You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What is it letting us down?
November 16 2026 8.21am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What is it letting us down?


Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Reknaw Flag 21 Oct 17 7.15pm

Just what is it that keeps letting us down, every season?

We’ve got a fantastic squad, great set of players, fantastic fans, well respected manager with a great history and career.

Year after year pundits say ‘they won’t go down their squad is too good’. Yet year after year, we end up in a mess one way or another.

Yes for the past 3 years we’ve somehow managed to survive, but pundits are correct, we should not be anywhere near relegation with a squad like ours.

I just can not put my finger on what it is that is causing us to become in a mess each season one way or another. Please, please discuss and shed some light on this for me.

 

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 21 Oct 17 7.26pm

Keep changing our manager, poor scouting, major balls up in recruitment this summer. All the talk of pushing on, rather than seeing 17th or above as the priority.

That said three teams go down every season and for the past four we've not been one of them. Our squad isn't that good that relegation is never an unrealistic possibility.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 21 Oct 17 7.32pm

Fitness and organisation.... the fitter and better organised a team is the better the concentration and the longer keep the intensity..... both of these though are improving at a rapid rate these last few games.... so I'm remaining positive

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Bangell Flag Oxford 21 Oct 17 7.34pm

Fantastic squad with only one striker? That's basically reliant on Zaha for creativity?

It's a ropey squad with a huge wage bill nevertheless.

 

davehuggins Flag 21 Oct 17 7.34pm

Very very poor management I'm afraid from the top. We take far to long doing everything and nearly always end up with the wrong manager. Them upstairs are to blame for this mess, sorry but it's true.

 

hastingseagle67 Flag 21 Oct 17 7.35pm

In my opinion, everything comes down to the settlement of that middle management position. If we could sort out and settle the manager and first team coaches I think it would go a long way towards our team performances. A club like ours has a problem that if a young manager comes in and does well, he’ll be snapped up by a better team. We have been unfortunate that with a less fashionable manager , (pulis, allardyce) they have decided to move on. This is the position that has to be settled to enable us to build and move on.

 


has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!

tillysosser Flag far far away 21 Oct 17 7.45pm

it's simple

we have a miss fit team assembled by several different managers and 1 chairman in such a short amount of time

where as we should, in an ideal world. have a team assembled by a minimum of just 2 separate managers over a long period

Edited by tillysosser (21 Oct 2017 10.39pm)

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 21 Oct 17 7.45pm

Originally posted by davehuggins

Very very poor management I'm afraid from the top. We take far to long doing everything and nearly always end up with the wrong manager. Them upstairs are to blame for this mess, sorry but it's true.

You can't really call it a mess though can you. They may be out of the depth in the PL but we also wouldn't be here without them. What do you expect them to do, get us up and then hand us over? They've earnt the right to have a go at this and you can't call it a mess compared to what we were then they saved our sorry asses.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Reknaw Flag 21 Oct 17 7.45pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Fantastic squad with only one striker? That's basically reliant on Zaha for creativity?

It's a ropey squad with a huge wage bill nevertheless.

Sorry, maybe i should have been clearer. By fantastic squad i mean of individuals.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Oct 17 7.45pm

Originally posted by hastingseagle67

In my opinion, everything comes down to the settlement of that middle management position. If we could sort out and settle the manager and first team coaches I think it would go a long way towards our team performances. A club like ours has a problem that if a young manager comes in and does well, he’ll be snapped up by a better team. We have been unfortunate that with a less fashionable manager , (pulis, allardyce) they have decided to move on. This is the position that has to be settled to enable us to build and move on.

That's the only time good decisions are made because when we don't have the best manager we could hope to get, Parish's decisions are mind boggling. In fact he'll only make the right manager selection when there isn't a choice and there's a klaxon going off above Pulis or Allardyce, Pardew or Burley's head. Yes the last 2 served a purpose for a while before being out of their depth.

Parish makes bad footballing decisions and it might take relegation for him to learn to let someone else make them. Yes I know bouncing back is a big ask but his errors cost more than initially needed to correct and set us back further.

For the first season I was getting used to relegation a few weeks ago. Thinking without a striker we'd be alright is a fvcking insult. Vs a back 3 trying to push for the title/top 4 is one thing. vs a back 4 that knows the odds of being resolute is completely different.

 


COYP

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 21 Oct 17 7.46pm

Originally posted by Reknaw

Just what is it that keeps letting us down, every season?

We’ve got a fantastic squad, great set of players,
fantastic fans, well respected manager with a great history and career.

Year after year pundits say ‘they won’t go down their squad is too good’. Yet year after year, we end up in a mess one way or another.

reputations dont count for jack. Today Huddersfield are the cock of the walk.
we are breaking records for worst premier league team for a reason. Its not all bad luck, there is something deeply mediocre about all our performances. Even the first goal against Chelscum was a deflection OG.

our players are expensive - yes
famous - yes, many of them.

performing and doing the business ? nope.

i cannot name any of the huddersfield squad, and they are storming it this season.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (21 Oct 2017 7.58pm)

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Oct 17 7.52pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

You can't really call it a mess though can you. They may be out of the depth in the PL but we also wouldn't be here without them. What do you expect them to do, get us up and then hand us over? They've earnt the right to have a go at this and you can't call it a mess compared to what we were then they saved our sorry asses.

You can't call 1 striker in the prem a mess?

The same mistake was made a year ago with left back. Only failure will teach Parish. Either Freedman kept quiet or Parish didn't listen in those 10 days before the deadline.

It was great until shower of sh1t decisions were made the moment we signed Adebayor on a free. From then on there's been too many terrible decisions that added up will relegate us and we were lucky haven't already.

I myself haven't said anything about handing us over but I have over Parish not being qualified or aware enough to be making football calls. Now Cenk's value is rocketing, our prem survival is crumbling, Freedman takes a trip to Monaco to scout him. If it wasn't do serious I'd laugh. Thank god I don't live in Sussex during this.

 


COYP

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 21 Oct 17 8.18pm

Not sure exactly what you lot want.
Last season from 8th to 17th there was a difference of 6 points.
Very fine lines.
The club are doing great to be competing in it.
Anyone of those positions would be marvellous for our club.
Fifth season enjoy it while it lasts.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 21 Oct 17 8.24pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1

Not sure exactly what you lot want
.
Last season from 8th to 17th there was a difference of 6 points.
Very fine lines.
The club are doing great to be competing in it.
Anyone of those positions would be marvellous for our club.
Fifth season enjoy it while it lasts.

A centre forward please. ...

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 21 Oct 17 8.40pm

Steve Parish. He doesnt know what he is doing, bottom line. No other chairman would have presided over the epic balls up that was the last transfer window and then FDB. If Parish stays, we will never ever establish ourselves properly, as his decision making is abysmal. He needs to find a suitable buyer and duck out, because he is the most culpable person on the planet as to why we are so bad right now. He cannot, or will not learn, not sure which but it doesnt matter really does it, point is he isnt learning, making the same errors time and time and time again. We cannot succeed with him calling the shots.

Edited by Maine Eagle (21 Oct 2017 8.40pm)

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 21 Oct 17 9.00pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1

Not sure exactly what you lot want.
Last season from 8th to 17th there was a difference of 6 points.
Very fine lines.
The club are doing great to be competing in it.
Anyone of those positions would be marvellous for our club.
Fifth season enjoy it while it lasts.

I don't mean this in an aggressive way but enjoy what exactly? A miracle win against Chelsea does not nullify going almost 1/4 of a season without even scoring and looking like continuing in that fashion with no striker. We are being humiliated on an unprecedented scale and it's possibly worse in the prem as it's in the spotlight.

We have competed but are no longer. The same mistakes are made season after season which I believe is the definition of insanity.

Maybe a few additions in Jan might make the second half of the season bearable but to call this embarrassing is a gross understatement.its painful.

Football is contextual and I do not buy in to 'at least we're in the prem' - I'd rather be competitive in the championship this season.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Oct 17 9.41pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I don't mean this in an aggressive way but enjoy what exactly? A miracle win against Chelsea does not nullify going almost 1/4 of a season without even scoring and looking like continuing in that fashion with no striker. We are being humiliated on an unprecedented scale and it's possibly worse in the prem as it's in the spotlight.

We have competed but are no longer. The same mistakes are made season after season which I believe is the definition of insanity.

Maybe a few additions in Jan might make the second half of the season bearable but to call this embarrassing is a gross understatement.its painful.

Football is contextual and I do not buy in to 'at least we're in the prem' - I'd rather be competitive in the championship this season.

We also didn't score in 4 of the last 5 last season. Parish wasn't concerned or just doesn't get it. Dougie lost his voice and then goes to watch Cenk when he's out of our reach. Amateurs. Typical us and I hate it. The money will evaporate next season and we'll be teased with more BS and patronising marketing campaigns.

Tune into hol for half gradual realisation of this shower and half sycophantic nonsense in defence of the indefensible. That's why this cr@p I've given up on this year. People defend the cr@p all summer and on and on and on when it's glaringly obvious where it's heading. The same way as last year, only no way back this time.

 


COYP

chris123 Flag hove actually 21 Oct 17 10.01pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

We also didn't score in 4 of the last 5 last season. Parish wasn't concerned or just doesn't get it. Dougie lost his voice and then goes to watch Cenk when he's out of our reach. Amateurs. Typical us and I hate it. The money will evaporate next season and we'll be teased with more BS and patronising marketing campaigns.

Tune into hol for half gradual realisation of this shower and half sycophantic nonsense in defence of the indefensible. That's why this cr@p I've given up on this year. People defend the cr@p all summer and on and on and on when it's glaringly obvious where it's heading. The same way as last year, only no way back this time.

Whether we stay up or not - having one striker was bonkers and highlighted on here repeatedly - that string of zeroes didn't seem to register with the leadership.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 21 Oct 17 10.08pm

We have no right to stay in this division. We have achieved a record (for us) 5th year in the prem so we are doing something right. Oh sorry it's all been luck. Come on, give credit where it is due.
Embarrassing is multiple administrations, years of wilderness in the third division, consecutive relegations, selling the stand to Sainsburys.
Enjoy the roller coaster, we still have a chance of staying up again. This league is all about taking risks with the handicap that half the league have the money to do whatever they like and are all but guaranteed to stay up.
Anybody remember our first stint in the top division. We lasted 4 years and went down after we spent a fortune in the last year and lost our soul somewhat. Spending money just doesn't guarantee any success.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Oct 17 10.17pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

We have no right to stay in this division. We have achieved a record (for us) 5th year in the prem so we are doing something right. Oh sorry it's all been luck. Come on, give credit where it is due.
Embarrassing is multiple administrations, years of wilderness in the third division, consecutive relegations, selling the stand to Sainsburys.
Enjoy the roller coaster, we still have a chance of staying up again. This league is all about taking risks with the handicap that half the league have the money to do whatever they like and are all but guaranteed to stay up.
Anybody remember our first stint in the top division. We lasted 4 years and went down after we spent a fortune in the last year and lost our soul somewhat. Spending money just doesn't guarantee any success.

Not scouting players enough is a recipe for overspending.

The left back fiasco means you have to buy 2 for more than you would've done to correct the mistake.

Not having a striker guarantees failure and is a repeat of LB.

I've been supporting Palace a long time and I know when it's cyclically inevitable we're going down due to our size and/or squad ageing, not being able to do this or that and this is not one of those occasions. At least it's not down to investing in golf clubs and personal wealth but it's the complete opposite from being clever over the rest of the football community. Thinking you can get away with that kind of thinking is only going to take you one way, which parish will feel the pain over and probably the only way he'll learn in this sport because he sure as hell hasn't before.

 


COYP

Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What is it letting us down?