This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by pefwin
It is a bit like the Nazi salute, not tasteful but free speech for the individual. Everyone gets offended by something, but the question is who is the biggest "plonker" the offender or the offendee? A small part of me feels that these elites coming out of university straight into political careers want to exclude anyone else from civvy street who's worked outside politics and is even a little bit normal. Blokey people banned from politics.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by chelys
Dianne Abbott tweeted about how he shouldn't have been appointed in the first place. This from a woman whose contribution to her professed support of the comprehensive school system was to send her own children to fee-paying private school. I am unclear as to why he got the job in the first place. I know he founded a free school but does he really have the qualifications for this role. The job sounds like a regulatory type role, what experience does have have in that area? As for the tweets this is just a gift for the PC brigade who wouldn't want a Tory in the first place. So all round a bad call but whoever appointed him.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by chelys
Dianne Abbott tweeted about how he shouldn't have been appointed in the first place. This from a woman whose contribution to her professed support of the comprehensive school system was to send her own children to fee-paying private school.
Completely and deliberately myopic.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I am unclear as to why he got the job in the first place. I know he founded a free school but does he really have the qualifications for this role. The job sounds like a regulatory type role, what experience does have have in that area? As for the tweets this is just a gift for the PC brigade who wouldn't want a Tory in the first place. So all round a bad call but whoever appointed him. Involved in the running of four schools, all successful. Certainly more qualified than many many people appointed in public life.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I am unclear as to why he got the job in the first place. I know he founded a free school but does he really have the qualifications for this role. The job sounds like a regulatory type role, what experience does have have in that area? As for the tweets this is just a gift for the PC brigade who wouldn't want a Tory in the first place. So all round a bad call but whoever appointed him. One of his biggest critics thus far: Angela Rayner. Labour shadow education secretary. Left school at 16 without any A-C GCSE's. "Qualified"
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
A small part of me feels that these elites coming out of university straight into political careers want to exclude anyone else from civvy street who's worked outside politics and is even a little bit normal. Blokey people banned from politics. Toby Young? What? Are we thinking of the same person here? I hold almost all 'comment' journalists in contempt, because I don't really see why any of them have a particularly insightful view on all matters, but he may just hold first place as the most repulsive. He writes for two sinking ship journals - the Times and the Spectator - where the revolving door towards working for the Tories seems never ending. To me, it's more the barefaced nepotism of his appointment that I find offensive. I expect any upper-middle class establishmentarian white guy to be a bit of a sexist, but the fact that they clog up the corridors of power with their self-entitled stench is horrible.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4 |
|
|
Do you like the sound of the echo chamber now that Nick's gone? Anyone here gonna fight for the right for his free speech?
|
|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
Toby Young? What? Are we thinking of the same person here? I hold almost all 'comment' journalists in contempt, because I don't really see why any of them have a particularly insightful view on all matters, but he may just hold first place as the most repulsive. He writes for two sinking ship journals - the Times and the Spectator - where the revolving door towards working for the Tories seems never ending. To me, it's more the barefaced nepotism of his appointment that I find offensive. I expect any upper-middle class establishmentarian white guy to be a bit of a sexist, but the fact that they clog up the corridors of power with their self-entitled stench is horrible. I agree. Wait, we are talking about Corbyn, and his son here, right?
|
|
|
Originally posted by davenotamonkey
I agree. Wait, we are talking about Corbyn, and his son here, right? Edit. Had never heard about Corbyn's son, also disappointing I'd add. Edited by serial thriller (09 Jan 2018 5.55pm)
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4 |
|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
Isn't that a sexist comment itself though?....and really.....the the unnecessary reference to his skin colour? Also, which class and skin colour would you prefer to be clogging up the corridors of power exactly? Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Jan 2018 6.13pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Isn't that a sexist comment itself though?....and really.....the the unnecessary reference to his skin colour? Also, which class and skin colour would you prefer to be clogging up the corridors of power exactly? Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Jan 2018 6.10pm) Stirling. I've attached a picture of the latest cabinet. In it you will see a group of people who, in their gender, race and class, are completely unrepresentative of the country and citizens who they govern. To pretend, as you seem to be doing, that race and gender are not intertwined within the power relations of our society is ridiculous. Is female or BME representation the sole basis of how we should judge power? Of course not, but its absence is evidence that power is detached from the streets, from the disenfranchised, from the very people who, in my eyes, it should be working for. I work in a school with kids who have been kicked out of mainstream education, and often feel alienated and lack any confidence in themselves. They are disproportionately black, and disproportionately from low economic backgrounds. We recently showed them a picture of Theresa May, and none of them knew who she was. And why should they? What has she ever done for them, and what has the thing she represents - Parliament - done for them in recent memory? With alienation comes division apathy and ultimately a destructive mentality. I see that, first hand, every day. The last thing these kids need is an education adviser like Toby Young, who pontificates from on high but would run crying back to his cushy journo job the first day he tried to discipline these kids.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4 |
|
| chelys |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
Stirling. I've attached a picture of the latest cabinet. In it you will see a group of people who, in their gender, race and class, are completely unrepresentative of the country and citizens who they govern. To pretend, as you seem to be doing, that race and gender are not intertwined within the power relations of our society is ridiculous. Is female or BME representation the sole basis of how we should judge power? Of course not, but its absence is evidence that power is detached from the streets, from the disenfranchised, from the very people who, in my eyes, it should be working for. I work in a school with kids who have been kicked out of mainstream education, and often feel alienated and lack any confidence in themselves. They are disproportionately black, and disproportionately from low economic backgrounds. We recently showed them a picture of Theresa May, and none of them knew who she was. And why should they? What has she ever done for them, and what has the thing she represents - Parliament - done for them in recent memory? With alienation comes division apathy and ultimately a destructive mentality. I see that, first hand, every day. The last thing these kids need is an education adviser like Toby Young, who pontificates from on high but would run crying back to his cushy journo job the first day he tried to discipline these kids. Surely the Cabinet should be made up of people best able to do the jobs, regardless of their gender, race and class.
|
|
|
Originally posted by chelys
Surely the Cabinet should be made up of people best able to do the jobs, regardless of their gender, race and class. Of course - and this current group of white posh (mainly) men are hopeless at their jobs!
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4 |
|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
Stirling. I've attached a picture of the latest cabinet. In it you will see a group of people who, in their gender, race and class, are completely unrepresentative of the country and citizens who they govern. I have a little sympathy for this, but only a little. I believe that opportunities should be for as many within the tax paid society as possible....however, meritocracy isn't about your skin colour or your race. And actually it isn't that unrepresentative at all when you factor in the numbers from each group that are qualified to access these positions. Originally posted by serial thriller
To pretend, as you seem to be doing, that race and gender are not intertwined within the power relations of our society is ridiculous. Is female or BME representation the sole basis of how we should judge power? Of course not, but its absence is evidence that power is detached from the streets, from the disenfranchised, from the very people who, in my eyes, it should be working for.
Don't talk to me about power. But I do agree with efforts to support greater social mobility and better representation for the lower classes....but not purely on your skin colour. Originally posted by serial thriller
I work in a school with kids who have been kicked out of mainstream education, and often feel alienated and lack any confidence in themselves. They are disproportionately black, and disproportionately from low economic backgrounds. We recently showed them a picture of Theresa May, and none of them knew who she was. And why should they? What has she ever done for them, and what has the thing she represents - Parliament - done for them in recent memory? With alienation comes division apathy and ultimately a destructive mentality. I see that, first hand, every day. The last thing these kids need is an education adviser like Toby Young, who pontificates from on high but would run crying back to his cushy journo job the first day he tried to discipline these kids. I come from a deprived and violent working class background. I have also worked as a secondary teacher for quite a few years. In my view you are willing to give bad family cultures towards education excuses here. What has May ever done for them? How about sit atop of a nation that pays for them to have free education and also pay your wages. I certainly hope you aren't feeding them the excuses you promoted here. Bad family culture is the real reason these children are let down....Sure, I agree, poor children don't get the same life chances that families with money and location can provide....Sure, I agree that isn't fair...but that is where the excuses end for me. The Asians that came here and now sit atop of the highest earning group are evidence that good families don't make excuses like alienation or racism....they work as damn hard as they can and break in. Ultimately someone is successful in life if they can provide value to a business......If you can do that, then the vast majority of businesses really don't give a damn what your race or gender is.....suggestions to the contrary are pure over emotional crap......If you can't do that and point to excuses.....then that's failure, and no amount of affirmative action programmes will create success....as the US has seen. Is life fair.....no.....Does everyone start at the same position on the starting grid.....no.....Should society look to stop the middle classes from hogging all the best in society for themselves......yeah to the extent that they block the 'just as good' working class from breaking in. Should this be done because of your skin colour or what you have between your legs.....Hell no.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
Stirling, I have no doubt that you are an excellent teacher as you are open minded and articulate, so I would rather you didn’t question my teaching skills. You are right that skin colour shouldn’t influence your social position. But there still remains the question:why are there no black people in the cabinet, but so many in places like where I teach? You mention Asians who have done well, but that totally disregards the reasons why each came to our country. Asians (as in Japanese, Korean etc) came typically with well established companies. Many black people came either from former colonies when legislation pushed for cheap labour to be imported, or else are asylum seekers, entering a Country which advocated phrenology, celebrated slavery and now stops and searches black people 1500% more than whites. To simply say skin colour doesn’t matter is to ignore the reality of the present and be blind to the past, in my opinion. And finally, on Toby Young, let’s not forget he wasn’t forced out by anyone other than who employed him, which is May, who listened to those in her electorate who argued he shouldn’t be in his position. That is accountability and democracy in action, not some shady purge.
When I said Asians I'm talking Indians as well as Koreans, Chinese and Japanese anyway. Family culture makes a huge difference to success. The brightest student I ever taught at Nene in Peterborough was a black lad from their football academy which also used the school....Bloody good attitude and it all came from his Dad. Slavery? Oh my good god....You hit upon one of the excuse cultures that is used to justify failure...Look racism exists everywhere in the world but I imagine it's better here than most places. There is nothing holding back black people or any other person other than their attitude...in this country the group that preforms the worst is poor white children (who by the way are on the bottom of the educational ladder) So where is their slavery excuse? It's all about family culture and attitude towards education. We don't all start from the same start line but we are massively lucky to live in a country where hard work and a good attitude can get you access to a life worth living. If you are poor it's just going to require more work....and that's it. If they think the world is against them because they are black....jeepers. And Toby Young was forced out by constant protests in parliament by feminists both male and female and constant left wing media outrage.....don't give me soppy stuff that May....who employed him and defended him....suddenly changed her mind without that pressure....or that Young wasn't happy to go because of all that outraged nonsense. Progressives sack people and they have been doing it for ages now. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Jan 2018 10.59pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by davenotamonkey
One of his biggest critics thus far: Angela Rayner. Labour shadow education secretary. Left school at 16 without any A-C GCSE's. "Qualified" I am not going to defend Diane Abbott or Angela Rayner I can't stand Labour. I stand by my original comment as to his qualifications. Toby Young has a highly controversial career and whilst I appreciate he has a passion for Free schools I see no evidence that he was qualified for the job. I may be wrong of course. His appointment and the process that led to it seems murky at the moment. Labour will keep picking away at that scab to embarrass the government. I am a Tory but this stinks of "jobs for the boys". If it is all above board and he went through an open selection then fine. But right now the government has not proved that so Labour are making political capital. I am annoyed that the government keeps scoring own goals. The Tories need to get on the front foot come up with some decent policies and highlight the failings of the Labour party.
One more point |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.