You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > So who will Meyer & Kouyate replace (or not).
November 16 2026 6.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

So who will Meyer & Kouyate replace (or not).


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Ecopalace Flag Wickham 14 Aug 18 7.37am

Interested to hear your thoughts, my view is they won’t until we start losing or players performance drops.

 

Portuguese Flag Porto 14 Aug 18 7.58am

Originally posted by Ecopalace

Interested to hear your thoughts, my view is they won’t until we start losing or players performance drops.

I've a hunch that maybe Max will come in instead of Macca and that's all about it.
Jordan should come from the bench for Andros.

 


1861 Football Club

FPL

GazJones Flag Southwark 14 Aug 18 8.20am

I was thinking Roy could drop Benteke and use the system we had at the end of last season, with Wilf and Andros up front and Meyer coming in in the Cabaye role.

 

Eltham Eagle Flag 14 Aug 18 9.23am

Macca will lose his place to either one. Not sure both of them will be starters.

 


Now here's Wright, his first chance to see what he can do, and he's through, it's Wright, ohhhh what an impact by the substitute. And it's Ian Wright who's sent the Palace fans into ecstasy!

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 14 Aug 18 9.49am

Why don't we get it, that it is a squad system.

Places are not lost there is no entitlement to them.

The manager chooses from the squad who will win him the game.

Despite Palace plonkers wanting to get rid of Riedewald the manager wanted him on the bench for a specific task.

Competition for places means each player must be PL match fit and ready to make his mark at any time.

Palace have a good looking squad let's keep it that way.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 14 Aug 18 9.53am

McArthur is an awesome player but in home games where teams sit back, it might be better to have a player who can control the game like Meyer. Also, Schlupp has been playing very narrowly, so Meyer could come in for him - especially as he's good with both feet.

Ayew I think will be a bench option - unless Benteke goes terrible again, in which case the best trainer out of him and Sorloth can take his place.

 

chateauferret Flag 14 Aug 18 9.57am

I thought he would just take over the Cabaye role. We seemed to miss that for the first half hour against Fulham before we asserted ourselves, but we will need it more against the bin dippers. Which said of course he won't quite be ready.

 


============
The Ferret
============

coulsdoneagle Flag London 14 Aug 18 10.10am

Originally posted by Eltham Eagle

Macca will lose his place to either one. Not sure both of them will be starters.

Why? Macca is one of our most consistent performers and I doubt either of them could match his energy and running.

 

Eltham Eagle Flag 14 Aug 18 10.38am

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

Why? Macca is one of our most consistent performers and I doubt either of them could match his energy and running.

I love Macca and his work rate is fantastic. However, his passing can let him down and, IMO, he would be the first place under threat. Luka is a brick wall and won't be moved.

But as someone said earlier, it's a squad game and this doesn' mean that Macca never starts. I just expect Meyer to get more

 


Now here's Wright, his first chance to see what he can do, and he's through, it's Wright, ohhhh what an impact by the substitute. And it's Ian Wright who's sent the Palace fans into ecstasy!

matthau Flag South Croydon 14 Aug 18 10.55am

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

Why? Macca is one of our most consistent performers and I doubt either of them could match his energy and running.

Mac’s is fab. He’ll be with us for a few more seasons yet hopefully, before gerrard can affOrd him anyway

But he’s not as good as milo as a dm and is put money on Meyer being better as a cam.

Squad game tho. But I think we are paying Meyer many more millions over the contract and paid him a hefty signing on fee, with that in mind, Meyer will soon be a starter, if he plays half as good as his rep anyway

A club the size of palace don’t let the highest earners hang on the bench, like benteke last year, we played him even when he looked lost and we knew he wasn’t gonna so much

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 14 Aug 18 11.12am

I think Schlupp is most likely player to be on bench on occasion depending on opposition.

Ayew, Wilf and Meyer can all play that position.

Against other opposition I think Ayew/Mayer will alternate with Wilf as second striker. I am not suggesting Wilf will be dropped but he will be moved to wing.

I think that against a side like Liverpool we may play with 2 defensive midfielders Kouyate and Luka. Macca may be on bench or play instead of Schlupp thus giving us a defensive midfield 3 when required with Macca playing higher up when we are on offensive. Wilf and Andros may both play as Wingers with a single Target man knocking balls off to Andros Wilf and Macca.Meyer when fit may alternate with Macca in this formation

Edited by Palace in the Blood (14 Aug 2018 11.14am)

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 14 Aug 18 11.50am

--------- Hennessy ---------
AWB - Tomkins - Sakho - PVA
--- Luka - Kouyate/Macca ---
---------- Meyer -----------
Andros ---------------- Wilf
---------- Benteke ---------

For Me, this seems reasonable base team. switching Kouyate for Macca(started not to last the 90 anyway?) when RH deems necessary!

only question is if Meyer wants to start from a deeper role? not sure....

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Rye Pie Flag East grinstead 14 Aug 18 12.15pm

Watching his highlights Meyer seems to have a lovely weighted through ball pass which if used slipping Zaha in behind could cause carnage.
Id like to see Meyer Zaha and Adros all in attack.

Leave the holding job to Luka he is the man for that role. Kouyate either in there with him or in and around the middle.

 

Aray Flag South London 14 Aug 18 12.29pm

Originally posted by Rye Pie

Watching his highlights Meyer seems to have a lovely weighted through ball pass which if used slipping Zaha in behind could cause carnage.
Id like to see Meyer Zaha and Adros all in attack.

Leave the holding job to Luka he is the man for that role. Kouyate either in there with him or in and around the middle.

Interesting one this. I thought we suffered last season when Cabaye wasn't in the team - both in terms of ball-retention and creativity. I can't wait to see if Kouyate is actually his replacement; receiving the ball from defence and starting the attacks. I love Jimmy Mac but that isn't the strongest part aspect to his game; in my view.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 14 Aug 18 12.37pm

We were great at the end of last season. Great pre season and great on Saturday.

I say let the new boys earn their right to play for us first before we start discussing who to drop.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 14 Aug 18 1.31pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

--------- Hennessy ---------
AWB - Tomkins - Sakho - PVA
--- Luka - Kouyate/Macca ---
---------- Meyer -----------
Andros ---------------- Wilf
---------- Benteke ---------

For Me, this seems reasonable base team. switching Kouyate for Macca(started not to last the 90 anyway?) when RH deems necessary!

only question is if Meyer wants to start from a deeper role? not sure....

This is how I see it going, but if benteke doesn't start scoring soon, could loose his starting place to Ayew.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 14 Aug 18 3.16pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

--------- Hennessy ---------
AWB - Tomkins - Sakho - PVA
--- Luka - Kouyate/Macca ---
---------- Meyer -----------
Andros ---------------- Wilf
---------- Benteke ---------

For Me, this seems reasonable base team. switching Kouyate for Macca(started not to last the 90 anyway?) when RH deems necessary!

only question is if Meyer wants to start from a deeper role? not sure....

This is also how I see it. Kouyate, Jimmy Mc and Luka together gives us a very strong base with which to attack. Meyer can provide the creativity that perhaps RLC would have given us. Schlupp can play on the left if we are struggling, as can Ayew for Tekkas or Andros. Fact is, the players we have bought are as good as the ones we have lost and in a way actually add more to the squad because they have more variety to their game. Overall I think this is a better squad than last year and that is all I would ever ask from the club - just get slightly better each year.

COYP

 

HolmesdaleUpper Flag Sanderstead 14 Aug 18 3.59pm

Could we actually be entering a new era, "Squad Rotation."
Ah, perhaps we can dream.

 

pssguy Flag 14 Aug 18 4.02pm

They are not paying Meyer a fortune to have him sit on the bench

Unless he is terrible in training, I'd start bedding him in after the Liverpool game. We have a relatively easy schedule up to October 21 - away to Everton. Optimistically, by then, even that will be regarded as winnable

The general consensus seems to be that Kouyate had gone off the boil at West Ham. Nevertheless, he was second in assists for the team last year

Medium term, I see Schlupp as an impact sub and McArthur as the first replacement for Meyer/Kouyate/Luka if any of them are missing

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 14 Aug 18 4.16pm

Originally posted by pssguy

They are not paying Meyer a fortune to have him sit on the bench

Unless he is terrible in training, I'd start bedding him in after the Liverpool game. We have a relatively easy schedule up to October 21 - away to Everton. Optimistically, by then, even that will be regarded as winnable

The general consensus seems to be that Kouyate had gone off the boil at West Ham. Nevertheless, he was second in assists for the team last year

Medium term, I see Schlupp as an impact sub and McArthur as the first replacement for Meyer/Kouyate/Luka if any of them are missing


Agreed, I can see Macca pushing for a starting berth slightly ahead of Schlupp if any of those three go missing, but we'll have to see how Roy sees it.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > So who will Meyer & Kouyate replace (or not).