cars.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

npn Flag Crowborough 04 Oct 17 11.06am

I do like it for getting opposing views, but it deteriorates so quickly when people seem incapable of debating in an adult way (the sort of people you talk to at a party for 30 seconds and think "nope, waste of time" and walk away).

Someone probably quite clever said you learn nothing when something goes right, only when it goes wrong, or similar. Same with a debate - "oh wow, yes, you're totally right" teaches you nothing, you should be accepting and welcoming of challenges to your views because it's the only way to test them out. It seems once sides are decided, it's deemed a sign of weakness to accept any contrary points.

The political discussions particularly would be a hell of a lot better on here without the playground stuff

 

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 04 Oct 17 11.12am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The point of General Talk (which is what you asked) seems to be for the same half dozen people to try and verbally bash each other senseless on every single thread thus ensuring that the majority of HOLers who might have something to say, stay well away.

There should be two General Talk forums with the first exclusively for nickgusset, hedgehog50, Hrolf The Ganger and two or three more to argue with each other until the cows come home and a second forum for the rest of us who might want to discuss issues without the rabble rousers involved

A sort of Premier League of rabble rousers you mean?Would there be any sort of promotion/relegation arrangement?

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 04 Oct 17 11.27am

General Talk has been following Palace in a spookily correlated manner. What was quite good has now turned into a completely skewed line up with too much head down aimless dribbling from the right and the left flanks with no one in the centre to take advantage of anything that may eventually come their way.

Consequently it's struggling to find any shape whatsoever, is stuffed full of time-rich pompossisists who can spend days on end going round and round with no end result, but who line up for the next thread ready to start the cycle all over again.

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > What's the point of General Talk?