You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Better Achievment - Pulis, Allardyce or Hodgson?
November 16 2026 7.06am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Better Achievment - Pulis, Allardyce or Hodgson?


Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Plaistow Eagle Flag 12 May 18 6.17pm

So all came in at times when we were in dire straits - but whose is the better achievement?

For me Roy - we were 5 games, no goals and no points. Response was not immediate - we went to 7 games, no goals and no points...!!

But since then we have taken 41 points from 30 games - outstanding achievement - beyond my wildest expectations.

Beyond that we are playing really good attractive football - unlike the Pulis and Allardyce tenures.

For me Roy is up there with Sir Steve and El Tel in terms of Palace Managers..!!

COYP

 

davehuggins Flag 12 May 18 6.23pm

Yes, Roy has been by far the best we have had. We are playing exciting attractive football and the future is looking much brighter indeed.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 12 May 18 6.25pm

Have to disagree....

Allardyce bought in quality players that RH has relied on, justifiably.

It was the extra quality they brought that has given us the edge this season and last.

Both BS and RH realised that you must be able to attack not just men behind the ball.

No disrespect to TP who did great for us.

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 12 May 18 6.26pm

Surely it has to be Pulis.

When Holloway left we had just got stuffed 1-4 at home to Fulham, had one win and seven defeats in eight games and were 4 points adrift.

He had no Zaha, had Cameron Jerome up front, turned Puncheon into a playmaker, shifted Ward to midfield enforcer / left back and played a masked Mariappa at r/b.

Talk about making a chicken salad out of chicken s***

Signed Scott Dann, a fantastic buy, and finished 11th!

 

gbox82 Flag Meols, Wirral 12 May 18 6.32pm

I'd say Roy, given the start we had, and given how low confidence must've been when he took over.

However, I'd say that if we are comparing rescue jobs and how far they took us as a club...then I'd say Pardews first year trumps the whole lot.

(Tin hat donned!)

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 12 May 18 6.39pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Have to disagree....

Allardyce bought in quality players that RH has relied on, justifiably.

It was the extra quality they brought that has given us the edge this season and last.

Both BS and RH realised that you must be able to attack not just men behind the ball.

No disrespect to TP who did great for us.

If you are basing your argument on players steve parish bought then your argument is NOT.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 12 May 18 6.43pm

Originally posted by silvertop

If you are basing your argument on players steve parish bought then your argument is NVG

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 12 May 18 6.46pm

Originally posted by gbox82

I'd say Roy, given the start we had, and given how low confidence must've been when he took over.

However, I'd say that if we are comparing rescue jobs and how far they took us as a club...then I'd say Pardews first year trumps the whole lot.

(Tin hat donned!)

Haha nice one.

And who could tell, it is so crazy, Pards could do another stint here and take us to winning a trophy as he nearly did.

Timing and luck and sheer audacity can work for you, if only there was a magic formula.

As Neil Warnock said if he could find it he would bottle it !!!!!

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 12 May 18 6.48pm

Really unfair Alan Pardew is not an option here, despite what people think of him now.

He took over from Warnock who had three wins in 16 games, with CPFC in the relegation zone.

He engineered a massive uplift immediately with wins against Spurs, Man City and Liverpool at Anfield.

We finished in 10th, the highest place since our recent return to the top flight.

 

gbox82 Flag Meols, Wirral 12 May 18 6.53pm

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

Really unfair Alan Pardew is not an option here, despite what people think of him now.

He took over from Warnock who had three wins in 16 games, with CPFC in the relegation zone.

He engineered a massive uplift immediately with wins against Spurs, Man City and Liverpool at Anfield.

We finished in 10th, the highest place since our recent return to the top flight.

And played probably the most watchable football we've seen in the top flight, before it all got a bit silly towards the end!

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 12 May 18 7.01pm

Looking at the posts on this thread.......

We have been well served by each of them really.

The job for Eagles is to stop getting in such a mess in the first place.

Hopefully RH has seen that, he needs a lot of help to persuade the owners IMO.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 12 May 18 7.08pm

Daft question - Roy most clearly.

 

Baldfella Flag Wigan 12 May 18 7.12pm

Hodgson by far then Pulis then Sam!

As Gary Lineker said the other day Roy has tightened things up but not at the expense of flair and attacking football! We’re playing some of the best stuff I’ve ever seen us play and when we play the big boys we give them a game not just hope for the best!

Pulis next because of the squad he had to work with was nowhere near as good as it is now or last season but the football wasn’t as good as it is now!

 

OllieMaidstoneEagle Flag Maidstone, Kent 12 May 18 7.16pm

Roy,and he is the only likeable one out of them all! Ollie's Dad,Ash.

 


Red and Blue Army!
LONDON BORN PALACE BRED LIVE AND DIE FOR BLUE AND RED
Football is not just a game, its a religion

coulsdoneagle Flag London 12 May 18 7.22pm

Hodgson without a shadow of a doubt, worst position we have been in.

Squad plagued by injuries, desperately short of personnel, lack of on pitch identity, terrible points and goal difference, pretty awful fixture list etc.

We have come out of that and are playing in my opinion our best football since promotion, and have seen loads of players come on leaps and bounds.

 

bashy2 Flag London 12 May 18 7.26pm

hodgeson by far with the start we had but we shouldn't of been at the bottom of the league anyway we should be were Burnley are.hope for better things next season but I say that every year

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 12 May 18 7.28pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Daft question - Roy most clearly.

Not a daft question at all. All three made significant contributions that in all cases saved us from certain relegation.

All three turned our seasons around and got us out of seemingly irretrievable tail spins. Very hard to separate them.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 12 May 18 7.35pm

Pulis, we had a championship squad following a chaotic summer window.

Roy who. is the better manager, has the potential to leave the bigger legacy.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

pssguy Flag 12 May 18 7.37pm

Objectively speaking, it has to be Pulis

The squad he took over was dire. Puncheon was arguably our best player and we had no-one of the class of Luka, Wilf, Yohan, Mama or cost of Benteke

Yet he averaged 1.46 points per game - which is 55 over a season - I'm guessing we'd settle for that next year. Allardyce, Pardew and Hodgson are all in the 1.21 to 1.24 range

Of course, the football was pretty ugly and he left on a very sour note but that shouldn't cloud the achievement. He won manager of the season. Let's see if Hodgson can match that first

 

leejaneagles Flag 12 May 18 7.44pm

Originally posted by pssguy

Objectively speaking, it has to be Pulis

The squad he took over was dire. Puncheon was arguably our best player and we had no-one of the class of Luka, Wilf, Yohan, Mama or cost of Benteke

Yet he averaged 1.46 points per game - which is 55 over a season - I'm guessing we'd settle for that next year. Allardyce, Pardew and Hodgson are all in the 1.21 to 1.24 range

Of course, the football was pretty ugly and he left on a very sour note but that shouldn't cloud the achievement. He won manager of the season. Let's see if Hodgson can match that first

Last part is a bit unfair and circumstantial. Man City have the richest squad in the world but have broken all records and played the best football the Prem has ever seen over the length of a whole season.

Pep has to win Manager of the Season. In any other season if City had just won the league normally, Hodgson would pick up the award. Doesn't mean he's had a lesser achievement than Pulis.

 

Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Better Achievment - Pulis, Allardyce or Hodgson?