You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Biggest player letdown so far this season?
November 16 2026 8.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Biggest player letdown so far this season?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
ozziex99 Flag London 13 Nov 17 1.11pm

For me it has to be PVA.

His positional sense when defending is poor at best, and he doesn't get as many crosses into the box as he should considering he is so attack minded.

Forget his individual mistakes, this can happen to anyone. For me he has a much bigger underlining defensive problem that needs fixing if we are to give ourselves the best possible chance of staying up.

 


[Link] - please support our matched betting site run by two Palace fanatics!

mars Flag Folkestone 13 Nov 17 1.16pm

PVA has been disappointing but not a s much as Benteke

 

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 13 Nov 17 1.21pm

Punch

 


@sxp55555

TheArmaniCode Flag 13 Nov 17 1.28pm

Benteke. I know he's our only striker, but not ONE goal in six games? That's really disappointing

 

ozziex99 Flag London 13 Nov 17 2.42pm

You know what you are going to get with Benteke - the man needs service which has not been great this season, especially with Zaha out at the beginning.

You also know that you are not going to get someone that runs around and puts pressure on the oppositions defence: Fraizer Campbell springs to mind, he was brilliant at this as was Cameron Jerome.

Yes, Benteke has missed a few sitters this season, but I wouldn't say he has been a letdown, as without proper service his goals to game ratio will reflect his form this season. This is the kind of player he has always been.

How I'd love a striker who can put himself about and MAKE things happen.

I guess we can all dream.

 


[Link] - please support our matched betting site run by two Palace fanatics!

Sewer Rat Flag bromley 13 Nov 17 2.58pm

PVA looked good when he arrived. Has since gone down hill. Not sure if its a lack of confidence or another player who looks the nuts when they join but then turn out s***e but we keep them just in case they turn good again. Sako for example looked quality first two games. After that absolute pony.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 13 Nov 17 3.15pm

Originally posted by ozziex99

You know what you are going to get with Benteke - the man needs service which has not been great this season, especially with Zaha out at the beginning.

You also know that you are not going to get someone that runs around and puts pressure on the oppositions defence: Fraizer Campbell springs to mind, he was brilliant at this as was Cameron Jerome.

Yes, Benteke has missed a few sitters this season, but I wouldn't say he has been a letdown, as without proper service his goals to game ratio will reflect his form this season. This is the kind of player he has always been.

How I'd love a striker who can put himself about and MAKE things happen.

I guess we can all dream.

I suppose you're right that he needs service, and my contribution is really a bit of a red herring. But I still often think about the goal he scored against us for Aston Villa, when (according to my fading memory) he picked up possession on the Arthur touch line, miles from goal, and just kept running and beating defenders till he scored. I think that's the night we lost 0-1, having had about 80% of the play.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 13 Nov 17 3.25pm

Originally posted by JRW2

I suppose you're right that he needs service, and my contribution is really a bit of a red herring. But I still often think about the goal he scored against us for Aston Villa, when (according to my fading memory) he picked up possession on the Arthur touch line, miles from goal, and just kept running and beating defenders till he scored. I think that's the night we lost 0-1, having had about 80% of the play.

[Link]
We need him to do this.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 13 Nov 17 4.35pm

Benteke - we've spent £40mill on him so far. Massively underwhelming in those first six games.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


iheartcpfc Flag SE25 13 Nov 17 5.16pm

his performances and work rate have been good and I'm a fan of his but it's disappointing that Andros hasn't scored this season

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 13 Nov 17 5.16pm

Based on his spell at Sunderland, most neutrals would have said that PVA was perhaps the worst defender in the league. His performances for us this season have proven this to be true.

Sadly, as he seems a nice lad, PVA's woeful positioning, non-existent game reading and powder puff man-marking leave us constantly exposed, and the only surprise is that he had to get injured before Hodgson (who prizes a well organised defence) left him out.

To dispel a lingering myth about him, his energy and enthusiasm for getting forward should not be mistaken for quality. He causes ten times more problems for our defence than he does for any of our opponents.

Sunderland were flailing about all over the place and looking clear favourites to go down when they received a pretty modest bid from us, a relegation rival, for this player. It says everything you need to know that they bit our hands off.

I wouldn't hold a barren spell in front of goal against Benteke, as all strikers have them. His general body language, lack of energy, fight and passion seem to come as part of the package based on his time with us, so that can hardly be called a specific disappointment this season.

Puncheon has been so bad for so long that I can't see how anyone could have been disappointed in his form this year.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (13 Nov 2017 5.26pm)

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 13 Nov 17 6.52pm

In no particular order:
Benteke: not looked a threat when fit, although willing to put it down to De Boers tactics
Puncheon: completely lost it sadly. Too slow on the ball, always plays backwards.
Reidewald: looks so out his depth, worst debut performance I’ve ever seen for Palace. He’s young so should improve
Hennessey: confidence shot, needs replacing in Jan. don’t think he’s made a telling contribution so far this season
PVA: definisvely all over the shop and ineffective going forward

 

leifandersonshair Flag Newport 13 Nov 17 7.43pm

Can't really argue with any of the names so far, but PVA really is just terrible. A not great player to start with whose confidence has gone

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 13 Nov 17 7.51pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

In no particular order:
Benteke: not looked a threat when fit, although willing to put it down to De Boers tactics
Puncheon: completely lost it sadly. Too slow on the ball, always plays backwards.
Reidewald: looks so out his depth, worst debut performance I’ve ever seen for Palace. He’s young so should improve
Hennessey: confidence shot, needs replacing in Jan. don’t think he’s made a telling contribution so far this season
PVA: definisvely all over the shop and ineffective going forward

Bit harsh. He wasn't even the worst player on the pitch. It wasn't great but there's been plenty that have been a lot worse.

 

mattteo Flag 13 Nov 17 10.07pm

RUBEN LOFTUS CHEEK. Let's take into consideration playing time here. He's had almost 0 contributions even though he was always used as an attacking player. I never understood this transfer anyway. I never expected anything from him. It's like some players get transferred just because they come from top 6 teams. He was never amazing in the U21 Premier League seasons or in other youth competitions. He seemed ok as a deep-lying playmaker for Chelsea.
But to play him as a starter......
I give him this: he's had a few decent shots and touches for a 21 year old, somewhat unlucky once not to get a goal in. But he doesn't have any sort of experience up there, near the opposing goal. He is just too inexperienced to make the correct choices so that the attacks end with goals scored. And he doesn't really cover ground fast enough or do his defensive duties either. He's like a Shelvey being forced to operate as winger or behind the striker. Playing such a player so much time guarantees that your team will not score, which unfortunately has happened. And he even gets called up to the national team......as an attacking midfielder!!


You can't name someone like Puncheon who played as a central and even defensive midfielder. I've said this and I'll say it again: Puncheon had wonderful season when he played on the wing. Really, really good PL seasons. Since they moved him to the center 2 years ago he has been struggling.

Edited by mattteo (13 Nov 2017 10.09pm)

Edited by mattteo (13 Nov 2017 10.09pm)

 

mattteo Flag 13 Nov 17 10.21pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Based on his spell at Sunderland, most neutrals would have said that PVA was perhaps the worst defender in the league.

Sunderland were flailing about all over the place and looking clear favourites to go down when they received a pretty modest bid from us, a relegation rival, for this player. It says everything you need to know that they bit our hands off.


Edited by TheBigToePunt (13 Nov 2017 5.26pm)

It says Sunderland were idiots and they got relegated exactly because they sold players like PVA. Keep PVA along with Giaccherini, Lens and Khazri and boom....you got another PL relegation avoided. But instead they got in Steven Pienaar at 36. What do you want? It was Moyes......

PVA doesn't cause more problems than he does good. It's like saying Marcelo causes more problems that does good for Real Madrid.
HANDS OFF! He's a darn good player. If anyone doesn't see that then he or she is in the wrong.
Last time this year everyone here except me was saying how terrible Townsend is. And then it was a time when everyone wanted Cabaye out of the team.

Yes, PVA has made a few defensive positioning mistakes. Everybody makes them! EVERY defender in the world. You should watch Aurier from Tottenham more often. Does he not make mistakes? Do you remember the ones from the match with us? He's a fullback, just as PVA. And he's a darn good player, even if he sometimes loses his man or the ball. We judge him by what he does in entire seasons, not by a few bad decisions.
And contributing to the attack that much, actually being the best left back in the PL outside of top 6 teams, makes PVA so great. He brings for the team more points than he loses in an entire season

Edited by mattteo (13 Nov 2017 10.22pm)

 

aashman12 Flag 14 Nov 17 1.05pm

Originally posted by ozziex99

For me it has to be PVA.

His positional sense when defending is poor at best, and he doesn't get as many crosses into the box as he should considering he is so attack minded.

Forget his individual mistakes, this can happen to anyone. For me he has a much bigger underlining defensive problem that needs fixing if we are to give ourselves the best possible chance of staying up.

He's not a let down because i had zero expectations for him.

 

Hansy Flag 14 Nov 17 1.10pm

Originally posted by mars

PVA has been disappointing but not a s much as Benteke

What do you expect from Benteke during FdB's reign? Playing football on the floor does not suit him. Using wingers and crossing the balls in to him does.

PVA for me.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 14 Nov 17 2.26pm

Originally posted by Hansy

What do you expect from Benteke during FdB's reign? Playing football on the floor does not suit him. Using wingers and crossing the balls in to him does.

PVA for me.

He was bloody good at Villa when they played it on the floor. And Belgium never used constant high ball tactics when he played. Maybe he is just not as good now? He also couldn't get into Liverpool's team even after Suarez leaving and Sturridge long-term injured.

We didn't buy a pony but we haven't bought a thoroughbred either even though he has cost us £40mill so far.

Edited by Kermit8 (14 Nov 2017 2.31pm)

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 14 Nov 17 2.41pm

Originally posted by mattteo

RUBEN LOFTUS CHEEK. Let's take into consideration playing time here. He's had almost 0 contributions even though he was always used as an attacking player. I never understood this transfer anyway. I never expected anything from him. It's like some players get transferred just because they come from top 6 teams. He was never amazing in the U21 Premier League seasons or in other youth competitions. He seemed ok as a deep-lying playmaker for Chelsea.
But to play him as a starter......
I give him this: he's had a few decent shots and touches for a 21 year old, somewhat unlucky once not to get a goal in. But he doesn't have any sort of experience up there, near the opposing goal. He is just too inexperienced to make the correct choices so that the attacks end with goals scored. And he doesn't really cover ground fast enough or do his defensive duties either. He's like a Shelvey being forced to operate as winger or behind the striker. Playing such a player so much time guarantees that your team will not score, which unfortunately has happened. And he even gets called up to the national team......as an attacking midfielder!!


You can't name someone like Puncheon who played as a central and even defensive midfielder. I've said this and I'll say it again: Puncheon had wonderful season when he played on the wing. Really, really good PL seasons. Since they moved him to the center 2 years ago he has been struggling.

Edited by mattteo (13 Nov 2017 10.09pm)

Edited by mattteo (13 Nov 2017 10.09pm)

One of the most bizarre posts I've read on this site - controversial for the sake of it.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Biggest player letdown so far this season?