You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Southgate - Best England Manager since Hoddle
November 22 2026 7.45pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southgate - Best England Manager since Hoddle


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Pussay Patrol Flag 03 Jul 18 10.40pm

Although slightly fortuitous in the end tonight, I felt all tournament our shape, tactics, discipline and togetherness of the squad has been exemplarary. It wasn't a sparkling performance but we didn't rise to provocation and we managed the game well

Ironically our tactics are the same as those deployed by Hoddle , 3 at the back, playing a wing back system. It plays to our strengths

Also destroys the myth there were no decent English managers to lead the England team. All the wasted years under Stupid Sven and Clueless Capello

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

mattteo Flag 03 Jul 18 10.50pm

No. Seriously, no. It was nothing about tactics. It was a normal game between 2 balanced teams, no magic don by Southgate to win it.

Not a world discovery to play 3 defenders at the back. In eliminatory matches it's actually proven that defending well and counter attacking can get you past better opponents in 90 or 180 minutes.

Hard thing when you play 5 defenders is to score many goals, qualify from the qualifying group or to win a league ) none which are needed at the WC

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 03 Jul 18 11.11pm

No quality to unlock a defence because Zaha wasn’t selected and then the passion/timing thing happening. Sterling is cr@p at this level.

 


COYP

Pussay Patrol Flag 03 Jul 18 11.21pm

Originally posted by mattteo

No. Seriously, no. It was nothing about tactics. It was a normal game between 2 balanced teams, no magic don by Southgate to win it.

Not a world discovery to play 3 defenders at the back. In eliminatory matches it's actually proven that defending well and counter attacking can get you past better opponents in 90 or 180 minutes.

Hard thing when you play 5 defenders is to score many goals, qualify from the qualifying group or to win a league ) none which are needed at the WC

if it was so easy why didn't Sven and Capello work that out ? too busy banking their 6m salaries

Also cast your mind back 12 years - Sven brought on Carragher specifically to take a penalty, he couldn't score a pen if his life depended on it and duely missed, Southgate brought on Dier and Rashford who both scored, that's the difference between a manager with a gameplan and man who is clueless

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

chateauferret Flag 04 Jul 18 12.10am

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

if it was so easy why didn't Sven and Capello work that out ? too busy banking their 6m salaries

Also cast your mind back 12 years - Sven brought on Carragher specifically to take a penalty, he couldn't score a pen if his life depended on it and duely missed, Southgate brought on Dier and Rashford who both scored, that's the difference between a manager with a gameplan and man who is clueless

Southgate didn't bring Dier on to score a penalty; he brought him on to protect a 1 - 0 lead which he promply failed to do.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Jamesrichards8 Flag 04 Jul 18 1.19am

Southgate completely changed a mentality that had become toxic. He’s got fresh new ideas (new for england), picks a team to play a system, and sticks by his guns.
Throw in some good leaders and a fantastic striker and this team is something to be proud of.
You can’t deny he’s done ana amazing job of keeping a balanced, focused and prepared mentality.

COME ON ENGLAND

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

Mr Palaceman Flag 04 Jul 18 1.59am

Never thought Southgate would be good as England manager. Leaving out RLC for Alli and leaving Sterling in showed me that he doesn't know his best team

However he has surprised me. He has created a good spirit to the team and that's always a good start.

As for best manager since.... Some just get too carried away. Tonight could how gone very wrong. Luckily it didn't.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 04 Jul 18 2.34am

Just lucky, lucky, lucky. Nothing to do with tactics.

Ineffective set pieces, our inability to shoot at goal from open play in 120+ minutes and lack of discipline exhibited from a few of our "top" football professionals who got themselves drawn into tit for tats with Columbian thugs.

Overall a poor spectacle of a game but admittedly, an excellent penalty shoot out.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Jul 18 2.54am

Southgate is a below average manager who happens to be a 'yes' man for the FA and so was given the job.

He's in charge of an average set of players who have had an easy group and came second.....losing the one game against a reasonably good side. We couldn't even beat Columbia over 120 minutes. We have an amazing draw.....again, luck.

Bobby Robson's team would make mince-meat of this team.....Venables side also.....Where's the Gascoigne....We don't even have a Beckham or anyone good at set pieces.

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jul 2018 2.55am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

twist Flag Miami, Florida 04 Jul 18 5.16am

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

Just lucky, lucky, lucky. Nothing to do with tactics.

Ineffective set pieces, our inability to shoot at goal from open play in 120+ minutes and lack of discipline exhibited from a few of our "top" football professionals who got themselves drawn into tit for tats with Columbian thugs.

Overall a poor spectacle of a game but admittedly, an excellent penalty shoot out.

Have to stop you there, our best chances came from set pieces, several free headers that would normally be in the net, were not. Thats not tactical problems, thats poor finishing.
There are problems with the team, but the deliveries in set pieces have been good (at least from Trippier).

 

Pussay Patrol Flag 04 Jul 18 6.14am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Southgate is a below average manager who happens to be a 'yes' man for the FA and so was given the job.

He's in charge of an average set of players who have had an easy group and came second.....losing the one game against a reasonably good side. We couldn't even beat Columbia over 120 minutes. We have an amazing draw.....again, luck.

Bobby Robson's team would make mince-meat of this team.....Venables side also.....Where's the Gascoigne....We don't even have a Beckham or anyone good at set pieces.

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jul 2018 2.55am)

In 1990 we looked like going out until we scraped past Egypt, Belgium we beat in extra time, just, Cameroon were better than us but gave us 2 cheap penalties

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

Pussay Patrol Flag 04 Jul 18 6.19am

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

Just lucky, lucky, lucky. Nothing to do with tactics.

Ineffective set pieces, our inability to shoot at goal from open play in 120+ minutes and lack of discipline exhibited from a few of our "top" football professionals who got themselves drawn into tit for tats with Columbian thugs.

Overall a poor spectacle of a game but admittedly, an excellent penalty shoot out.

Absolute nonsense, our discipline was superb, we didn't rise to the provocation to the point where Colombia lost their heads. Compare that to 98 with Beckham and 2006 with Rooney

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 04 Jul 18 7.02am

We were 'lucky' on the lottery of penalties and he has put some self belief in the players. But his decision to try to hang on to a 1-0 lead with 15 mins left against a team who were at that stage clueless and resorting to thuggery and cheating was a poor one. We were in control and his decisions had us hanging on in the first period of extra time.

So pleased we won a penalty shoot out, but I hope he has learnt from his mistakes. He also perseveres with Ali and Sterling who are offering very little threat.

 

Pussay Patrol Flag 04 Jul 18 8.55am

Originally posted by fish mitten

We were 'lucky' on the lottery of penalties and he has put some self belief in the players. But his decision to try to hang on to a 1-0 lead with 15 mins left against a team who were at that stage clueless and resorting to thuggery and cheating was a poor one. We were in control and his decisions had us hanging on in the first period of extra time.

So pleased we won a penalty shoot out, but I hope he has learnt from his mistakes. He also perseveres with Ali and Sterling who are offering very little threat.

But Southgate said we practiced penalties and we prepared for that situation, we won.

Previous managers never practiced penalties saying that you cannot recreate the same scenario, we lost

Just sayin'

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 04 Jul 18 9.23am

Once Dier came on we suddenly ceased to have a midfield. I understand the thinking but it wasn't the right tactic IMO as it invited pressure and broke the link between defence and attack, especially given we play it out from the back. RLC, Delph or Rashford would have been better options than Dier, or even with Dier but taking Lingard off, whose first touch last night was awful. Apart from one link up behind their left back Lingard may as well have been a brick wall for all the control, link up and threat he offered.

I do think he's quite limited in his options, with Vardy and Sterling both offering little. Could have started Rashford though.

But in Southgate's defence he at least has a plan A that is reasonably solid and helps ball retention and picks players to suit the system rather than trying to shoehorn as many Manure or Liverpool players in as possible. He also has clearly managed to create a good atmosphere in the camp and made the right call against Belgium by throwing the game.

 

becky Flag over the moon 04 Jul 18 9.46am

Best Manager since Hoddle?

Nah!

He'll never beat Sam Allardyce's 'unbeaten as Manager' record

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Jul 18 10.27am

Originally posted by becky

Best Manager since Hoddle?

Nah!

He'll never beat Sam Allardyce's 'unbeaten as Manager' record

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 04 Jul 18 10.31am

No-one's mentioned Roy's tenure as national manager.

 


Red and Blue Army!

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 04 Jul 18 11.47am

We may have practiced, we indeed won, with some wonderful penalties. Still maintain that it ended up going to extra time due to Southgate's substitutions. Rather that sticking Dier on to shore up a game we were well in control of, I would have brought Rashford on for Dele Alli. He could have stretched the Colombian defence if they pushed forward, and if they did equalise, he is more likely to create a goal out of nothing than Vardy is.

Done nothing to suggest he is our greatest manager for awhile yet. All a matter of opinion of course!


Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

But Southgate said we practiced penalties and we prepared for that situation, we won.

Previous managers never practiced penalties saying that you cannot recreate the same scenario, we lost

Just sayin'

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 04 Jul 18 11.53am

Agree with everything you've said. Rashford for Dele Alli was the obvious substitution for me. Would have stretched the Colombia defence, more likely to draw more fouls and in the event of a equaliser, is a potential game changer. Instead he tried to shore it up and just gave up possession and invited pressure. I really doubt if Vardy is of much international use, he's only good for a long ball through when the opposition are pressing. Once Colombia equalised the two changes we had made, had actually made things worse for us.


Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

Once Dier came on we suddenly ceased to have a midfield. I understand the thinking but it wasn't the right tactic IMO as it invited pressure and broke the link between defence and attack, especially given we play it out from the back. RLC, Delph or Rashford would have been better options than Dier, or even with Dier but taking Lingard off, whose first touch last night was awful. Apart from one link up behind their left back Lingard may as well have been a brick wall for all the control, link up and threat he offered.

I do think he's quite limited in his options, with Vardy and Sterling both offering little. Could have started Rashford though.

But in Southgate's defence he at least has a plan A that is reasonably solid and helps ball retention and picks players to suit the system rather than trying to shoehorn as many Manure or Liverpool players in as possible. He also has clearly managed to create a good atmosphere in the camp and made the right call against Belgium by throwing the game.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Southgate - Best England Manager since Hoddle