You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > FA Adopts Rooney Rule
November 22 2026 8.02pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

FA Adopts Rooney Rule


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Badger11 Flag Beckenham 09 Jan 18 2.22pm

The FA has announced that future appointments will be governed by the Rooney rule.

I think this is fine for the FA if they want to go this way but I am against it for Premier League clubs.

In The US the Rooney rule has worked however they do not have relegation. If they sack a coach they can afford to take their time and go through a process as there are no financial implications.

We don't have the luxury of time in the Premier league. Additionally what is the point if you have already decided who you want. I once went to an interview and it was obvious that the candidate before me had the job. As it was council they had to advertise it but it was a farce. I was not annoyed that they knew who they wanted but that they had wasted my time.

Could we see BME candidates constantly on the road going from one interview to another. That doesn't seem fair.

I think the better solution is to identify BME candidates before there is a vacancy. I hope at Palace we have a shortlist of future managers we keep an eye on. Getting a BME candidate on that shortlist should be the goal.

Final point there aren't enough BME candidates with the right qualifications. I believe that Dalian Atkinson was appointed by the FA to try and drum up more interest from players. We have to have a bigger gene pool to select from.

Anyway over to you thoughts?

 


One more point

davenotamonkey Flag 09 Jan 18 3.21pm

Originally posted by Badger11

The FA has announced that future appointments will be governed by the Rooney rule.

I think this is fine for the FA if they want to go this way but I am against it for Premier League clubs.

In The US the Rooney rule has worked however they do not have relegation. If they sack a coach they can afford to take their time and go through a process as there are no financial implications.

We don't have the luxury of time in the Premier league. Additionally what is the point if you have already decided who you want. I once went to an interview and it was obvious that the candidate before me had the job. As it was council they had to advertise it but it was a farce. I was not annoyed that they knew who they wanted but that they had wasted my time.

Could we see BME candidates constantly on the road going from one interview to another. That doesn't seem fair.

I think the better solution is to identify BME candidates before there is a vacancy. I hope at Palace we have a shortlist of future managers we keep an eye on. Getting a BME candidate on that shortlist should be the goal.

Final point there aren't enough BME candidates with the right qualifications. I believe that Dalian Atkinson was appointed by the FA to try and drum up more interest from players. We have to have a bigger gene pool to select from.

Anyway over to you thoughts?

Meritocracy please. Best person for the job, even if they identify as an attack helicopter.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 09 Jan 18 4.29pm

Originally posted by davenotamonkey

Meritocracy please. Best person for the job, even if they identify as an attack helicopter.

Of course I should have said that. The presumption was that the BME person has the talent but not the profile.

 


One more point

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 09 Jan 18 4.41pm

Ridiculous.

Thr FA logic is that there a lots of Black footballers so we should have more Black coaches.
The amount of Black coach is in line with the population. This is yet another FA exercise in pandering to identity politics.

I hope we all still remember the disgraceful treatment of the women's coach.

 

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 09 Jan 18 4.48pm

Originally posted by davenotamonkey

Meritocracy please. Best person for the job, even if they identify as an attack helicopter.

My name is Bert Apache and I assert my right to a guaranteed interview.

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 09 Jan 18 4.50pm

Originally posted by Mr_Gristle

My name is Bert Apache and I assert my right to a guaranteed interview.

Certainly Mr Apache but would you mind moving your horse into the car park first.

 


One more point

Bangell Flag Oxford 09 Jan 18 9.00pm

Don't see why anyone has a problem with the Rooney Rule. Not a quota system or anti-meritocratic - it just ensures that candidates who might otherwise be overlooked at least get a chance, and the rule's effectiveness in the US has demonstrated that indeed decent candidates had previously been overlooked.

 

davenotamonkey Flag 09 Jan 18 9.08pm

Originally posted by Mr_Gristle

My name is Bert Apache and I assert my right to a guaranteed interview.

respect.jpg Attachment: respect.jpg (104.72Kb)

 

Username Flag Horsham 10 Jan 18 2.50pm

Originally posted by davenotamonkey

Meritocracy please. Best person for the job, even if they identify as an attack helicopter.

No one is forced to hire someone they don't want, they just have to make the effort to interview a BAME candidate.

It doesn't effect anyone already on the shortlist, other than adding more competition.

That BAME candidate who gets on the list then gets the chance at an interview they probably wouldn't get normally. They still have to be qualified, and occasionally they will convince someone to give them a job. On the occasions they don't, they get interview practice and a chance to learn what is required in the future.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 10 Jan 18 5.49pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Don't see why anyone has a problem with the Rooney Rule. Not a quota system or anti-meritocratic - it just ensures that candidates who might otherwise be overlooked at least get a chance, and the rule's effectiveness in the US has demonstrated that indeed decent candidates had previously been overlooked.

The problem for me is not the idea but the reasons for implementing it.
Why is 4% of coaches being Black a problem? Less than 4% of the population are Black.
There are very few Asians playing at the top level.

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 10 Jan 18 5.56pm

I think it's a great idea.

If a black or asian is guaranteed an interview for the England job that is progress.

I will also say the best person should get any future England job regardless of colour.

 

davenotamonkey Flag 10 Jan 18 6.26pm

Originally posted by Username

No one is forced to hire someone they don't want, they just have to make the effort to interview a BAME candidate.

It doesn't effect anyone already on the shortlist, other than adding more competition.

That BAME candidate who gets on the list then gets the chance at an interview they probably wouldn't get normally. They still have to be qualified, and occasionally they will convince someone to give them a job. On the occasions they don't, they get interview practice and a chance to learn what is required in the future.


If no-one is forced to hire someone they don't want, why should they be "forced" (I concede, it's not direct force, but activist pressure) to interview them in the first place?

It does affect people on the shortlist, as:

i) they were there by virtue of merit, not by whatever pigeon-hole identity-politiks has put them in (if indeed you can fit an attack helicopter into a pigeon-hole). This makes a value statement on the candidates, and a two-tier one at that.
ii) the interviewer has to spend more (total) time interviewing, or less per-candidate time if they only have (eg) a limited time for hiring. "Sorry, I've only got 5 minutes with you, as HR told us we had to fit in an extra six Attack Helicopters and a Panda. Tell us why you want the job?"

They should "make the effort" to interview a "BAME" candidate if said candidate has the skills and qualities they sodding well desire in an employee. Businesses should not have to adopt tokenism to sate the bloodlust of Common Purpose and the likes.

I agree implicit bias in candidate selection needs to be monitored: if HR systematically chuck out the CVs of people "sexually-identifying" as an Attack Helicopter, then that's wrong. That's why I support non-identifying job applications with no ethnographic or gender data.

But I stand by my comment: the best candidates should be shortlisted, and the best person should get the job. Otherwise, you'll end up looking utterly hypocritical when you ram an agenda down our throats and serve up this at the same time:

[Link]

 

Crazy_Eagle Flag South London 10 Jan 18 6.32pm

I once got an interview via the 2 ticks scheme (guarantees an interview for those with a disability should your application meet the min requirements). It was such a waste of time for everyone as it was clear they wasn't actually going to hire me and was just ticking a box.

 


R.I.P. DJ Hardline

CPFC2010

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 10 Jan 18 8.12pm

Originally posted by Crazy_Eagle

I once got an interview via the 2 ticks scheme (guarantees an interview for those with a disability should your application meet the min requirements). It was such a waste of time for everyone as it was clear they wasn't actually going to hire me and was just ticking a box.

Exactly my earlier point.

Rather than have the "token" to meet the quota better to deepen and broaden the gene pool. I suspect most managers get jobs because they are "known". So how do you get on the "known" list.

What if Mark Bright suggested to Steve Parish a young BME manager in the lower leagues. Let's say over time Parish keeps an eye on him and is impressed. When the next vacancy comes up he's on the shortlist not because he is the token but because he has become "known" to the club. That still doesn't get him the job but at least when he walks into the interview he doesn't get "who are you?"

Whilst I think the Rooney rule has its shortcomings one thing I hope we can all agree on. There is a managerial merry go round full of the usual suspects. Maybe this will force clubs to re-evaluate their recruitment process not just for diversity but to give those not on the "known list" a chance.

 


One more point

cryrst Flag The garden of England 10 Jan 18 9.04pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Exactly my earlier point.

Rather than have the "token" to meet the quota better to deepen and broaden the gene pool. I suspect most managers get jobs because they are "known". So how do you get on the "known" list.

What if Mark Bright suggested to Steve Parish a young BME manager in the lower leagues. Let's say over time Parish keeps an eye on him and is impressed. When the next vacancy comes up he's on the shortlist not because he is the token but because he has become "known" to the club. That still doesn't get him the job but at least when he walks into the interview he doesn't get "who are you?"

Whilst I think the Rooney rule has its shortcomings one thing I hope we can all agree on. There is a managerial merry go round full of the usual suspects. Maybe this will force clubs to re-evaluate their recruitment process not just for diversity but to give those not on the "known list" a chance.

The usual suspects will eventually disappear so new blood will come on the scene.
It can't happen overnight but again like you say will it be ability or colour that gets them into a job.
Also are women not entitled to apply as there are plenty in the game.(not on the game !).

 

becky Flag over the moon 10 Jan 18 9.26pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Exactly my earlier point.

Rather than have the "token" to meet the quota better to deepen and broaden the gene pool. I suspect most managers get jobs because they are "known". So how do you get on the "known" list.

What if Mark Bright suggested to Steve Parish a young BME manager in the lower leagues. Let's say over time Parish keeps an eye on him and is impressed. When the next vacancy comes up he's on the shortlist not because he is the token but because he has become "known" to the club. That still doesn't get him the job but at least when he walks into the interview he doesn't get "who are you?"

Whilst I think the Rooney rule has its shortcomings one thing I hope we can all agree on. There is a managerial merry go round full of the usual suspects. Maybe this will force clubs to re-evaluate their recruitment process not just for diversity but to give those not on the "known list" a chance.

Like anyone who wants a career always used to do - you get in at the bottom level, prove yourself and gradually work your way up the ladder as your competence and experience increased until such time as you become a valid and worthwhile candidate for the cream of the crop jobs.

It's how I and many others built our CV's and careers, and gives the employer a good overall view of your abilities and capabilities over a period of time - by which time you WILL have become a 'known' contender.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

davenotamonkey Flag 10 Jan 18 9.35pm

Originally posted by becky

Like anyone who wants a career always used to do - you get in at the bottom level, prove yourself and gradually work your way up the ladder as your competence and experience increased until such time as you become a valid and worthwhile candidate for the cream of the crop jobs.

It's how I and many others built our CV's and careers, and gives the employer a good overall view of your abilities and capabilities over a period of time - by which time you WILL have become a 'known' contender.

No, no, no. You're doing it all wrong! You have to be in a particular box, or a certain rung on the SJW privilege ladder.. then you have the right to be interviewed for the job.

Don't come on here with all your "career progression and development" rubbish.

Sigh.

 

becky Flag over the moon 10 Jan 18 9.41pm

Originally posted by davenotamonkey

No, no, no. You're doing it all wrong! You have to be in a particular box, or a certain rung on the SJW privilege ladder.. then you have the right to be interviewed for the job.

Don't come on here with all your "career progression and development" rubbish.

Sigh.

ffs dave, I'm an unrepentant pension-drawing post-war baby, blimey, I even think that a woman who gets into bed naked with a man and indulges in foreplay is asking for everything that she gets.....

I am beyond hope or redemption

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

davenotamonkey Flag 11 Jan 18 4.33pm

Originally posted by becky

ffs dave, I'm an unrepentant pension-drawing post-war baby, blimey, I even think that a woman who gets into bed naked with a man and indulges in foreplay is asking for everything that she gets.....

I am beyond hope or redemption

Just be glad I'm not reporting this post to a mod for "wrongthink" ;-)

 

chateauferret Flag 11 Jan 18 9.51pm

When I saw this headline I thought it was to do with letting team captains tell referees what to do.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > FA Adopts Rooney Rule